04:00:05 #startmeeting fwaas 04:00:06 Meeting started Wed Oct 12 04:00:05 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is njohnston. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 04:00:07 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 04:00:09 The meeting name has been set to 'fwaas' 04:00:26 Hello All 04:00:30 Good morning 04:00:34 Hi All 04:00:37 or evening, as the case may be 04:00:41 #chair SridarK 04:00:42 Current chairs: SridarK njohnston 04:01:04 #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/fwaas-meeting meeting agenda 04:01:19 njohnston: thanks as always 04:01:35 my pleasure 04:02:02 #topic neutron stadium requirements 04:02:44 #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/383881/ 04:03:09 The meeting etherpad has a breakdown of all the places where we do not meet the stadium requirements as noted in Armando's assessment. 04:03:50 this lists the pending requirements for compliance and stadium inclusion and njohnston has captured the shortfalls in the etherpad 04:04:00 ok 04:04:25 njohnston: & I also discussed this and we felt that we have a good chance to get this satisfied before the deadline of Nov 14 04:04:35 basically Ocata-1 04:05:16 There are some unowned items 04:05:26 And if youw ant to chip in with an item that has someone 04:05:36 someone's name, sync with them and split up the work 04:05:39 I am happy that Armando gave us credit for having "made quite a progress during the Newton cycle". 04:05:47 +1 04:06:04 great 04:06:12 Nice 04:06:44 Yes pls feel free to add urself and help out with any of these tasks 04:06:46 specifically we don't have anyone tagged to update the api-ref documentation to add info about fwaas v2 (item D2) 04:07:08 and we don't have anyone looking at multinode CI, which I will admit is a bit of a daunting task 04:07:57 never mind, Chandan is going to look at multinode CI! I think the networking-ovn project may have an example of multinode that we can look at 04:08:08 ya just added 04:08:23 cool, will have a look 04:08:57 chandanc: great, i am not sure if there are some folks that have done this for our internal vendor CI - i will ask 04:09:20 and let u know if there is something useful 04:09:23 oh ok, that will be great help 04:11:25 i think this should be a very high priority objective for us 04:11:41 ok 04:11:52 njohnston: anything else to add on this topic 04:12:00 no sir 04:12:16 ok lets move on 04:12:24 #topic FWaaS v2 04:12:51 padkrish: sorry i could not connect with u today on the debugging 04:13:10 for the L2agent - db interaction 04:13:12 SridarK# It's ok....i was able to proceed 04:13:22 we can do this tomorrow if u still need somethings looked at 04:13:35 yes, we should.. 04:13:42 but pls go ahead with any updates or things u want discuss 04:14:17 i sent another patch for l2 agent extension, wherein was able to test a simple case of handle_port notification 04:14:39 ofcourse, the driver calls are not tested for now :) 04:15:14 just a create port, which lands in fwaas extension, which does a RPC to plugin, retrieves the FWG attributes and stores it locally is tested 04:15:46 That is very promising :-) 04:15:56 in the plugin, i need a handler to retrieve FWG given a port... 04:15:57 padkrish: ok great, we can worry abt the driver later 04:16:10 padkrish: ok 04:16:23 i think i had a method for this 04:16:33 i had some problems, using the mixin...just got around it by directly calling the db calls for now :)...this is what SridarK was referring to 04:16:44 this will be in another patch 04:17:01 to ensure that before we associate a fwg we want to make sure there isn't one on it already 04:17:07 we may need to tweak that 04:17:14 we can certainly debug that 04:18:08 anything else to discuss on this ? 04:19:42 i also have this in the etherpad 04:19:42 SridarK# sure 04:19:42 then, i will push another patch for the FW attribute changes...for now, we will just use RPC and not versioned objects 04:19:43 nope, feel free to comment on the etherpad and patch :) 04:19:52 ok cool 04:19:56 sorry, got disconnected for a bit 04:20:00 that's all from me 04:20:07 thx padkrish 04:20:22 chandanc: SarathMekala: pls go ahead on the iptables 04:20:45 SridarK, the contrack patch is fixed now with the UTs 04:21:04 chandanc: yes saw that and nice and thx for the email 04:21:08 reaching out 04:21:11 I have pinged Kevin over mail, will ping him on IRC 04:21:23 yes that will be more effective 04:21:40 thx chandanc: 04:21:44 ya, i still have to fix the UTs on the IPTables manager patch 04:22:01 should be done this week, 04:22:21 that area has still some UTs pending fixes 04:22:24 ok cool, i know u guys probab also had local holidays over the last few days 04:22:32 but if anyone can help with getting some time from kevin, it will be great 04:23:06 also, if you are going to the Summit, please put a word to kevin, i will make sure that i ping him on IRC before that 04:23:15 chandanc: surely, try pinging him on IRC, he is usually around and very helpful 04:23:16 will do 04:23:53 yes, we had the big festivals going on last week 04:24:00 :) 04:24:14 thx chandanc SarathMekala 04:24:24 SridarK, will surely ping him 04:24:29 ok 04:24:49 I dont have much update otherwise 04:24:59 i think yushiro should be back end of the week and we can hopefully get the CLI patch moving again 04:25:03 no updates from my side either 04:25:22 SridarK, He will be back from tomorrow 04:25:35 hoangcx: thx much for the heads up 04:25:40 +1 04:26:04 i think thats about all i had on v2 04:26:50 njohnston: pls go ahead on other topics u want to discuss 04:26:56 Thanks, SridarK 04:27:06 hi 04:27:18 reedip: hi 04:27:19 #topic miscellany 04:27:22 hi reedip 04:27:32 reedip: yes i need to get to the review 04:27:56 First, I just wanted to note that we only have 19 weeks left in the Ocata cycle. 04:28:24 and I for one will be gone for two of them, in late December 04:28:32 Including Christmas, thanksgiving, Summit... 04:28:52 so so we should keep our focus high and our expectations low for Ocata :-) 04:29:04 +1 04:29:35 In the neutron team meeting earlier today ihrachys mentioned that the theme for this release is "to make this cycle more calm, stabilizing things and completing features that were incomplete in Newton" 04:29:56 #link http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/networking/2016/networking.2016-10-11-14.01.log.html starting at 14:16:29 04:30:34 i would echo, that for Ocata - our focus should be to put the wraps on few missing things and also do more testing 04:31:56 I think that is it for now from me, just wanted to pass those along 04:32:01 while it is good to start planning for more features for P and do the ground work - realistically the time is quite tight 04:32:13 and we can focus on stability 04:32:13 I will email the group with new kinds of testing as they become operative 04:32:23 per the stadium work 04:32:23 sounds good 04:32:30 ok 04:32:52 oh, and you should be aware that there are now 2 tempest jobs - one that runs the tests against fwaas v1, and one that runs tests against fwaas v2 04:32:57 reedip: i will get back to u on #link https://review.openstack.org/370731 04:33:03 this needs more work 04:33:12 SridarK_ no worries :) 04:33:21 i am a bit swamped but have not forgotten 04:34:10 i had nothing else major to say as well 04:34:49 sounds like we can close the meeting early 04:34:53 thanks all! 04:35:21 yes i think so, unless anyone wants to discuss anything else 04:35:44 nothing from my side 04:35:54 padkrish: we will sync tomorrow 04:36:10 sure SridarK# 04:36:31 ok then looks like we can end early, thanks all for joining 04:36:52 #endmeeting