08:03:19 <aspiers> #startmeeting ha
08:03:20 <openstack> Meeting started Mon Apr 18 08:03:19 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is aspiers. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
08:03:21 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
08:03:24 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'ha'
08:03:42 <aspiers> hi all, who do we have today?
08:03:45 <haukebruno> morning all. so it is 8 utc not 9 utc?
08:04:06 <aspiers> haukebruno: the meeting is at 9am Europe/London
08:04:18 <aspiers> as discussed last week
08:04:30 <haukebruno> ah! I missunderstood that, thought it will be 9 UTC, but no problem for me :p
08:06:09 <aspiers> haukebruno: http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/ha/2016/ha.2016-04-11-09.03.log.html#l-180
08:06:39 <aspiers> which reminds me I need to update the schedule
08:07:32 <masahito> hi
08:07:52 <masahito> I've been here :)
08:08:02 <samP_> o/
08:08:14 <aspiers> hi guys :)
08:08:36 <aspiers> ok let's start
08:09:00 <aspiers> #topic Current status (progress, issues, roadblocks, further plans)
08:09:29 <aspiers> ddeja and I have been preparing our Austin talk
08:09:55 <aspiers> it would be great if you could review the draft
08:10:14 <aspiers> to make sure we represent each solution fairly
08:10:36 <aspiers> we can share the URL maybe later today or tomorrow
08:11:06 <aspiers> that's all from my side
08:11:22 <haukebruno> cool, I am looking forward to read it.
08:11:28 <moiz> hello everyone :)
08:11:33 <aspiers> welcome moiz
08:11:46 <masahito> moiz: welcome
08:11:56 <aspiers> anything from anyone else?
08:12:08 <masahito> I have
08:12:44 <masahito> samP_ and me relased masakari 1.1.0 release
08:12:48 <aspiers> cool
08:13:17 <masahito> details are here. https://github.com/ntt-sic/masakari/releases
08:13:29 <masahito> that's from our side.
08:13:40 <aspiers> #info masakari 1.1.0 is out
08:13:54 <aspiers> moiz: you want to summarize your experiments so far?
08:14:16 <moiz> sure.
08:15:49 <moiz> 1. firstly, i deployed RHOS and tried out VM evac using pacemaker 1.1.13. i was successful in doing so after some debugging and fire fighting. and ran several evacuation and made a small benchmarking document (VM downtimes for different nova flavors)
08:16:37 <moiz> 2. secondly, i moved to a canonical deploy with 14.04. i ran into several problems here. firstly, an outdated pacemaker version 1.1.10 held me down
08:17:00 <aspiers> moiz: was that using the RH-supported code?
08:17:17 <moiz> then i moved to 1.1.12 version and connected remote nodes. tried replicating the same testbed as in RHOS but i was not able to do that
08:17:35 <aspiers> 1.1.12 is still too old
08:18:14 <moiz> i tried compiling 1.1.13 & 1.1.14 on the POD but ran into dependency issues. i asked ubuntu guys but they said move to 16.04
08:18:23 <aspiers> ah
08:18:29 <moiz> right now i am trying out Masakari
08:18:54 <moiz> aspiers: yes
08:19:07 <aspiers> is there documentation for the RH install process?
08:19:37 <moiz> i basically followed this link:https://access.redhat.com/articles/1544823
08:19:48 <aspiers> thanks
08:20:12 <moiz> and beekhof post helped me alot in understanding the workflow http://blog.clusterlabs.org/blog/2015/openstack-ha-compute/
08:20:49 <aspiers> that blog is out of dateeeeeeeeeeeeee
08:20:54 <aspiers> date :)
08:20:59 <haukebruno> :p
08:21:00 <aspiers> sorry, stuck keys
08:21:14 <aspiers> keyboard is 15 years old
08:21:17 <moiz> i have made a sort of a document which contains step by step guide from a vanilla install to setting up compute HA
08:21:40 <moiz> haha.
08:21:43 <aspiers> cool
08:22:01 <moiz> i replicated the RHOS 2 times and second time it went flawless
08:22:28 <moiz> i can have update for you guys regarding Masakari 2 days from now :)
08:22:33 <aspiers> moiz: I look forward to you trying SUSE OpenStack Cloud, where you can set up VM HA with just a few drags of the mouse
08:22:49 <aspiers> you really didn't try the easiest option first ;-)
08:23:18 <masahito> moiz: sounds nice. I'm looking forward.
08:23:27 <aspiers> we can provide you with an appliance .iso for quick install
08:23:43 <moiz> ahh.. wished i had talked to you guys earlier :) you all have been great help in my learning curve
08:23:53 <moiz> aspiers: sure i would love that.
08:23:57 <aspiers> moiz: I told you about it a long time ago ;-p
08:24:20 <aspiers> anyway, it is good for you to try them all
08:24:32 <moiz> yes you did. but at that time i was already into RHOS and didnt want to leave it without a proper conclusion :p
08:24:38 <aspiers> right
08:24:45 <moiz> After masakari i am going to try out SOC
08:24:49 <aspiers> great
08:24:56 <aspiers> haukebruno: any updates from you?
08:25:04 <haukebruno> not :(
08:25:11 <aspiers> no problem
08:25:16 <ddeja> hi, sorry, I'm attending another meeting in the same time
08:25:18 <aspiers> no need for the :( face ;-)
08:25:21 <aspiers> ddeja: no problem
08:26:02 <aspiers> #topic Austin
08:26:42 <aspiers> hope to see you all at our talk on Tuesday 3:40pm https://www.openstack.org/summit/austin-2016/summit-schedule/events/7327
08:27:01 <aspiers> I am also trying to get the PWG to arrange a meeting with us
08:27:10 <aspiers> since they said VM HA is their #2 priority
08:27:13 <aspiers> but nothing fixed yet
08:27:51 <aspiers> also kgaillot (Pacemaker maintainer) suggested meeting Wed lunch or evening
08:28:04 <aspiers> again nothing fixed yet
08:28:19 <ddeja> cool
08:28:27 <aspiers> he might book a room if possible
08:28:57 <aspiers> let's keep watching #openstack-ha to finalize plans
08:29:25 <samP_> aspiers: thanks
08:29:33 <aspiers> #info trying to finalize meeting plans, please watch #openstack-ha
08:29:53 <aspiers> any other HA talks we should watch out for?
08:30:18 <ddeja> I'm not aware of any
08:30:24 <aspiers> https://www.openstack.org/summit/austin-2016/summit-schedule/events/8326
08:30:25 <masahito> aspiers: could you send a mail in ML?
08:30:38 <aspiers> masahito: when something is fixed, yes
08:30:45 <masahito> ok.
08:31:00 <aspiers> masahito: or you mean, to help fix a time?
08:31:36 <masahito> the official meeting is great! but, I wouldn't attend the meeting if it's just after Wed launch.
08:31:45 <aspiers> ok
08:31:56 <masahito> because I have Congress meeting ;-)
08:32:11 <aspiers> masahito: we meant Wed lunch, not after lunch
08:32:18 <aspiers> "working" lunch
08:32:25 <aspiers> but it was just an idea
08:32:33 <masahito> oh, got it.
08:32:57 <moiz> masahito: any other informational content on masakari ? i could only find your talk and github page.
08:32:58 <aspiers> I would like to join the Congress meeting too :)
08:33:19 <moiz> i am atm looking at the code itself to understand the internal workflow.
08:34:27 <masahito> moiz: I have the 2 stuffs about masakari.
08:34:53 <aspiers> ok any other topics?
08:35:23 <aspiers> the spec and user story still need reviews IIRC
08:37:07 <aspiers> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/289469/
08:37:07 <patchbot> aspiers: patch 289469 - openstack-user-stories - High Availability for Virtual Machines
08:37:32 <aspiers> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/257809/
08:37:32 <patchbot> aspiers: patch 257809 - openstack-specs - Instances auto evacuation
08:37:56 <aspiers> even though the cross-project team voted to abandon the spec
08:38:42 <aspiers> #action (anyone) review spec and user story
08:39:07 <aspiers> also I plan to finish setting up openstack-resource-agents-specs this week
08:39:11 <aspiers> I keep getting delayed on it
08:39:38 <aspiers> #topic AOB
08:39:42 <aspiers> anything else?
08:39:47 <aspiers> if not we can finish early
08:39:55 <haukebruno> how was the ha meetup last week in manchester?
08:40:13 <aspiers> haukebruno: it was very good!
08:40:21 <haukebruno> poorly I didn't make it, 500 � just for the flight was too hard
08:40:25 <aspiers> I did a live demo of SOC compute HA, and it worked perfectly :-D
08:40:30 <haukebruno> aspiers, are there any slides outthere?
08:40:39 <aspiers> haukebruno: are you coming to Austin?
08:40:39 <haukebruno> oh very nice
08:41:27 <haukebruno> no :( hard project deadlines and stuff
08:41:34 <aspiers> the slides are at http://aspiers.github.io/compute-ha-presentation/
08:41:38 <haukebruno> but the barcelona summit is blocked in my calendar
08:41:43 <haukebruno> cool, thanks
08:41:46 <aspiers> but we will do a better version in Austin
08:42:01 <ddeja> and there will be youtube video
08:42:05 <aspiers> right
08:42:10 <ddeja> so audio + slides :)
08:42:19 <aspiers> so anyone coming to Austin should not look at those slides, to avoid spoiling the nice surprise ;-)
08:42:28 <haukebruno> haha
08:42:54 <aspiers> I'm joking, since we want masahito, samP_, beekhof etc. to review our draft slides
08:43:13 <aspiers> but I will send the link for those later today or tomorrow when they are closer to ready
08:43:46 <aspiers> btw does anyone know an OpenStack HA expert at Canonical?
08:45:10 <aspiers> anything else? otherwise we can finish
08:46:39 <aspiers> ok I guess not
08:46:55 <aspiers> let's continue planning for Austin on #openstack-ha :)
08:47:07 <haukebruno> thanks so far
08:47:13 <masahito> bye
08:47:14 <ddeja> bye
08:47:14 <aspiers> oh, of course we will cancel the meeting next week
08:47:20 <aspiers> #info no meeting next week
08:47:23 <samP_> thx and bye
08:47:26 <aspiers> and the week after I am on holiday
08:47:32 <moiz> bye guys :)
08:47:38 <aspiers> maybe we will all need a rest then anyway ;-)
08:47:47 <aspiers> thanks and see some of you in Austin!
08:47:50 <aspiers> #endmeeting