14:00:21 <rosmaita> #startmeeting glance
14:00:22 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Feb  8 14:00:21 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is rosmaita. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:00:23 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:00:25 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'glance'
14:00:31 <rosmaita> #topic roll call
14:00:35 <McClymontS> o/
14:00:50 <abhishekk> o/
14:00:54 <bhagyashris> o/
14:01:37 <kairat> o/
14:01:56 <jokke_> o/
14:02:05 <rosmaita> ok, let's get started!
14:02:16 <rosmaita> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/glance-team-meeting-agenda
14:02:23 <rosmaita> #topic updates
14:02:50 <rosmaita> i believe that jokke_ is now officially Rocky PTL for glance
14:02:56 <jokke_> so it seems
14:03:01 <rosmaita> congratulations!
14:03:16 <McClymontS> nice jokke_
14:03:24 <rosmaita> jokke_ is going to take over the PTG planning, because now it's his baby
14:04:05 <bhagyashris> congratulations!
14:04:33 <rosmaita> i think the biggest issue facing glance right now is we need more contributors ... so if anyone has any ideas on how to make that happen, please share them with jokke_
14:04:45 <rosmaita> i personally am out of ideas
14:04:52 <rosmaita> ok, next item
14:05:05 <abhishekk> jokke_, congratulations
14:05:14 <jokke_> rosmaita: so in between topics
14:05:55 <rosmaita> go ahead
14:05:55 <jokke_> just quick one, mind to review that db check batch rosmaita or abhishekk after that we should be good to go with rc1
14:06:14 <jokke_> I gave my +2 in there after the latest changes
14:06:22 <rosmaita> actually, there are a few more patches
14:06:34 <abhishekk> jokke_, I will
14:06:35 <jokke_> ah ok
14:06:46 <jokke_> rosmaita: then continue and we get back to them :)
14:06:52 <jokke_> sorry
14:06:59 <rosmaita> yeah, so RC-1 has to be cut today and the stable branch cut
14:07:14 <rosmaita> this is what we're looking at:
14:07:16 <rosmaita> https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/glance-queens-rc1-patches
14:08:30 <rosmaita> kairat you had a concern about image import
14:08:45 <bhagyashris> jokke_, abhishekk, rosmaita: thank you :)
14:10:19 <rosmaita> kairat i can't find the patch you -1'd , but was your concern the XML stuff?
14:10:43 <rosmaita> that's all i could figure from the timing of your comment and the bug list
14:10:51 <kairat> yep, we detected it after bandit
14:11:00 <rosmaita> ok, that's fixed then
14:11:03 <rosmaita> cool
14:11:12 <kairat> seems defusedxml patch has been merged
14:11:44 <rosmaita> yes, not backported to pike though
14:11:53 <rosmaita> i left a comment on the patch for that
14:11:54 <jokke_> ok, cool so it was the one that did not affect the API in the first place ;)
14:11:58 <rosmaita> yeah
14:12:02 <rosmaita> great
14:12:25 <rosmaita> ok, i will revise https://review.openstack.org/542030 immediately following the meeting
14:12:29 <rosmaita> but i have a question
14:12:51 <rosmaita> the version negotiation middleware still looks at the enable_image_import option
14:13:02 <rosmaita> http://git.openstack.org/cgit/openstack/glance/tree/glance/api/middleware/version_negotiation.py
14:13:07 <rosmaita> line 87
14:13:36 <rosmaita> what that means is that if someone makes a request like /v2.6/whatever, it will be rejected
14:13:46 <rosmaita> so i think we should remove that?
14:14:19 <rosmaita> the individual 2.6 calls, discovery, stage, and import are all protected by the option
14:14:35 <rosmaita> so those will 404 with a message like "import not enabled at this site"
14:15:02 <rosmaita> any thoughts?
14:15:40 <jokke_> rosmaita: indeed something I clearly missed
14:15:47 <rosmaita> (btw, i was working too late last night, don't know what i was thinking with that supported business)
14:15:53 <rosmaita> jokke_ me too
14:16:05 <rosmaita> i know we have tests for version negotiation
14:16:14 <jokke_> fortunately it's quick fix ... will implement it right after the meeting
14:16:22 <rosmaita> but now that enable_image_import is True by default, they all passed!
14:16:26 <rosmaita> yeah, cool
14:16:36 <rosmaita> ok, i will revise the releasenotes for that
14:16:52 <rosmaita> only other change i want to do, and i will do it immediately also, is revise the api-ref
14:17:09 <rosmaita> that will be a quick merge because it only does docs gates
14:17:31 <rosmaita> i just want to get the "2.6 is experimental" stuff out of there
14:17:53 <rosmaita> i will revise the interoperable image import workflow to include web-download for RC-2
14:18:10 <rosmaita> and we are goiing to need an RC-2 anyway
14:19:39 <abhishekk> I guess so, https://review.openstack.org/#/c/523029/ (this needs to be get merged)
14:20:30 <rosmaita> yes, that has been sitting a while
14:20:43 <rosmaita> i had a question about it but never had time to look into it
14:21:29 <rosmaita> dyk what happens if something is being uploaded to the store when the delete is issued?
14:22:32 <abhishekk> need to check it though, but I guess it clears the image data
14:23:17 <rosmaita> i think you feel strongly that that needs to be in RC-1
14:23:25 <rosmaita> since image import is enabled by default
14:23:26 <jokke_> rosmaita: yeah I think doc patches should be fine for rc2 as well as bugfixes ... as long as we have all features onboard (like the db check)
14:24:11 <rosmaita> jokke_ cool, i do want to make 2.6 unexperimental in the api-ref before we cut RC-1 though
14:25:25 <rosmaita> jokke_ your thoughts about https://review.openstack.org/#/c/523029/ ? should we merge it for RC-1
14:26:48 <jokke_> it's a bug fix, it's fine either way ... we defo need it in for the release
14:27:07 <jokke_> we should aim for rc2 early next week anyways
14:27:32 <jokke_> but if we get it reviewed and merged for rc1 even better
14:27:40 <rosmaita> ok
14:28:12 <rosmaita> i think it is 8pm for abhishek right now
14:28:16 <jokke_> I'd like to avoid pushing rcx out day before we tag the final :D
14:28:43 <abhishekk> i will be available if required for next 4 hours
14:28:43 <rosmaita> yeah, agreed
14:29:12 <rosmaita> jokke_ do you have time to look over 523029 right after the meeting?
14:29:18 <jokke_> yes
14:29:24 <jokke_> have it open
14:29:53 <rosmaita> ok, great, let's get abhishekk some feedback immediately so he can go home
14:29:59 <rosmaita> next topic
14:30:02 <rosmaita> this is a bad one
14:30:23 <rosmaita> namely, postgresql support is broken
14:30:35 <rosmaita> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/glance/+bug/1747869
14:30:36 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1747869 in Glance "./stack.sh doesn't work with postgres" [Critical,Triaged] - Assigned to Brian Rosmaita (brian-rosmaita)
14:30:56 <jokke_> yes ... that also breaks non-voting manila test atm. tbarron dropped down to glance channel earlier today
14:30:56 <rosmaita> the person who filed that is correct, it's because of https://review.openstack.org/#/c/433934/
14:31:09 <rosmaita> yes, i saw his comment on the bug
14:31:39 <jokke_> we _need_ to fix that way or another before the release
14:31:57 <rosmaita> yes
14:32:03 <jokke_> good news is, that it's a bugfix we can get to RCx instead of having it in today
14:32:14 <abhishekk> are we targeting this for rc2?
14:32:16 <rosmaita> right, they are good with RC-2 time frame
14:32:21 <rosmaita> abhishekk yes
14:32:43 <rosmaita> the problem is online vs offline db migrations
14:33:10 <Shilpa> so are we allowing postgreSQL for EMC?
14:33:30 <rosmaita> we have to
14:33:44 <Shilpa> earlier EMC has that condition to support EMC only for MySQL
14:33:46 <jokke_> and I truly hope we can find a fix that does not involve reverting those patches involved
14:33:56 <rosmaita> the problem is, we can't support zero-downtime migrations for postgres
14:34:22 <rosmaita> but there should be no problem with offline migrations
14:34:40 <abhishekk> rosmaita, right
14:35:12 <rosmaita> anyway, i need to look more closely and am not prepared to make any suggestions ATM
14:35:29 <rosmaita> but i may need to call an emergency meeting on monday
14:35:31 <abhishekk> I will also have look tomorrow my time
14:35:32 <Shilpa> so postgreSQL support needed only for offline DB upgrade?
14:35:53 <rosmaita> Shilpa correct
14:36:12 <jokke_> Shilpa: more like we can only support postgre offline
14:36:35 <rosmaita> jokke_ yes, that's more accurate!
14:37:00 <rosmaita> ok, next item
14:37:13 <rosmaita> is anyone interested in backend migrations?
14:37:20 <rosmaita> or can i postpone that to next week?
14:37:31 <rosmaita> i think we have enough to do today to get RC-1 out
14:37:59 <jokke_> interested, yes; do I have time to focus on them now, no
14:38:02 <rosmaita> ok, postponed to next week
14:38:13 <rosmaita> #topic open discussion
14:38:48 <rosmaita> jokke_ btw, lance said that keystone will have a session about service tokens on monday of PTG
14:39:05 <rosmaita> i think the time is on the keystone planning etherpad
14:39:08 <jokke_> rosmaita: cool ... will need to find our way there then :D
14:39:53 <rosmaita> who put the team photo item on the agenda?
14:40:15 <abhishekk> me
14:40:30 <abhishekk> just to inform you
14:40:42 <rosmaita> jokke_ that's you now!
14:41:03 <abhishekk> I guess wrong timing :(
14:41:23 * jokke_ lost the link to the etherpad
14:41:32 <rosmaita> http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2018-February/127105.html
14:41:33 <jokke_> too many etherpads
14:41:41 <abhishekk> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/glance-team-meeting-agenda
14:41:54 <rosmaita> jokke_ also, there is the video interview thing again
14:42:14 <rosmaita> photos are tuesday and thursday, i think we will all be there on tuesday?
14:42:40 <abhishekk> i will o/
14:42:52 <jokke_> yeii
14:42:55 <rosmaita> anyway, jokke_ pick a time and sign glance up
14:43:03 <bhagyashris> jokke_, abhishekk, rosmaita: thank you for your support, help and time to get merge two feature in this cycle :)
14:43:12 <rosmaita> bhagyashris thanks for all your work!
14:43:20 <rosmaita> i hope you will stick around for Rocky!
14:43:24 <jokke_> what rosmaita just said!
14:43:46 <bhagyashris> rosmaita: yup
14:43:58 <rosmaita> so, jokke_ , just to be clear, you are in charge of signing glance up for (1) team photo, and (2) video interview
14:44:05 <rosmaita> great
14:44:07 <rosmaita> anything else?
14:44:18 <jokke_> rosmaita: I guess that comes with the title, yes
14:44:29 <jokke_> along with finalizing the PTG planning
14:44:31 <rosmaita> :)
14:44:46 <jokke_> we need PR liaison :P
14:44:53 <McClymontS> lol
14:45:26 <rosmaita> ok, so before we adjourn
14:45:53 <rosmaita> jokke_ will look over abhishekk 's data-not-getting-deleted-from-stage patch right away and let abhishekk know if it's ok
14:46:05 <rosmaita> rosmaita will revise the api releasenote
14:46:13 <rosmaita> rosmaita will revise the api-ref
14:46:27 <abhishekk> noted;
14:46:37 * jokke_ will fix the version neg middleware
14:46:46 <rosmaita> cool, i forgot about that one
14:47:04 <rosmaita> ok, please keep https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/glance-queens-rc1-patches updated
14:47:22 <rosmaita> i'll put up the release patch
14:47:43 <rosmaita> will -1 workflow it until it's clear what the hash is
14:47:59 <rosmaita> anything else?
14:48:08 <abhishekk> sounds good
14:48:28 <rosmaita> ok, great ... thanks everyone
14:48:32 <McClymontS> thank you
14:48:35 <jokke_> thanks all!
14:48:35 <rosmaita> and congratulations to jokke_ !
14:48:39 <abhishekk> thank you
14:48:41 <rosmaita> and my sympathies
14:48:44 <rosmaita> :)
14:48:46 <jokke_> cheers
14:48:47 <abhishekk> :D
14:48:54 <jokke_> some pints will be drank
14:49:01 <rosmaita> for sure!
14:49:14 <abhishekk> leave some for me as well :P
14:49:22 <rosmaita> #endmeeting