20:05:30 <redrobot> #startmeeting barbican
20:05:31 <openstack> Meeting started Mon Aug 29 20:05:30 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is redrobot. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
20:05:32 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
20:05:35 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'barbican'
20:05:42 <redrobot> Sorry I'm late y'all
20:05:46 <redrobot> #topic Roll Call
20:06:00 <woodster_> o/
20:06:06 <alee> o/
20:06:09 <arunkant> o/
20:06:09 <panatl> o/
20:06:21 <kfarr> o/
20:06:37 * redrobot needs to invest in a better alarm clock for these meetings
20:07:17 <redrobot> As usual the agenda can be found here:
20:07:23 <redrobot> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Barbican
20:08:04 <redrobot> #topic Swift Keymaster
20:08:15 <redrobot> Question around swift keymaster : Does it have barbican/castellan impl in newton release?
20:08:23 <redrobot> arunkant this is your topic
20:08:34 <redrobot> I don't know the answer, maybe kfarr does?
20:08:51 <kfarr> last time I looked at it, which was several months ago, it did not
20:08:57 <arunkant> redrobot: yes, trying to find out what kind of barbican integration is there, if any , for swift keymaster
20:09:23 <notmyname> you mean in swift itself, or does there exist a keymaster for swift that uses barbican?
20:09:45 <redrobot> notmyname I think the latter
20:10:02 <arunkant> notmyname, swift using barbican as one swift keymaster impl ?
20:10:19 <notmyname> I don't know about the latter (for the former, no there's nothing in-tree yet that has barbican, although it's on the short-list for next things in crypto)
20:10:30 <redrobot> thanks notmyname !
20:10:36 <notmyname> happy to help
20:10:46 <kfarr> notmyname, were there any plans to use Castellan instead?
20:11:10 <notmyname> kfarr: oh, yeah. in my mind, castellan and barbican are generically the same ;-)
20:11:27 <notmyname> "those things over there that do the hard part" ;-)
20:11:47 <kfarr> notmyname haha gotcha, I am curious to see what it will look like!
20:12:08 <notmyname> IIRC the most recent thinking was to use castellan instead of barbican directly. but it's not somehting I've been paying close attention to in the last month or so
20:13:57 <kfarr> notmyname, thanks, I'll keep an eye out for it
20:14:37 <redrobot> arunkant does that answer your question?
20:15:12 <arunkant> redrobot: yes it does..so it appears that work is post-newton . thanks notmyname
20:15:33 <redrobot> ok, cool
20:15:34 <redrobot> moving on
20:15:47 <redrobot> #topic Feature Freeze Exception for Multiple Backend
20:16:19 <redrobot> This week is the newton-3 milestone release week
20:16:29 <redrobot> which includes the Feature freeze
20:16:51 <redrobot> all implementation is in review, so if we can land by tomorrow/wednesday then we won't need a FF
20:17:19 <arunkant> redrobot: I have all of the reviews impl for multiple backend. So was hoping to get exception so that all 5 reviews .. I am not sure if all can be done by this week
20:17:22 <redrobot> if for some reason reviews are slow we can have a FFE, since there's still a couple of weeks left before RC1
20:17:27 <redrobot> #link https://releases.openstack.org/newton/schedule.html
20:17:36 <redrobot> arunkant yeah, I really want this stuff to land for newton
20:17:48 <redrobot> arunkant we'll do a FFE if it doesn't all land by Wednesday.
20:18:24 <arunkant> redrobot: okay.
20:18:38 <redrobot> Any other questions/comments about this feature?
20:19:31 <redrobot> cool deal,
20:19:46 <redrobot> cores, please take  a look at the agenda page since all pending reviews are listed there
20:20:06 <redrobot> or see here:
20:20:08 <redrobot> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/q/topic:bp/multiple-secret-backend
20:20:33 <redrobot> ok, moving on
20:20:46 <redrobot> #topic python-barbicanclient release
20:21:23 <redrobot> #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2016-August/102451.html
20:21:34 <redrobot> per Doug Hellman, we need to make a release of python-barbicanclient this week
20:22:06 <redrobot> I'll be requesting the release by wednesday along with the newton-3 barbican release unless someone things we shouldnt?
20:22:29 <kfarr> redrobot +1 sounds good to me
20:23:19 <woodster_> redrobot: did the midcycle client work bring up any issues with the barbican client?
20:23:36 * woodster_ can't recall if there were any big gaps to try to fill
20:23:45 <redrobot> woodster_ nothing that's broken, I think... lots of missing features though
20:25:03 <redrobot> ok, moving on
20:25:15 <redrobot> #topic Barcelona Design Summit Room Requirements
20:25:29 <redrobot> I need to let Thierry know how much space to set aside for Barbican in Barcelona
20:26:02 <redrobot> So any potential O-cycle PTLs can chime in
20:26:15 <redrobot> since this needs to be finalized before the next PTL election
20:26:21 <woodster_> curious how many barbican cores are attending the summit?
20:26:36 * woodster_ very likely not going myself :(
20:26:38 <redrobot> woodster_ afaik nobody at Rackspace has gotten the official go-ahead
20:27:26 <redrobot> For reference, in Austin we had 2x Fishbowl, 6x Working Room sessions, and 1x half-day contributors meetup
20:27:37 <redrobot> I think we may only need one fishbowl this time around?
20:27:43 <woodster_> may not need a big room this go around :)
20:27:43 <kfarr> I'll be in Barcelona!
20:27:52 <redrobot> kfarr \o/
20:27:58 <alee> I'll be there too !
20:28:01 <woodster_> nice!
20:28:12 <redrobot> alee did you see the workshop was accepted? :D
20:28:21 <woodster_> we'll have some barbican reps then
20:28:23 <alee> I did indeed :)
20:28:52 <alee> redrobot, so we have some work ahead of use before the summit
20:29:17 <alee> did any other barbican related talks get accepted?
20:29:23 <redrobot> alee yup!  I'm crossing my fingers that I'll get to go... still haven't heard from the powers that be
20:31:20 <alee> redrobot, so yeah - the room we had in austin was sufficient
20:31:59 <redrobot> alee I agree...  I was thinking maybe asking for 1fb, 8wr, 1cm this time around
20:32:21 <alee> sounds ok to me
20:34:33 <redrobot> #topic Open discussion
20:34:51 <redrobot> That's all we have on the agenda for today.  Any other topics we need to talk about before we call it a day?
20:36:41 <alee> redrobot, I believe you and fernando were going to add to the install guide
20:37:06 <redrobot> alee ah yes... I need to start chipping away at my midcycle TODOs
20:37:18 <alee> can we get folks to look at that, so that we can publish it this cycle?
20:37:53 <alee> it would be nice to have an accurate install guide we can point folks to in the summit demo
20:39:46 <redrobot> alee +1
20:42:45 <redrobot> Anything else?
20:45:42 <redrobot> alrighty guys, thanks for coming!
20:45:45 <redrobot> #endmeeting