14:00:33 <SridarK> #startmeeting fwaas
14:00:34 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Mar  1 14:00:33 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is SridarK. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:00:35 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:00:37 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'fwaas'
14:00:44 <SridarK> #chair xgerman_ yushiro
14:00:45 <openstack> Current chairs: SridarK xgerman_ yushiro
14:01:17 <SridarK> Lets do a quick mtg mainly to sync up with xgerman_ and yushiro from PTG
14:01:23 <SridarK> #topic PTG
14:01:39 <yushiro> Thanks SridarK.  Let me sync up current status.
14:01:47 <xgerman_> iPad/
14:01:51 <SridarK> are u guys having a productive PTG
14:02:04 <yushiro> :)
14:02:06 <xgerman_> Hi
14:02:08 <chandanc> Hello All
14:02:15 <yushiro> Hi chandanc
14:02:22 <chandanc> hello yushiro
14:02:26 <xgerman_> Ok, so Dublin is a mess. No flights, no hotels…
14:02:48 <SridarK> xgerman_: oh really
14:03:24 <xgerman_> Sadly…
14:03:33 <yushiro> Due to heavy snow, PTG for today is over(17:00 --> 14:00)
14:04:27 <SridarK> oh boy
14:04:57 <yushiro> So, tomorrow's schedule is under consideration for The OpenStack Foundation.  There is a plan to continue the meeting by taking place to another.
14:05:15 <xgerman_> yeah, curfew beginning 3 pm
14:05:25 <SridarK> sigh that is a mess
14:05:46 <yushiro> xgerman_, Are you OK to your flight?
14:05:57 <SridarK> Is weather expected to clear up for u guys to leave on Fri/Sat
14:06:17 <xgerman_> no, had to rebook to Sunday
14:06:23 <yushiro> SridarK, Yes.  I'll leave at Sat.  but there is a strike at London :(
14:06:36 <xgerman_> Sat is canceld for most of us as well
14:06:36 <SridarK> ouch
14:06:49 <yushiro> Sad Sat. :(
14:07:37 <SridarK> stay safe and i hope u guys can have some flights
14:07:38 <yushiro> xgerman_, OK..
14:07:56 <yushiro> Yes. I hope so.
14:08:25 <yushiro> OK, Please take a look https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/neutron-ptg-rocky   at L.274
14:08:59 <yushiro> and L.183
14:09:25 <SridarK> Ah stateless Firewalling
14:09:38 <SridarK> basically like an ACL
14:09:45 <SridarK> and no state
14:09:54 <yushiro> Our agenda is added 2 topics.  1st: stateless firewalling,   2nd: Common Classifier Framework(CCF)
14:10:14 <yushiro> SridarK, Yes, I think so too. (stateless = ACL)
14:10:37 <xgerman_> +1
14:10:41 <SridarK> ok that we can look at if someone wants it and has an usecase
14:10:48 <xgerman_> Internet is getting flaky here
14:10:56 <SridarK> xgerman_: ok
14:11:00 <yushiro> ndefigueiredo here?
14:11:31 <ndefigueiredo> Hi, yes.
14:12:26 <SridarK> ndefigueiredo: hi
14:12:45 <yushiro> ndefigueiredo, Thanks for adding your topic.  Could you add this topic into https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/fwaas-rocky-planning  ?
14:13:01 <yushiro> ndefigueiredo, And,  could you tell us a usecase for it?
14:13:25 <yushiro> ndefigueiredo, Regarding usecase, it's also OK to write on etherpad(https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/fwaas-rocky-planning)
14:13:42 <SridarK> yes on etherpad would be fine too
14:13:47 <ndefigueiredo> Essentially stateless firewalling would be like an ACL. The implementation would take advantage of matching on TCP flags to perform a pseudo firewall.
14:14:13 <SridarK> ndefigueiredo: but no conn track ?
14:14:28 <ndefigueiredo> I will add more detail / thoughts to the etherpad.
14:14:34 <SridarK> just match on the TCP flags amont other things
14:14:39 <SridarK> *among
14:14:46 <ndefigueiredo> No conntrack, yes.
14:15:10 <xgerman_> ok
14:15:11 <SridarK> ndefigueiredo: also if u could add the best way to contact u if we need more discussion that will be great
14:15:11 <yushiro> +1.  Please add a usecase not to use "conntrack".
14:15:23 <xgerman_> +1
14:15:27 <ndefigueiredo> ok
14:16:23 <SridarK> anything else u would like to discuss here ndefigueiredo
14:17:05 <ndefigueiredo> do you mean in the FWaaS session?
14:17:42 <yushiro> ndefigueiredo, on etherpad and FwaaS session :)
14:18:09 <SridarK> ndefigueiredo: yes and i also meant here in this mtg
14:18:16 <xgerman_> yes
14:18:20 <yushiro> +1
14:18:35 <SridarK> but i think if would like put some details on etherpad that is fine
14:18:42 <ndefigueiredo> nothing I can think of right now
14:18:48 <SridarK> ok
14:18:58 <SridarK> lets move on CCF
14:19:16 <SridarK> xgerman_: yushiro: how do u see the adoption moving forward ?
14:19:23 <SridarK> for CCF
14:19:33 <SridarK> should we prioritize it ?
14:20:10 <SridarK> i think if we see momentum towards that across all services - we should do it
14:20:22 <SridarK> now that L2 is done
14:20:51 <yushiro> SridarK,  David and Isaku will explain about current status of CCF and something.  Unfortunately, I don't know much information about that.
14:21:03 <SridarK> yushiro: ok
14:21:12 <SridarK> once u discuss with them we can plan
14:21:23 <xgerman_> ok, I need to dig into that, too — still busy with LBaaS
14:21:24 <yushiro> SridarK, sure, OK.
14:21:42 <SridarK> if CCF is ready and there is a push for that - we can pick that up
14:21:43 <xgerman_> yeah, we should sit down with him here
14:21:46 <yushiro> xgerman_, OK.  I know you're very busy :)
14:22:04 <xgerman_> SridarK: +1
14:23:10 <yushiro> I'll try to reach out to Davit about tomorrow's schedule.
14:23:43 <xgerman_> k
14:23:49 <yushiro> In addition, when should we start? :)  I heard that Croke park will open at 8:30.
14:24:18 <yushiro> Therefore, 8:30 is the fastest time to start meeting.
14:24:33 <yushiro> But now sure tomorrow is available or not.
14:24:47 <SridarK> ok
14:25:22 <SridarK> maybe given the chaos there at PTG - do we really want to do the call again during ur daytime tomorrow
14:25:25 <xgerman_> we can start earlier but meet in the lobby
14:25:41 <SridarK> I was going to ask before setting up the WebEx
14:25:58 <SridarK> I am thinking we can just connect after u guys are back
14:26:09 <xgerman_> if we start before others we will have good Internet ;-)
14:26:14 <yushiro> xgerman_, You mean "lobby" is croke park hotel?
14:26:19 <xgerman_> yes
14:26:22 <yushiro> xgerman_, OK
14:27:22 <yushiro> So, time is not change, right? --> 8:00 am
14:27:30 <xgerman_> yes
14:27:42 <yushiro> OK
14:27:46 <xgerman_> let’s do 8 am in the library at the ground floor
14:28:01 <yushiro> I will update on etherpad in Neutron PTG.
14:28:10 <xgerman_> Thanks!!
14:28:59 <yushiro> DONE
14:29:03 <SridarK> xgerman_: yushiro: Do u want me to set a WebEx for the rest of us ?
14:29:15 <SridarK> or do u think there is too much chaos already
14:29:31 <xgerman_> that early we should have good bandwith
14:29:32 <SridarK> and we can do it after u guys get back home
14:29:51 <yushiro> SridarK, I'd like to!  But not decided yet that we can use any suitable room or not.
14:30:22 <SridarK> yushiro: ok
14:30:37 <yushiro> I'll ping you if any update from the Foundation.
14:30:43 <SridarK> yushiro: ok
14:30:47 <yushiro> s/ping/sync up
14:30:57 <xgerman_> ok, I think 8 am we should have our pick
14:31:07 <yushiro> xgerman_, +1
14:31:13 <SridarK> my feeling is that most likely from past experience - audio is going to be bad
14:32:17 <xgerman_> +1
14:32:35 <yushiro> :)
14:33:01 <yushiro> I just recovered from jet-lag so it's easy to get up early :)
14:34:45 <SridarK> So unless u really see a need for the call - i propose that u guys interface with the CCF folks and we can pick up the conversation next week
14:35:27 <SridarK> chandanc: will u be able to attend ?
14:36:06 <SridarK> alternatively i will set it up and log on and see if u guys are able to find a proper place and get on
14:36:08 <ndefigueiredo> SridarK: sry, didn't realise you wanted to discuss it here too
14:36:26 <chandanc> SridarK: should be able to
14:36:31 <xgerman_> sweet
14:36:43 <SridarK> we can keep it best effort - so u guys are not under  pressure in case internet is bad or u dont find a place
14:37:09 <chandanc> +1
14:37:15 <SridarK> ndefigueiredo: if u want to or etherpad is fine too
14:38:25 <ndefigueiredo> busy adding detail now
14:40:19 <SridarK> ndefigueiredo: yes no issues - u can add it and maybe if u attend this meeting next week - we can discuss more as well
14:40:52 <SridarK> ndefigueiredo: if u can connect with xgerman_ & yushiro in Dublin tomorrow that will be great too
14:41:04 <yushiro> +100 Yes
14:41:21 <xgerman_> yes, I am in the 4th floor lounge
14:41:45 <SridarK> Ok i will setup a WebEX for 8am UTC and share it with the FWaaS team
14:42:00 <yushiro> SridarK, Thank you
14:42:08 <SridarK> and lets keep it best effort given the weather in Dublin
14:42:28 <yushiro> yes.  That is,  Snowpenstack.
14:42:29 <SridarK> in case u guys are not able to make it - or audio is bad - we will connect next week
14:42:38 <SridarK> yushiro: :-)
14:42:47 <yushiro> haha
14:43:04 <njohnston> I'd like to join the webex too, if you don't mind :-)
14:43:15 <SridarK> ah njohnston: surely
14:43:20 <yushiro> njohnston, Super welcome!!!
14:43:41 <njohnston> :-)
14:44:26 <ndefigueiredo> SridarK: yes, my intention was to get some face time tomorrow and I will definitely attend the IRC meetings.
14:44:37 <SridarK> ndefigueiredo: ok perfect
14:44:59 <SridarK> anything else we want to sync on ?
14:45:45 <SridarK> If nothing else we can wrap it up
14:45:52 <yushiro> 1 thing!  Guiness beer was ultimately great.  :p
14:46:03 <SridarK> :-)
14:46:24 <yushiro> Thanks. That's all for me.
14:46:33 <SridarK> stay safe guys and i hope u will be able to get back home with all the flights and choas
14:46:43 <SridarK> bye all thanks for attending
14:46:48 <SridarK> #endmeeting