14:00:56 <annp_> #startmeeting fwaas
14:00:56 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Oct 18 14:00:56 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is annp_. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:00:57 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:00:59 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'fwaas'
14:01:19 <annp_> xgerman_ hi
14:02:40 <xgerman_> o/
14:02:52 <annp_> #chair xgerman_ annp
14:02:53 <openstack> Warning: Nick not in channel: annp
14:02:54 <openstack> Current chairs: annp annp_ xgerman_
14:03:04 <xgerman_> annp_: thanks for starting - you like to run the meeting?
14:03:42 <annp_> xgerman_ ok. let me try :-)
14:03:47 <annp_> #topic announcements
14:04:07 <annp_> Next week is Stein-1 milestone (October 22nd - 26th)
14:04:30 <annp_> and please note that less than one month than a month away from the Summit in Berlin.
14:05:02 <annp_> xgerman_ do you have any other announcement?
14:05:34 <annp_> hi hongbin
14:05:42 <hongbin> o/
14:06:06 <annp_> hongbin, do you have any other announcement?
14:06:19 <hongbin> annp_: no, i don't
14:06:42 <xgerman_> #link https://docs.openstack.org/oslo.policy/latest/user/usage.html#naming-policies
14:06:53 <xgerman_> not sure if that will drive changes for us
14:07:13 <xgerman_> #link https://www.irccloud.com/irc/freenode/channel/link
14:07:31 <xgerman_> haven’t read through that but might mean work for our dashboard
14:07:48 <xgerman_> in other news dims from the OpenStack TC got elected to the k8s steering committee
14:08:03 <xgerman_> that’s all
14:08:30 <annp_> xgerman_, thanks for your inform.
14:09:20 <xgerman_> yeah, http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2018-October/135805.html
14:09:33 <xgerman_> ^^ that’s the link for the last one - copy&paste error
14:10:32 <annp_> xgerman_ no worries.
14:14:05 <annp_> xgerman_, do we need to a CI plugin for neutron-fwaas-dashboard?
14:16:48 <xgerman_> likely
14:17:14 <annp_> xgerman_, I see.
14:17:22 <xgerman_> but I haven’t checked with neutron/mlavalle
14:17:39 <xgerman_> or amotoki  for that matter
14:18:10 <annp_> xgerman_ ok. let reach out them first.
14:18:19 <xgerman_> +1
14:18:49 <amotoki> even if I take care of the tempest plugin, we need volunteers to write actual tests?
14:20:34 <xgerman_> yep
14:21:31 <annp_> amotoki, may be I can help you write actual test.
14:21:44 <xgerman_> thanks
14:21:47 <annp_> amotoki, please reach out me when you start
14:22:22 <amotoki> annp_: you don't need to wait me :)  I don't have much bandwidth on horizon plugins in this release.
14:23:26 <annp_> amotoki, Ok. I will to start and reach out you if i don't understand something. :-)
14:23:44 <annp_> Shall we move on?
14:23:55 <xgerman_> +1
14:24:07 <annp_> #topic specs
14:24:26 <annp_> hongbin: do you have any update?
14:24:44 <hongbin> annp_:  ack
14:25:19 <hongbin> just a bit update, the specs i proposed received a few feedback from reviewers
14:26:03 <annp_> introduce action 'redirect': https://review.openstack.org/#/c/600563/
14:26:18 <annp_> add support for dynamic rules https://review.openstack.org/#/c/597724/
14:26:30 <annp_> extend firewall group inclusion https://review.openstack.org/#/c/600261/
14:26:40 <hongbin> yes
14:26:45 <annp_> hongbin: sorry, I haven't check your spec yet.
14:26:56 <hongbin> annp_: np
14:27:19 <hongbin> right now, i have enough feedback to digest :)
14:27:33 <hongbin> i will work on address the comments in the next a few weeks
14:28:00 <annp_> hongbin, +1
14:28:04 <xgerman_> thanks. +1
14:28:04 <hongbin> annp_: that is all from my side
14:28:13 <longkb> you work so hard, hongbin :)
14:28:19 <annp_> hongbin, thanks for bring it up.
14:28:30 <hongbin> np, thanks for the feedback team
14:28:39 <annp_> Hi wkite
14:28:56 <annp_> fwaas 2.0 address groups support  https://review.openstack.org/557137
14:29:16 <annp_> this one already merge in rocky.
14:29:38 <annp_> but I haven't see any reference implementation for it.
14:30:15 <annp_> wkite: Do you have a plan to implement this feature?
14:31:08 <annp_> he seems not around here.
14:31:49 <longkb> annp_: please go ahead :)
14:32:21 <annp_> #topic bugs
14:32:45 <annp_> L3 HA: https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1759773
14:32:45 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1759773 in neutron "FWaaS: Invalid port error on associating L3 ports (Router in HA) to firewall group" [Undecided,Confirmed] - Assigned to Sridar Kandaswamy (skandasw)
14:33:20 <annp_> last week, we've just landed the fix for this bug at  https://review.openstack.org/#/c/580552/.
14:34:08 <annp_> thank SridarK, longkb, and yushiro for your great effort
14:34:51 <annp_> next: Don't bind FWG on vm port if no firewall_l2_driver
14:34:51 <longkb> thanks annp :)
14:35:03 <annp_> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/605988/
14:35:32 <annp_> xgerman_, amotoki, Could you take a look at it?
14:37:04 <xgerman_> will add it to my lisy
14:37:07 <annp_> From my understanding, there seems difficult to check firewall_l2_driver is noop or not at server side.
14:37:39 <annp_> xgerman_ +1
14:38:39 <annp_> so I've just replied on the patch. Let's waiting feedback from author of this patch.
14:38:48 <amotoki> if you really need to check the firewall driver you can query it via RPC, but it needs to be done carefully
14:39:13 <amotoki> IIRC there was a similar thing in fwaas v1 code.
14:39:21 <annp_> amotoki, yes.
14:40:35 <annp_> amotoki, Is it worth to check via RPC?
14:41:17 <annp_> I'm afraid "No".
14:41:36 <amotoki> annp_: I haven't checked the full context. I just responded to your comment "there seems difficult to check firewall l2 driver is noop at the server side."
14:42:41 <annp_> amotoki, I see. So could you help us to push some comment on this after go through the patch.
14:42:53 <amotoki> annp_: ack
14:43:04 <annp_> amotoki, thanks a ton.
14:43:31 <annp_> next: https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1798577
14:43:31 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1798577 in neutron "[FWaas-DVR]wrong port name in iptables rules" [Undecided,New]
14:44:01 <annp_> actually, I haven't had much experience on DVR.
14:44:41 <xgerman_> yeah, me neither
14:44:54 <xgerman_> (or no positive experience)
14:45:19 <annp_> xgerman_, yeah. So I will learn more and will give comment on this one.
14:45:34 <xgerman_> thanks
14:45:41 <annp_> amotoki, Do you have any experience on DVR case?
14:45:53 <xgerman_> Sridark has some experience
14:46:04 <xgerman_> so we can always wait until he is back
14:46:08 <annp_> xgerman_, Yeah.
14:46:10 <amotoki> annp_: I have less unfortunately
14:46:53 <annp_> amotoki, No worries. No one can know everything.
14:46:57 <annp_> :-)
14:47:25 <annp_> I will ping SridarK when he is back.
14:47:51 <annp_> #topic Open Discussion
14:48:25 <annp_> Anything else we should discuss today?
14:49:47 <annp_> if there no things need to discussion.
14:49:56 <annp_> Shall we close the meeting?
14:50:08 <annp_> thanks everyone for show up.
14:50:15 <xgerman_> yeah, let’s close
14:50:19 <annp_> it's my first run the meeting
14:50:24 <xgerman_> thanks everyone and thanks annp_  for running the meeting
14:51:11 <annp_> xgerman_ thank you for giving me a chance to run the meeting.
14:51:16 <annp_> :-)
14:51:24 <longkb> thanks annp_
14:51:30 <amotoki> annp_: thnx
14:51:43 <annp_> #end meeting
14:51:55 <amotoki> wrong command  :)
14:52:02 <amotoki> no space is needed
14:52:24 <annp_> amotoki thanks a lot
14:52:27 <annp_> :-)
14:52:33 <annp_> #endmeeting