15:00:59 <matrohon> #startmeeting bgpvpn
15:01:00 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Apr 12 15:00:59 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is matrohon. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
15:01:01 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
15:01:03 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'bgpvpn'
15:01:36 <matrohon> vthapr, tmorin, timirnich, enikher : hi
15:01:50 <matrohon> anyone around for the bgpvpn meeting?
15:08:25 <timirnich> Hi folks
15:08:39 <timirnich> sorry for being late
15:09:01 <timirnich> matrohon: hi
15:09:11 <matrohon> hi timirnich
15:09:53 <matrohon> timirnich, we're the only two guys who attend this meeting!
15:10:13 <matrohon> I was hoping vthapar could attend too
15:10:22 <timirnich> matrohon: well in that case let's just skip it and I can ask you an informal question
15:10:39 <matrohon> and that we can discuss https://review.openstack.org/#/c/296289/
15:11:06 <matrohon> That's the only patch we're waiting for before tagging our mitaka release
15:11:13 <matrohon> I'll leave a comment on it
15:11:23 <matrohon> timirnich, please ask!
15:11:38 <timirnich> I actually wanted to know the timeline for mitaka release
15:11:50 <timirnich> I mean the BGPVPN rebased version
15:12:24 <timirnich> But I guess you kind of answered the question already ;-)
15:13:07 <matrohon> timirnich, we want to avoid the burden of maintaining a mitaka code after neutron offcialy released its mitaka version
15:13:23 <matrohon> timirnich, it causes some painful gate issues
15:13:45 <matrohon> I think neutron tagged mutaka now
15:13:51 <matrohon> let's check!
15:14:20 <timirnich> matrohon, not sure if I understand, did you mean we don't want to maintain a Liberty version after Mitaka has released?
15:16:15 <matrohon> timirnich, oh no, I meant we'd to have a stable/mitaka branch not too late after the neutron stable/mitaka branch has been released
15:16:35 <timirnich> matrohon, I see
15:17:50 <matrohon> timirnich, did you plan to have other features in bgpvpn/mitaka?
15:18:09 <timirnich> matrohon, is there a list of changes we have between stable/Liberty and stable/Brahmaputra?
15:18:32 <matrohon> timirnich, you meant stable/mitaka?
15:18:43 <timirnich> matrohon, reason for the question: would like to understand what additional tests we should consider for OPNFV
15:19:19 <timirnich> matrohon, yes stable/Mitaka sorry
15:21:22 <matrohon> not much actually, I think there has been the heat support
15:22:39 <timirnich> matrohon, are we doing something like release notes?
15:23:16 <matrohon> timirnich, we should!
15:24:21 <timirnich> matrohon, ok what I'd like to do is make a list of additional "capabilities" compared to Liberty so that we in OPNFV can see what tests we should add to our backlog
15:24:24 <matrohon> timirnich, I have to look at existing tools in openstack to manage releases along with release notes
15:24:39 <matrohon> timirnich, makes sense
15:24:50 <timirnich> matrohon, since we are aiming at system-level verification
15:25:14 <matrohon> the reno project in openstack is here to help us, but we have to be more familiar with it
15:25:18 <timirnich> matrohon, for example if we now have Heat, we should add test cases that actually do BGPVPN configuration through Heat
15:26:14 <matrohon> timirnich, fine!
15:27:01 <timirnich> matrohon, is that something you or thomas could pull together or should we have a separate meeting and do it together over phone?
15:28:11 <matrohon> timirnich, all you need is a release note that you can work on to create new test cases?
15:28:44 <timirnich> matrohon, if the release note details what additions the release contains that should be fine
15:29:29 <matrohon> ok, I think it should automatically be produced by reno if our launchpad is correctly configured
15:30:22 <timirnich> matrohon, I guess that means autogeneration from the commit messages of the commits that went into the release right?
15:31:02 <matrohon> timirnich, I think reno rely on launchpad blueprints, not on commit messages
15:31:25 <timirnich> matrohon, ok, understand
15:31:29 <matrohon> timirnich, but I might be wrong! I need to dig into it
15:32:10 <matrohon> timirnich, moreover I see that bgpvpn's lauchpad is not really accurate, I need to fix that
15:32:14 <timirnich> matrohon, ok let's clarify this - Nikolas has sent an email earlier today, I'll add to that and we can take it in that thread
15:33:00 <matrohon> fine, but we get the point of releasing bgpvpn/mitaka along with a release note
15:34:49 <matrohon> timirnich, for example : https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Trove/create-release-notes-with-reno
15:35:45 <timirnich> matrohon, alright that looks reasonably straightforward
15:37:15 <matrohon> that's all for me any other topic?
15:37:47 <timirnich> matrohon, nope that's it for now - will shoot out a mail shortly
15:38:03 <matrohon> timirnich, fine
15:38:03 <timirnich> Matrohon, have a nice day\
15:38:15 <matrohon> timirnich, you too
15:38:19 <matrohon> #closemeeting
15:38:27 <matrohon> #endmeeting