15:00:13 <n0ano> #startmeeting gantt
15:00:13 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Nov 11 15:00:13 2014 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is n0ano. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
15:00:14 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
15:00:16 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'gantt'
15:00:25 <n0ano> anyone here to talk about the scheduler?
15:01:16 <PaulMurray> hi
15:01:19 <vigneshvar> hi
15:02:19 <n0ano> #topic Summit recap
15:02:38 <n0ano> PaulMurray, I know you were there so you don't need a summary, vigneshvar were you there?
15:02:49 <vigneshvar> yes i was there
15:03:11 <n0ano> we can make this quick then, I had 2 main takeaways for the scheduler:
15:03:29 <vigneshvar> sure
15:03:45 <n0ano> 1) Of the kilo imperatives the scheduler clean up is on the list (this is doubleplus good)
15:04:24 <n0ano> 2) we have an explicit set of 8 BPs/Specs that, once implemented, everyone agrees the scheduler interfaces are sufficiently cleaned up
15:05:08 <n0ano> after we do 2) in Kilo we can do the actual split to Gantt in L (gantt as an optional scheduler) and the in M we can hopefully make Gantt the default
15:05:14 <doron_afk> hi guys
15:05:32 <n0ano> doron_afk, hi, did you see my summit summary
15:05:33 <doron> just a quick updates, many folks are away since there's some holiday today
15:06:07 <doron> n0ano: sadly, no/
15:06:22 <n0ano> doron, yeah, I wanted to have the meeting to get things back on track but not much to day.
15:06:27 <n0ano> OK, just to recap:
15:06:33 <n0ano> 1) Of the kilo imperatives the scheduler clean up is on the list (this is doubleplus good)
15:06:34 <n0ano> <n0ano> 2) we have an explicit set of 8 BPs/Specs that, once implemented, everyone agrees the scheduler interfaces are sufficiently cleaned up
15:06:34 <n0ano> <n0ano> after we do 2) in Kilo we can do the actual split to Gantt in L (gantt as an optional scheduler) and the in M we can hopefully make Gantt the defaul
15:06:45 * n0ano cut & paste sort of works
15:07:12 <n0ano> does anyone have anything else from the summit they'd like to point out?
15:07:13 <vigneshvar> This is my first time in the meeting.  i was working on a different scheduler blueprint. Now since it wont be part of 8 BPs, could i contribute to one of these
15:07:30 <doron> yes. To be more specific we have the milestones here: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/kilo-nova-milestone-targets
15:07:50 <doron> prio's here: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/kilo-nova-priorities
15:07:51 <n0ano> vigneshvar, sure, any help would be appreciated
15:07:58 <doron> and scheduler indeed takes a dignified prio.
15:08:28 <n0ano> doron, indeed, that's why I'm cautiously optimistic that we can actually make progress (emphasis on the cautious)
15:08:46 <doron> n0ano: +1
15:09:13 <doron> to my best knowledge sbauza is reviewing current bp's.
15:09:24 <doron> mainly the ones assigned to him.
15:09:54 <n0ano> kind of sequing (sp) into the next topic
15:10:09 <n0ano> #topic scheduler BPs for Kilo
15:10:31 <n0ano> in the agenda email I sent out I listed the current set of 8 BPs/Specs
15:10:46 <n0ano> sbauza commented on that list and we're making progress
15:11:15 <n0ano> once jay gets back from vacation I expect we can find out who's working on what and get some progress made
15:11:35 <n0ano> I intend to create a wiki page to track progress on those BPs (I don't like etherpads for that)
15:11:52 <n0ano> I'll post an email when I have it up and we can fine tune what it looks like.
15:12:03 <doron> n0ano:  quick Q;
15:12:19 <doron> should we break the bp's into smaller tasks? (is it needed)
15:12:27 <doron> just to keep track and see we make it on time.
15:12:57 <doron> or we can check with jay next week.
15:12:59 <PaulMurray> n0ano, the list is missing make-resource-tracker-use-objects
15:13:18 <n0ano> doron, potentially, depends upon the specific BP, the isolate DB ones are well scoped and don't need to change, we can study the others to see
15:13:27 <n0ano> PaulMurray, my bad, looks like I missed that
15:13:41 <PaulMurray> n0ano, I should reply to the list
15:13:53 <n0ano> PaulMurray, I'll be sure to include it into the wiki page and yes, replying on list would be good.
15:14:36 <n0ano> basically, we need to focus on those BPs and make sure we get them included in kilo, that is going to be my focus for this cycle.
15:15:07 <PaulMurray> n0ano, also something that was to make a pci stats object (s) - like the virt hardware case
15:15:16 <doron> and reviews are more than welcome to make sure we have as much progress as possible.
15:16:02 <n0ano> PaulMurray, we kind of punted on the PCI issue, we'll need to get the PCI people involved to clean that up properlyu
15:16:06 <doron> PaulMurray: wasn't it decided to keep it as a blob to make sure it does not block the scheduler efforts?
15:16:20 <doron> n0ano: indeed so.
15:16:27 <n0ano> doron, that was my understanding also
15:17:19 <PaulMurray> n0ano, doron, hm, I talked to Jay about it, I went back over the etherpads and found no decision recoreded - I thought it didn't actually get decided
15:17:33 <PaulMurray> n0ano, doron, do you remember more?
15:17:45 <n0ano> PaulMurray, no, I thought it got left punted
15:17:46 <doron> PaulMurray: well not in so many words, but this is what I remember mostly;
15:18:12 <doron> ie- pci folks are needed for the cleanup, and it should not block the scheduler work.
15:18:41 <n0ano> doron, that's what I remember and I +1 that plan
15:19:09 <PaulMurray> ok - I will follow up on that - it was my task to chase up the pci stats
15:19:35 <n0ano> OK, moving on...
15:19:43 <n0ano> #topic opens
15:19:56 <n0ano> anyone have anything else to talk about?
15:20:26 <doron> just a big thanks for everyone on their work last week from /me.
15:20:50 <n0ano> doron, NP
15:21:09 <n0ano> OK, I was expecting a relatively short meeting today so I'll let everyone go
15:21:18 <n0ano> tnx and talk to you next week (if not before)
15:21:21 <PaulMurray> bye
15:21:28 <doron> cya all.
15:21:33 <vigneshvar> since i am new, i would like to know how i can start contributing to scheduler Any pointers or any offline help. I dont want to divert the meeting
15:21:42 <n0ano> #endmeeting