14:00:38 <rosmaita> #startmeeting cinder
14:00:41 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Dec  4 14:00:38 2019 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is rosmaita. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:00:41 <LiangFang> hi rosmaita
14:00:42 <whoami-rajat> Hi
14:00:42 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:00:43 <whfnst> hi
14:00:44 <anastzhyr> Hello)
14:00:45 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'cinder'
14:00:46 <davee_> o/
14:00:48 <tosky> o/
14:01:11 <m5z> hi :)
14:01:23 <enriquetaso> o/
14:01:31 <whfnst> This is my first meeting
14:01:39 <enriquetaso> welcome whfnst !
14:01:41 <rosmaita> welcome!
14:01:47 <smcginnis> o/
14:01:55 <rosmaita> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/cinder-ussuri-meetings
14:02:28 <smcginnis> Nice instructions rosmaita ;)
14:02:36 <rosmaita> looks like a good turnout, let's wait a minute in case people are having trouble finding the room
14:02:38 <rosmaita> smcginnis: ty
14:02:52 <sfernand> o/
14:03:23 <rosmaita> LiangFang: please take a look at the translation instructions in chinese at the top of the etherpad and see if they make sense
14:03:31 <rosmaita> (i used google translate)
14:03:32 <jungleboyj> o/
14:03:42 <LiangFang> ok
14:04:21 <rosmaita> ok, i guess we can get started
14:04:28 <rosmaita> #topic announcements
14:04:42 <rosmaita> first, welcome to our first meeting in our new time slot!
14:04:51 <whoami-rajat> rosmaita, yay!
14:05:13 <sfernand> :)
14:05:41 <LiangFang> the translate of chinese is correct
14:05:47 <e0ne> hi
14:05:52 <rosmaita> LiangFang: thanks!
14:06:14 <rosmaita> hopefully that will be useful to people and keep the etherpads un-messed-up
14:06:21 <jungleboyj> Yay Google Translate!
14:06:43 <LiangFang> google translate is powerful:)
14:06:51 <rosmaita> sure is!
14:07:18 <rosmaita> LiangFang: is Chinese like French, where there's a governing body that approves new words?
14:07:28 <rosmaita> i wonder if they'll introduce an 'etherpad' character
14:07:45 <rajinir> o/
14:07:57 <jungleboyj> After 3 weeks in Shanghai I have new appreciation for Google's power.
14:08:05 <rosmaita> :)
14:08:22 <rosmaita> ok, the PTG summary wiki page has been updated with virtual PTG info
14:08:33 <rosmaita> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/CinderUssuriPTGSummary
14:08:58 <rosmaita> it would be good for people to search for their names and/or irc nicks for Actions that they volunteered for
14:09:13 <rosmaita> you have to do both, i was kind of inconsistent using nicks and first names
14:09:29 <rosmaita> also, we have some actions that are looking for owners
14:09:36 <rosmaita> i put them into a handy etherpad
14:09:46 <rosmaita> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/cinder-ussuri-ptg-actions
14:10:33 <rosmaita> so please take a look ... if you missed the PTG or Virtual PTG and aren't clear on what the action items are, please ping me in IRC or ask at one of the cinder weekly meetings
14:10:35 <LiangFang> rosmaita: no governing body approves new words, lots of new words every month in network
14:11:02 <rosmaita> LiangFang: let me know if 'etherpad' shows up as a new word!
14:11:06 <smcginnis> :)
14:11:08 <jungleboyj> rosmaita:  Thanks for getting that put together so quickly.
14:11:16 <jungleboyj> LiangFang: ++
14:11:34 <jungleboyj> rosmaita: I will get the videos uploaded today.  Sorry I have been slow getting to that.
14:11:42 <LiangFang> :)
14:11:45 <rosmaita> jungleboyj: no problem, i know you've been busy
14:11:59 <smcginnis> jungleboyj: You have the power to get it done. ;)
14:12:03 <rosmaita> i'll send an update to the ML when we get the video links on the wiki page
14:12:14 <LiangFang> and the photo
14:12:28 <jungleboyj> He!
14:12:30 <rosmaita> LiangFang: noted!
14:12:42 <LiangFang> thanks
14:13:00 <jungleboyj> Yes I do. https://usercontent.irccloud-cdn.com/file/RKVQHqtz/image.png
14:13:10 <rosmaita> ok, the only other announcement i have is to save the dates for the Virtual Mid-Cycle
14:13:24 <rosmaita> we decided to do it as two 2-hour meetings, like the virtual PTG
14:13:28 <rosmaita> except spread out more
14:13:45 <rosmaita> first one will be either the 3rd or 4th week in January
14:13:55 <rosmaita> the spec freeze is last week of January
14:14:14 <rosmaita> i was thinking if we have it week before, we can address questions
14:14:23 <rosmaita> but that's awful soon
14:14:33 <rosmaita> so maybe last week in January is better
14:14:45 <rosmaita> let me know what you think
14:14:55 <rosmaita> i will send out a poll so we can determine the day and time
14:15:23 <rosmaita> the other session will be the week of 16 March
14:15:41 <rosmaita> that's on the Ussuri release schedule as the "Cinder new feature status checkpoint"
14:15:50 <rosmaita> so it makes sense to check in and see how things are going
14:16:01 <whoami-rajat> poll is good :)
14:16:18 <rosmaita> we'll do a poll for that one too, but closer to march
14:16:33 <jungleboyj> Sounds like a good plan.
14:16:46 * jungleboyj is sad I don't have an excuse to travel to RTP though.
14:16:46 <rosmaita> my point in bringing them up now is in case there's some kind of major event somewhere that would interfere with attendance
14:16:54 * rosmaita is too
14:17:33 <rosmaita> ok, that's all for announcements
14:17:44 <rosmaita> #topic Outreachy internship
14:17:48 <rosmaita> enriquetaso: that's you
14:17:57 <enriquetaso> ok
14:18:03 <enriquetaso> Welcome to Anastasiya ( anastzhyr ) !
14:18:13 <enriquetaso> yesterday was her first day !
14:18:13 <anastzhyr> Hello everyone!
14:18:18 <rosmaita> welcome!
14:18:19 <whoami-rajat> Welcome anastzhyr
14:18:19 <jungleboyj> anastzhyr: Welcome!
14:18:23 <davee_> welcome
14:18:28 <enriquetaso> From December to March Anastasiya will help us to improve Cinder Tempest.
14:18:40 <LiangFang> welcome
14:18:58 <enriquetaso> I think we'll use a launchpad tag to keet track of the test scenarios
14:19:07 <enriquetaso> Test and Tempest scenarios: https://bugs.launchpad.net/cinder/+bugs?field.tag=test-coverage. Feel free to add or tag any test idea.
14:19:40 <enriquetaso> that's all I have
14:19:57 <enriquetaso> :)
14:20:06 <jungleboyj> enriquetaso:  Thanks for being a mentor!
14:20:07 <rosmaita> thanks!
14:20:08 <tosky> thanks
14:20:25 <rosmaita> #topic question about cinder iSCSI
14:20:36 <rosmaita> #link https://review.opendev.org/#/c/685271/
14:20:49 <rosmaita> yangziguan: lvbin01: this is your topic
14:21:07 <yangziguan> rosmaita: yes
14:21:33 <yangziguan> in os.brick module ,   iscsi.py,   ISCSIConnector.connect_volume  will call   "_connect_to_iscsi_portal"  ( connect single path).  if you target portal not with "3260" ,  will endless loop.
14:22:28 <rosmaita> gerrit is loading really slowly for me
14:22:29 <yangziguan> in my commit, eric Mention of removing 3260 ,but i test ,  in _connect_to_iscsi_portal will endless loop
14:23:02 <yangziguan> multipath_connect have no problem
14:23:15 <geguileo> that is weird...
14:23:54 <yangziguan> eric mention of removing 3260 , want to support ipv6
14:23:56 <geguileo> they use the same code afaik
14:24:15 <geguileo> yangziguan: is this an IPv4 or IPv6 issue?
14:24:40 <yangziguan> is os.brick code issue
14:24:47 <yangziguan> not ipv6 issue
14:25:05 <geguileo> yangziguan: yes, but are you using IPv4 or IPv6
14:25:29 <yangziguan> ipv4 to test
14:25:45 <yangziguan> now i also want to support ipv6
14:26:03 <geguileo> which one is failing? IPv4 with single path?
14:26:06 <yangziguan> my product support ipv6 to iscsi
14:26:10 <yangziguan> ipv4
14:26:34 <yangziguan> i first join the meeting
14:26:46 <yangziguan> how to send a picture
14:27:20 <rosmaita> that is a good question
14:27:30 <rosmaita> jungleboyj: any suggestions?
14:27:42 <jungleboyj> :-)  In IRC?
14:27:51 <yangziguan> also i can sent to all use email
14:28:03 <jungleboyj> Hmmm, if you are using IRC cloud you just paste it into the chat.
14:28:14 <yangziguan> i send it to eric , but he don't reply to me
14:28:19 <rosmaita> i think my client is too primitive
14:28:30 <jungleboyj> That are upload it somewhere and share the link.
14:28:47 <geguileo> yangziguan: You can open a launchpad bug and attach files there
14:29:02 <rosmaita> geguileo: good suggestion!
14:29:27 <geguileo> yangziguan: https://bugs.launchpad.net/os-brick/+filebug
14:29:41 <yangziguan> hao de
14:29:43 <smcginnis> Apparently works for other backends, so something strange is going on here.
14:29:46 <yangziguan> ok
14:29:50 <geguileo> yangziguan: you write a one line summary, then a description, and then you can attach logs, images, etc
14:30:12 <rosmaita> we have a light agenda today, so if you want to do it now, that would be good
14:30:18 <geguileo> smcginnis: yes, I testted it both with single path and multipath, and worst case it doesn't connect
14:30:28 <geguileo> I've never seen it loop forever :-(
14:30:37 <geguileo> rosmaita: +1
14:31:07 <yangziguan> not with 3260 in portal
14:31:07 <rosmaita> yangziguan: while you are filing that bug and uploading the image, i will go to the next topic and then come back to you
14:31:17 <yangziguan> ok
14:31:29 <rosmaita> #topic EOL some branches follow-up
14:32:00 <rosmaita> we decided to EOL the driverfixes/m and /n and stable/o and /p
14:32:11 <rosmaita> i sent out a final note to the ML, and this time did get a response
14:32:26 <rosmaita> #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-discuss/2019-December/011349.html
14:32:55 <rosmaita> the upshot is that there is interest in keeping ocata and pike in Extended Maintenance mode
14:33:11 <rosmaita> i think that is fine, it will also keep cinder in sync with the other openstack projects
14:33:25 <rosmaita> tosky has a concern that ocata will start failing badly soon
14:33:37 <tosky> was there just the single answer? It would be interesting to know how long they plan to support both old branches
14:33:50 <rosmaita> but when that happens, we'll see what the openstack community wants to do
14:34:19 <rosmaita> tosky: i didn't ask because AFAIK, we would be the first project to EOL o and p
14:34:34 <tosky> re ocata: I think I mentioned it already; most of the changes related to zuulv3 (including devstack and tempest) are available (or have been backported) from pike onwards, ocata was caught in the transition
14:34:53 <tosky> it may simply happen that we decide to just drop everything which is not unit test and pep8
14:35:14 <tosky> that may be an acceptable solution according the definition of Extended Maintenance
14:35:30 <rosmaita> i believe that's acceptable based on my reading of the docs
14:35:47 <rosmaita> but on that note
14:35:58 <rosmaita> even the unit tests and pep8 are failing in driverfixes branches
14:36:10 <tosky> oh, I meant how long that specific operator who uses them is interested in them
14:36:26 <rosmaita> i tried a quick fix (run them on xenial) but it did not work
14:36:58 <rosmaita> tosky: yes, he did not say
14:37:46 <rosmaita> anyway, i kept a -W on my release patch to EOL m,n,o,p
14:38:18 <rosmaita> until monday coming up (9 December)
14:38:39 <rosmaita> we can see if anyone wants to step up and maintain driverfixes/newton
14:38:50 <rosmaita> but that looks unlikely at this point
14:39:10 <rosmaita> so my proposal is that we EOL driverfixes/* only
14:39:11 <tosky> rosmaita: re your fix, you may need to backport some flake8 constraints
14:39:18 <tosky> but yeah, let's see if there is interest
14:39:43 <rosmaita> tosky: that and it looked like there were some packages missing from the index on xenial
14:40:25 <rosmaita> although, i don't think we ever allowed windows line endings
14:40:45 <tosky> the package missing may have been a mirror issue; but again, let's see
14:41:12 <rosmaita> tosky: yes, it may or may not be easy to fix, i didn't want to get too far into it
14:41:27 <rosmaita> ok, so to summarize:
14:41:45 <rosmaita> i won't ask the release team to EOL anything until Monday 9 December
14:42:08 <rosmaita> and we will *not* EOL any stable branches
14:42:11 <rosmaita> just the driverfixes
14:42:28 <rosmaita> any thoughts?
14:43:13 <rosmaita> i guess i should say that implied in that is if someone steps up who wants to maintain driverfixes/newton, we'll discuss at next week's meeting
14:43:19 <tosky> can you please ask the question on how long they are interested in keeping ocata and pike?
14:43:21 <tosky> (or I can do it)
14:43:22 <jungleboyj> rosmaita:  That makes sense to me.
14:43:57 <rosmaita> tosky: if you don't mind, it will make it look like there's a wide community of interest
14:44:07 <tosky> oki
14:44:30 <rosmaita> although, i was going to reply after this meeting to say what we decided
14:44:42 <rosmaita> so i can ask as part of that
14:44:52 <rosmaita> and you can follow up if the answer isn't clear
14:45:07 <rosmaita> tosky: ^^
14:45:33 <rosmaita> ok, let's get back to the previous discussion
14:45:48 <yangziguan> https://bugs.launchpad.net/os-brick/+bug/1855126
14:45:48 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1855126 in os-brick "target portal not with "3260" , will endless loop" [Undecided,New]
14:45:59 <rosmaita> #topic question about cinder iSCSI continued
14:46:08 <rosmaita> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/os-brick/+bug/1855126
14:46:13 <rosmaita> thanks, yangziguan
14:47:38 <jungleboyj> Hmmm.
14:47:54 <rosmaita> btw, the code link is https://opendev.org/openstack/os-brick/src/branch/master/os_brick/initiator/connectors/iscsi.py#L1022-L1087
14:47:57 <jungleboyj> yangziguan:  For future reference you can provide reference to a line in git.
14:48:07 <jungleboyj> yangziguan:  Like rosmaita  Just did.  :-)
14:48:34 <rosmaita> so line 1071 is the problem?
14:48:57 <rosmaita> #link https://opendev.org/openstack/os-brick/src/branch/master/os_brick/initiator/connectors/iscsi.py#L1071
14:49:01 <yangziguan> yes
14:49:50 <geguileo> yangziguan: OK, thanks for the bug report!!!
14:51:36 <whfnst> Is there still time?
14:52:03 <yangziguan> iscsiadm -m session will   get ip:3260, but i not with 3260 ， then will goto endless loop
14:52:55 <geguileo> yangziguan: I understand...
14:54:14 <yangziguan> why you don't to encount it
14:54:30 <yangziguan> why you don't to encounter it
14:55:14 <LiangFang> means: why have not
14:55:53 <jungleboyj> Right.  Guessing no one has used something other than port 3260?
14:56:14 <geguileo> wait, I may be missing something
14:56:35 <geguileo> are you using something different than 3260 like 4444, or are you just not returning the port_
14:56:36 <geguileo> ?
14:56:51 <yangziguan> no
14:56:59 <yangziguan> alway use 3260
14:57:51 <rosmaita> looks like we may need some discussion on the bug report
14:58:09 <geguileo> yangziguan: do you have logs in DEBUG mode, please?
14:58:16 <rosmaita> #topic open discussion
14:58:21 <rosmaita> whfnst: did you have something?
14:58:25 <smcginnis> yangziguan: Feel free to bring up any of these questions in the #openstack-cinder channel. They don't need to wait for a meeting.
14:58:34 <rosmaita> smcginnis: ++
14:58:40 <whfnst> I have a question about volume host....
14:58:43 <yangziguan> I need to Reappearance
14:58:44 <smcginnis> And really probably shouldn't be in the meeting, since not everyone here needs to be debugging this together.
14:58:49 <geguileo> yangziguan: yes, please feel free to ping me to discuss this
14:58:55 <geguileo> smcginnis: +1
14:59:33 <jungleboyj> geguileo:  Thank you!
14:59:44 <geguileo> jungleboyj: np
15:00:05 <rosmaita> whfnst: let's take your question into the #openstack-cinder channel
15:00:11 <rosmaita> we're out of time here
15:00:17 <rosmaita> thanks, everyone!
15:00:22 <LiangFang> bye!
15:00:22 <rosmaita> #endmeeting