17:00:01 <jroll> #startmeeting ironic
17:00:02 <openstack> Meeting started Mon Jan 30 17:00:01 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is jroll. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
17:00:03 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
17:00:04 <TheJulia> o/
17:00:05 <mariojv> o/
17:00:06 <JayF> o/
17:00:06 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'ironic'
17:00:10 <mat128_> O/
17:00:10 <lucasagomes> o/
17:00:15 <galyna> o/
17:00:16 <aslezil> o/
17:00:17 <jroll> welcome, everyone
17:00:21 <soliosg> o/
17:00:25 <stendulker> o/
17:00:26 <rloo> o/
17:00:27 <vdrok> o/
17:00:30 <dtantsur|mtg> o/
17:00:33 <aarefiev> o/
17:00:34 <joanna> o/
17:00:36 <joanna> o/
17:00:38 <jlvillal> o/
17:00:38 <crushil> o/
17:00:44 <jroll> as always, agenda:
17:00:46 * dtantsur|mtg will switch to this meeting soon, still finishing
17:00:47 <rpioso> o/
17:00:54 <jroll> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Ironic#Agenda_for_next_meeting
17:01:04 <jroll> #topic announcements and reminders
17:01:11 <jroll> just a few things here
17:01:36 <jroll> #info reminder to add to the PTG discussion list: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/ironic-pike-ptg
17:01:38 <jroll> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/ironic-pike-ptg
17:01:59 <jroll> #info we intend to feature freeze ironic/inspector/IPA this week, and release them next week
17:02:32 <jroll> #info pike PTL elections open this week, we have 3 candidates, should be exciting :)
17:02:35 <jroll> #link https://governance.openstack.org/election/
17:02:38 <jroll> more info there ^^
17:02:51 <jroll> good luck JayF, dtantsur|mtg, TheJulia :)
17:02:59 <TheJulia> Thank you jroll
17:03:02 <jroll> any other announcements/reminders?
17:03:05 <rloo> may the best person win :)
17:03:17 <rloo> even though you are all best in my book!
17:03:19 <vgadiraj> o/
17:03:27 <NobodyCam> o/
17:03:31 <TheJulia> rloo: Thank you :)
17:03:47 <JayF> if the best person wins, I might be in for a bit of electoral trouble ;0
17:03:50 <lucasagomes> rloo, ++
17:04:38 <soliosg> does each project have different timings for PTL election?
17:04:51 <jroll> soliosg: no, they're all at the same time
17:05:06 <jroll> many do not have elections, though, as they only have one candidate
17:05:10 <soliosg> I received an email this weekend announcing the new PTL for docs
17:05:28 <soliosg> or maybe I misunderstood something :(
17:05:36 <jroll> yes, many projects only have one candidate
17:05:38 <dtantsur|mtg> if there are no elections (e.g. one candidate), the outcome is obvious
17:05:41 <jroll> and so they must win
17:05:46 <soliosg> I see, thanks!
17:05:47 <jroll> see https://governance.openstack.org/election/
17:05:50 <rloo> soliosg: only one person ran for ptl in docs i believe, so no need to vote
17:06:13 <jroll> shall we move on to subteams?
17:06:26 <jroll> #topic subteam status updates
17:06:37 * jroll updates things he knows about
17:06:59 <mgould> o/
17:07:31 <bfournie> o/
17:08:42 <jroll> did anyone get to reviewing node tags last week? how's that looking?
17:08:47 * dtantsur didn't
17:09:08 <rloo> jroll: i did, i stopped after the first patch when it seemed to me the client part would not make it.
17:09:25 * jlvillal didn't. Was focused on driver composition
17:09:46 <jroll> do we want to punt it to pike, or try to get it in this week?
17:09:50 <rloo> jroll: cuz i had some comments with the first patch, and there were at least 2 more after that...
17:09:56 <jroll> right
17:10:06 <rloo> jroll: i think we should punt it. i could be wrong but i think the author is still on holiday
17:10:16 <jroll> rloo: aha, right, forgot about that. +1
17:10:20 <dtantsur> without a client change, it does not look THAT useful to land it right now
17:10:25 <vdrok> yup, chinese new year
17:10:41 <jlvillal> Year of the Rooster. According to Overwatch ;)
17:11:16 <rloo> jlvillal: yup
17:11:24 <rloo> yay, soft power things are done! :)
17:11:36 <dtantsur> yep, even nova part has landed
17:11:47 <jroll> NMI stuff may even land in nova with an FFE
17:11:57 <dtantsur> jroll, did they request one?
17:11:59 <rloo> jroll: who is asking for the FFE? (has it been asked?)
17:12:06 <jroll> dtantsur: dunno, but it's on nova's list nonetheless
17:12:10 <JayF> Nova said on ML last week no FFEs
17:12:12 <jroll> I'll ask matt, I didn't see that
17:12:21 <JayF> and listed a small handful of patches that were the last to land in Ocata
17:12:25 <jroll> https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/nova-ocata-feature-freeze
17:12:28 <jroll> is where I see that
17:12:35 <rloo> i thought matt is away but could be wrong
17:12:40 <jroll> I'll clarify with matt or someone
17:12:42 <jroll> he's in and out
17:13:03 <rloo> nmi isn't a huge priority for us though
17:13:04 <dtantsur> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/376548/ has 1x +2
17:13:18 <dtantsur> rloo, yeah, I just like finished stuff :)
17:13:22 <jroll> rloo: I agree, but the status is unclear, so I'm going to clarify.
17:13:31 * jroll is not pushing, just asking
17:13:34 <rloo> dtantsur: don't we all! :D
17:13:40 <dtantsur> I hope so :)
17:13:53 <rloo> thx jroll, clarification is always good
17:13:59 <dtantsur> (except for the driver composition - it never finishes..)
17:14:05 <jroll> so, is there any feature work besides driver composition we want to get done this week?
17:14:11 <jroll> seems everything is done or bumped to pike
17:14:22 <dtantsur> let's get some bugs fixed? :)
17:14:34 <vsaienk0> jroll CI improvements? :)
17:14:40 <jroll> well, yes, just sanity checking on feature work
17:14:58 <dtantsur> yeah, and CI stuff
17:15:00 <jroll> vsaienk0: maybe, depends on the thing, I want to be careful not to break CI right before release :)
17:15:14 <dtantsur> just don't make anything voting and don't refactor too much
17:15:29 <jroll> ++
17:15:31 <rloo> wrt portgroups, there are a few things not done yet. do we want to get them done (tempest tests, doc) in ocata?
17:15:49 <jroll> rloo: yes, testing and docs isn't really "feature" work
17:15:53 <jroll> (imo)
17:16:05 <dtantsur> both can be (and often should be) backported
17:16:07 <rloo> jroll: huh? aren't they part of the feature?
17:16:10 <vdrok> I'll get to docs this week
17:16:17 <jroll> rloo: in terms of freezing.
17:16:28 <rloo> jroll: oh yeah. i was just asking wrt ocata.
17:16:30 <jroll> so yeah, driver composition is the only feature thing to get in before feature freeze, best I can tell
17:16:40 <jroll> and then let's finish up docs, testing, fix some bugs
17:16:44 <jroll> and call it a cycle :)
17:16:51 <vdrok> \o/
17:16:57 <rloo> ocd. ocata cycle done...
17:17:01 <dtantsur> good plan!
17:17:03 <TheJulia> sounds good to me
17:17:13 <milan> o/
17:17:33 <mariojv> congrats all on a good cycle
17:17:46 <rloo> mariojv: it ain't over yet :)
17:17:53 <jroll> ^^ :P
17:17:54 <dtantsur> yeah, we still can make it bad :D
17:18:07 <jroll> okay, I listed quick priorities, I don't have particulars to list there
17:18:48 <jroll> feel free to add links if you come across some high-priority bugs or whatever :)
17:19:08 <rloo> wrt bug fixes and docs. could we have two volunteers maybe, to look into those two and let the rest of us know what we should be looking at?
17:19:12 <jlvillal> Should we add the ironic-tempest-plugin repository work to the CI status section?
17:19:28 <dtantsur> jlvillal, I'd wait until the PTG with any actions on that
17:19:29 <jroll> jlvillal: we already agreed to wait for pike on that, so meh
17:19:35 <jroll> rloo: yes, I'd love that
17:19:38 <jlvillal> Okay
17:19:43 <lucasagomes> jlvillal, are we decided on it already ? If so yes
17:20:15 <jlvillal> I wasn't sure if people wanted to have updates on what has been going on there. But can wait until PTG time :)
17:20:21 <rloo> ^^ volunteers? you can apply here or elsewhere :)
17:20:33 <dtantsur> rloo, I can look at bugs
17:20:42 <dtantsur> I always look at them anyway :)
17:20:51 <rloo> fwiw, i looked at the bugs/patches for the client release last week
17:20:52 <jroll> I'll try to skim things but idk how much time I'll have to do so
17:20:54 <rloo> dtantsur: thx!
17:20:59 <vdrok> I can do docs then :)
17:21:06 <rloo> jroll has to focus on driver composition
17:21:31 <rloo> thx vdrok!
17:21:42 <jroll> thanks vdrok and dtantsur
17:21:46 <jroll> anything else here?
17:22:19 <jroll> #topic open discussion
17:22:43 <JayF> Were there no RFEs to go over this week? Or is that usually after open discussion?
17:22:44 <rloo> jroll: anyone. wrt ptg, is the plan to hold ironic things m-f all day?
17:22:54 <rloo> oh, i mean wed-fri
17:23:07 <jlvillal> FYI: 3 weeks until the PTG.
17:23:17 <jroll> JayF: there were none on the agenda
17:23:36 <jroll> rloo: I suspect people will leave friday night, as such, friday afternoon may be light[
17:23:41 <mariojv> rloo: i thought friday afternoon would be left off for folks traveling, yeah that ^
17:23:46 <jroll> I'd like to talk friday morning at least
17:24:11 <rloo> jroll, mariojv: good to know! that traditional friday 'meet up' may be different at the ptg i guess.
17:24:26 <jroll> rloo: the whole thing will be less formal :)
17:24:38 <soliosg> regarding the ironic-tempest-plugin move to new repo
17:24:53 <soliosg> at some time we'll need a code freeze on ironic/ironic_tempest_plugin
17:25:03 <rloo> jroll: right.
17:25:22 <soliosg> so, just keep in mind in case devs have patches that update ironic and ironic/ironic_tem...
17:25:29 <vdrok> huh, I'm not guessing with the tickets again :) in US it's usually till friday midday, and in EU it's usually whole afternoon? :)
17:25:43 <rloo> soliosg: how much time is needed for this code freeze?
17:26:02 <jroll> vdrok: dunno, it's first PTG, this is just what I guess will happen :)
17:26:06 <rloo> soliosg: where are we/you tracking this. would be good to document this code freeze thing.
17:26:30 <soliosg> we'll try to sync-up code from ironic to ironic-tempest-plugin regularly
17:26:43 <jlvillal> rloo: If and when it happens. Basically code that would have gone into openstack/ironic/ironic_tempest_plugin will instead go into openstack/ironic-tempest-plugin/ironic_tempest_plugin
17:26:44 <TheJulia> why would we not "freeze" at the same time, as in whatever commit hash matches ironic when it is frozen?
17:27:12 <rloo> since we're not doing this til pike, perhaps this is something to discuss later?
17:27:15 <soliosg> and have test runs, when the time comes, should be a matter of updating project-config to point to the new repo
17:27:29 <rloo> soliosg: would help if you coudl write up something about the process/plan?
17:27:51 <soliosg> yeap, we should get to the details later, after ocata cycle ends
17:28:05 <TheJulia> Agreed
17:29:06 <rloo> crickets?
17:29:16 <jroll> yep
17:29:18 <jroll> anything else?
17:29:21 <jroll> going once
17:29:25 <jroll> twice
17:29:27 <jroll> #endmeeting