14:01:36 <SridarK> #startmeeting fwaas
14:01:37 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Aug 30 14:01:36 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is SridarK. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:01:39 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:01:41 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'fwaas'
14:01:49 <SridarK> #chair xgerman_
14:01:50 <openstack> Current chairs: SridarK xgerman_
14:02:02 <SridarK> yushiro said he is going to be late
14:02:06 <xgerman_> +1
14:02:23 <SridarK> welcome back xgerman_ hope PTO was good
14:02:43 <xgerman_> was great :-)
14:02:48 <mlavalle> where did you go?
14:03:04 <annp> xgerman_ +1 :D
14:03:06 <xgerman_> Norway (I managed to drop off my kids in Germany at my parents)
14:03:25 <SridarK> oh nice
14:03:34 <longkb> kkk
14:04:52 <SridarK> ok lets get started with things
14:05:09 <SridarK> probab light agenda unless some one has things to bring up and discuss
14:06:21 <SridarK> Thx all for the efforts to get Rocky out - we did have a fair amt of changes on logging but a great job by yushiro, annp, longkb, hoangcx to get things in
14:06:40 <SridarK> and mlavalle thx for the accomodation and help to get things in
14:06:47 <mlavalle> glad to help!
14:06:53 <xgerman_> +!
14:07:03 <annp> SridarK, thank you too.
14:07:26 <SridarK> great lets move on to Stein as we leave Rocky
14:07:28 <longkb> Thank guys. I just a new comer in FWaaS. I learned a lot from you guys :D
14:07:43 <xgerman_> :-)
14:07:45 <SridarK> longkb: u are a veteran now !!
14:07:52 <xgerman_> +1
14:07:57 <annp> +1
14:08:02 <SridarK> #topic Stein Planning and Roadmap
14:08:16 <xgerman_> PTG is near!!
14:08:21 <mlavalle> yeah
14:08:24 <longkb> Thanks SridarK
14:08:29 <xgerman_> the last PTG (ever)
14:08:32 <SridarK> We have a few things listed at #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/fwaas-meeting
14:09:24 <SridarK> I think the team has clarity on things that are needed to complete logging (L2 support and few other things)
14:09:47 <SridarK> other than that we have a few things may be we can do a quick run thru that list for any comments
14:10:07 <SridarK> 1. Address Group Support
14:10:13 * mlavalle would like to ask question when doen running dow the list
14:10:25 <SridarK> mlavalle: surely
14:10:31 <SridarK> we can run thru quickly
14:10:59 <SridarK> I think we have a plan and contributor wkite lined up on this, spec is approved as well
14:11:34 <SridarK> 2. Remote FWG - i belive we just have a few cycles left on this and just missed Rocky
14:11:41 <SridarK> xgerman_: is on this
14:11:58 <xgerman_> yeah, I am hoping to get together with some ovs expert to hammer out the details
14:12:08 <xgerman_> maybe there is one at the PTG?
14:12:25 <SridarK> xgerman_: +1
14:12:39 <annp> xgerman_ +1
14:12:53 <SridarK> 3. Firewall Audit notification #link https://review.openstack.org/461657
14:13:14 <SridarK> Zhaobo is the proposer - i think we shd get coverage on this
14:13:22 <SridarK> mlavalle: is that fair
14:13:28 <mlavalle> yeap
14:13:33 <SridarK> ok perfect
14:13:34 <mlavalle> he will be in Denver
14:13:43 <SridarK> ok great
14:14:38 <xgerman_> +1
14:14:44 <SridarK> 4. Firewall Rule scheduling #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/236840/
14:15:00 <SridarK> this spec needs more review and we can pick that up to decide
14:15:18 <SridarK> reedip is not here today
14:15:28 <SridarK> but we can discuss more gerrit
14:16:10 <SridarK> 5. Tempest scenario tests - SridarK will work on this
14:16:38 <SridarK> and if anyone else wants to chip in we can increase the coverage which is long overdue
14:16:57 <SridarK> 6. Scoping of L4 - L7 support
14:17:07 <SridarK> annp: do u plan to take the lead on this ?
14:17:22 <annp> SridarK, yes. I will take on it
14:17:44 <longkb> Greate!!! annp
14:18:02 <SridarK> annp: thx perfect - i think u can start some discussions on it - if we can have some ground work and good plan in place in Stein that will be great
14:18:29 <xgerman_> +1
14:18:31 <SridarK> 7. Common Classifier Framework integration
14:18:41 <SridarK> perhaps a good topic for PTG
14:19:04 <annp> SridarK, xgerman_ here is my presentation at Viet OpenInfraday: https://www.slideshare.net/nguyenphuongan1/l7-firewall-api-for-neutronfwaas?qid=ecc118f5-33db-49b5-95dc-e66a7586ad31&v=&b=&from_search=1
14:19:12 <SridarK> mlavalle: will be good to see how things stand on the CCF side to plan for integration
14:19:18 <annp> Please feel free to check it. :)
14:19:24 <SridarK> annp: thx
14:19:43 <annp> SridarK, +1
14:19:44 <mlavalle> SridarK: yes, I also have questions on that... so it will be good to find out in Denver
14:19:48 <xgerman_> +1 -- that must have been a big meeting ;-)
14:19:53 <SridarK> mlavalle: perfect
14:20:01 <SridarK> and lastly
14:20:26 <SridarK> 8. Refactor to handle status of FWG
14:20:35 <SridarK> SridarK: will look into this
14:20:59 <longkb> FWG status is crazy now :D
14:22:12 <SridarK> the notion of status was simple earlier but with multiple ports being associated a FWG - the notion of status needs a fresh look as each port is an independent entity and how the status of the port drives the FWG status is an issue
14:22:31 <SridarK> longkb: +1 crazy is the perfect way to describe it
14:23:00 <SridarK> I think those are some topics we had
14:23:56 <SridarK> we can ofcourse continue the discussion over the next couple of days and try to converge on a concrete plan around PTG or the days after PTG
14:24:25 <SridarK> If there are no other comments, mlavalle pls go ahead
14:25:11 <SridarK> mlavalle: u had a list as well - so we can certainly add or relook at priorities
14:25:21 <mlavalle> back in Sydney, hongbin and I presented a proposal for an API expansion
14:25:32 <SridarK> mlavalle: +1
14:25:50 <mlavalle> the conversation we had with SridarK and xgerman_ was to create a set of specs
14:25:53 <hongbin> o/
14:26:09 <xgerman_> oh, yeah, that was in Vancouver :-)
14:26:09 <annp> hongbin hi
14:26:14 <xgerman_> +1
14:26:17 <mlavalle> 3 specs were suggested, to make them more easily digestable by the FWaaS team
14:26:19 <hongbin> annp: hi
14:26:52 <mlavalle> hongbin is working hard this week eand next to create the first versions of those specs
14:27:05 <SridarK> great
14:27:07 <mlavalle> so we can review them with the team in Denver
14:27:18 <SridarK> mlavalle: sounds good
14:27:20 <xgerman_> great!
14:27:24 <longkb> greate!
14:27:29 <hongbin> yes, hopefully, we can get those specs ready before the ptg
14:27:42 <annp> +1
14:27:48 <SridarK> mlavalle: i wont be able to make it to PTG but will be remote and can participate
14:27:53 <mlavalle> during my recent trip to China I had a conversation with the internal group interested in this feature
14:28:18 <annp> mlavalle: I will be remote also
14:28:26 <mlavalle> and there is much interest on them
14:28:50 <yushiro> Hi all!  I'm sorry I was late.
14:29:00 <SridarK> yushiro: no worries
14:29:07 <longkb> Hi super yushiro :D
14:29:17 <yushiro> SridarK: Thanks.
14:29:20 <xgerman_> +1
14:29:24 <yushiro> longkb: haha,  Hi :)
14:29:42 <mlavalle> we are going to commit resources to implement this during Stein
14:30:12 <annp> mlavalle, great!
14:30:27 <yushiro> mlavalle: Hi
14:30:43 <xgerman_> annp: +1
14:30:54 <SridarK> mlavalle: great
14:31:00 <mlavalle> can we add the specs to your list in the etherpad?
14:31:09 <SridarK> mlavalle: most certainly
14:31:40 <hongbin> SridarK: mlavalle thanks, i will add those specs to the etherpad once they are ready
14:32:11 <mlavalle> hongbin: please look at point 1 in the list. it had overlap with what we are prposing
14:32:33 <hongbin> mlavalle: ack, i will take a look
14:33:13 <mlavalle> that's all we had :-)
14:33:15 <mlavalle> Thanks
14:33:25 <SridarK> mlavalle: thx
14:34:07 <SridarK> hongbin: if u think u are ready - u can just add a topic headline to the list in #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/fwaas-meeting
14:34:18 <SridarK> whenever u are ready
14:34:27 <hongbin> SridarK: ack
14:35:08 <SridarK> Oh the other topic i missed was Dashboard technical debt
14:35:17 <SridarK> we definitely need some work here
14:35:23 <xgerman_> +1
14:35:30 <yushiro> +1
14:35:52 <SridarK> lets see how we address that
14:36:40 <SridarK> xgerman_:, yushiro: will both of u be at the PTG ?
14:36:45 <yushiro> +1  I bought a book for django :)
14:36:52 <SridarK> yushiro: he he
14:36:59 <yushiro> SridarK: I and honangCX will join.
14:37:06 <SridarK> yushiro: ok
14:37:40 <yushiro> Yes, so we can discuss more at PTG :)
14:37:46 <mlavalle> have you guys added your name to the neutron PTG etherpad?
14:37:51 <mlavalle> I know xgerman_ did
14:38:07 <yushiro> mlavalle: I added my name at today's afternoon :)
14:38:12 <SridarK> perhaps we can plan some time for an IRC or conf call for more discussion with those of us who cannot make it
14:38:16 <yushiro> mlavalle: Glad to see you again :)
14:38:35 <mlavalle> same here :-)
14:38:36 <xgerman_> yes, but historically Wifi is bad at this location
14:38:45 <SridarK> xgerman_: sigh yes
14:39:07 <yushiro> xgerman_: +1
14:39:08 <xgerman_> hope we can work something out - I have a hotspot
14:39:19 <SridarK> xgerman_: but perhaps an audio so i can hear the trains - i miss them so much ... :-)
14:39:25 <annp> xgerman_, ++1
14:39:43 <yushiro> xgerman_: I'll bring my wi-fi as well :)
14:39:55 <xgerman_> I have been told train problem is fixed - but PTG is doomed so there will be something...
14:40:00 <annp> yushiro, +1
14:40:13 <SridarK> :-)
14:40:16 <yushiro> haha
14:40:30 <longkb> Thanks guys. Hope that I can remote to Denver :D
14:41:05 <SridarK> be careful on what u inhale at Denver :-)
14:41:28 <yushiro> longkb: +1
14:41:37 <xgerman_> SridarK:  ha
14:42:40 <SridarK> I think those were some thing reg Stein we had
14:42:46 <SridarK> #topic Open Discussion
14:43:55 <yushiro> SridarK: I'm sorry I didn't have any update for https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1759773
14:43:55 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1759773 in neutron "FWaaS: Invalid port error on associating L3 ports (Router in HA) to firewall group" [Undecided,Confirmed] - Assigned to Sridar Kandaswamy (skandasw)
14:44:09 <SridarK> yushiro: no worries - lets talk offline
14:44:15 <yushiro> SridarK: yes
14:44:54 <yushiro> We can bring it in PTG as well :p
14:44:54 <SridarK> and attend the L3 meeting next
14:45:08 <yushiro> Yes
14:45:08 <SridarK> surely
14:45:56 <SridarK> ok if nothing else we can end the mtg
14:46:17 <SridarK> Ok all thx for joining and have a great week
14:46:25 <yushiro> Thanks all
14:46:33 <SridarK> bye
14:46:33 <annp> Thanks all
14:46:35 <annp> bye
14:46:36 <yushiro> bye bye
14:46:39 <longkb> Thanks guys :D
14:46:47 <SridarK> #endmeeting