14:02:16 <xgerman_> #startmeeting fwaas
14:02:17 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Jul  5 14:02:16 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is xgerman_. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:02:18 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:02:20 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'fwaas'
14:02:36 <xgerman_> #chair yushiro, sridark
14:02:36 <openstack> Warning: Nick not in channel: yushiro
14:02:37 <openstack> Warning: Nick not in channel: sridark
14:02:38 <openstack> Current chairs: sridark xgerman_ yushiro
14:03:26 <xgerman_> since I don’t want to meet just with my self…
14:03:45 <longkb> o/ xgerman_
14:03:49 <annp> hi
14:04:09 <yushiro> Hi!!
14:04:12 <xgerman_> hi!!
14:04:12 <yushiro> Sorry I was late.
14:04:27 <xgerman_> no worries
14:04:39 <xgerman_> #announcements
14:04:43 <yushiro> Thanks xgerman_
14:04:46 <xgerman_> #topic announcements
14:05:46 <xgerman_> Berlin RfP closes 7/17
14:06:08 <xgerman_> Topic are similar to Vancouver…
14:06:28 <yushiro> yeah.  Will register it.
14:06:48 <xgerman_> I am still brainstorming topics…
14:06:56 <annp> +1
14:07:00 <yushiro> Ya, me too.
14:07:01 <longkb> +1
14:07:13 <yushiro> Currently, we're facing gate issue.  Trung is trying to fix it: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/578001/
14:07:46 <xgerman_> yeah, saw comment from njohnston
14:07:49 <yushiro> However, njohnston has commented and it is reasonable.  So, I'll remove -2 at that time and research more.
14:07:52 <yushiro> xgerman_, +1
14:07:57 <yushiro> Thanks njohnston !
14:08:00 <xgerman_> +1
14:08:44 <yushiro> So, I'll also try to fix it ASAP.
14:09:04 <xgerman_> +1
14:09:09 <xgerman_> #topic Rocky
14:09:41 <xgerman_> Logging for FWaaS v2: https://review.openstack.org/#/q/topic:bug/1720727+(status:open)
14:10:54 <annp> longkb: please go ahead
14:10:57 <annp> :)
14:11:05 <longkb> Hi, I and AnNP are working on Logging for FWaaS v2
14:11:48 <longkb> I plan to finish driver patch tomorow
14:11:53 <xgerman_> sweet - I have seen patches fly by…
14:11:53 <longkb> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/553738/
14:12:25 <yushiro> longkb, If you finished driver patch, could you share your local.conf for us?
14:12:34 <longkb> yep
14:12:38 <longkb> of course
14:12:45 <yushiro> So, we all can deploy devstack with fwaas logging and easy for review :)
14:12:58 <annp> yushiro, +1
14:12:59 <longkb> I will make a document for environment setup
14:13:04 <xgerman_> +1
14:13:09 <xgerman_> yes docs are important
14:13:19 <yushiro> xgerman_, +10
14:13:22 <wkite3> +1
14:13:22 <annp> xgerman_, +1
14:13:40 <yushiro> Hopefully to put document patch as well.
14:13:52 <longkb> +1 yushiro
14:14:11 <longkb> I will push document patch soon :D
14:14:51 <annp> longkb: +10
14:15:15 <longkb> thanks you guys :D
14:15:17 <yushiro> OK, I'll review all of logging patch.
14:15:26 <xgerman_> k, yes
14:16:02 <annp> In order to support logging for fwg, We need https://review.openstack.org/#/c/529814/ first.
14:16:13 <longkb> thanks yushiro
14:16:47 <annp> So we'd like to get your eyes on this first. :)
14:17:01 <annp> thanks in advance!
14:17:10 <longkb> +1 annp
14:17:40 <yushiro> annp, longkb OK, will review it first.
14:17:59 <annp> yushiro, thanks!
14:18:06 <yushiro> annp, longkb ah, plz reply to my comments :)
14:18:17 <longkb> yushiro: I got it
14:18:18 <annp> xgerman_, please go ahead.
14:18:27 <xgerman_> remote firewall group: https://review.openstack.org/521207
14:18:51 <xgerman_> I noticed in the latest devstack sg is on ovs!!
14:19:02 <yushiro> xgerman_, Yes,  I noticed today :)
14:19:30 <annp> xgerman_, I'm sorry, I haven't reviewed your patch yet.
14:19:40 <xgerman_> Anyhow, it installs, doesn’t throw errors but I need to do much more testing. If someone who knows more about ovs than I do could do a thorough review that would be appreciated ;-)
14:20:20 <xgerman_> it’s now really down to getting the conjecture flows installed properly, fix/add some unit tests, and lots of testing
14:20:21 <annp> xgerman_, Because this week I'm quite busy with logging and wsgi server for neutron. So I'm planning review your patch in tomorrow.
14:20:33 <xgerman_> annp: thanks a dozen!!
14:20:44 <yushiro> xgerman_, me too :p
14:20:56 <annp> xgerman_ you're always welcome!
14:21:37 <xgerman_> yeah, we have a about two weeks for the client patches
14:22:02 <xgerman_> 7/23
14:22:26 <yushiro> xgerman_, Aha, so, in order to review your remote_group patch, it's better to include your client patch, isn't it?
14:22:59 <xgerman_> yes, you then will be able to manipulate it + that patch comes a week earlier
14:23:20 <xgerman_> 7/30 is RC1 so we have one more week for not client
14:24:04 <xgerman_> that’s why I am stressing the client we need to get that out of the door rather quickly :-)
14:24:15 <yushiro> OK,  I'll also add https://review.openstack.org/#/c/571331/  (Adds the destination and source fwg to fwr)
14:24:24 <yushiro> I see.
14:24:40 <xgerman_> thanks
14:25:04 <xgerman_> #topic Open Discussion
14:25:48 <yushiro> Regarding launchpad bugs for L3-HA with FWaaS v2.
14:26:31 <yushiro> Just a moment, I'll paste the link.
14:27:01 <xgerman_> ok
14:27:15 <yushiro> https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1762454
14:27:15 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1762454 in neutron "FWaaS: Invalid port error on associating ports (distributed router) to firewall group" [Medium,Triaged] - Assigned to Sridar Kandaswamy (skandasw)
14:27:47 <yushiro> I just tested in DVR + L3HA environment.
14:28:25 <xgerman_> yeah, thanks for looking into that. I know DVR has a lot of hard coded stuff :-(
14:29:21 <yushiro> So, we should enable to specify a router port that 'device_owner' is 'network:router_interface_distributed'  in case of DVR.
14:29:32 <yushiro> xgerman_, OK.
14:30:19 <yushiro> So, fix is easy but verification takes time I think :p
14:30:49 <xgerman_> yeah, if it’s a big concern we might need a DVR gate
14:30:51 <annp> :)
14:31:19 <wkite3> emmm… I have a question. What should I do for merging the address groups spec?
14:31:44 <yushiro> Yes,  at least we should take care of 2 patterns.  1: DVR,  2:DVR+L3HA
14:33:04 <xgerman_> wkite3: we need to review and +2 I think
14:34:31 <yushiro> wkite3, Currently, we all put +2 from FWaaS side.  It means this SPEC is ready for merging.  I think in this cycle, it is difficult to implement and merge.  So, driver team are waiting next cycle('stein') and merge ASAP...
14:35:04 <yushiro> That's my expectation.  I'll ping other driver cores about that.
14:36:12 <yushiro> wkite3, I think neutron-specs should have 'approved' directory :)
14:36:41 <yushiro> wkite3, Anyway, will ping driver-team about address-groups support SPEC.
14:37:06 <annp> wkite3, Can you push some code for review? I think you can start with code now.
14:37:31 <yushiro> annp, +1.  Yes, you can start coding for it.
14:38:04 <wkite3> yushiro: i see, thank for your answer.
14:38:49 <wkite3> annp: ok, good idea.
14:39:47 <xgerman_> annp: +!
14:40:40 <yushiro> wkite3, If you push a code, please specify reviewer forus.
14:41:04 <wkite3> yushiro: no problem.
14:41:17 <yushiro> annp, Regarding gate issue(https://review.openstack.org/#/c/578001), can you take a look as well?
14:41:37 <annp> yushiro, Sure.
14:41:42 <yushiro> K, thanks.
14:42:35 <longkb> annp: fighting!!!
14:44:05 <annp> yushiro, I will investigate more about Nate comments.
14:44:17 <annp> yushiro, Will sync up with you tomorrow.
14:44:24 <yushiro> OK.
14:44:32 <yushiro> That's all for me.
14:46:03 <yushiro> wow, suddenly disconnected.
14:46:11 <xgerman_> mmh,
14:46:48 <yushiro> That's all for me ( my last word )
14:48:05 <xgerman_> ok, let’s close then ;-)
14:48:11 <xgerman_> #endmeeting