14:01:17 <abhishekk> #startmeeting glance
14:01:18 <openstack> Meeting started Thu May 14 14:01:17 2020 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is abhishekk. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:01:19 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:01:21 <abhishekk> #topic roll call
14:01:22 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'glance'
14:01:29 <jokke_> o/
14:01:31 <abhishekk> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/glance-team-meeting-agenda
14:01:35 <abhishekk> o/
14:01:46 <abhishekk> small agenda today
14:01:55 <abhishekk> lets wait couple of minutes for others
14:02:17 <rosmaita> o/
14:02:31 <abhishekk> cool, lets start
14:02:41 <abhishekk> #topic Updates
14:03:04 <abhishekk> Ussuri is released \o/
14:03:17 <jokke_> \\o \o/ o// o/7
14:03:20 <jokke_> GZ!
14:03:25 <rosmaita> yay!
14:03:27 <abhishekk> We did manage to achieve what we planned for this cycle
14:03:41 <jokke_> well done abhishekk
14:03:46 <abhishekk> Thank you everyone for support
14:04:07 <abhishekk> jokke_, thank you
14:04:09 <rosmaita> abhishekk: was this your first release?
14:04:21 <jokke_> rosmaita: it was
14:04:21 <abhishekk> rosmaita, as PTL yes
14:04:39 <rosmaita> congratulations! i wish you many more!!!
14:04:50 <abhishekk> thank you :D
14:05:23 <abhishekk> Now this leads us officially for V planning
14:05:42 <abhishekk> #link https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/Glance-Victoria-PTG-planning
14:05:53 <abhishekk> I have added some topics and will identify some more
14:06:24 <abhishekk> Kindly have a look and help me if I miss anything
14:06:31 <abhishekk> jokke_, rosmaita ^^
14:06:40 <rosmaita> ack
14:06:44 <jokke_> sure
14:06:52 <abhishekk> thank you
14:06:58 <abhishekk> Moving ahead
14:07:12 <abhishekk> #topic release periodic jobs update
14:07:25 <abhishekk> Same couple of failures due to oslo issue
14:07:51 <abhishekk> Bug is reported for the same in oslo, I will try to followup for the same
14:08:00 <jokke_> cool, let keep eye on that bug
14:08:07 <abhishekk> jokke_, yes
14:08:18 <jokke_> that way we know if we keep failing after that is reported fixed
14:08:27 <abhishekk> Other than that everything is green at the moment
14:08:32 * smcginnis sneaks in late
14:08:33 <abhishekk> jokke_, right
14:08:44 <abhishekk> smcginnis, o/
14:08:56 <rosmaita> smcginnis was out late partying after the release yesterday :)
14:09:00 <smcginnis> Hah
14:09:03 <jokke_> mhm
14:09:22 <smcginnis> To bed early since release activities started way too early my time. ;)
14:09:24 <abhishekk> haha, well deserved
14:09:26 <jokke_> smcginnis: thanks for yet another cycle of release support
14:09:38 <abhishekk> this is what I will miss this time, our dinner together in PTG
14:09:38 <smcginnis> Nice work everyone. It was a good release cycle.
14:09:55 <smcginnis> Yeah, would be really nice to see everyone.
14:10:01 <rosmaita> abhishekk: maybe we should plan a virtual happy hour at the PTG
14:10:29 <abhishekk> +2 if jokke_ hosts :D
14:11:02 <rosmaita> +2 to jokke_ hosting
14:11:27 <abhishekk> jokke_,please  vote +w :P
14:11:36 <rosmaita> :D
14:11:42 <jokke_> hahah!
14:11:51 <jokke_> +W
14:12:15 <abhishekk> :D
14:12:20 <abhishekk> moving ahead
14:12:33 <abhishekk> #topic Image encryption
14:12:44 <abhishekk> Contact 'Josephine Seifert <Luzi on irc> for image encryption
14:12:54 <abhishekk> I am not able to trace her
14:13:04 <abhishekk> jokke_, is it possible for you to contact her?
14:13:23 <rosmaita> i had been attending the weekly meetings, but don't think it was held the past 2 weeks
14:13:30 <rosmaita> (or i was in the wrong irc channel)
14:13:47 <abhishekk> we need to make sure whether she or her team is still working on this
14:13:54 <rosmaita> tell you what, i will reach out to her
14:14:01 <abhishekk> rosmaita, great
14:14:11 <rosmaita> because i have her scheduled to do the os-brick work for victoria M-1
14:14:29 <jokke_> Yeah will try to ... last update I got was that they were waiting for the barbican bits to be released
14:14:31 <abhishekk> awesome, we need to target this work in V cycle
14:14:35 <rosmaita> ok, i will report back next week
14:14:41 <abhishekk> +2
14:14:43 <rosmaita> the barbican stuff got reverted
14:14:52 <abhishekk> jokke_, thank you
14:15:01 <rosmaita> not sure exactly what the problem was, but i think it will land early in victoria
14:15:07 <jokke_> oh, that's unfortunate setback
14:15:13 <abhishekk> rosmaita, barbican stuff is tracked in storyboard, right?
14:15:23 <rosmaita> i think so
14:15:42 <rosmaita> i will reach out about the barbican stuff, too, because we would like to use that in cinder, too
14:15:46 <jokke_> AFAIK they are not even participating the vPTG so not sure what's going on in that space
14:15:59 <rosmaita> and maybe to harden the encryptino key removal stuff in glance
14:16:11 <abhishekk> jokke_, right
14:16:16 <jokke_> I was hoping to catch up with them, but they were not listed
14:17:06 <abhishekk> ok, so hopefully we will get some update by next week
14:17:35 <jokke_> ++
14:17:42 <abhishekk> moving ahead to Open discussion
14:17:51 <abhishekk> #topic Open discussion
14:18:08 <abhishekk> #link https://review.opendev.org/#/c/626008/
14:18:14 <abhishekk> review request from rosmaita
14:18:27 <rosmaita> yes, please!!! it's been sitting since 2018
14:18:34 <abhishekk> will have a look immediately after the meeting
14:18:41 <rosmaita> our lower-constraints job has never actually tested anything
14:18:55 <abhishekk> :o
14:18:59 <rosmaita> also, smcginnis noted that we could refactor the tox.ini file a bit
14:19:09 <rosmaita> might be a good low-hanging-fruit bug
14:19:15 <smcginnis> I think that was a good call to make that a separate effort.
14:19:19 <abhishekk> will have a look
14:20:11 <abhishekk> So regarding registry code removal, I have a devstack patch up which was -2 by QE guys
14:20:34 <abhishekk> they want us to remove registry usages from all other projects
14:20:51 <abhishekk> #link http://codesearch.openstack.org/?q=g-reg&i=nope&files=&repos=
14:21:18 <smcginnis> Hmm. That's not usually on the team that has deprecated something for a long time like this.
14:21:34 <abhishekk> I am planning to send mail on openstack-discuss saying we are going to remove it by V2 milestone
14:22:29 <abhishekk> and will request respective teams to remove it from there code base as well before V2
14:22:38 <abhishekk> Does this sounds good?
14:22:55 <jokke_> So who is using registry directly?
14:23:41 <rosmaita> looks like a lot of people from that link above
14:23:59 <abhishekk> no idea, the above link lists lots of usage
14:24:47 <jokke_> the link lists bunch of local.conf samples that enables it,
14:24:52 <abhishekk> I can see some tempest plugins and neutron
14:24:55 <jokke_> it doesn't list any usage of it
14:25:28 <abhishekk> some yaml and rc files are also there
14:26:06 <smcginnis> I would be based on most of these that they are not actually using g-reg. It was just copy pasted along as different projects set up their configuration files.
14:26:20 <jokke_> smcginnis: ++
14:26:22 <abhishekk> We need a proper plan to get registry code out in this cycle
14:27:02 <jokke_> abhishekk: disable tempest, remove registry, deal with dumpsterfires, profit
14:27:02 <rosmaita> yeah, i think maybe put up a patch that makes that option a no-op, and then we put up patches that run each of those project's tests depending on the no-op to show that they're not really using the registry
14:27:09 <abhishekk> So I will send a mail to ML next week and then we will start removing code around 2nd week
14:27:44 <abhishekk> rosmaita, that could be more time consuming
14:27:56 <abhishekk> jokke_, that will be last option :D
14:29:00 <jokke_> abhishekk: I like rosmaita's approach as well. Just change the g-reg in devstack to be dummy no-op, if that goes through clean, we can remove registry from glance and leave the no-op to devstack
14:29:31 <rosmaita> it is time-consuming, but would probably be faster overall
14:29:46 <abhishekk> If all of you agree, then I will draft one mail and send it next week around Monday/Tuesday
14:30:08 <smcginnis> ++
14:30:08 <abhishekk> rosmaita, jokke_ Ok, I will start doing changes
14:31:00 <jokke_> maybe make `alias glance-registry echo "Glance registry service has been removed." >> /var/log/glance/glance-registry.log` so calling it and the logfiles will be there
14:31:05 <jokke_> breaking even less things
14:32:00 <abhishekk> Ok, let me see how I can do it, will update you accordingly
14:32:05 <jokke_> ;)
14:32:39 <abhishekk> That's it from me
14:32:51 <abhishekk> Do we have anything else to discuss
14:33:16 <jokke_> I don't think I have anything
14:33:27 <abhishekk> rosmaita, smcginnis ?
14:33:51 <rosmaita> the PTG etherpad looks pretty full for victoria
14:34:40 <abhishekk> Yes, I still need to add registry removal though
14:34:41 <smcginnis> Nope
14:34:58 <smcginnis> Nothing from me I mean.
14:35:11 <abhishekk> great, lets warp up early today
14:35:19 <jokke_> Thanks all!
14:35:26 <abhishekk> Once again thank you all and have a nice weekend ahead
14:35:27 <jokke_> really good release
14:35:30 * jokke_ is happy
14:35:40 * abhishekk #metoo
14:35:55 <rosmaita> if jokke_ and abhishekk are happy, then i am too
14:36:05 <abhishekk> :D
14:36:26 <abhishekk> I like it when everyone is happy
14:36:31 <smcginnis> :)
14:36:43 <abhishekk> cool, wrapping up
14:36:50 <abhishekk> #endmeeting