14:00:07 <SridarK> #startmeeting fwaas
14:00:07 <openstack> Meeting started Thu May 10 14:00:07 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is SridarK. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:00:09 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:00:09 <yushiro> Hi,
14:00:12 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'fwaas'
14:00:16 <SridarK> #chair xgerman_ yushiro
14:00:23 <openstack> Current chairs: SridarK xgerman_ yushiro
14:00:51 <mlavalle> Hi there
14:01:00 <hongbin> o/
14:01:03 <yushiro> Hi mlavalle :)
14:01:25 <SridarK> I forget, today xgerman_ 's turn to chair ?
14:01:35 <longkb> Hi everyone, I am a new comer in fwaas
14:01:38 <xgerman_> o/
14:01:46 <longkb> o/
14:01:49 <xgerman_> welcome longkb
14:02:03 <yushiro> longkb, welcome to FWaaS :)
14:02:10 <xgerman_> #topic Announcements
14:02:14 <SridarK> ah good we love to see new folks join in welcome
14:02:23 <xgerman_> The prices for the PTG are about to go up —
14:02:46 <SridarK> +1 i am still awaiting a decision - will remind my bosses
14:03:26 <xgerman_> #link https://www.eventbrite.com/e/project-teams-gathering-denver-2018-tickets-45296703660
14:03:41 <xgerman_> yeah, haven’t heard from my bosses neither
14:04:08 <xgerman_> now as I look it’s $199 as opposed to $99 before…
14:04:34 <SridarK> oh yes the prices went up
14:04:45 <yushiro> yes..
14:04:47 <SridarK> inflation :-)
14:04:59 <mlavalle> Keep in mind that the deadline for the current price is tomorrow
14:05:08 <SridarK> +1
14:05:17 <yushiro> +99
14:05:19 <SridarK> I think we can get a refund if we dont go
14:05:47 <njohnston> o/
14:06:05 <xgerman_> njohnston: how is RedHat treating you?
14:06:17 <SridarK> ah that is news
14:06:30 <annp_> hi
14:06:33 <SridarK> congrats njohnston
14:06:40 <xgerman_> +1
14:06:42 <yushiro> Wow, congrats njohnston !
14:06:43 <annp_> +1
14:06:44 <chandanc> +1
14:07:10 <njohnston> Thanks!  I don't start there until 6/4; I am on vacation. this week, then a few weeks to wrap up things at Comcast.
14:07:25 <SridarK> njohnston: enjoy
14:07:36 <xgerman_> +1 — glad you could make it to our meeting :-)
14:07:40 <yushiro> ya, plz enjoy and enjoy :)
14:07:47 <annp_> ++
14:07:54 <xgerman_> #topic Rocky Pluggable backend driver
14:08:04 <xgerman_> doude: pls go ahead
14:08:33 <SridarK> So it seems VMWare folks concerns are addressed
14:09:00 <annp_> doube: I'm sorry. I haven't tested your patch in multi-node environment yet.
14:09:19 <annp_> I have a trouble with etcd service
14:09:24 <SridarK> looks like doude may have stepped away
14:09:35 <annp_> I'm trying to fix it.
14:10:29 <xgerman_> sounds good
14:10:44 <xgerman_> let’s aim to get that in before R-2
14:10:46 <xgerman_> #topic Rocky Remote FWG
14:10:48 <annp_> hey folks, do you test with doube's patch in multi-node?
14:11:44 <xgerman_> I have been distracted this week :-(
14:11:44 <yushiro> annp_, Me too.  I have same problem for multi-node in doube's patch.  Cannot deploy due to etcd.
14:11:53 <SridarK> annp_: I am have difficulty with getting a multnode setup to test
14:12:28 <annp_> I got it. :) xgerman_ please go ahead
14:12:29 <yushiro> In All-in-one node, I've tested and confirmed there is no error message while updating firewall group(associating a port with default fwg).
14:12:46 <yushiro> oops, sorry xgerman_  for interrupting.
14:13:01 <xgerman_> annp_: I have been distracted this week - so no progress on my end
14:13:45 <annp_> xgerman_: I got it :)
14:14:25 <xgerman_> #topic Rocky FWaaS Logging Spec
14:14:54 <xgerman_> So one of my distractions was GDPR ;-)
14:15:31 <SridarK> I am ok with it, if amotoki is happy with with his last set comments being addressed
14:15:31 <xgerman_> As I understand the spec we are shipping the logs of for retention so should be fine…
14:16:02 <amotoki> will look at it tomorrow morning
14:16:08 <xgerman_> +1
14:16:14 <SridarK> amotoki: thx and then we can move fwd with it
14:16:20 <yushiro> I will review it tomorrow too.
14:16:21 <annp_> amotoki, thanks in advance
14:16:31 <xgerman_> just as a PSA we need to look at all logging through a GDPR lense
14:16:31 <SridarK> perhaps needs a +A from amotoki or mlavalle
14:16:39 <yushiro> SridarK, +1
14:16:50 <xgerman_> +1
14:16:53 <annp_> SridarK, yushiro, +1
14:17:01 <SridarK> mlavalle: can u pls keep it in ur radar too
14:17:03 <mlavalle> I already told annp_ earlier this week that I am going to look at it
14:17:10 <SridarK> ok cool
14:17:12 <xgerman_> awesome
14:17:18 <yushiro> thanks mlavalle
14:17:35 <annp_> mlavalle, yes. thanks for remind me.
14:19:07 <xgerman_> #topic Rocky Address Group Spec
14:19:16 <xgerman_> wkite: pls go ahead
14:19:50 <xgerman_> #link https://review.openstack.org/557137
14:20:06 <wkite> i need review
14:20:31 <SridarK> annp_: chandanc can u pls take a quick look from the driver side of things as well
14:20:44 <chandanc> will confirm SridarK
14:20:58 <annp_> SridarK, yes. Will confirm soon
14:20:58 <SridarK> thx chandanc annp_
14:21:04 <xgerman_> +1
14:21:26 <wkite> +1
14:21:43 <SridarK> I think straddling across CIDR boundaries was a bit of a concern but i think it is a requirement
14:21:53 <SridarK> and we shd be ok
14:22:21 <xgerman_> +1
14:22:27 <yushiro> +1
14:23:12 <xgerman_> ok, let
14:23:21 <xgerman_> ’s aim to get that merged soon
14:23:27 <SridarK> +1
14:23:38 <xgerman_> #topic Stateless Firewall
14:23:49 <xgerman_> ndefigueiredo ?
14:24:16 <SridarK> dont see him around
14:24:30 <xgerman_> ok, let’s move on then
14:24:33 <xgerman_> #topic Open Discussion
14:24:40 <mlavalle> o/
14:24:49 <mlavalle> I have a topic I want to bring up
14:24:55 <xgerman_> sure, go ahead
14:25:27 <mlavalle> At Huawei we have been working on a proposal on where we would like to see the API evolve in the future
14:25:56 <mlavalle> We put together a document here: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1lnzV6pv841pX43sM76gF3aZ7jceRH3FPbKaGpPumWgs/edit
14:26:12 <mlavalle> We want to start socializing this proposal with the community
14:26:33 <njohnston> I’ll definitely check it out!
14:26:45 <mlavalle> I spent some time last week looking at the current API, as defined here: https://specs.openstack.org/openstack/neutron-specs/specs/mitaka/fwaas-api-2.0.html
14:27:07 <mlavalle> and there is a lot of overlap with that API definition
14:27:08 <SridarK> mlavalle: the service groups / service objects has been an ask
14:27:35 <SridarK> mlavalle: i think there is bound to be some good alignment
14:27:44 <SridarK> i will go thru the doc completely
14:27:45 <mlavalle> I understand that there may be overlap also with efforts or requests currently in the pipeline
14:28:29 <mlavalle> I will send a message with some highlights where we see the features that need to be added
14:28:29 <SridarK> and address groups is in discussion
14:29:17 <SridarK> +1
14:29:27 <mlavalle> what I propose to do is that when we have a first round of feedback and we now how our porposal overlaps with what is already implemented and current efforts, we can maybe put together a spec
14:29:28 <xgerman_> e-mail is good
14:29:56 <yushiro> OK.
14:30:04 <mlavalle> ns maybe also have conersations with team members in Vancouver
14:30:06 <annp_> +1
14:30:07 <SridarK> mlavalle: i think a spec to target the deltas is good with referece to the orig spec
14:30:15 <xgerman_> +!
14:30:20 <SridarK> with address group we have done that
14:30:25 <mlavalle> SridarK: exactly, that is what I was thinking
14:30:50 <SridarK> xgerman_: annp_ & I will be there at Vancouver
14:31:07 <mlavalle> ahh perfect, let's dicuss there
14:31:09 <xgerman_> me, too
14:31:14 <SridarK> we can find a time to do a quick discussion and find th overlaps
14:31:24 <yushiro> That's good!
14:31:34 <xgerman_> yes — we should also be cognizant to not start an FWaaS V3
14:31:40 <yushiro> Plz connect me if necessary :)
14:31:45 <SridarK> :-)
14:31:51 <annp_> :)
14:31:59 <mlavalle> and also, please register here:  https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/YVR-neutron-atendees
14:32:16 <mlavalle> we will have a Neutron team dinner on Tuesday
14:32:34 <annp_> mlavalle,  that's sound great
14:32:49 <SridarK> ok perfect
14:33:03 <mlavalle> so that's the topic I wanted to bring up
14:33:12 <mlavalle> thanks for listening
14:33:12 <SridarK> mlavalle: thx
14:33:18 <xgerman_> thx
14:33:28 <SridarK> Also yushiro: now that u are back from vacation - lets all get together to do bug scrub maybe Mon ?
14:33:29 <annp_> regarding to l7 filtering topic
14:33:38 <mlavalle> if you have trouble accesing the document, please let me know
14:33:42 <xgerman_> SridarK: +1
14:33:50 <xgerman_> annp_: go head
14:33:55 <xgerman_> ahead
14:34:02 <annp_> xgerman_ thanks.
14:34:37 <yushiro> SridarK, Yes :)  Thanks for doing chair at last week.
14:34:54 <annp_> I just create very first draft agenda and content for L7 filtering at https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1nyu4Hd6cwSoffa2OoOpfeyK59GYbfVQWPSgqQx8oaQY/edit#slide=id.g337a530e8c_0_17
14:35:01 <SridarK> yushiro: i thnk it was my turn last week
14:35:04 <annp_> Please take a look at it.
14:35:13 <yushiro> aha :p
14:35:15 <SridarK> annp_: ok
14:35:33 <SridarK> annp_: lets discuss some next week b4 we head to summit and then also talk there
14:36:05 <mlavalle> yushiro: you going to Vancouver?
14:36:21 <SridarK> annp_: we can start an email thread with urself, xgerman_ , amotoki and me to coordinate time to meet etc
14:36:31 <yushiro> mlavalle, Unfortunately,  I cannot go to Vancouver...
14:36:38 <mlavalle> :-(
14:36:47 <xgerman_> :-(
14:36:54 <yushiro> Ahhhhhhhh.....  so sad :-(
14:36:56 <annp_> SridarK, Thanks, I will send a email as your suggestion
14:37:12 <SridarK> yushiro: i think in a long time u have had to miss
14:37:22 <SridarK> wish u could have made it
14:37:23 <mlavalle> LOL
14:37:52 <yushiro> Yeah.  Maybe I can go to PTG in Denver :p
14:38:05 <SridarK> sometimes i think yushiro is also checking out an alternate career as a standup comic :-)
14:38:06 <annp_> yushiro, +1
14:38:42 <amotoki> +1 :)
14:39:01 <yushiro> SridarK, hahaha, it's good way :-)
14:39:06 <SridarK> :-)
14:39:31 <xgerman_> :-)
14:40:03 <yushiro> Plz enjoy and spend precious time in Vancouver.  I hope that all day will be fine.
14:40:41 <SridarK> ok folks - i need to step away for school drop
14:40:45 <xgerman_> ok
14:40:52 <xgerman_> I think we can close anyway
14:41:02 <SridarK> c u all next week and try for a bug scrub on Mon
14:41:09 <mlavalle> o/
14:41:10 <xgerman_> +!
14:41:15 <yushiro> sure
14:41:17 <chandanc> o/
14:41:22 <SridarK> bye all
14:41:32 <yushiro> BTW, long time no see, chandanc  :)
14:41:33 <xgerman_> bye
14:41:39 <annp_> xgerman_, thank you so much for your comments in L7 filtering.
14:41:50 <chandanc> ya yushiro :)
14:41:58 <xgerman_> you are welcome :-)
14:42:00 <mlavalle> don't forget to close the meeting, xgerman_ or SridarK
14:42:01 <chandanc> bit busy in office
14:42:07 <xgerman_> #endmeeting