15:08:43 <tmorin> #startmeeting bgpvpn
15:08:44 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Jul  5 15:08:43 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is tmorin. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
15:08:45 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
15:08:49 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'bgpvpn'
15:09:13 <tmorin> hi everyone, doude, michchap, pcarver, timirnich, steve_ruan
15:09:28 <steve_ruan> hi
15:10:14 <tmorin> wimdeclerq told me he would not attend
15:10:33 <tmorin> I think this will be a short meeting
15:10:42 <doude> hi
15:10:47 <tmorin> hi
15:10:54 <tmorin> #topic work in progress
15:10:59 <tmorin> a few things
15:11:09 <tmorin> the horizon tenant GUI work is in progress
15:11:24 <tmorin> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/335091/
15:11:37 <tmorin> not much more to say about it
15:12:06 <tmorin> work is in progress as well to fix a bug happening with the opencontrail driver
15:12:22 <tmorin> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bgpvpn/+bug/1596962
15:12:22 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1596962 in networking-bgpvpn "opencontrail driver issue with a particular network association" [Medium,In progress] - Assigned to Thomas Monguillon (thomas-monguillon)
15:12:30 <tmorin> different people have hit this bug
15:12:40 <tmorin> the fix is simple and I'll merge it soon
15:13:14 <tmorin> except that our unit test job is currently broken (let's discuss this later)
15:13:30 <tmorin> the VNI change is in progress (steve_ruan)
15:14:08 <tmorin> we still need to reflect in the API doc which additional constraints we need to put on associations to avoid conflicts between BGPVPN VNIs and VNIs used by Neutron L2/VXLAN
15:15:14 <tmorin> steve_ruan: I have seen your last comment, but I still need to think a bit more what we need to specify for BGPVPN VNIs and Router associations
15:15:15 <steve_ruan> yes, the constraints need more consideration
15:15:30 <steve_ruan> thanks
15:16:18 <tmorin> #topic open discussion
15:16:25 <tmorin> do we have anything more to discuss today ?
15:16:32 <tmorin> #undo
15:16:34 <openstack> Removing item from minutes: <ircmeeting.items.Topic object at 0x7f2b350f3c90>
15:16:36 <steve_ruan> my college find another bug https://bugs.launchpad.net/bgpvpn/+bug/1599055
15:16:36 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1599055 in networking-bgpvpn "tox unit test failed without testresources package" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Henry Dong (henry-dong)
15:16:37 <tmorin> ah yes, of course
15:16:46 <tmorin> our gate is broken
15:16:47 <steve_ruan> it blocked the tox
15:17:01 <tmorin> I had a look at is as well
15:17:12 <tmorin> I don't get where the issue is
15:17:49 <steve_ruan> it's very strange that someone remove "testresources>=0.2.4"
15:17:58 <steve_ruan> from test_requirement
15:18:05 <tmorin> where/when was it removed ?
15:18:31 <steve_ruan> need dig out
15:19:34 <tmorin> I would have expected testresources to be installed in the test venv because neutron is installed there, but maybe only neutron/requirements.txt deps are installed
15:21:09 <tmorin> identifying the change that caused the failure would be very useful
15:21:20 <tmorin> have you discussed with net-sfc folks about that yet ?
15:23:37 <steve_ruan> sorry, the root cause is not that someone change test_requirement.text
15:23:52 <steve_ruan> but add testresource can fix it
15:24:32 <steve_ruan> I found since March 2016, test_requirement.text is not changed
15:25:31 <regXboi> someone rang?
15:26:27 <tmorin> :)
15:26:57 <tmorin> cross IRC room discussion
15:27:22 <regXboi> the problem with missing testresources is that you need to include it in test-requirements.txt
15:27:22 <tmorin> steve_ruan: feel free to read #openstack-neutron logs
15:27:34 <regXboi> but... that's not likely going to be enough
15:27:44 <tmorin> regXboi: did you identify why it wasn't necessary before ?
15:28:18 <regXboi> tmorin: I wasn't in a search mode, I was in a fix mode
15:28:25 <tmorin> .. or more generally why much more is now needed
15:28:29 <tmorin> regXboi: ok
15:29:01 <regXboi> oh well *that* I know
15:29:18 <regXboi> first, the testresources is an update from openstack bot
15:29:27 <regXboi> but I suspect neutron was forking and changed
15:29:44 <regXboi> but as far as the OVS stuff is concerned, neutron switched to the native ovs interface
15:29:56 <regXboi> and looking at neutron-vpnaas, it's not prepared for that change
15:30:08 <regXboi> so that's where I'd look next
15:30:39 <tmorin> test-requirements has included testresources since January, so this is not recent, right ?
15:31:27 <regXboi> well, for neutron it has, neutron-vpnaas is another matter - I can't speak to networking-sfc
15:31:36 <regXboi> er wait I said that wrong (too many projects)
15:31:39 <tmorin> regXboi: understood about the ofctl/native switch, it seems to be a likely cause why importing testresources now fails
15:31:58 <regXboi> networking-sfc didn't have it, I can't speak to networking-bgpvpn
15:32:16 <tmorin> it doesn't have it either
15:33:24 <regXboi> then I'd add look at adding it and seeing what breaks next
15:33:31 <tmorin> yes
15:34:21 <regXboi> now i've not dug beyond just adding that
15:34:34 <tmorin> I wanted to know why we now had to include it explicitly, but I think I will just assume that one of the requirements or test-requirements of net-bgpvpn was declaring it as a requirement
15:36:13 <regXboi> somebody in #openstack-neutron might have a better idea
15:36:23 <regXboi> as to the chapter and verse of why
15:36:54 <tmorin> yep, let's follow-up there
15:37:08 <tmorin> http://logs.openstack.org/41/337541/1/check/gate-networking-bgpvpn-python27/21135f0/console.html#_2016-07-05_09_39_56_293009
16:00:25 <openstack> hongbin: Error: Can't start another meeting, one is in progress.  Use #endmeeting first.
16:01:12 <adrian_otto> hongbin: the bgbvpn meeting has not ended
16:01:33 <hongbin> It looks they forgot to end the meeting
16:01:38 <strigazi> shardy: ping
16:01:45 <muralia> can you end it yourself?
16:01:57 <hongbin> #endmeeting
16:02:08 <hongbin> No, doesn't seem to work
16:02:13 <muralia> hmm
16:02:18 <strigazi> I think shardy started it
16:05:04 <strigazi> I pinged on tripleo
16:05:50 <openstack> hongbin: Error: Can't start another meeting, one is in progress.  Use #endmeeting first.
16:06:05 <hongbin> ..........
16:06:25 <derekh> tmorin ^^ the bgpvpn meeting is still running
16:06:26 <adrian_otto> we need to keep trying to end it.
16:06:30 <adrian_otto> #endmeeting
16:06:56 <tmorin> wops
16:06:59 <tmorin> #endmeeting
16:07:09 <tmorin> #endmeeting