15:07:42 <tmorin1> #startmeeting bgpvpn 15:07:45 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Oct 11 15:07:42 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is tmorin1. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 15:07:46 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 15:07:48 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'bgpvpn' 15:08:13 <tmorin1> hi everyone 15:08:47 <tmorin1> hi bfernando, doude, lewo, matrohon, pcarver, timirnich ... 15:09:02 <doude> hi 15:09:33 <bfernando> hi 15:11:09 <lewo> hi 15:13:27 <tmorin1> we'll wait a bit for matrohon 15:13:47 <tmorin1> but I can start with what he already knows 15:13:55 <tmorin1> #topic announcements 15:15:13 <tmorin1> I've triggered yesterday a last mitaka release 4.0.2, including a pile of fixes among which the one merged end of last week (doude) 15:15:35 <tmorin1> and after merges the last pending things for our newton.0 release, we've just asked for a release 15:15:42 <doude> thanks for the backport tmorin1 15:15:50 <tmorin1> you're welcome :) 15:16:18 <tmorin1> I expect our 5.0.0 to be out very soon (https://review.openstack.org/#/c/383624/) 15:17:52 <matrohon> hieulq_, sorry 15:17:56 <matrohon> hieulq_, sorry 15:18:06 <tmorin1> we have one small horizon bug, but which can be fixed in a 5.0.1 (bug 1632264) 15:18:06 <openstack> bug 1632264 in networking-bgpvpn "horizon admin GUI: failure if there is one BGPVPN with non-existant tenant" [Low,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1632264 15:18:06 <matrohon> hi sorry 15:18:09 <matrohon> :) 15:18:11 <tmorin1> :) 15:18:28 <tmorin1> I just explained the release work done/in progress 15:19:41 <tmorin1> next topic ? 15:19:44 <tmorin1> odl driver ? 15:19:50 <tmorin1> #topic ODL driver 15:20:10 <tmorin1> we've hit an issue yestreday, where our gate was broken because of a broken DB migration script in ODL 15:20:43 <tmorin1> because we have odl as a test-requirement and we have a db migration test that runs every db hook installed in the venv 15:20:54 <tmorin1> all this was quite easily worked around 15:21:14 <matrohon> yamahata, is on the patch too 15:21:21 <tmorin1> but lead us to think that its probably time for ODL driver to move in networking-odl 15:21:35 <matrohon> it is targeted for ocata : 15:21:39 <matrohon> https://bugs.launchpad.net/bgpvpn/+bug/1632117 15:21:39 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1632117 in networking-bgpvpn "odl driver for bgpvpn should be moved to networking-odl and v2 type driver is needed" [Undecided,Confirmed] 15:22:57 <tmorin1> see bug 1632117 15:22:57 <openstack> bug 1632117 in networking-bgpvpn "odl driver for bgpvpn should be moved to networking-odl and v2 type driver is needed" [Undecided,Confirmed] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1632117 15:22:57 <tmorin1> https://bugs.launchpad.net/bgpvpn/+bug/1632117 15:23:12 <tmorin1> openstack bot doing funky things :) 15:23:58 <tmorin1> we currently also have bagpipe bgpvpn driver sitting partly in networking-bgpvpn and partly in networking-bagpipe, we'll consider changing that in ocata as well 15:24:15 <tmorin1> but we'll have other things to do for ocata... 15:24:27 <tmorin1> ... next topic : stadium ? 15:24:42 <tmorin1> #topic networking-bgppvn in stadium 15:24:46 <matrohon> well, this way we would avoid assessment for bagpipe... 15:25:36 <tmorin1> matrohon: perhaps, but perhaps not, it would still be a dependency ... 15:26:00 <tmorin1> anyhow, the goal for bagpipe is to meet the stadium criteria as well 15:26:10 <matrohon> I mean avoid assesment for net-bagpipe 15:26:19 <tmorin1> maybe others wonder what assessment we are talking about 15:26:29 <matrohon> maybe :) 15:26:33 <tmorin1> matrohon: yes, but I'm not sure we can/want avoid it :) 15:26:46 <tmorin1> #link https://review.openstack.org/383906 15:26:58 <tmorin1> it's basically a checklist of things we should do 15:27:06 <tmorin1> we do a fair number of them, but not all 15:27:24 <tmorin1> here is an HTML version 15:27:28 <tmorin1> #link http://docs-draft.openstack.org/06/383906/2/check/gate-neutron-specs-docs-ubuntu-xenial/5191893//doc/build/html/specs/stadium/ocata/networking-bgpvpn.html 15:28:15 <tmorin1> we pretty good on N.* 15:28:28 <tmorin1> we are also pretty good for D.* 15:28:59 <tmorin1> tmorin1: we are partially meeting C.* criteria 15:30:05 <tmorin1> the parts missing are: C4 (fulstack), do better on C3 (functional), C6 (grenade), C7 (multinode: does it apply for us?), C8 (python3) 15:30:45 <tmorin1> and C1 is missing as well (grafana) 15:31:17 <tmorin1> R1 and R2 are ok 15:31:38 <tmorin1> S1 ok as well 15:32:04 <matrohon> I think we can emulate multinode with fullstack... 15:32:11 <tmorin1> possibly 15:32:27 <matrohon> AFAIR, neutron does that 15:33:37 <tmorin1> neutron has also grenade... multinode tests 15:33:51 <tmorin1> last criteria is " L1. If the project requires a client library, how does it implement CLI and API bindings? " 15:33:55 <matrohon> neutron has a lot of dev... 15:34:12 <tmorin1> I think our answer won't be in our favor until we support openstack client 15:34:58 <tmorin1> armax: we're discussing about networking-bgpvpn scorecard 15:36:29 <tmorin1> armax: how are we expected to update it ? first merge the empty score card then we push changes with real content ? or we push PS2..PS3... to the current change (https://review.openstack.org/383906) ? 15:36:58 <armax> tmorin1: I’ll have a first pass, then you can review/comment and go from tehre 15:37:39 <tmorin1> armax: ok, is it helpful if we comment on certain items 15:37:47 <matrohon> armax summed it up in : https://review.openstack.org/#/c/383907/ 15:38:10 <matrohon> armax, ok 15:38:49 <tmorin1> matrohon: ok, thanks for the pointer 15:38:52 <tmorin1> armax: thanks 15:42:11 <tmorin1> so quite obviously, the better we fare on this scorecard at ocata-1 deadline, the better 15:42:47 <tmorin1> we'll need willing contributors to help improve on the criteria that we don't meet yet 15:44:07 <tmorin1> in particular (no order): openstack client (L1), grafana (C1), fullstack (C4), python3, grenade (C6), multinode (C7) 15:45:50 <tmorin1> I have a colleague with whom we've already started looking at adding fullstack testing for networking-bgpvpn and networking-bagpipe 15:46:12 <matrohon> cool! 15:47:11 <tmorin1> pcarver, doude, lewo/bfernando, timirnich: don't be shy, don't hesitate to take on one of these items ! 15:47:25 <doude> :) 15:48:24 <tmorin1> doude: I'm sure doing the openstack client stuff, or adjusting code for python 3, are the kind of things that would take you only 2-3 hours :) 15:48:42 <doude> sorry, I don't follow all the OpenStack neutron activities. What is fullstack? Or perhaps is no the place to discuss it, but do you have doc link? 15:49:00 <tmorin1> http://docs.openstack.org/developer/neutron/devref/fullstack_testing.html 15:49:10 <doude> certainly 15:49:13 <doude> not 15:49:18 <doude> thanks tmorin1 15:49:51 <tmorin1> in Barcelona, i'll buy drinks to whoever has started work on any of these ! ;) 15:50:11 <doude> I take the openstaclient one 15:50:17 <matrohon> Ill buy nachos and tacos! 15:50:18 <doude> do you have a bug , 15:50:20 <doude> ? 15:50:22 <tmorin1> goood :) 15:50:25 <tmorin1> let me check 15:50:28 <pcarver> tmorin1: I don't expect to have any time before the summit, but will hopefully be able to help with some of this after 15:50:31 <tmorin1> I think that we do 15:50:53 <matrohon> https://bugs.launchpad.net/bgpvpn/+bug/1561993 15:50:53 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1561993 in networking-bgpvpn "support for openstack CLI" [High,Confirmed] 15:51:03 <tmorin1> pcarver: ok... ocata-1 is November 17th, so we won't have /that/ much time after Barcelona 15:51:58 <tmorin1> doude ^ for the openstack client bug 15:52:05 <doude> ok 15:52:07 <tmorin1> thanks matrohon 15:52:30 <tmorin1> #topic barcelona 15:52:34 <tmorin1> about Barcelona 15:52:58 <tmorin1> we didn't check yet where to "ask" for a design summit slot 15:53:05 <tmorin1> or did anyone ? 15:53:08 <tmorin1> matrohon: ? 15:53:30 <matrohon> not really 15:53:41 <matrohon> I thinks we will do as previous summit 15:54:33 <tmorin1> doude, this is a better link on fullstack : http://docs.openstack.org/developer/neutron/devref/development.environment.html#fullstack-tests 15:54:46 <doude> tmorin1: yes thanks 15:54:54 <tmorin1> matrohon: yes 15:55:22 <tmorin1> which means meeting at sometime in the week, and then on Friday morning if need be 15:56:40 <tmorin1> ok 15:56:45 <tmorin1> anything else for today ? 15:56:54 <tmorin1> #topic open discussion, wrap up... 15:57:38 <tmorin1> ok, thanks everyone 15:57:40 <tmorin1> bye bye... 15:57:45 <tmorin1> #endmeeting