20:00:15 <redrobot> #startmeeting barbican
20:00:16 <openstack> Meeting started Mon Sep 29 20:00:15 2014 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is redrobot. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
20:00:17 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
20:00:20 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'barbican'
20:00:49 <redrobot> Welcome to the weekly meeting, everyone.
20:00:55 <redrobot> As usual the agenda can be found here:
20:00:56 <redrobot> https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Barbican#Agenda
20:00:59 <redrobot> #topic Roll Call
20:01:07 <chellygel> \o/
20:01:14 <reaperhulk> \o
20:01:19 <SheenaG1> o/
20:01:25 <jaosorior> o/
20:01:34 <alee> o/
20:01:54 <akoneru_> o/
20:02:50 <redrobot> let's give it a couple more minutes to see if any other Barbicaneers show up
20:03:02 <rm_work> o/
20:03:54 <redrobot> Ok, let's get started
20:04:01 <redrobot> #topic Juno Release Candidate 1
20:04:23 <redrobot> So there's one big CR that is waiting for reviews https://review.openstack.org/#/c/110817/
20:04:57 <redrobot> this is Arun's work to consume Keystone events
20:05:23 <jaosorior> well, that took a while to read, but it's good stuff
20:06:09 <redrobot> yes, I would really like to get this merged today if possible
20:06:26 <redrobot> we're well into RC1 timeframe right now, and we still have a lot of outstanding stuff
20:06:40 <redrobot> #link https://launchpad.net/barbican/+milestone/juno-rc1
20:06:45 <atiwari> redrobot, I am working on https://review.openstack.org/#/c/121269/ too
20:07:12 <redrobot> atiwari is this necessary for RC1?
20:07:26 <redrobot> atiwari if so, how long until you get a passing CR?
20:07:49 <redrobot> looks like it's failing on a merge conflict now.
20:07:50 <atiwari> no, it can wait for RC2
20:07:59 <atiwari> but I will fit today
20:08:02 <jaosorior> atiwari: I haven't checked it out because of the -1 from Jenkins
20:08:18 <redrobot> so... ideally we would not want an RC1
20:08:22 <redrobot> * not want an RC2
20:08:39 <redrobot> Thierry would like RC1 to truly be a release candiate
20:08:40 <arunkant> redrobot: I joined late..Is CR https://review.openstack.org/#/c/110817/ already discussed ?
20:08:44 <atiwari> redrobot, then let me fix it for rc1
20:09:00 <jaosorior> arunkant: yes
20:09:04 <redrobot> arunkant yes, I asked for it to be looked at, and hopefully merged today
20:09:14 <redrobot> arunkant I would really like your work to be part of RC1
20:09:19 <jaosorior> arunkant: And good stuff! by the way
20:09:21 <arunkant> Okay..thanks.
20:09:49 <atiwari> jamiehannaford, +1
20:10:22 <redrobot> we also have a lot of outstanding bugs
20:10:45 <redrobot> It would be awesome if we can get as many of those fixed as possible.
20:11:17 <redrobot> it would be a shame to have a Release Candidate with known bugs...  so if you have any time, please look into closing some bugs.
20:11:25 <jaosorior> alright
20:11:41 <jvrbanac> :)
20:12:43 <redrobot> as far as bugfixes go, please review woodster_ 's CR https://review.openstack.org/#/c/124274/
20:13:03 <redrobot> and jvrbanac 's CR https://review.openstack.org/#/c/124514/
20:14:08 <redrobot> any questions/comments regarding RC1 ?
20:14:18 <redrobot> any patches ready for review that I may have missed?
20:14:32 <jvrbanac> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/12127
20:14:42 <jvrbanac> wooks
20:14:46 <jvrbanac> woops! https://review.openstack.org/#/c/121272
20:15:42 <redrobot> Got it... any others?
20:16:14 <redrobot> Ok, moving on.
20:16:26 <redrobot> #topic Kilo Design Sessions
20:16:35 <redrobot> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/barbican-kilo-design-sessions
20:17:09 <redrobot> So, it seems that the 3 most important topics, based on etherpad voting we agreed on last week were:
20:17:19 <redrobot> Integration with other OpenStack Projects
20:17:52 <redrobot> How to deal with multiple Pliguins over a System's lifetime
20:17:55 <redrobot> and
20:18:08 <redrobot> Common Certificate Issuance API
20:18:39 <redrobot> I'm still not sure how many slots we're getting on the schedule, but those will be the three topics that will fill them.
20:18:59 <redrobot> We'll work through the rest of the items during table discussions.
20:19:42 <redrobot> any questions/comments about those?
20:20:35 <rellerreller> Who will lead the integration discussion?
20:21:01 <rellerreller> Do we or should we alert the other PTLs about it?
20:21:06 <redrobot> I'll probably be the one leading all the Design Sessions
20:21:23 <redrobot> yes, that sounds like a good idea to ping everyone
20:21:23 <rellerreller> Cool :)
20:21:52 * redrobot needs to start a PTL task list
20:22:00 <rellerreller> I would be interested to know what topics we would like to cover for that one.
20:22:10 <rellerreller> I do not need that now but for future
20:22:46 <redrobot> I think we'll definitely want to talk to the Swift folks
20:22:52 <redrobot> about Swift encryption
20:23:30 <rellerreller> Nova as well. There is an outstanding patch there for this.
20:24:04 <redrobot> for sure.
20:24:04 <rellerreller> We need that patch to get the Cinder volume encryption working
20:24:27 <rellerreller> And ephemeral encryption
20:24:41 <alee> rellerreller, redrobot - I think that session will be most helpful if we reach out to the other PTLs beforehand and have them help set the topics on the agenda
20:24:52 <alee> rellerreller, which patch is this?
20:25:11 <jaosorior> alee: I agree
20:25:21 <rellerreller> alee I would need to ask developer for that
20:25:32 <redrobot> #todo redrobot to contact other project PTLs for Barbican Integration design session
20:25:56 <rellerreller> alee https://review.openstack.org/#/c/104001/
20:26:06 <alee> rellerreller,  cool - thanks!
20:26:49 <rellerreller> alee https://review.openstack.org/#/c/106437/
20:27:08 <jaosorior> funky
20:27:29 <rellerreller> Actually that last one was the spec, but the code was already merged. Sorry about that.
20:27:43 <rellerreller> On the Cinder side we are good, I believe.
20:28:07 <rm_work> I was going to help with the integration with other openstack projects thing (as I'm writing the Neutron integration) but... >_>
20:28:42 <alee> rellerreller, eh?  the "code was already merged"?  but it has a -2?
20:28:46 <rm_work> ptoohill (Phil) might be able to talk about the Neutron side
20:29:10 <rellerreller> For Cinder our code was merged (https://review.openstack.org/#/c/104339/)
20:29:17 <alee> ok
20:29:22 <rellerreller> alee For Nova our code has not
20:29:41 <alee> rellerreller, gotcha
20:29:42 <rellerreller> Oslo would be another good PTL to invite.
20:30:15 <rellerreller> There is duplicate code that should be consolidated into one place.
20:30:41 <alee> rellerreller, which code?
20:31:17 <rellerreller> I believe we have defined the KeyManager interface in both.
20:31:32 <rellerreller> Then wrote KeyManager plugins that talk to Barbican
20:32:20 <rellerreller> KeyManager is an abstract 'interface' that we defined to be able to talk to any key manager. Barbican was the first candidate.
20:33:00 <alee> ok
20:34:24 <alee> rm_work, you have a link for the neutron changes perchance?
20:34:49 <rm_work> very much just stubs, but here is the original one: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/109849/
20:34:59 <rm_work> but it has been moved to a branch I think, not sure if that CR will be abandoned
20:35:18 <rm_work> there is some turmoil going on internal to Neutron with regards to sub-projects and where they need to live <_<
20:35:35 <alee> rm_work, gotcha thanks
20:35:54 <redrobot> ok, sounds like we've got a good plan for this session.  Any other questions/comments before we move on?
20:36:46 <redrobot> ok, that's all I have on the agenda for today.
20:37:09 <rm_work> oh
20:37:10 <alee> redrobot, so right now, we have cinder/nova integration for encrypted volumes, neutron lbaas, and possible glance encryption ..
20:37:11 <rm_work> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/123492/
20:37:14 <rm_work> there's the new CR
20:37:29 <alee> and possibly oslo work ..
20:37:46 <alee> rm_work, cool thanks
20:38:05 <redrobot> alee yep.  Also I think there was a Keystone use case they were interested in
20:38:08 <rellerreller> Who is doing the glance encryption?
20:38:35 <redrobot> reaperhulk do you know if anyone is working on glance encryption now?
20:39:03 <reaperhulk> Not to my knowledge
20:39:13 <alee> redrobot, there is also possible kite/oslo work - although I'm not sure we want to add that to this session ..
20:39:22 <alee> reaperhulk, is there a spec/blueprint?
20:39:24 <reaperhulk> There are more significant prelim conversations for swift, but very early days there
20:39:29 <reaperhulk> alee: no
20:39:34 <rellerreller> reaperhulk redrobot if you do hear of anyone then let me know. We are looking at encrypting glance images for the next release.
20:39:44 <reaperhulk> rellerreller will do
20:39:47 <reaperhulk> good to know :)
20:39:49 <notmyname> reaperhulk: we're currently actively discussion (and maybe working on) encryption in swift
20:39:49 <rellerreller> Not sure if it will make it on our todo list at the moment
20:40:20 <reaperhulk> ah, sweet, thanks for being here notmyname
20:40:39 <notmyname> just got back to my computer and checked IRC ;-)
20:40:46 <alee> notmyname, you have a link for a blueprint/ spec / cr?
20:41:29 <alee> notmyname, and are you really in Mongolia?
20:41:51 <notmyname> alee: heh. no :-)
20:41:57 <notmyname> alee: looking for links..
20:42:22 <notmyname> spec for encryption in swift https://review.openstack.org/#/c/123220/
20:42:43 <alee> notmyname, thanks
20:42:49 <reaperhulk> oh excellent, I'll take a look at that as well
20:45:02 <redrobot> I think notmyname has a sixth sense that alerts him when someone is talking about Swift
20:45:09 <redrobot> good stuff.
20:45:19 <notmyname> my swift sense is tingling
20:45:37 <redrobot> Ok, guys any more questions/comments before we call it a day?
20:46:01 <atiwari> redrobot, jaosorior FYI  I have resolve the conflict on https://review.openstack.org/#/c/121269/. It wd be good if we can include it in rc1
20:46:45 <redrobot> atiwari will look as soon as it passes the gates.
20:47:12 <atiwari> redrobot, sure
20:47:15 <jaosorior> atiwari, sure thing man, will check it tomorrow probably :) today I think I'm running out of steam
20:47:19 <redrobot> Thanks everyone for coming.  Please try to review the CRs we talked about for RC1.  We'll aim for RC1 before the end of the week.
20:47:54 <redrobot> #endmeeting
20:47:55 <atiwari> jaosorior, thanks
13:00:15 <openstack> baoli: Error: Can't start another meeting, one is in progress.  Use #endmeeting first.
13:01:48 <baoli> #endmeeting