14:00:23 <ddieterl_> #startmeeting freezer
14:00:24 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Mar  3 14:00:23 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is ddieterl_. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:00:25 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:00:28 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'freezer'
14:00:36 <ddieterl_> hi everybody
14:00:45 <ddieterl_> can we get a show of attendees?
14:00:50 <ddieterl_> o/
14:01:17 <EinstCrazy> Today meeting not in openstack-meeting-alt?
14:01:23 <daemontool_> ddieterl_,  the meeting it on #openstack-meeting-alt
14:01:28 <ddieterly> why do we meet in the alt room
14:01:29 <daemontool_> s/it/is/
14:01:40 <ddieterly> #endmeeting
14:01:51 <daemontool_> because in openstack the project use the common rooms to do the meetings
14:01:55 <ddieterly> ok
14:02:19 <daemontool_> ddieterly,  http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/#Freezer_Meeting
14:20:17 <openstackgerrit> Deklan Dieterly proposed openstack/freezer-api: Introduce tempest tests  https://review.openstack.org/287369
14:33:27 <daemontool_> frescof, ping
15:00:56 <yangyapeng> ping EinstCrazy
15:01:24 <daemontool_> ok
15:01:26 <EinstCrazy> yes?
15:01:27 <daemontool_> so here we are
15:01:29 <daemontool_> yangyapeng,
15:01:37 <zhangjn> we can enable freezer-schedule in devstack.
15:01:38 <daemontool_> would you like to make that better
15:01:41 <daemontool_> yes
15:01:44 <daemontool_> zhangjn, yes
15:01:48 <yangyapeng> I think we should do a good job in devstack
15:01:54 <daemontool_> couldn't agree more
15:01:58 <yangyapeng> Can let others more simple to run freezer
15:02:47 <zhangjn> some problem in freezer-web-ui use devstack to install.
15:03:55 <zhangjn> freezer-web-ui is unavailable in master.
15:04:46 <zhangjn> who can review our devstack patch?
15:07:32 <daemontool_> zhangjn,  which one
15:07:35 <daemontool_> one sec
15:08:34 <zhangjn> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/265111/
15:09:25 <zhangjn> This is obvious bug.
15:12:55 <daemontool_> zhangjn, shouldn't be redirected to openstack/?
15:13:18 <zhangjn> This patch is ok
15:13:21 <daemontool_> ok
15:13:24 <daemontool_> yes yes
15:13:25 <daemontool_> sure
15:13:32 <daemontool_> but when you hit stackforge/
15:13:34 <zhangjn> but it's nobody to review.
15:13:39 <daemontool_> ok
15:13:41 <zhangjn> LOL
15:13:54 <daemontool_> the thing is the py34 job is failing
15:14:02 <daemontool_> I've rechecked it
15:14:17 <daemontool_> of course it can't be related to that change
15:14:22 <daemontool_> as it is very simple
15:14:32 <zhangjn> I got it, thx.
15:15:17 <zhangjn> have someone to review all summit patch everyday?
15:16:08 <zhangjn> Like other project
15:18:39 <zhangjn> m3m0, freezer-web-ui use freezer project as freezer_client in devstack.
15:21:18 <zhangjn> sudo -H -E pip install -e git+${FREEZER_CLIENT_REPO}@${FREEZER_CLIENT_BRANCH}#egg=freezer-origin_${FREEZER_CLIENT_BRANCH}  to install  is unnormal.
15:23:25 <daemontool_> zhangjn,  ok
15:26:39 <m3m0> the problem is that we don't have a pip version of freezer
15:26:59 <m3m0> so we need to do it by installing the source
15:27:25 <m3m0> zhangjn ^^
15:29:00 <zhangjn> I think install freezer-web-ui is not relate to freezer-client.
15:32:04 <m3m0> mmm it is, we need to install the freezer-client to communicate with the api
15:32:38 <zhangjn> now I will install twice freezer.
15:34:23 <zhangjn> otherwise freezer is not install in $DEST, it's unnormal in devstack.
15:38:15 <m3m0> but why twice? do you have 2 virtualenvs?
15:39:09 <zhangjn> devstack enable freezer, freezer-api, freezer-web-ui
15:39:30 <zhangjn> freezer install first, freezer-web-ui install another
15:43:06 <m3m0> oooook ok ok ok, so you think we should remove freezer installation from freezer-web-ui, do you want to do it?
15:46:13 <daemontool_> now it can be removed
15:46:18 <daemontool_> cause we have the python-freezerclient
15:46:23 <daemontool_> so do not need the agent and scheduler anymore
15:47:49 <zhangjn> we can define the require in requirements.txt.
15:48:21 <zhangjn> when freezer-client is work.
15:48:57 <daemontool_> ++
15:58:41 <zhangjn> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/287935/
15:59:17 <zhangjn> I summit a path set, pls to review it.
16:00:20 <daemontool_> zhangjn,  ok
16:01:10 <zhangjn> pls add workflow in this review:https://review.openstack.org/#/c/282215/
16:02:03 <daemontool_> ddieterly, currently freezer-api fails on the dsvm https://jenkins03.openstack.org/job/gate-freezer-api-devstack-dsvm/1/console
16:02:29 <m3m0> daemontool_: +2 and +A respectively
16:02:36 <m3m0> zhangjn: +2 and +A respectively
16:02:59 <zhangjn> thx
16:04:05 <daemontool_> m3m0,  referring to https://review.openstack.org/#/c/265111/
16:04:30 <daemontool_> zhangjn,  as soon as it is verified I'll approve it
16:09:33 <daemontool_> ddieterly,  what's the tempest related gate job that is enabled now?
16:09:47 <daemontool_> there's a path issue
16:23:55 <m3m0> that needs a rebase
16:24:01 <m3m0> sorry a recheck
16:24:10 <m3m0> it fail at the gates
16:27:38 <zhangjn> ERROR: InvocationError: '/bin/bash tools/pretty_tox.sh --concurrency=4 freezer_api_tempest_plugin'
16:28:05 <zhangjn> what about freezer_api_tempest_plugin?
16:29:41 <zhangjn> there is no test for freezer-api?
16:30:33 <zhangjn> post_test_hook.sh is null to test.
16:31:01 <daemontool_> I think is related to this change https://review.openstack.org/#/c/287486/1/jenkins/jobs/freezer.yaml
16:31:43 <ddieterl_> daemontool_: yes, i'm working on it
16:32:03 <ddieterl_> here is the new gate job: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/287486/
16:35:58 <daemontool_> ddieterl_,  np
16:36:07 <daemontool_> take all the time you need
16:36:12 <ddieterl_> lol
16:36:13 <ddieterl_> ok
16:36:23 <ddieterl_> i think this next run will work
16:36:37 <daemontool_> (fingerscrossed)
16:36:38 <ddieterl_> if the test fails, then the tests are running
16:36:39 <daemontool_> lol
16:37:01 <ddieterl_> i put assertequals(1,2)
16:37:08 <ddieterl_> we should see that failure in the gate
16:38:31 <daemontool_> ok
16:40:10 <zhangjn> :)
16:42:32 <ddieterly> success!
16:42:50 <ddieterly> the tempest plugin is running in the gate in freezer-api
16:43:18 <ddieterly> ==============================
16:43:18 <ddieterly> 2016-03-03 16:40:25.951 | Failed 1 tests - output below:
16:43:18 <ddieterly> 2016-03-03 16:40:25.951 | ==============================
16:43:20 <ddieterly> 2016-03-03 16:40:25.951 |
16:43:22 <ddieterly> 2016-03-03 16:40:25.951 | freezer_api_tempest_plugin.tests.api.test_api_version.TestFreezerApiVersion.test_api_version[gate]
16:43:24 <ddieterly> 2016-03-03 16:40:25.951 | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
16:43:26 <ddieterly> 2016-03-03 16:40:25.952 |
16:43:28 <ddieterly> 2016-03-03 16:40:25.952 | Captured traceback:
16:43:30 <ddieterly> 2016-03-03 16:40:25.952 | ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
16:43:32 <ddieterly> 2016-03-03 16:40:25.952 |     Traceback (most recent call last):
16:43:34 <ddieterly> 2016-03-03 16:40:25.952 |       File "/opt/stack/new/freezer-api/freezer_api/tests/freezer_api_tempest_plugin/tests/api/test_api_version.py", line 23, in test_api_version
16:43:36 <ddieterly> 2016-03-03 16:40:25.952 |         self.assertEqual(1, 2, 'First test case')
16:43:38 <ddieterly> 2016-03-03 16:40:25.952 |       File "/usr/local/lib/python2.7/dist-packages/testtools/testcase.py", line 362, in assertEqual
16:43:40 <ddieterly> 2016-03-03 16:40:25.952 |         self.assertThat(observed, matcher, message)
16:43:42 <ddieterly> 2016-03-03 16:40:25.952 |       File "/usr/local/lib/python2.7/dist-packages/testtools/testcase.py", line 447, in assertThat
16:43:44 <ddieterly> 2016-03-03 16:40:25.952 |         raise mismatch_error
16:43:46 <ddieterly> 2016-03-03 16:40:25.952 |     testtools.matchers._impl.MismatchError: 1 != 2: First test case
16:50:13 <ddieterly> daemontool_: i fixed the test to pass. if it passes, we can +2 the patch.
16:50:27 <ddieterly> then we can start to add tempest tests as needed
16:52:44 <daemontool_> sure
16:57:48 <openstackgerrit> Merged openstack/freezer: Add space to log message  https://review.openstack.org/285991
17:04:05 <openstackgerrit> Merged openstack/freezer: Add SSL support for freezer  https://review.openstack.org/278367
17:05:22 <daemontool_> vannif_, ping https://review.openstack.org/#/c/277352/
17:21:49 <ferhat> hello all
17:22:01 <ferhat> I did not know this channel exist
17:22:14 <ddieterly> ferhat: hello
17:22:24 <ferhat> thank you Fausto fro the info
17:23:13 <ferhat> and also thank for developing freezer. this is one of the most anticipated project from my side of view
17:23:53 <ferhat> I am having some trouble. I would be glad if some of you guys can lead me to right direction
17:24:10 <ddieterly> daemontool_: this is working now https://review.openstack.org/#/c/287369/6
17:24:16 <daemontool_> ferhat, I'm here
17:24:20 <daemontool_> ddieterly, +2ed
17:24:28 <daemontool_> if you have to send a new patchset
17:24:31 <ddieterly> graci
17:24:35 <daemontool_> please fix the README
17:24:35 <daemontool_> ok
17:24:45 <daemontool_> well done (thumbsup)
17:24:49 <daemontool_> ferhat,
17:25:01 <daemontool_> please do tell
17:25:03 <daemontool_> :)
17:25:08 <ferhat> we are planning to use freezer for our openstack enviroment.
17:25:13 <daemontool_> ok
17:25:24 <daemontool_> which release?
17:25:44 <ferhat> I have installed freezer-api v1.2.0 to our one of the controller
17:26:03 <ferhat> our openstack is kilo
17:26:26 <daemontool_> ok
17:26:40 <daemontool_> vannif_, ping ^^
17:26:47 <ferhat> I have followed the installation instruction on https://github.com/openstack/freezer-api/
17:27:00 <daemontool_> ok
17:27:13 <ferhat> and started freezer-api with "freezer-api 176.53.94.6"
17:27:26 <daemontool_> did you registered the freezer api endpoint to keystone?
17:27:31 <ferhat> yes I did
17:27:33 <daemontool_> ok
17:27:34 <daemontool_> :)
17:27:36 <ferhat> with following commend
17:27:49 <ferhat> keystone endpoint-create \   --service-id $(keystone service-list | awk '/ backup / {print $2}') \   --publicurl http://176.53.94.6:9090 \   --internalurl http://176.53.94.6:9090 \   --adminurl http://176.53.94.6:9090 \   --region RegionOne
17:27:56 <daemontool_> ok
17:28:11 <ferhat> and I am getting following error
17:28:12 <ferhat> http://176.53.94.6:9090/
17:28:19 <ferhat> Authentication required
17:28:53 <daemontool_> ok
17:29:01 <daemontool_> so you have sourced your OS credentials right?
17:29:02 <daemontool_> like
17:29:09 <daemontool_> env | grep ^OS
17:29:14 <daemontool_> you see OS_things
17:29:17 <daemontool_> ?
17:29:21 <ferhat> I have not
17:29:32 <daemontool_> ok so you need to have creedntials
17:29:37 <daemontool_> to do that
17:29:43 <daemontool_> do you have a user?
17:30:04 <ddieterly> daemontool_: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/287999/1
17:30:45 <daemontool_> otherwise from browser
17:30:48 <ferhat> let me check that
17:30:50 <daemontool_> you need to install the freezer-web-ui
17:30:51 <daemontool_> also
17:30:59 <daemontool_> but I'd like to understand
17:31:09 <daemontool_> what happen if you have the creds and try something like
17:31:09 <daemontool_> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/287999/1
17:31:11 <daemontool_> sorry
17:31:19 <daemontool_> freezer-scheduler client-list
17:31:33 <ferhat> OS_REGION_NAME=RegionOne OS_PROJECT_NAME=admin OS_PASSWORD= OS_AUTH_STRATEGY=keystone OS_AUTH_URL=http://192.168.0.2:5000/v2.0/ OS_USERNAME=admin OS_TENANT_NAME=admin OS_ENDPOINT_TYPE=internalURL OS_NO_CACHE=true
17:31:47 <ferhat> I have sourced following
17:32:06 <daemontool_> ok
17:32:56 <daemontool_> can you get the list of services endpoints?
17:33:09 <ferhat> sure let me get them
17:33:26 <daemontool_> something like
17:33:26 <daemontool_> openstack endpoint list
17:34:27 <ferhat> | 1b4014505c8b4537929cb88b0bdb8696 | freezer  |     backup     |      Freezer Backup Service      |
17:34:40 <ferhat> 77c382ef33e145d7a90d2e23eb38551d | RegionOne |            http://176.53.94.6:9090            |            http://176.53.94.6:9090            |            http://176.53.94.6:9090            | 1b4014505c8b4537929cb88b0bdb8696 |
17:34:51 <daemontool_> ok
17:34:54 <ferhat> last one is endpiont list
17:34:57 <daemontool_> if you execute the command
17:35:08 <daemontool_> freezer-scheduler client-list
17:35:56 <ferhat> before we go further. I do not have freezer scheduler installed on this server
17:36:16 <daemontool_> ok
17:36:28 <daemontool_> and the freezer-agent?
17:36:32 <daemontool_> or freezerc?
17:36:59 <ferhat> root@control01:~# freezer-scheduler client-list 2016-03-03 17:36:48.785 47531 ERROR freezer.scheduler.freezer_scheduler [-] Please provide valid keystone auth url with valid keystone api version to use Please provide valid keystone auth url with valid keystone api version to use
17:37:05 <ferhat> I get this
17:38:44 <daemontool_> if you execute
17:38:48 <daemontool_> swift list
17:38:51 <daemontool_> what do you get?
17:39:26 <ferhat> I get nothing
17:39:38 <daemontool_> no error
17:39:38 <daemontool_> ok
17:39:38 <ferhat> but if I execute nova list
17:39:53 <ferhat> I get my vms
17:39:56 <daemontool_> ok
17:40:12 <ferhat> I am also getting following error in the logs
17:40:12 <ferhat> 2016-03-03 17:38:48,585 keystonemiddleware.auth_token INFO Rejecting request
17:41:43 <daemontool_> mmhhh
17:41:46 <ferhat> keystonemiddleware.auth_token WARNING Configuring auth_uri to point to the public identity endpoint is required; clients may not be able to authenticate against an admin endpoint
17:41:49 <ferhat> and this one
17:42:00 <ferhat> keystonemiddleware.auth_token WARNING Using the in-process token cache is deprecated as of the 4.2.0 release and may be removed in the 5.0.0 release or the 'O' development cycle. The in-process cache causes inconsistent results and high memory usage. When the feature is removed the auth_token middleware will not cache tokens by default which may result in performance issues. It is recommended to use  memcache for the auth_
17:42:08 <ferhat> also this warning
17:43:07 <daemontool_> export OS_ENDPOINT_TYPE=publicURL
17:43:08 <daemontool_> try that
17:43:19 <daemontool_> and see if the error is still there
17:45:56 <ferhat> still getting same error
17:46:01 <daemontool_> export OS_IDENTITY_API_VERSION=2
17:47:24 <daemontool_> try that and then
17:47:43 <daemontool_> freezer-scheduler client-list
17:47:49 <ferhat> ok
17:47:50 <openstackgerrit> Saad Zaher proposed openstack/freezer: Adding option disable-exec to freezer-scheduler  https://review.openstack.org/288008
17:48:08 <daemontool_> szaher, ping
17:49:03 <szaher> daemontool_: pong
17:49:18 <daemontool_> szaher, do you have 10 minutes?
17:49:24 <szaher> Yes Sure
17:49:25 <daemontool_> I have to go home in 5 minutes it's 7 pm here
17:49:33 <szaher> Ok take your time
17:49:34 <daemontool_> can you provide some support to ferhat
17:49:39 <daemontool_> ?
17:49:44 <szaher> Ok
17:49:49 <daemontool_> we need to understand
17:49:51 <ferhat> thx deamontool
17:49:51 <daemontool_> if the scheduler
17:50:01 <daemontool_> can complete the authentication against the freezer api
17:50:08 <daemontool_> the freezer service is registered
17:50:14 <szaher> Ok
17:50:28 <daemontool_> with the other clients he can
17:50:29 <daemontool_> auth
17:50:50 <szaher> Ok no worries
17:50:55 <szaher> ferhat: Hi
17:51:10 <ferhat> hello szaher
17:51:19 <ferhat> thank you daemon
17:51:38 <szaher> Could you please, dump your config file and log file here http://paste.openstack.org/
17:51:44 <szaher> and pass me the link
17:52:14 <ferhat> freezer-ap.cfg?
17:53:19 <ferhat> http://paste.openstack.org/show/489198/
17:53:26 <szaher> /etc/freezer-api.conf
17:55:00 <ferhat> I can work with feezerc without any problem
17:57:12 <vannif_> hello.
17:57:21 <ferhat> hi vannif
17:57:23 <vannif_> yes. what about the freezer-api.conf ?
17:57:34 <szaher> ferhat: Can you try this http://paste.openstack.org/show/489203/ ?
17:58:03 <vannif_> if has configuration options for the database endpoint and the keystonemiddleware which manages the authentication on behalf of the API
17:58:04 <szaher> ferhat: Could you please, dump this log in paste and send us the link /var/log/freezer-api.log ?
17:59:37 <ferhat> ok will do
18:01:12 <ferhat> here is is the /var/log/freezer-api.log
18:01:17 <ferhat> http://paste.openstack.org/show/489204/
18:02:08 <ferhat> I have installed freezer-api in our horizon dashboard server.
18:02:31 <ferhat> this server also contains keystone swift and some other services
18:03:00 <szaher> did you try the new configurations I sent to you while ago ?
18:03:46 <ferhat> yes I did
18:04:09 <ferhat> the log file contains my last config change
18:04:59 <szaher> are you using devstack ?
18:06:25 <ferhat> no I am using Mirantis OpenStack 7
18:06:27 <ferhat> kilo release
18:06:40 <ferhat> the nodes have deployed with fuel infra
18:09:07 <szaher> and what is the problem you are facing for the time being ?
18:09:17 <daemontool_> szaher,  he cannot finalize the authentication
18:09:23 <daemontool_> against the freezer-api
18:10:07 <daemontool_> ferhat,  OS_PASSWORD= you have something there right?
18:10:16 <daemontool_> you just sanitized the value before is it?
18:11:23 <szaher> ferhat: could you please source openstack credentials and try the following command and let me know the result. freezer-scheduler job-list
18:11:56 <szaher> daemontool_: It's not an error. if you access freezer-api from http you will get the same message !
18:12:12 <ferhat> ok let me get them
18:12:24 <ferhat> I have my password on OS_PASSWORD
18:12:27 <ferhat> it is correct
18:12:48 <ferhat> I have sourced following env
18:13:28 <ferhat> http://paste.openstack.org/show/489205/
18:13:41 <ferhat> root@control01:~# freezer-scheduler job-list 2016-03-03 18:13:36.859 13850 ERROR freezer.scheduler.freezer_scheduler [-] Please provide valid keystone auth url with valid keystone api version to use Please provide valid keystone auth url with valid keystone api version to use
18:14:25 <ferhat> if you access freezer-api from http you will get the same message !
18:14:32 <ferhat> Authentication required
18:14:36 <daemontool_> ok ferhat
18:14:42 <daemontool_> unset OS_PROJECT_NAME
18:14:43 <daemontool_> and retry
18:15:06 <daemontool_> so you have
18:15:06 <daemontool_> export OS_TENANT_NAME='services'
18:15:06 <daemontool_> export OS_PROJECT_NAME='admin'
18:15:15 <daemontool_> unset OS_PROJECT_NAME
18:15:22 <daemontool_> export OS_TENANT_NAME=admin
18:15:32 <daemontool_> execute the last 2
18:15:48 <daemontool_> but I don't understand, it should work anyway
18:16:22 <szaher> ferhat: http://paste.openstack.org/show/489206/ run these commands in your terminal then freezer-scheduler job-list
18:17:17 <szaher> ferhat: Please, let me know the results when there are some
18:20:57 <ferhat> http://paste.openstack.org/show/489207/
18:21:04 <ferhat> getting 503
18:22:30 <szaher> logs ?
18:22:35 <szaher> api logs ?
18:23:22 <szaher> ferhat: do you copy ?
18:24:11 <ddieterly> daemontool_: can we get https://review.openstack.org/#/c/287369/ and https://review.openstack.org/#/c/287999/ out the door?
18:24:33 <ferhat> yes
18:24:38 <ferhat> let me get api logs
18:24:40 <szaher> ferhat: can you try again with these credentials http://paste.openstack.org/show/489208/
18:26:47 <ferhat> http://paste.openstack.org/show/489209/
18:27:43 <openstackgerrit> Saad Zaher proposed openstack/freezer: Adding option disable-exec to freezer-scheduler  https://review.openstack.org/288008
18:29:16 <szaher> ferhat: do you have keystone v3 enabled ?
18:29:59 <ferhat> http://176.53.94.3:5000/v3/
18:30:05 <ferhat> please check this page
18:35:07 <szaher> ferhat: Can you login to the dashboard ?
18:35:15 <szaher> Can you try keystone user-list
18:35:20 <szaher> can you try openstack user list
18:35:28 <szaher> let me know what is the result
18:36:14 <ferhat> yes I can login to dashboard
18:36:39 <ferhat> http://paste.openstack.org/show/489212/
18:37:30 <ferhat> do I have to install the api to same server horizon dashboard resides?
18:38:06 <ferhat> I am suspecting somethings is mixing up with openstack installation
18:41:25 <ferhat> [*] Critical Error: Container PUT failed: http://176.53.94.3:8080/v1/AUTH_c0852b6eb95b47e380446d26382a9f6d/freezer_backups 404 Not Found  [first 60 chars of response] <html><h1>Not Found</h1><p>The resource could not be found.<
18:42:11 <szaher> openstack user list
18:42:11 <szaher> Could not determine a suitable URL for the plugin
18:43:04 <szaher> It could be better if you installed the api on the same server where keystone resides
18:44:39 <ferhat> yes I have installed api in the server where keystone also installed
18:44:57 <ferhat> I think I am hitting some sort of bug.
18:48:42 <szaher> ferhat: I think keystone has a problem
18:48:50 <szaher> can you dump keystone logs ?
18:49:57 <szaher> I will take a look at it after 20 minutes, is that Ok ?
18:50:43 <ferhat> that would be ok
18:50:49 <ferhat> thank you for your time
18:53:55 <ferhat> keystone log http://paste.openstack.org/show/489218/
19:03:24 <ferhat> thank you for all of your help
20:26:41 <dhellmann> hi, folks, I'm looking for daemontool, do you know when he's usually online?
20:29:57 <dhellmann> are there any other freezer cores around who know about the release plans? I want to make sure you don't miss the release window today
21:13:19 <ddieterl_> dhellmann: daemontool is usually online in the morning in the us. he lives in italy.
21:29:23 <dhellmann> ddieterl_ : we haven't seen a milestone release proposal for freezer, are you planning one?
21:33:09 <ddieterl_> not sure
21:34:17 <ddieterl_> daemontool has stated that we need to respect the mitaka release schedule, so i think there is a plan for a milestone release proposal
21:34:44 <ddieterl_> unfortunately, i can't speak for daemontool, and i'm not core on freezer
21:43:11 <ddieterly> seeing this when trying to run freezer-api on mac os x
21:43:21 <ddieterly> Connected to pydev debugger (build 143.1919)
21:43:22 <ddieterly> Unable to start server: 'module' object has no attribute 'TCP_KEEPCNT'
21:43:30 <ddieterly> anyone know of a workaround?
21:45:27 <ddieterly> it looks like this problem https://bugs.launchpad.net/keystoneauth/+bug/1527131
21:45:28 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1527131 in keystoneauth "AttributeError: 'module' object has no attribute 'TCP_KEEPCNT'" [Undecided,Fix released] - Assigned to Federico Ressi (federico-ressi-9)
01:06:48 <zhangjn> who can add workflow this review:https://review.openstack.org/#/c/287935/