15:03:47 <matrohon> #startmeeting bgpvpn
15:03:48 <openstack> Meeting started Tue May 31 15:03:47 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is matrohon. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
15:03:49 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
15:03:51 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'bgpvpn'
15:04:36 <pcarver> hi
15:04:37 <matrohon> hi pcarver, tmorin, doude
15:04:49 <wdeclercq> hello
15:04:55 <matrohon> hi wdeclercq
15:06:47 <matrohon> waiting few minutes to let tmorin join us
15:10:27 <matrohon> ok let's go
15:10:59 <matrohon> I made some cleanup on launchpad :
15:11:10 <matrohon> https://launchpad.net/bgpvpn
15:11:51 <matrohon> #topic bugs
15:12:25 <matrohon> I put a highest priority to bugs that are mandatory for us to stay in the neutron stadium
15:12:52 <matrohon> I also added one about OVO
15:13:07 <matrohon> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bgpvpn/+bug/1587511
15:13:07 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1587511 in bgpvpn "use OsloVersionObject to be able to upgrade with no interrupt" [High,Confirmed]
15:13:49 <matrohon> I think OVO is the way for us to provide upgrades without stopping the neutron service
15:14:03 <matrohon> But I don't know OVO enough yet
15:14:45 <matrohon> But I think that's what armax want us to use to stay in the stadium
15:14:54 <matrohon> armax can you confirm? ^
15:15:28 <armax> matrohon: ovo is not currently one of the criteria
15:16:03 <armax> matrohon: until neutron alone adopts them across the board it would be premature to consider them one of the criteria
15:16:40 <matrohon> armax : wasn't what you had in mind when you said we should provide an acceptable path for upgrades?
15:17:12 <armax> matrohon: there’s many upgrade paths
15:17:49 <armax> ovo are not strictly necessary for upgrades
15:18:18 <matrohon> armax : ok, the traditional alembic might be acceptable, with a service interruption of the neutron server?
15:19:07 <armax> yes
15:19:15 <matrohon> armax : ok thanks
15:20:19 <armax> matrohon: one must be able to demonstrade upgrade capabilities with one of the grenade jobs as neutron does today
15:20:46 <matrohon> I also gave a highest priority to bugs about tempest tests and bugs about integrating the openstack CLI
15:21:49 <matrohon> armax : ok, I'll create a bug that ask for a grenade job to run in our gate
15:24:33 <tmorin> hi everyone
15:24:47 <matrohon> hi tmorin
15:24:47 <tmorin> did you start already ?
15:24:50 <matrohon> yep
15:25:01 <tmorin> topic is bugs
15:25:06 <matrohon> it is
15:25:12 <matrohon> can you scroll back?
15:25:27 <tmorin> I'll do it right now
15:25:38 <tmorin> you can carry on in the meantime
15:26:08 <matrohon> no hurry :)
15:27:43 <tmorin> nothing is logged after 15:14 UTC
15:28:00 <tmorin> what's been said in the last 13 minutes I can't read
15:28:06 <tmorin> were you still discussing OVO ?
15:28:37 <matrohon> ovo is not mandatory, but we should run a grenade job in our gate at least
15:28:59 <tmorin> yes, this was my understanding
15:29:24 <matrohon> I moved https://bugs.launchpad.net/bgpvpn/+bug/1587511 this way
15:29:25 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1587511 in bgpvpn "demonstrate ability to upgrade" [High,Confirmed]
15:29:48 <matrohon> ok next topic?
15:30:20 <tmorin> more bugs  to talk about!
15:30:35 <tmorin> one is that our gate is broken because of https://bugs.launchpad.net/bgpvpn/+bug/1587511
15:30:35 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1587511 in bgpvpn "demonstrate ability to upgrade" [High,Confirmed]
15:30:41 <tmorin> sorry, not this one
15:30:56 <tmorin> this one: https://bugs.launchpad.net/bgpvpn/+bug/1587359
15:30:56 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1587359 in neutron " oslo_config.cfg.NoSuchOptError: no such option in group DEFAULT: config_dirs" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Ihar Hrachyshka (ihar-hrachyshka)
15:31:13 <tmorin> a fix is in progress
15:31:18 <tmorin> not much to say about it
15:31:53 <tmorin> but the discussion with ihrachys on it lead to ihrachys suggesting that we should update our tox.ini to apply upper constraints
15:32:01 <matrohon> ihrachys took the bug
15:32:22 <tmorin> to prevent uselessly-too-recent pip releases of our dependencies to introduce bugs
15:33:09 <tmorin> we need to do things like this: https://github.com/openstack/neutron-lbaas/blob/master/tox.ini#L10
15:34:05 <matrohon> ok
15:35:29 <matrohon> I also wanted to point out this rfe on the neutron side :
15:35:41 <matrohon> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/322654/
15:35:47 <tmorin> still on bugs: we have a fix applied to master, waiting for being merged into stable/mitaka (for bug https://bugs.launchpad.net/networking-bagpipe/+bug/1582598 )
15:35:47 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1582598 in bgpvpn "Same cookie value for br-tun flows rules added by OVS agent and its bagpipe_bgpvpn extension" [High,Fix released] - Assigned to Thomas Morin (tmmorin-orange)
15:36:17 <tmorin> matrohon: yes, on https://review.openstack.org/#/c/322654/  --> good if everyone can have a look at it
15:36:41 <matrohon> am I the only one who cannot open the .rst?
15:36:59 <matrohon> I get a gerrit error : service unavailable...
15:37:02 <wdeclercq> nah, me too. server unavailable
15:37:19 <matrohon> mickeys, around?
15:37:57 <tmorin> I can open https://review.openstack.org/#/c/322654/2/specs/newton/bgp-evpn-advertisement.rst without any issue
15:38:13 <matrohon> ok....
15:38:29 <tmorin> you can also read the spec here: http://docs-draft.openstack.org/54/322654/2/check/gate-neutron-specs-docs/e06688e//doc/build/html/
15:38:43 <tmorin> well here: http://docs-draft.openstack.org/54/322654/2/check/gate-neutron-specs-docs/e06688e//doc/build/html/specs/newton/bgp-evpn-advertisement.html
15:39:02 <wdeclercq> I could open it in another browser
15:39:20 <matrohon> I tried different browser, with no luck...
15:39:48 <matrohon> I'll try to workaround that!
15:39:56 <matrohon> thanks tmorin for the links
15:40:19 <matrohon> any other topics?
15:40:56 <wdeclercq> (I was getting ERR_BLOCKED_BY_CLIENT which is apparently often what you get with adblocks - turning mine off also fixed it in my 1st browser.)
15:41:14 <matrohon> wdeclercq, thanks
15:41:56 <ihrachys> tmorin: it's independent thing
15:42:07 <ihrachys> tmorin: but you should do it nevertheless
15:42:37 <ihrachys> for your immediate issue, the following should land in neutron: https://review.openstack.org/323428
15:43:07 <ihrachys> and I don't expect any change needed for bgpvpn on that one
15:43:45 <matrohon> ihrachys, thanks!
15:43:59 <tmorin> ihrachys: yes, understood :)
15:46:24 <matrohon> anything else for today?
15:46:38 <tmorin> yes
15:46:52 <tmorin> we have made some good progress on API evolution in the last week
15:46:57 <tmorin> most things are captured on the pad
15:47:14 <tmorin> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/bgpvpn_advanced_features
15:48:25 <tmorin> the more the merrier, so anyone is encouraged to read & discuss
15:48:52 <tmorin> pcarver: you may be interested, there are many things related to advanced use cases with l3vpns
15:49:21 <tmorin> #topic horizon
15:49:27 <tmorin> short topic/announce
15:49:36 <pcarver> tmorin: I've looked at them and asked a couple of other folks to look at them. Might need to schedule an internal conference call to get out non-OpenStack-focused folks to give input.
15:49:47 <pcarver> s/out/our/
15:50:00 <tmorin> pcarver: excellent ! feel free to reach out
15:50:19 <tmorin> #undo
15:50:55 <tmorin> pcarver: the earlier the better, or we'll end up with the API definiton done for Newton, but not time to implement any of the new things :)
15:51:50 <tmorin> #topic horizon announce
15:52:04 <tmorin> we have a contribution in the pipe on horizon
15:52:22 <tmorin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/322134
15:52:53 <tmorin> this covers only the admin-side of horizon
15:53:03 <tmorin> but the tenant side will reuse a lot of this code
15:53:22 <tmorin> the work still needs some work, essentially to make sure the code is extensible enough for new types of associations or new attributes
15:54:37 <tmorin> are we done for today ?
15:54:59 <wdeclercq> tmorin. I asked if we (nuage) have public documentation available to link in the documentation of the driver. Answer is we don't :) So what we suggest is to link to our https://github.com/nuagenetworks/nuage-openstack-neutron/blob/master/devstack/README.rst - Which is a bit out of date atm. But we'll be adding a small bgpvpn section there.
15:55:23 <tmorin> ok, that's still good
15:55:48 <tmorin> can you push a gerrit change to add the link when the README is updated with this section ?
15:56:09 <wdeclercq> Yup, will do
15:57:04 <tmorin> wdeclercq: perfect, then !
15:57:12 <tmorin> anything else ?
15:58:02 <tmorin> matrohon: closing ?
15:58:05 <matrohon> ok let's close this meeting
15:58:11 <matrohon> #endmeeting