07:00:38 <skraynev> #startmeeting heat
07:00:39 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Feb 17 07:00:38 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is skraynev. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
07:00:40 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
07:00:43 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'heat'
07:00:53 <skraynev> #topic  rollcall
07:01:09 <stevebaker> \o
07:01:20 <ananta> o/
07:01:21 <skraynev> ramishra, shardy
07:01:36 <skraynev> jdob
07:01:38 <elynn> o/
07:01:57 <skraynev> neelashah: ping
07:03:09 <skraynev> #topic Adding items to agenda
07:03:22 <skraynev> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/HeatAgenda#Agenda_.282016-02-17_0700_UTC.29
07:03:38 <stevebaker> skraynev: heat osc commands?
07:04:03 <skraynev> stevebaker: do you have updates ?
07:04:25 <stevebaker> skraynev: yep
07:04:31 <skraynev> stevebaker: ok. added
07:04:49 <ramishra> hi
07:05:11 <skraynev> ramishra: hi
07:05:24 <skraynev> ok. we can start
07:05:42 <skraynev> #topic Spec-lite review request
07:05:55 <skraynev> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/heat/+bug/1545857
07:05:55 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1545857 in heat "Add a heat.type constraint" [Undecided,New] - Assigned to Jay Dobies (jdob)
07:06:11 <stevebaker> our first spec-lite?
07:06:21 <skraynev> I think about moving it to heat-next and landing in N
07:06:24 <skraynev> stevebaker: yeah :)
07:06:50 <stevebaker> a new constraint is fairly low risk though if he can land it for m
07:07:15 <ramishra> +1
07:07:47 <stevebaker> I (ahem) may be writing my own spec-lite for M tomorrow
07:08:02 <skraynev> lol
07:08:16 <stevebaker> just a tiny little feature
07:08:25 <skraynev> I have not enough time for reviewing all of it ;)
07:09:26 <ramishra> btw, can we get the spec-lite contrib guidelines in too;)  reviews appreciated https://review.openstack.org/#/c/271177/
07:09:30 <skraynev> stevebaker; k. let's try. I think, that I may reduce some uncomplete bugs on the next meeting
07:10:04 <skraynev> stevebaker: the another interesting question: can we merge spec-lite after FF ?
07:10:13 <skraynev> ramishra: ^
07:10:55 <stevebaker> skraynev: you mean the feature itself? I'd assume feature freeze rules would apply
07:12:06 <skraynev> stevebaker: yes. it's a bit confusing, that launchpad will show this as a bug, not BP
07:13:30 <skraynev> stevebaker: but I think, that we can deal with it ;)
07:13:38 <ramishra> skraynev: it would be  of importance wishlist.  IMO we should handle it like a feature with FF.
07:13:51 <ramishra> skraynev: though we can check with glance team how they are doing it.
07:13:52 <stevebaker> I guess as soon as we hit ff the spec-lite bugs get kicked to the next milestone
07:14:02 <stevebaker> unless they have a ffe
07:14:19 <skraynev> ramishra: stevebaker: kk
07:14:47 <skraynev> stevebaker: do I need ping someone about potential ffe ?
07:15:09 <stevebaker> I think its basically up to us these days
07:15:15 <stevebaker> us==PTL
07:15:57 <skraynev> heh. ok
07:17:00 <skraynev> #topic LBaaS v2 support in Heat
07:17:10 <skraynev> so it's a good candidate for ffe
07:17:39 <elynn> I think most of codes for LBaaS v2 are submitted.
07:17:49 <elynn> Waiting for more reviews.
07:18:00 <stevebaker> agreed, its self contained, being actively reviewed
07:18:04 <ananta> i tested the lbaasv2 and basic things work with the changes i suggested
07:18:10 <skraynev> elynn: yes, but I still wait +1 from Jenkins without -1 from reviewers
07:18:27 <skraynev> ananta: cool. thank you
07:18:44 <elynn> That's great.
07:19:07 <skraynev> update priority to High
07:19:27 <elynn> Just make sure this feature can be merged in m-3 :)
07:19:59 <elynn> Thanks skraynev :)
07:20:28 <ananta_> skraynev: I am following up
07:20:45 <skraynev> #topic OSC commands
07:21:08 <skraynev> stevebaker: it's your show time  :)
07:21:26 <stevebaker> only 5 commands need to land, but I've been writing some enhancement changes too https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/heat-support-python-openstackclient
07:21:59 <skraynev> stevebaker: I have seen that more then 50 % merged, but I spent a lot of time for reviewing merged patches (to understand how it should looks like)
07:22:17 <skraynev> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/heat-support-python-openstackclient
07:22:32 <stevebaker> so stuff is happening, but there is only a week to go
07:22:57 <stevebaker> I finally started the "stack failures list" command https://review.openstack.org/#/c/280963/
07:23:05 <stevebaker> will finish the unit tests tomorrow
07:23:10 <skraynev> stevebaker: more over, I think about updating output-show and output list with supporting new API too
07:24:02 <stevebaker> skraynev: +1, although if it doesn't change the UI that could be a stable-backportable bug fix
07:25:04 <skraynev> stevebaker: yeah. it's already work for old cli, but we need to use the same approach for osc methods
07:25:26 <skraynev> stevebaker: do you want to land "stack failures list" before 1.0.0 ?
07:25:38 <stevebaker> I'd like to
07:25:58 <skraynev> ok. just wanted to clarify
07:26:29 <stevebaker> I've got nothing else on this topic, unless someone else has
07:27:47 <skraynev> nothing from my side :) it looks like a really awesome works was done and we need to finish it and then drink a beer
07:28:01 <stevebaker> I know, I'm amazed
07:29:01 <skraynev> #topic amazing stevebaker ;)
07:29:05 <skraynev> oops
07:29:17 <stevebaker> hur
07:29:22 <skraynev> #topic M3 status
07:29:41 <skraynev> #link https://launchpad.net/heat/+milestone/mitaka-3
07:30:12 <skraynev> so we have a big numbers of BP
07:30:20 <skraynev> and also a lot of bugs for m3
07:30:41 <skraynev> I think, that we should finish BP first of all and then focus on bugs during preparing for rc1
07:31:35 <skraynev> elyn: what's about senlin resources?
07:31:48 <elynn> most codes are submitted
07:31:49 <skraynev> I have seen two new on review + constraints
07:32:10 <elynn> No more resources needed to add.
07:32:10 <skraynev> do you plan to add more resources ?
07:32:34 <elynn> But I will add some templates to heat-templates later.
07:32:41 <skraynev> elynn: it's ok
07:33:45 <skraynev> please make sure, that it will land during this and next week
07:34:17 <skraynev> I will also ping personally all BP assignee and ask status.
07:35:06 <ramishra> update restrict functional tests have a dependency on https://review.openstack.org/#/c/248676/, but it seems to be stuck with unrelated gate failures(number of rechecks)
07:36:04 <skraynev> ramishra: is't failures related  with changes?
07:36:14 <ramishra> skraynev: nope
07:36:40 <skraynev> unexpected API error...
07:36:52 <ramishra> I'll try one more time
07:36:55 <skraynev> I have seen such error early
07:37:08 <skraynev> ramishra: yeah. please do it
07:38:24 <skraynev> ramishra: also it looks like good tome to ping shardy and anant to look on other patches
07:38:37 <skraynev> related with restrict update for convergence case
07:38:40 <ramishra> some patches seem to be going through a cycle of errors at times;)
07:38:44 <skraynev> and functional tests
07:39:02 <skraynev> ramishra: yeah. I know.
07:39:04 <skraynev> btw...
07:39:13 <ramishra> yeah will do that today. Expecting to get it approved today.
07:39:16 <ramishra> :)
07:39:57 <skraynev> stevebaker: ramishra: elynn: please review this patch https://review.openstack.org/#/c/280129/
07:40:13 <stevebaker> sure
07:40:16 <skraynev> it's one of frequently error on the gate
07:40:32 <elynn> will do
07:40:41 <skraynev> we discussed it with therve and it loks like should fix one of blockers and makes gate more stable
07:40:46 <skraynev> thx guys
07:42:15 <skraynev> #topic Open discussion
07:43:56 <skraynev> do we have anything else for discussion?
07:44:21 * ricolin come here very late
07:44:34 <skraynev> if no, let's try to review all High priority patches ;)
07:44:51 <elynn> :)
07:44:57 <skraynev> ricolin: no. you come at the best moment
07:45:16 <ricolin> review!!:)
07:45:16 <skraynev> moment, when I can say: please review high priority patches ;)
07:45:21 <skraynev> yes ;)
07:45:30 <skraynev> ricolin: this one https://launchpad.net/heat/+milestone/mitaka-3
07:45:37 <ricolin> on it
07:45:54 <skraynev> or try to focus on lbaas or osc https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/heat-support-python-openstackclient
07:46:11 <skraynev> ricolin: great. we need your +2 ;)
07:46:20 <skraynev> and -1 too :)
07:46:34 <ricolin> and please help to review this
07:46:35 <ricolin> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/252201/
07:47:31 <ricolin> tempest team still waiting for this patch to get merge before they put their patch
07:47:41 <ricolin> so we're waiting for each otehr
07:48:47 <skraynev> ricolin: Oh I remember this one. I will take i a look
07:49:14 <skraynev> let's continue in #heat
07:49:29 <skraynev> thanks everyone
07:49:36 <skraynev> #endmeeting