Thursday, 2016-09-15

openstackgerritamrith proposed openstack/releases: Tag trove newton RC1
*** lucas-dinner has quit IRC00:10
*** lucasagomes has joined #openstack-release00:16
*** bobh has joined #openstack-release00:19
*** jlvillal has quit IRC00:41
*** jlvillal has joined #openstack-release00:46
*** jlvillal has quit IRC00:47
*** jlvillal has joined #openstack-release00:47
*** jlvillal has quit IRC00:47
*** jlvillal has joined #openstack-release00:47
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC01:14
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release02:10
*** TravT has quit IRC02:16
*** TravT has joined #openstack-release02:16
*** TravT has quit IRC02:20
*** inc0 has joined #openstack-release02:43
*** mriedem has quit IRC02:49
*** bobh has quit IRC03:00
*** sdake has joined #openstack-release03:01
*** inc0 has quit IRC03:45
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC04:08
*** mordred has quit IRC04:08
*** mordred has joined #openstack-release04:10
*** flwang1 has quit IRC04:26
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release04:52
*** sdake has quit IRC05:03
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC05:09
*** sdake has joined #openstack-release05:22
*** pcaruana has joined #openstack-release06:04
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release06:06
*** pcaruana is now known as pcaruana|afk|06:13
*** sdake has quit IRC06:36
*** pcaruana|afk| is now known as pcaruana06:40
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC07:02
*** shardy has joined #openstack-release07:20
*** jpich has joined #openstack-release07:36
*** cody-somerville has quit IRC07:37
*** cody-somerville has joined #openstack-release07:38
*** Rockyg has quit IRC07:45
*** dtantsur|afk is now known as dtantsur07:55
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release07:58
*** basilAB has quit IRC08:03
*** basilAB has joined #openstack-release08:05
*** amotoki has joined #openstack-release08:14
*** sheeprine has quit IRC08:15
*** sheeprine has joined #openstack-release08:18
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC08:29
*** electrofelix has joined #openstack-release08:43
*** ihrachys has joined #openstack-release08:55
*** vgridnev has joined #openstack-release09:19
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release09:26
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC09:32
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release09:39
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC09:44
*** AJaeger has joined #openstack-release09:54
AJaegerttx, dhellmann: Is astara project officially dead now? Looking at I see no changes reviewed since 5 weeks - and Jenkins giving a -1 since 7 weeks on all changes ;(. So, they'll have some fun to do a RC...09:56
*** dtantsur is now known as dtantsur|bbl10:39
*** rtheis has joined #openstack-release10:48
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release10:55
*** shardy has quit IRC10:57
*** sdague has joined #openstack-release11:01
*** electrofelix has quit IRC11:01
*** lucasagomes is now known as lucas-hungry11:06
*** dave-mccowan has joined #openstack-release11:06
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC11:47
*** trown|outtypewww is now known as trown11:52
amrithAJaeger, got the message re: coveragejob, will look into it.11:53
dhellmannAJaeger : it's likely, but they're looking for folks to take it over I think11:54
dhellmannttx, dims: good morning11:54
AJaegerdhellmann: interesting11:55
dhellmannAJaeger : it should be sorted out by/at the summit11:55
AJaegerdhellmann: Ok, let's see what happens11:56
dhellmannwe have a dearth of rc1 tag proposals this morning :-/11:56
dhellmannAJaeger : yeah, it won't hurt to wait before we do anything, and I'll work with ryanpetrello to mothball it if we need to11:56
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release11:57
AJaegerdhellmann: no need to rush anything - I just wondered and thought you might know or were interested in it since I don't expect them do a RC...11:58
*** gordc has joined #openstack-release11:59
dhellmannyeah, they thought they might do one last release, but we'll see11:59
openstackgerritamrith proposed openstack/releases: Tag trove newton RC1
amrithdhellmann, and; trove newton RC1. sorry it took so long12:02
dhellmannamrith : np, you're one of the first few12:03
amrithoh, for today, maybe :)12:03
amrithI'm sure that I've seen others who've already tagged their rc1's, no?12:03
amrithnow to get to AJaeger's observation that our coverage job is failing.12:03
*** bobh has joined #openstack-release12:06
dimsdhellmann : ttx : good morning12:08
amrithdims, g'morning. long time!12:09
dimshey yeah :)12:09
*** TravT has joined #openstack-release12:09
AJaegeramrith: that's not a release blocker ;)12:10
amrithAJaeger, it is a puzzle. see
dhellmannamrith : I don't think so12:10
amrithI run the exact command on my machine and it doesn't fail.12:10
dhellmanndims: it's been quiet in here all week, so I expect a lot of business today12:10
amrithdhellmann, hmm ... this is a first for me in that case. I'm usually the guy running in as they close the doors.12:11
dimsack dhellmann sounds good :)12:11
* dims checking the 2 reviews from amrith 12:11
amrithdhellmann, dims heads up re:
amriththere was some gerrit snafus last night12:11
dhellmannamrith : if you confirm you're ready to branch at those rc1 points we can process them as soon as the tests pass12:11
amrithwhen I was trying to push them12:11
amrithand you'll notice that there are patch sets 1, 2, 5 and 612:12
amrithbut 3 and 4 don't appear to exist12:12
dhellmannthat's odd12:12
dhellmannyou should make sure infra knows12:12
dhellmannfungi : ^^12:12
amrithit was at 8pm yesterday12:12
amrithI did let infra know12:12
amriththe odd thing is that when I pushed 5 and it worked, it actually just pushed 2 again.12:12
amrithand if I'd blindly removed my WF-1, I'd have tagged the wrong spot12:13
amrithbut now /6 is good12:13
amrithwill let infra know again12:13
dhellmannamrith : if you confirm you're ready to branch at those rc1 points we can process them as soon as the tests pass12:13
amrithif it causes your tooling grief, I'll resubmit12:13
amrithyes, dhellmann those are our rc1 points and point for branch newton12:13
amrithtrove and dashboard12:13
dhellmannamrith : ack, thanks12:14
amrithI don't anticipate an rc2, if there is one it will be minor12:14
amrithlike to fix the coverage job (tox.ini change, maybe)12:14
dimsamrith : dhellmann : both reviews look good to me12:14
dhellmannbswartz : I want to double-check that you're ready to branch manila at the point where you're requesting an rc1 tag12:14
amriththat AJaeger pointed to last night.12:14
dhellmannrtheis : I want to double-check that you're ready to branch networking-ovn at the point where you're requesting an rc1 tag12:14
dhellmannamrith : do you get translation patches?12:15
amrithyes we do12:15
dhellmannamrith : ok, you might have an rc2 for those, then12:15
dhellmannkeep an eye out for patch updates12:15
amrithyes, that's true. there have been string changes up to the last change that went in12:15
amrithyes, will keep an eye on them and keep an rc2 open for those.12:16
dhellmanndims : I'll approve the trove tags and create the branches12:16
dimsdhellmann : sounds good12:16
*** lucas-hungry is now known as lucasagomes12:17
openstackgerritMerged openstack/releases: Tag trove-dasbhoard newton RC1
fungiamrith: dhellmann: yes, during database backups, gerrit can end up not recording newly-pushed patchsets in the db (i think its insert/update queries time out), resulting in that behavior12:25
dimsAJaeger : dhellmann : amrith : this job should have run after the branch was cut?
openstackgerritMerged openstack/releases: Tag trove newton RC1
dimsfungi : ah interesting, is there certain time of day/week when it's more likely to happen?12:27
rtheisdhellmann: yes, we are ready to branch. Thanks for checking12:28
amrithdims, was that a question for me (this job should have ...)12:28
dhellmanndims : for today:
dhellmannrtheis : ack12:29
dimsdhellmann : ack12:30
dimsdhellmann : are there any manual steps for branches?12:30
dhellmanndims : yeah12:35
dhellmannfirst, you probably want this version of the tools:
dimsamrith : it's a post pipeline job so, should be ok12:36
*** rhallisey has joined #openstack-release12:36
dhellmannthen we have to send the announce emails12:36
dhellmannwe can create the branches with branch_from_yaml.sh12:36
dhellmannI'll put this in the etherpad12:36
dimsthanks dhellmann !12:36
amriththx dims12:37
*** sdake has joined #openstack-release12:38
fungidims: yes, daily at 00:00 utc until about 00:05 or so. by 00:10 it's well over anyway12:41
dimsfungi : gotcha thanks12:41
dhellmannamrith : your repos are branched, look for 3 patches from me in stable/newton and master on both repos12:41
fungiif we get around to building an active/passive cluster for the gerrit db, we can stop relying on running mysqldump on the production db server12:42
dimsdhellmann : am following alone, trove-dashboard has 2, trove has 3 (*trove.*)12:43
amrithdhellmann, 5 of your reviews have been approved, 2 for release notes, 3 for upper constraints and the branch12:44
amrithdhellmann, dims, release team, thanks!12:44
*** mriedem has joined #openstack-release12:44
dhellmanndims, amrith : hmm, does the dashboard not have constraints?12:45
*** bobh has quit IRC12:45
amrithdhellmann, let me check12:45
amrithI don't know for sure12:45
amrithapparently not12:45
amriththat's an issue12:45
amrithwill fix it ...12:45
amrithbut I suspect that it isn't as big of a deal, let me check other dashboards12:45
amrithand follow that pattern12:45
dimsamrith : need to fix the branch by hand then12:46
amrithdims, yes12:46
amrithdims, dhellmann appears that some dashboards don't have u-c (designate) ... ping mugsie ... this is incoming to you as well12:48
dhellmannamrith : you're going to want to set that up, but it's not a blocker for any of the release processes12:48
amrithwill do that12:48
amrithwe'll have it into the rc2 with the new translations12:48
*** shardy has joined #openstack-release12:50
amrithdims, dhellmann please see I've tagged it newton-rc-potential and you can throw other proejcts onto it if you want; i left the description open.12:50
openstackLaunchpad bug 1623932 in trove-dashboard "make *-dashboard respect upper-constraints" [Undecided,New] - Assigned to Amrith (amrith)12:50
*** dtantsur|bbl is now known as dtantsur12:51
*** electrofelix has joined #openstack-release12:53
openstackgerritMerged openstack/releases: Release Newton RC1 for Manila
dhellmanndims : I'm going to be heading into the city shortly. Do you want to run the networking-ovn branch while I'm here in case you have questions?12:57
dimsdhellmann : how much time do i have? i need to pull down the review etc12:59
dhellmanndims : I'm not on a tight schedule so I can wait to leave12:59
dimsk give me 5-10 mins12:59
dhellmannthe longer I wait, the less traffic I'll hit anyway12:59
*** askb has quit IRC13:00
*** myoung|gone is now known as myoung13:01
dims+W'ing (networking-ovn Newton RC1 deliverable)13:06
dimswatching zuul for networking-ovn13:07
bswartzdhellmann: yes manila should branch at the rc1 tag13:07
* bswartz will brb13:07
dhellmannbswartz : done!13:07
ttx\o/ I think I managed to pack Design Summit without conflicts13:08
ttxonly took me 8 hours13:08
dhellmannttx: congratulations!13:08
dhellmannthat has to be a first13:08
ttxIt's probably full of errors13:09
openstackgerritMerged openstack/releases: networking-ovn Newton RC1 deliverable
dimsdhellmann : which script calls
dhellmanndims : calls calls add_release_note_page.sh13:09
ttxdhellmann: saw the oslo-db thread ?13:10
* dhellmann starts humming "hole in the bottom of the sea"13:10
dhellmannttx: yeah, I was going to let them sort it out13:10
dhellmannhmm, I guess maybe if we end up with requirements changes we don't want to keep branching13:10
dhellmannttx: if we're anticipating rc2s for translations anyway, and it's not clear oslo.db is the issue, should we put things on hold?13:12
sdaguedhellmann / dims - was filed a couple hours ago13:13
openstackLaunchpad bug 1623838 in OpenStack Compute (nova) "Nova requires netaddr >= 0.7.12 which is not enough" [Critical,In progress] - Assigned to Sylvain Bauza (sylvain-bauza)13:13
dhellmanndims : go ahead and finish the one you're working on, then let's pause for a bit and see what happens with oslo.db13:13
dimsdhellmann : notes say "local copy of the release repository" but that review i need to pull down is from project-config so should i be running project-config/jenkins/scripts/release-tools/ ?13:13
*** sdake_ has joined #openstack-release13:14
dhellmanndims : you need the review copy of the tools, and you need a local copy of the releases repo with the patch with the rc1 tag info in it13:14
dhellmanndims : and yes, that's the script you want to run (not the old one in the release-tools repo, but the new one in the project-config repo)13:14
dhellmannsdague : is someone going to try to fix that or are we going to deal with it as a bug in the stable branch version of requirements?13:15
dhellmanntonyb, prometheanfire : ^^13:15
dimsdhellmann : ack i think i got it now13:15
sdaguedhellmann: I think that's the question. Apparently there was an earlier conversation which was hesitant to bump the minimum13:15
*** sdake has quit IRC13:16
* ttx needs to collect a few neurons, this constraints game is exausting13:16
sdaguehowever, the alternative fix is work around code in nova that's not really going to be tested. And given that we known minimums are often wrong, it really feels like we should just bump that to 0.7.13 and be done with it.13:16
sdaguethe constraint we've tested with all cycle is 0.7.18, fwiw13:17
dhellmanngiven the number of users of netaddr, I would just fix it with a release note in nova --
dhellmannwe have some ideas about how to detect these issues better, but they need more thought13:17
dhellmannsdague : between now and the summit I could use your feedback on
sdaguedhellmann: ok, I'll stick that on my list13:18
dhellmannno rush13:18
dimsdhellmann : script ran fine (see command line in the notes), got 2 reviews out of it*ovn.*13:18
dhellmanndims: looks good13:19
dimsdhellmann : i didn't see the trove RC1 from you to -announce13:20
dhellmanndims : send it to -dev13:20
sdaguedhellmann: ok, bauzas is going to submit a req bump, and we'll see how that goes13:20
dimsack i see it there thanks13:20
dhellmannsdague : ok13:21
dhellmanndims, ttx: I've started an issues section in this week's part of the tracking etherpad13:21
dimsdhellmann : ack13:22
*** shardy has quit IRC13:22
dhellmanndims : I made a note in the dashboard spreadsheet that networking-ovn was branched before the oslo.db thing was fixed, just in case we have to update its requirements for rc213:25
dimsthanks dhellmann13:26
dhellmanndims, ttx: I'm going to prep for my commute. Shall we pause any more branches until we know about the oslo.db thing and if we're going to have to block that release?13:27
dhellmannsdague : does the netaddr issue affect any projects besides nova?13:27
*** bobh has joined #openstack-release13:28
ttxdhellmann: I don't think we need to pause. That could have happened tomorrow13:28
ttxI'll catch up with you after commute13:29
dhellmannttx: fair enough13:29
*** mriedem has quit IRC13:29
dimsdhellmann : email sent13:29
sdaguedhellmann: I do not know13:29
dimsdhellmann : looks like i am all set. thanks!13:29
dhellmannsdague : ok13:29
sdagueI know nova started using a function introduced in 0.7.13 this cycle13:29
dhellmanndims : great, thanks13:29
sdaguethat was released in 201413:29
dimssdague : sorry was not paying attention to what you were saying, reading scroll back now :)13:31
* dhellmann is heading off to the big city13:31
openstackgerritSteve Martinelli proposed openstack/releases: tag keystone (newton) rc1
*** bobh has quit IRC13:34
*** trown is now known as trown|afk13:40
dimsstevemar : may i get the rc1 tag out now?13:42
dimsstevemar : see oslo.db stuff, dunno if you are interested in that13:43
*** inc0 has joined #openstack-release13:46
stevemardims: what do you mean oslo.db stuff?13:46
*** TravT has quit IRC13:46
*** TravT has joined #openstack-release13:47
*** TravT has quit IRC13:47
rtheisdims, dhellmann: FYI: The release note emails (e.g. mention master is open for Newton instead of Ocata.13:49
dimsrtheis : lol thanks for spotting :)13:50
dimswill fix the template13:50
dimsstevemar :
*** hongbin has joined #openstack-release13:52
stevemardims: we haven't seen any transient errors in our tests13:54
stevemardims: maybe its cause we don't to the 'walkthrough' that nova does13:55
stevemardims: anyway, you can go ahead and tag rc113:55
stevemardims: we may have an rc2, for 1 or 2 more bugs, but i don't want to wait for them, can release rc2 next week if necessary13:56
dimsstevemar : ack, just making sure you know,13:57
*** mriedem has joined #openstack-release14:03
dimsstevemar : processing now14:09
*** therve has joined #openstack-release14:11
thervedims, Hey14:11
dimstherve : ok for me to process RC1 now? there are 2 things that are blocking nova (netaddr, oslo.db), but wanted to check if you are good14:12
thervedims, AFAIK we're good, at least our gate is good. What are those issues?14:13
dimstherve : oslo.db is
dimstherve : netaddr is
openstackLaunchpad bug 1623838 in OpenStack Compute (nova) "Nova requires netaddr >= 0.7.12 which is not enough" [Medium,In progress] - Assigned to Sylvain Bauza (sylvain-bauza)14:13
dimstherve : keystone folks ok'ed their RC1 so am doing that now as they are not worried about those 214:14
therveWe haven't seen any failure on oslo.db. And I don't think netaddr impacts us either14:14
mriedemtonyb: dims: dhellmann: prometheanfire: in case you haven't seen the email yet, nova has a reqs FFE for a netaddr min bump
dimstherve : cool, will process RC1 now14:15
dimsmriedem : let's do that on -requirements :)14:16
mriedemomg another channel14:16
openstackgerritMerged openstack/releases: tag keystone (newton) rc1
* ttx recovered enough neurons to be useful14:23
ttxreads backlog14:24
dimsyay ttx :)14:24
openstackgerritMerged openstack/releases: Release Heat
ttxdims: please update the dashboard as you go14:28
ttxespecially if you created the branch14:28
dimstherve : stevemar : you should see 3 reviews (reno, .gitreview, UPPER_CONSTRAINTS_FILE)14:28
dimstherve : stevemar :*heat+OR+project:%255E.*keystone)14:29
*** trown|afk is now known as trown14:30
ttxdims: bah I'm updating it for you14:32
thervedims, Cool, looks ok to me14:33
dimsttx : oops14:34
dimsnetworking-ovn, keystone, heat so far ttx14:34
dimsthanks ttx i opened up the spreadsheet so i wont forget14:35
stevemardims: you were too slow in updating the dashboard :)14:36
dimsyep :)14:36
dimsa few more of these i can do it when i am asleep :)14:37
stevemarthanks dims!14:37
stevemardims: i've got your changes approved14:37
dimsstevemar : i had to re check Keystone uppercase/lowercase so i don't get on your bad side :)14:37
stevemardims:  :D14:38
stevemardims: you are always on my good side14:38
dimsthanks! :)14:38
*** TravT has joined #openstack-release14:52
dimsmriedem : now you know why i sent you there to the other channel :)14:57
openstackgerritAntoine Cabot proposed openstack/releases: Release Watcher for Newton rc1
*** csomerville has joined #openstack-release15:16
*** spzala has joined #openstack-release15:17
*** cody-somerville has quit IRC15:19
*** pcaruana has quit IRC15:19
*** bobh has joined #openstack-release15:32
openstackgerritAntoine Cabot proposed openstack/releases: Release Watcher for Newton rc1
amrithstevemar has a not-good side? who knew?15:34
dimsamrith : you don't want to be on that side :)15:34
* amrith recognizes the tone of a person who speaks from experience :>15:35
openstackgerritVitaly Gridnev proposed openstack/releases: [sahara] RC1 for Sahara project
*** bobh has quit IRC15:36
dhellmanndms, ttx: I'm back online15:37
ttxdhellmann: ohai15:37
ttxdhellmann: we had a discussion on #openstack-requirements about the netaddr bump15:38
ttxIt seems low-risk enough -- the idea would be to not aggressively sync requirements pre-release15:38
dhellmannttx: catching up now15:38
ttxand consider it a .z bump when it finally happens15:38
openstackgerritAntoine Cabot proposed openstack/releases: Release Watcher for Newton rc1
ttxdhellmann: main difference with "how we used to do things" is that we'd end up with slightly different requirements file being shipped at release time for various components.15:40
ttxBut then they start to diverge with post-releases quite quickly anyway15:40
stevemaramrith: my bad side is the same as the good side, i just toss in an extra "darn!"15:45
stevemardims: question about LP stuff, will the ocata bits get created automagically?15:45
stevemaror is that something i have to do?15:45
dhellmannstevemar : the release team doesn't do launchpad any more15:46
stevemardhellmann: the chains have been broken eh15:46
dhellmannstevemar : something like that15:47
stevemardhellmann: alright, but it's cool if i still create the ocata series and milestones?15:48
dimsstevemar : y, if you wish, we don't mind15:48
stevemardims: okie doke15:49
*** bobh has joined #openstack-release15:50
dhellmannstevemar : yeah, go for it, like dims said15:50
*** jgriffith has quit IRC15:52
openstackgerritPierre Mathieu proposed openstack/releases: Release Freezer 3.0.0rc1
vgridnevdhellmann, ttx So, about sahara project: I think that our team is ready for RC1, but probably we will need RC2 later if there are requirements updates or translations updates. If so, I will propose RC2 on the next week I think15:54
dimsdhellmann : 3 more in the queue, do you want me to to continue?15:57
dimsfreezer, sahara, watcher...15:57
dhellmannvgridnev : yes, it's expected that you'll have an rc2 with translation updates if those come in15:58
dhellmanndims : yes, if you're on a roll keep going15:59
dimsdhellmann : i can use a +2 from you and i can do the legwork15:59
dhellmanndims : ok, looking16:00
vgridnevdhellmann, or if there are few Critical bugs, right? (but now we should land in master first + back port to stable/newton )16:00
dhellmannvgridnev : at this point only release blocker bugs should be considered critical, and yes you need to start backporting changes as soon as we branch16:00
amrithdhellmann, this is odd, in the upper-constraints change for trove ...
dhellmannamrith : we haven't branched the requirements repo yet16:05
amrithok, so this is fine in that case, will leave it with a failure and recheck later16:06
vgridnev is step of updating u-c required?  we almost always were successful in jobs without having upper constraints16:08
vgridnevcurrently we don't have those in tox.ini16:08
*** jgriffith has joined #openstack-release16:11
dimsvgridnev : are you happy with the list of changes?
dimsvgridnev : updating u-c with what?16:14
vgridnevdims, yes, I'm happy with those changes. I think that probably we will have RC2 later for q-r updates or for translations, but it doesn't  matter now16:16
dhellmannvgridnev : you should set up the constraints job to ensure you work with the packages we're declaring as what needs to be used to be co-installable16:16
dhellmannvgridnev : but we should wait to discuss that until after today, please, we're pretty busy with rc1 tasks16:16
dimsdhellmann : processing sahara now16:16
vgridnevdims, about u-c, see , we don't have u-c right there16:17
vgridnevdhellmann, Ok, sure16:17
dimsvgridnev : gotcha, please consider doing that for master after we get stable/newton out16:17
vgridnevok, thanks dims16:18
openstackgerritMerged openstack/releases: [sahara] RC1 for Sahara project
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC16:24
*** lucasagomes is now known as lucas-dinner16:24
*** dtantsur is now known as dtantsur|afk16:25
*** vgridnev has quit IRC16:26
*** inc0 has quit IRC16:26
*** inc0 has joined #openstack-release16:27
ttxdhellmann: about to log off, will you be around some time tomorrow or completely away ?16:29
dhellmannttx: I have an early flight to a family thing, so I'll be reachable by email but not on irc16:29
dhellmannttx: let's plan to catch up monday16:29
dhellmannI'll send email16:30
ttxdhellmann: I'll be back on IRC for the Arch WG meeting, we can sync then16:30
dhellmannttx: ok16:30
*** jpich has quit IRC16:32
*** TravT has quit IRC16:32
ttxdhellmann: all of the milestone-driven stuff will get the requirements bump with their RC216:32
*** TravT has joined #openstack-release16:32
ttxor not16:33
dhellmannttx: they will. do we need to tell them whether to merge that patch?16:33
ttxwe should check when they request a RC2 that they have a fresh translation / requirements anyway16:33
ttx(even for RC1 to be fair)16:33
ttxit's good practice for all RCs16:33
ttxcan avoid having to do another one16:34
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release16:34
ttxanyway, email makes sense16:34
ttx(wrong channel)16:34
*** spzala has quit IRC16:39
*** spzala has joined #openstack-release16:39
dimsdhellmann : sahara done (updated spreadsheet)16:40
dhellmanndims : ack, thanks16:40
dhellmannsdague : do you expect the oslo.db issue to be resolved by changing the timeouts? or are we likely to need a new release or to lower the constraints?16:41
*** spzala has quit IRC16:49
dhellmannamrith : with that reno update in place you can add a link to your release notes to your deliverable file(s)16:56
*** TravT has quit IRC16:57
amrithdhellmann, i'm not following. deliverable files?16:57
dhellmannamrith : sorry, that's what we all the yaml files in openstack/releases16:57
amrithok, understood. thanks16:58
*** TravT has joined #openstack-release17:01
*** thingee has joined #openstack-release17:02
openstackgerritamrith proposed openstack/releases: add release notes links for newton trove deliverables
amrithdhellmann ^^17:04
amrithi checked the links, they work17:04
amrithtox passed locally17:04
dhellmannamrith : you want those to point to the newton.html page17:05
amrithI don't see newton pages, so I followed what some other projects had done.17:05
amrithwill update17:05
dhellmannoh, they might not have finished building yet17:05
openstackgerritamrith proposed openstack/releases: add release notes links for newton trove deliverables
amrithtrove has not, the other two are ready.17:08
dhellmannok, that explains it. I saw one of the patches land but only noticed the name "trove" not what repo it was17:09
amrithOK, the trove patch should've landed. at least that's what the notification in #openstack-trove says17:10
amrithyou refer, I assume, to
dhellmannit looks like the post job to rebuild the notes is still queued up17:12
dimsdhellmann : stepping out for a bit (couple of meetings)17:12
dhellmanndims : ack, thanks17:12
amrithdhellmann, I'll keep an eye on it.17:12
*** bobh has quit IRC17:16
*** trown is now known as trown|lunch17:28
*** electrofelix has quit IRC17:31
sdaguedhellmann: I think that zzzeek's analysis that there is nothing in the 4.13.x series that looks suspicious is right17:31
*** vgridnev has joined #openstack-release17:31
sdagueso I think we're going to just try the timeouts and see if that makes life better17:32
sdaguebecause the only changes that might have impacted this seem way back in the 4.10 -> 4.12 range I think17:32
dhellmannsdague : ok, good. I'll keep an eye on that thread for updates just in case17:32
*** inc0 has quit IRC17:41
*** ihrachys has quit IRC17:43
openstackgerritKirill Zaitsev proposed openstack/releases: Release newton-RC1 Murano deliverables
*** TravT has quit IRC18:06
dhellmanndims , ttx: I'll take the murano rc118:07
dimsack dhellmann18:07
dhellmannkzaitsev_mb : can you confirm that you're ready for us to create branches for the murano repositories when we tag rc1?18:08
*** bobh has joined #openstack-release18:16
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC18:19
*** bobh has quit IRC18:21
openstackgerritMerged openstack/releases: add release notes links for newton trove deliverables
openstackgerritMerged openstack/releases: Release newton-RC1 Murano deliverables
*** pcaruana has joined #openstack-release18:22
*** spzala_ has joined #openstack-release18:25
*** sdake_ is now known as sdake18:26
*** spzala_ has quit IRC18:27
*** spzala has joined #openstack-release18:28
amriththx dhellmann18:32
dhellmannkzaitsev_mb: the murano-agent build failed because of bad metadata in your setup.cfg
dhellmannkzaitsev_ws : you'll need to backport for an rc218:37
ttxdhellmann: I'm back18:41
* ttx checks the dashboard18:42
dhellmannttx: I fear we're doomed to a long night18:42
ttxI'll probably pick up the pieces tomorrow morning18:42
ttxdhellmann: the process is to approve the merge and then run the script for stable branches by hand ?18:43
dhellmannttx: yes, see for notes and an email template18:43
dimsdhellmann : i have a school event (6:30-8:30), so i can do before and after18:43
*** trown|lunch is now known as trown18:43
ttxdhellmann: see what?18:43
dimsttx : y, i have been tweaking that (
dhellmannpaste failed18:44
dhellmannthat's what I get for trying to do 2 chats at once18:44
ttxthat happens18:44
ttxdhellmann: you're fine with me handling the open RC1 requests tomorrow morning ? What about if some arrive tomorrow afternoon ?18:45
ttx(I consider RC1 to be an open milestone)18:46
dhellmannyeah, I guess that's ok18:46
dhellmannsince it's a target and not a deadline18:46
ttxWhat if we get intermediary releases, should I hold due to the Friday rule ?18:46
ttxI think I'll hold anything that is not a RC1 OR a first-intermediary-for-the-cycle (like if cloudkitty releases I'll pick it up)18:47
ttxEverything else waits for Monday18:47
*** spzala has quit IRC18:47
dhellmannyeah, that seems like a good approah18:48
dhellmannreally we only need to hold libraries, since requirements are frozen18:48
dhellmannserver projects tend not to appear in the requirements list18:48
ttxdims: we can have a short sync at the relmgt team meeting hour18:50
dimsttx : ack18:50
ttxdhellmann: enjoy your travel day18:50
dhellmannttx, dims: I made a note in the etherpad18:50
dhellmannI'll be flying to pittsburgh18:51
dimsttx : also if you want me to process something, just +2 and leave me a note, i can get to it tomorrow as well18:51
dimsdhellmann : safe travels18:51
dhellmannttx, dims: we should talk about when to branch the intermediary projects that don't post another release this week18:52
dhellmannmaybe monday?18:52
dimssounds good dhellmann18:52
dhellmannI can script it up18:52
ttxdhellmann: I would wait a bit more18:53
ttxdhellmann: traditionally we have the last swift release a lot later18:53
ttxlike unless they tell you it's their newton candidate it's hard to branch18:54
dhellmannso wait until final or something?18:54
ttxwe did some branches on week -1 last cycles18:54
dhellmannwe should fit that into the process document18:54
dhellmannI'll work on a patch18:54
ttxWe wait until they say it's a final -- or that we have no choice18:54
ttxon release day we just take what's there obviously18:54
ttxnotmyname: any timing for the last swift release for newton ( if any) ?18:55
notmynameplan for the swift release is to finish up the last few patches and get a SHA asap. I doubt it will be this week, but I expect it by the end of next week (also, I'm traveling to DC sun-thurs next week)18:55
ttxnotmyname: sounds good18:56
dhellmannnotmyname : thanks for the update18:56
notmynameI'll do the -release repo patch as soon as I have an answer. expect it 2nd half of next week. and we can all be happily surprised if it's sooner18:56
ttxnotmyname: we'll cut the stable/newton release branch from that one, so you can always do a last-minute bugfix release if needed18:57
ttx(same as usual)18:57
*** Rockyg has joined #openstack-release18:59
openstackgerritDoug Hellmann proposed openstack/releases: add step for branching intermediary projects
dhellmannttx: ^^19:00
*** pcaruana has quit IRC19:32
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release19:33
dhellmannmugsie : how's designate's rc1 shaping up?19:34
dhellmannnikhil : how is glance's rc1 looking?19:34
dhellmannrobcresswell : how is horizon's rc1 coming along?19:34
nikhildhellmann: close, we're finishing up release notes19:34
nikhildhellmann: this is the last one
dhellmannrakhmerov : how is mistral's rc1 doing?19:35
dhellmannnikhil : ack, sounds good19:35
dhellmannarmax: how are the various neutron rc1 releases looking?19:35
AJaegerdhellmann: is aodh done? They have an outstanding translation import:,n,z - as well as murano-dasbhoard...19:35
armaxdhellmann: I am planning to refresh the release patch from Ihar sometime today19:35
*** bobh has joined #openstack-release19:35
dhellmannmriedem : are you waiting for anything other than that requirements change for nova's rc1?19:35
armaxwe’re trying to nail down one or two more critical bugs19:35
armaxbefore we feel like it’s safe to release RC119:36
dhellmannAJaeger : we did murano earlier. but not aodh19:36
dhellmannarmax : ok19:36
* AJaeger pings aodh folks then...19:36
mriedemdhellmann: yes19:36
dhellmannTravT: how is the searchlight rc1 looking?19:36
dhellmannmriedem : ok19:37
mriedemtracking things here
dhellmannQiming : how is senlin's rc1 coming along?19:37
dhellmannmriedem : ack, thanks19:37
* dhellmann still has several ptls/liaisons who aren't in channel :-(19:38
*** david-lyle has quit IRC19:40
dhellmannhuats : how is cloudkitty doing? ready for rc1?19:40
*** david-lyle has joined #openstack-release19:40
dhellmannjrist : is bifrost 2.0.0 going to be your final release? should we branch from there?19:41
dhellmannoops, that should be jroll ^^19:41
dimsdhellmann : is that you or a bot? :)19:41
dhellmanndims : me19:41
dimsjust kidding19:41
dhellmanndims : although now that you mention it, a bot wouldn't be a bad thing19:41
dhellmannmsg pesterbot * "are you ready for your rc1?"19:42
jristdhellmann: :) it happens a lot19:42
dhellmannjrist : I blame tab-completion, sorry for the distraction19:42
dhellmannjroll : same question about the other ironic deliverables -- let us know if you think you're ready for branches or if you want to wait until closer to the end of the cycle19:43
dimsdhellmann : i talked with a lots of bots over on kubernetes pull requests / reviews19:43
dhellmanndims : oh? interesting19:43
dhellmannmaybe an IRC bot would be a fun project19:44
dhellmannjd__ : what's the plan for aodh and ceilometer? you're at b3, are you going to do an rc1 or go right to a final?19:45
dhellmannjd__ : ditto panko19:45
jd__dhellmann: do we need to branch to do a rc1?19:45
dhellmannjd__ : we would branch from your rc1 if you did that, or we can give you a final and wait to branch (since you're using the intermediary model)19:46
openstackgerritMerged openstack/releases: add step for branching intermediary projects
dhellmannshardy, EmilienM : are you planning rc1 releases for the os-*-config projects?19:46
dhellmannodyssey4me: are you planning an rc1 for openstack-ansible?19:47
huatsdhellmann: Yes it is. Thanks ! Actually sheeprine  is currently working of the final details....19:47
dhellmannhuats, sheeprine : ok, good19:47
*** sdake has quit IRC19:49
*** sdake_ has joined #openstack-release19:49
odyssey4medhellmann yes, we're just having a very hard time with nova at the moment - the upstream changes coming in are giving us massive inconsistency in test reults19:53
dhellmannodyssey4me : ack19:53
jrolldhellmann: was thinking next week for ironic's stuff19:53
odyssey4medhellmann would it be a problem if we can submit the request tomorrow in the EU morning?19:54
dhellmannjroll : ok19:55
dhellmannodyssey4me : no, that should work19:55
odyssey4medhellmann ok great, thanks - that buys me a little time to get the SHA pins in, tested and merged19:56
mugsiedhellmann: sorry, i had left the office. designate is working 2 criticals right now19:56
dhellmannmugsie : ok19:56
mugsiei am hoping for tomorrow afternoon19:56
mugsiebut if that looks like it is slipping i will let you know19:57
jd__dhellmann: yeah I think we'll go for a RC1, we don't have anything important waiting. Let me do a pass over all the patches tomorrow and we can branch Monday?19:58
jd__dhellmann: for Ceilometer/Aodh/Panko :)19:58
dhellmannjd__ : you know today's the target date, right?19:58
dhellmannbut monday is ok19:59
dhellmannttx, dims: I'm collecting responses to my queries from above in the notes column of the dashboard spreadsheet20:01
dimsthanks dhellmann20:02
*** ifat_afek has joined #openstack-release20:02
EmilienMdhellmann: i'm not sure, we're still bring our CI back to a stable state20:03
EmilienMdhellmann: we made progress and resolve most of blockers20:03
dhellmannEmilienM : good! let us know when have decided on a plan20:04
EmilienMdhellmann: I think the plan for us is to do our best to stabilize all the things and do rc maybe next week20:05
ifat_afekhi, I have a question regarding the rc1 numbering20:05
dhellmannEmilienM : ok20:05
dhellmannifat_afek : sure, what's your question?20:05
ifat_afekI noticed that most project named their versions e.g., and now however, in vitrage I named the versions 1.0.0, 1.1.0, 1.2.0… so how should I name the rc1 version?20:07
dhellmannifat_afek : vitrage is using the cycle-with-intermediary model, which does not do beta or rc releases. you have some time to do a patch or other final release before we'll create your stable branch. Of course, if you're ready now, we can go ahead and create the branch for you.20:08
jd__dhellmann: I should have known :(20:08
dhellmannthere's no rush, though,20:08
dhellmannjd__ : I'll get you a calendar for Christmas.20:09
jd__dhellmann: <320:09
jd__dhellmann: get me people to review patches rather :P20:09
dhellmannI should put together an ICS file that folks can subscribe to20:09
jd__dhellmann: that should be a good idea; I  would use it!20:09
ifat_afekdhellmann: thanks. so once we are ready, I should tag a release and ask you to create the stable branch? and what’s the deadline for that?20:13
dhellmannifat_afek : 25 Sept
dhellmannifat_afek : you should let us tag the release for you, though, by posting to openstack/releases20:14
ifat_afekdhellmann: ok, thanks. I already understood that part about tagging :-)20:15
dhellmannok, just making sure (we've found a few projects still doing their own tagging)20:15
*** rhallisey has quit IRC20:16
openstackgerritJulien Danjou proposed openstack/releases: Release Panko for Newton
openstackgerritStéphane Albert proposed openstack/releases: Release newton-RC1 CloudKitty deliverables
openstackgerritStéphane Albert proposed openstack/releases: Release newton-RC1 CloudKitty dashboard
jd__dhellmann: see I'm trying ^^^ ;)20:18
dhellmannjd__ : A for effort20:18
jd__the backlog for Aodh is less scary than what I thought, so I should be able to push it too20:19
* EmilienM also wants a calendar with cholocates inside20:20
dhellmannan openstack advent calendar?20:20
EmilienMyou can count on me to release on time :)20:20
prometheanfirewith the rc1 I guess it's about time to start updating20:20
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC20:21
dhellmannsheeprine : are you ready for stable/newton branches on those cloudkitty releases, or do you want to wait in case you have some critical bugs to fix between now and the final release?20:30
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release20:31
robcresswelldhellmann: Waiting on a final review on something critical20:33
robcresswellfor horizon. Just chasing cores now.20:33
openstackgerritMerged openstack/releases: Release Panko for Newton
dhellmannjd__ : I created the stable/newton branch for panko20:35
dhellmannrobcresswell : ack, thanks20:35
jd__thanks dhellmann20:39
dhellmannjd__ : let me know if you want a stable/$number branch instead20:40
jd__dhellmann: we only do that for Gnocchi because it's… special :)20:41
dhellmannjd__ : ok20:41
jd__and it's such a pain that I don't think I want to do it for any other project right now lol20:41
jd__there's so many things that are hardcoding random stuff20:42
jd__assumption about what stable/* should be :)20:42
openstackgerritMerged openstack/releases: Release newton-RC1 CloudKitty deliverables
openstackgerritMerged openstack/releases: Release newton-RC1 CloudKitty dashboard
*** askb has joined #openstack-release20:44
odyssey4medhellmann does the gating now do the new branch, the tag signing and everything?20:45
*** ifat_afek has quit IRC20:45
dhellmannodyssey4me : it does not create the branch or the changes after the branch is created, though we do have that scripted20:45
dhellmannhaving the ci system do that work is part of what we have on the schedule for ocata20:45
odyssey4meso the tagging side of things is now automated20:46
odyssey4menext step - branching.. fantastic20:46
odyssey4methat's awesome :)20:46
dhellmannodyssey4me :
dhellmannthat's the branch-automation spec20:47
*** myoung is now known as myoung|bbl20:47
dhellmannit's time for me to move locations again, I'll be back online in ~20 minutes20:47
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC20:48
*** Rockyg has quit IRC20:48
*** trown is now known as trown|outtypewww20:48
robcresswelldhellmann: Still waiting on a review. Can I cut the release tomorrow UTC AM?20:50
odyssey4medhellmann good spec :)20:54
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release21:00
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC21:06
sridhar_ramdhellmann: ping, i've question about upcoming newton for tacker21:07
sridhar_ram*newton release21:08
*** TravT has joined #openstack-release21:08
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release21:10
huatsdhellmann: thanks for the cloudkitty release !21:12
*** TravT has quit IRC21:16
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC21:18
dhellmannsridhar_ram : I'm here, what's your question?21:24
dhellmannhuats : no problem!21:24
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release21:26
robcresswelldhellmann: Did you see my question? No rush, just wanted to make sure it had been noticed.21:32
dhellmannrobcresswell : no, I thing that got lost when I moved location21:32
robcresswelldhellmann: Just asked if I tag in UTC AM. Still waiting on a final review and gate, will be a couple of hours.21:33
robcresswellOtherwise I'll wait up21:34
dhellmannrobcresswell : sure. ttx and dims will be online tomorrow to process those21:36
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC21:37
robcresswelldhellmann: Ah, thats a relief. I wasn't sure how strict the Thursday cut was. Thanks.21:37
*** vgridnev has quit IRC21:37
dhellmannrobcresswell : it's a little more flexible than the milestones, but we still want to stick as close as we can to the published schedule to leave space for an update if you have more translations or a critical bug update21:38
openstackgerritPierre Mathieu proposed openstack/releases: Release Freezer 3.0.0rc1
robcresswelldhellmann: Got it, good to know.21:39
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release21:44
*** AJaeger has quit IRC21:46
*** jhesketh has quit IRC21:47
*** mattoliverau has quit IRC21:47
*** matt6434 has joined #openstack-release21:47
*** jhesketh has joined #openstack-release21:49
*** matt6434 is now known as mattoliverau21:49
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC21:51
sridhar_ramdhellmann: tacker is marked release-with-intermediary... my understanding I don't need to go through RC builds, instead directly go for the final newton release. Can you confirm ?21:53
sridhar_ramdhellmann: if above is true, i'm planning to request the "final" newton release by Sep 26th or 27th.21:54
dhellmannsridhar_ram : yes, that's right21:55
sridhar_ramdhellmann: thanks21:56
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release21:56
*** mriedem has quit IRC21:58
*** csomerville has quit IRC21:58
*** csomerville has joined #openstack-release21:59
*** AJaeger has joined #openstack-release22:00
openstackgerritJulien Danjou proposed openstack/releases: Release Aodh for Newton
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC22:03
*** rtheis has quit IRC22:03
openstackgerritMerged openstack/releases: Release Freezer 3.0.0rc1
openstackgerritLingxian Kong proposed openstack/releases: Newton RC1 for Mistral
openstackgerritSean McGinnis proposed openstack/releases: Release Cinder
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release22:14
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC22:21
openstackgerritMerged openstack/releases: Release Aodh for Newton
*** gordc has quit IRC22:29
*** TravT has joined #openstack-release22:33
nikhildhellmann: I see you're still pushing releases.. not sure how long you are planning to be around but glance's final patch looks about an hour or so away from merge22:34
dhellmannnikhil : I'll be online for a little longer, and then dims and ttx will pick up tomorrow morning. submit when you're ready and we'll get to it22:35
nikhildhellmann: cool, thanks.22:35
nikhilhave a good one, I will go afk for a bit then.22:37
*** bobh has quit IRC22:38
openstackgerritMerged openstack/releases: Newton RC1 for Mistral
*** mriedem has joined #openstack-release22:44
sdake_dhellmann - we are short 1 review of cutting rc1 of kolla22:52
*** sdague has quit IRC22:52
sdake_dhellmann hopefully not too late22:52
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release23:03
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC23:07
*** hongbin has quit IRC23:13
dhellmannsdake_ : nope, if you don't get to it before I go offline ttx or dims will handle it in the morning23:14
openstackgerritFei Long Wang proposed openstack/releases: Release Zaqar
sdake_dhellmann thanks - waiting on core reviewers to show up23:14
sdake_2pm-5pm pst i'm pretty much the only one aorund23:14
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release23:14
sdake_the rest of the time - off the hook23:15
sdake_normally i just take a nap from 2-5 ;)23:15
openstackgerritMerged openstack/releases: Release Cinder
openstackgerritFei Long Wang proposed openstack/releases: Release zaqar-ui
*** TravT has quit IRC23:36
*** flwang1 has joined #openstack-release23:37
*** armax has quit IRC23:37
flwang1dhellmann: hi any idea why this patch failed ?23:39
*** TravT has joined #openstack-release23:40
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC23:50
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-release23:50
mriedemwell nova just hit a problem in the gate with the last patch we're trying to get in for rc1 so i'm fixing that now23:53
*** armax has joined #openstack-release23:54
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC23:56

Generated by 2.14.0 by Marius Gedminas - find it at!