14:00:44 <yushiro> #startmeeting fwaas 14:00:45 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Mar 15 14:00:44 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is yushiro. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 14:00:46 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 14:00:48 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'fwaas' 14:01:07 <SarathMekala> hi all o/ 14:01:12 <yushiro> #chair xgerman_ njohnston 14:01:12 <openstack> Current chairs: njohnston xgerman_ yushiro 14:01:39 <yushiro> I don't see SridarK today.. 14:02:05 <xgerman_> daylight savings confuses everyone 14:02:36 <chandanc> xgerman_: +1 14:02:45 <yushiro> +1 14:02:50 <yushiro> #chair SridarK 14:02:50 <SridarK> Hi All 14:02:51 <openstack> Current chairs: SridarK njohnston xgerman_ yushiro 14:03:02 <yushiro> Hi SridarK good timing :) 14:03:07 <SridarK> :-) 14:03:17 <yushiro> OK, let's begin 14:03:18 <njohnston> hello all :-) 14:03:35 <yushiro> Hi njohnston ! 14:03:49 <chandanc> hello ndefigueiredo 14:03:55 <annp> Hi 14:04:02 <chandanc> njohnston: 14:04:08 <chandanc> sorry auto correct 14:04:14 <njohnston> :-) 14:04:25 <yushiro> #topic announcements 14:05:00 <xgerman_> neutrin is renaming q-> neutron 14:05:00 <yushiro> We're now R-1 cycle now. 14:05:25 <yushiro> xgerman_, +1 14:05:39 <yushiro> #link https://releases.openstack.org/rocky/schedule.html 14:06:11 <yushiro> "R-1" is 16-20th Apr. 14:06:16 <doude> Hi o/ 14:06:34 <xgerman_> voting for S is open… 14:07:42 <yushiro> Yes, please vote "S" naming candidate... :) 14:09:37 <yushiro> a 14:10:23 <yushiro> In addition, travel support program for OpenStack Vancouver is up to March 22th. 14:10:40 <xgerman_> mmh, when will they announce speakers? 14:10:50 <yushiro> #link https://www.openstack.org/summit/vancouver-2018/visa-and-travel-support/ 14:10:56 <SridarK> shd be soon 14:11:40 <yushiro> I hope so :) I don't get any response.. 14:12:15 <yushiro> OK, anything else to announce? 14:12:33 <yushiro> OK, let's move on 14:12:42 <yushiro> #topic Rocky 14:14:16 <yushiro> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/550822/ 14:14:48 <yushiro> Thanks chandanc for your patch. This patch has merged and now backported into stable/queens 14:14:55 <SridarK> +1 14:15:03 <njohnston> +1 14:15:06 <yushiro> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/552390/1 14:15:11 <chandanc> thanks yushiro and all for reviews 14:15:17 <yushiro> NP :p 14:15:23 <SridarK> chandanc: thx for updating the bug as well - will be good to hear back from the submitter 14:15:35 <chandanc> SridarK: +1 14:15:44 <yushiro> SridarK, chandanc +1 Yes, it is reasonable. 14:16:19 <SridarK> i wonder how we have not hit this before 14:16:25 <xgerman_> +1 14:16:59 <yushiro> Yes, that's strange 14:17:17 <xgerman_> only tells us we need more tests… 14:17:46 <yushiro> +1 Yes, we're lucky to realize that we need more tests :) 14:17:46 <chandanc> i saw it due to multicast packets, may be triggered by vrrp config in router 14:18:07 <SridarK> +1 on more tests 14:18:16 <chandanc> agree 14:18:21 <SridarK> chandanc: yes but that should be fairly common 14:18:34 <chandanc> ya, i thought so 14:18:45 <SridarK> will be good to keep an eye 14:18:59 <yushiro> So, sorry I didn't backport into stable/pike. I will it in tomorrow. 14:19:21 <yushiro> It is necessary to fix merge conflict :p 14:20:49 <yushiro> #link https://releases.openstack.org/ 14:21:21 <yushiro> This is release status for each series. 14:22:34 <yushiro> So, I'll take care not only queens but pike. 14:22:58 <xgerman_> sounds good 14:23:06 <yushiro> OK, next 14:23:24 <yushiro> Pluggable backend driver https://review.openstack.org/#/c/480265/ 14:23:46 <doude> RFE was approved by the Neutron Driver team 14:23:51 <yushiro> doude, hi 14:24:07 <SridarK> yes approval went thru quite easily no issues 14:24:09 <doude> https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1702312 14:24:10 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1702312 in neutron "[RFE][FWaaS v2] Does not work with core plugin non based on Neutron DB model" [Wishlist,In progress] - Assigned to Édouard Thuleau (ethuleau) 14:24:12 <SridarK> thx doude 14:24:12 <doude> thanks SridarK 14:24:17 <yushiro> doude, Thanks 14:24:35 <doude> I rebased the patch with master yesterday 14:24:52 <SridarK> doude: i have started looking at it 14:24:59 <doude> and this morning because I made an error in conflict resolution 14:25:05 <doude> cool SridarK 14:25:08 <SridarK> lets have a plan with some testing as well 14:25:17 <xgerman_> +1 14:25:34 <doude> yes there is an etherpad to laist them https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/fwaas-pluggable-backend-testing 14:25:55 <yushiro> doude, +11 14:26:00 <xgerman_> +1 14:26:22 <SridarK> we discussed if it would make sense to break up the patch - for easier review - but this may not be very easy 14:26:27 <doude> btw, the CI seems broken actually. Jobs fail during venv dependencies installation on my last patch set http://logs.openstack.org/65/480265/18/check/openstack-tox-py27/e0af4f5/job-output.txt.gz#_2018-03-15_10_36_04_636780 14:26:38 <SridarK> so we will stick with the current version 14:26:44 <yushiro> current neutron error from CI was "Could not satisfy constraints for 'neutron': installation from path or url cannot be constrained to a version" This error doesn't releate your patch. 14:26:56 <SridarK> doude: yes nothing is moving fwd 14:27:03 <doude> ok 14:27:11 <xgerman_> we had to replace the cloner with something else 14:27:15 <xgerman_> there should be patches 14:27:16 <SridarK> yushiro: & i have been looking at another patch related to DVR 14:27:24 <xgerman_> (in LBaaS) 14:27:45 <yushiro> Yes. 14:28:06 <xgerman_> DVR is the devil 14:28:17 <SridarK> :-) 14:28:21 <chandanc> :) 14:28:23 <doude> yes and I also reviewed it in n8g-bgpvpn for that 14:28:40 <doude> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/553017/ 14:28:43 <yushiro> DVL vs DVR :) 14:30:20 <yushiro> anyway, I'll review doude etherpad for testing 14:30:41 <doude> thx yushiro 14:31:24 <SridarK> +1 14:32:01 <yushiro> After that, I'll review your patch about testing. 14:32:17 <yushiro> Hopefully, we can merge your patch until early R-1 14:32:41 <yushiro> OK, next 14:32:56 <yushiro> #topic Horizon support 14:32:57 <doude> I've some work for the rest of the week, I plan to continuing testing my patch next week 14:33:19 <yushiro> doude, I see. 14:33:45 <yushiro> SarathMekala, Hi. Do you have any announce? 14:34:16 <SarathMekala> no yushiro .. I was totally tied up since quite some time 14:34:59 <yushiro> SarathMekala, Oh, OK no problem ! 14:35:18 <SridarK> SarathMekala: if u can evaluate if there are any gaps related to L2 support that will be good 14:35:38 <SarathMekala> sure SridarK.. will do 14:35:51 <SridarK> thx SarathMekala 14:35:56 <yushiro> +1 SarathMekala 14:36:37 <SarathMekala> I will sync up with yushiro and amotoki on mail regarding the dashboard and see what I can pickup 14:36:54 <yushiro> +1 14:36:57 <xgerman_> +1 14:37:57 <yushiro> #topic testing 14:38:45 <SridarK> I will start a first pass on some tempest scenarios 14:39:50 <yushiro> SridarK, +1 14:40:05 <xgerman_> +1 14:40:08 <SridarK> I think we have some basic scenarios for L3 but nothing related to L2 support 14:40:11 <xgerman_> once we have a basis we can all fill in 14:40:26 <SridarK> +1 we can keep adding 14:40:28 <xgerman_> SridarK: they also rewrote tempest n Queens so you might need to start over 14:40:53 <SridarK> xgerman_: yes i think some API changes 14:42:43 <yushiro> In addition, Thanks for your update, njohnston fullstack testing https://review.openstack.org/#/c/394619/ 14:42:48 <xgerman_> yeah, I didn’t spend too much on that bit my LBaaS friends had to rewrite all tests 14:43:08 <njohnston> yushiro: Actually, it looks like that has been superceded by https://review.openstack.org/#/c/527627/ possibly? 14:43:26 <xgerman_> yes, redip was working onn it for a while as well 14:43:47 <njohnston> So I am comparing the changes, looks like the newer one has some fixes. 14:44:19 <SridarK> we can confirm with reedip as well - i think he has been busy on some other stuff 14:44:32 <njohnston> Thanks SridarK! 14:44:46 <yushiro> njohnston, aha, OK. That's why you are rechecking 2 patches :) 14:45:06 <SridarK> njohnston: i am not sure that he had much bandwidth to move fwd significantly 14:45:24 <xgerman_> this is myb understanding as well 14:46:04 <yushiro> SridarK, I'll reach out to him about that on FB. 14:47:12 <SridarK> "Like" ;-) 14:48:03 <njohnston> :-) 14:48:41 <yushiro> haha :) 14:48:44 <yushiro> #topic bugs 14:51:09 <yushiro> https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1752006 14:51:10 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1752006 in neutron "[FWaaS] firewall l2 agent extension is not compatible with LinuxBridge agent" [High,Confirmed] - Assigned to Nguyen Phuong An (annp) 14:52:25 <yushiro> annp, I think this bug has already fixed by https://review.openstack.org/#/c/548195/ 14:53:24 <annp> yushiro, Yes. 14:53:36 <yushiro> ok 14:53:54 <yushiro> #topic Open Discussion 14:54:18 <yushiro> 6 minutes left :p 14:56:39 <yushiro> silent night :) 14:56:45 <ndefigueiredo> I have something 14:56:45 <SridarK> :-) 14:56:55 <ndefigueiredo> I added links to the etherpad 14:56:56 <yushiro> Hi ndefigueiredo 14:56:57 <annp> :) 14:56:58 <SridarK> ndefigueiredo: hi - i saw ur email 14:57:13 <ndefigueiredo> great, I just wanted to make sure you are aware of it 14:57:16 <SridarK> so it seems there is a proposal in SG to do stateless as well 14:57:24 <yushiro> Yes, I saw it too. 14:57:34 <ndefigueiredo> yes, but I think fwaas is a better approach 14:58:13 <SridarK> I saw ur update but no response from the folks (Nokia ?) if there is a reason why they prefer SG 14:58:42 <ndefigueiredo> I am not sure, it seems like they are not aware of fwaas. 14:58:48 <SridarK> hmm ok 14:58:56 <ndefigueiredo> also, no response yet 14:59:27 <ndefigueiredo> they were not aware of the PTG discussion at least 14:59:44 <SridarK> When u are ready - perhaps file a RFE bug 14:59:49 <xgerman_> +1 15:00:00 <xgerman_> and we need to do some more advertisment for FWaaS 15:00:02 <yushiro> +1 15:00:07 <SridarK> and since this was discussed with the PTL during PTG 15:00:17 <SridarK> xgerman_: +1 15:00:32 <yushiro> Ok, this is our time 15:00:35 <njohnston> thanks all! 15:00:38 <yushiro> Thanks all!!!! 15:00:41 <yushiro> #endmeeting