15:00:02 #startmeeting ironic 15:00:03 Meeting started Mon Jul 2 15:00:02 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is TheJulia. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 15:00:04 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 15:00:05 Good morning everyone! 15:00:06 o/ 15:00:06 The meeting name has been set to 'ironic' 15:00:13 o/ 15:00:17 o/ 15:00:24 \o 15:00:27 o/ 15:00:31 o/ 15:00:33 \o 15:00:37 o/ 15:00:38 o/ 15:00:40 o/ 15:00:42 o/ 15:00:46 Our meeting agenda is on the wiki this week. It looks like we have a few announcements, so hopefully this will be a fairly quick meeting. 15:00:47 o/ 15:00:53 #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Ironic#Agenda_for_next_meeting 15:01:10 #topic Announcements / Reminders 15:01:13 * dtantsur cannot stop removing code, send help!! 15:01:39 #info dtantsur needs help to stop removing code, please send help ;) 15:01:43 #undo 15:01:44 Removing item from minutes: #info dtantsur needs help to stop removing code, please send help ;) 15:01:47 :D 15:01:58 o/ 15:02:20 o/ 15:02:31 #info We are hoping to schedule a "mid-cycle" call on the 17th or 18th of this month, with times that are fairly early to the US, to be friendlier to EU and Asia. 15:02:41 #link https://doodle.com/poll/nu7bf2t8ygxfm6vf 15:02:49 thanks goes to rpioso for creating the doodle 15:03:06 :) 15:03:18 #info The plan is to release ironic 11.0 this week. 15:03:49 #info TheJulia is on vacation starting Wednesday returning next Monday for the meeting. 15:04:05 woot 15:04:15 so, tomorrow release then? :) 15:05:03 #info A quick reminder that all reviews count and help to making a better ironic! Please remember to engage the patch author if you think there needs to be a change to the revision. 15:05:31 jroll: likely, I'm wondering if dtantsur will loose his mind before removing driver loading, or if we should just wait on it 15:05:36 the driver loading changes 15:05:46 heh 15:06:04 it'd be good to have that in for the major version bump 15:06:05 I'm trying really hard to finish it 15:06:23 mostly fighting with unit tests that expect it to be possible to create a classic driver 15:06:57 so removal technically would force our version bump to be major 15:07:21 I guess we need to discuss this a little more 15:07:26 Anyway, moving on! 15:07:30 #topic Review action items from previous meeting 15:08:18 We had two action items, ironic-lib/ipa timeouts, which I believe we managed to sort, and I indicated I would send out a summary email of stuff. I'm going to try and shift gears to doing an occasional "whats going on in ironic" email instead. 15:08:44 moving on! 15:08:47 #topic Review subteam status reports 15:08:56 #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/IronicWhiteBoard 15:09:08 Starting at line 137! 15:09:42 jiapei: Any update on xclarity CI? 15:10:14 We've setup Zuul, but it still can't connect to Gerrit... 15:10:47 Logs show that it fails to pull devstack to the local, still debugging 15:11:02 jiapei: firewalls maybe? 15:11:40 Oh, I'll check it tomorrow 15:11:48 \o/ jroll has started writing some conductor location awareness code 15:12:40 \o/ 15:12:41 :) 15:12:58 not terribly far along but hoping to have most of it up this week 15:13:00 zshi: Do you know if there is any ETA on the minor bios interface patches? 15:13:43 jroll: I came to a realization hacking on changing around the concurrency behavior that it would be intertwined with location awareness, so perhaps maybe a worthy PTG topic would be concurrency stuffs 15:14:18 TheJulia: makes sense 15:14:34 * jroll is curious which concurrency bits you're looking at but saves that for later 15:14:38 Looks like the graphical console work could use some hardware assistance? Alternatively it might be viable to just do virtually initially 15:15:00 can we implement it virtually? 15:15:11 I think so, we just need to have agreement on a way to turn it on 15:15:28 redfish is likely the best route to take if it is standardized in the API 15:15:34 wweeeelllll 15:15:37 qemu does do vnc 15:15:43 it's something like iKVM IIRC 15:15:46 not vnc 15:15:52 * dtantsur summons etingof|brb 15:15:59 it works with vnc clients is all I know :) 15:16:06 idrac does VNC, too. 15:17:02 I guess the concern that we might run into is compatibility with slightly different authentication behaviors that might exist 15:17:40 but I seem to remember someone mentioning they were able to connect to idrac via the nova-vnc-proxy 15:18:22 mkrai: You around? 15:18:56 * TheJulia wonders if the internets are stable in hshiina's part of the world today. 15:19:24 we can probably discuss this later, right? 15:19:28 yeah 15:19:37 I'm ready to move on, I'm just going to put a note in the update 15:20:43 o/ mjturek 15:20:44 * hshiina is suffering from unstable network 15:20:53 hshiina: :( 15:20:53 o/ hey TheJulia 15:21:05 Everyone ready to move on? 15:21:49 * TheJulia hears crickets 15:21:57 Yeah 15:22:06 #topic Deciding on priorities for the coming week 15:22:24 #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/IronicWhiteBoard 15:23:18 Starting at line 91, I've updated some of the items from the prior week's list, aside from that I think it is good for a week where many of us are taking vacation time 15:24:09 Anyone think anything needs to be added? 15:24:16 yeah, I'm fine with it 15:24:21 Is there anything I'm missing that should be looked at this week? 15:25:10 dtantsur ? 15:25:15 a bit moar specs? 15:25:24 at least I wanted to take a look at your ramdisk deploy suggestion 15:25:30 but mostly lgtm 15:26:04 I think that would be high impact if we could reach consensus and land something before end of cycle 15:26:22 we have nearly everything we need, it is just glue.... 15:26:28 I'm good with adding that spec to the list 15:26:38 yeah, I plan to look at that soon 15:27:09 Okay then, I'll add it to the list. 15:27:17 Anything else, or are we ready to move on to Discussion! 15:27:34 * TheJulia maybe needs less.... or more coffee. 15:28:30 * TheJulia takes the silence as a no, and that we should move on 15:29:01 #topic Open Discussion 15:29:17 dtantsur: any feeling for driver interface stuff? punting on the removal at the moment? or... ? 15:29:39 TheJulia: it seems like as we speak I got all the tests passing 15:29:45 * dtantsur runs full tox 15:30:04 \o/ 15:30:07 dtantsur: \o/ 15:30:22 I think we can finish it by tomorrow EOD, which leaves enough time for a release 15:30:33 :TheJulia, I just remember that I can use "git clone" as a zuul user, so maybe not firewall issue 15:31:31 dtantsur: I am okay if that is the route taken, it might mean we post the prelude in and end up getting the release approved early wednesday if it takes a while to merge 15:31:46 This is the error log http://paste.openstack.org/show/724714/ 15:31:46 yep 15:31:47 jiapei: can you use "git review -s; git review -d anychangeid" ? 15:32:40 * TheJulia wonders what exit code -13 is 15:32:48 Sam Betts proposed openstack/ironic master: Ensure we allow Ironic API traffic from baremetal network https://review.openstack.org/579560 15:32:49 dtantsur: works for me! 15:33:20 Ran: 4899 tests in 141.0000 sec. 15:33:22 - Passed: 4887 15:33:31 - Skipped: 12 15:33:35 adds up nicely :) 15:34:07 I didn't test "git review" yet, will try it later. And I googled "git exit code -13" but got nothing... 15:34:31 jiapei: have you tried asking on #openstack-infra? 15:34:48 or in #openstack-third-party-ci ? 15:35:03 Yes, I asked on the #openstack-infra", but didn't solve it yet... 15:35:17 Maybe I can try the other one 15:35:36 jiapei: likely a good idea 15:35:52 jiapei: sometimes people don't see it because of time zones 15:35:53 It seems that CI is harder than I've thought 15:36:10 Yeah, it can be difficult at times to get started :( 15:36:23 are we done with the meeting then? :) 15:36:23 Does anyone else have anything to discuss today as a team? 15:36:26 so wrt to bug day, the first week on the month kinda snuck up on me. Normally we would have a bug day on thursday. Would anyone be terribly upset if I pushed it a week? Considering the US Holiday on wednesday, it's a bit busy on my end right now 15:36:28 jiapei: have you setup a gerrit user with SSH keys for zuul?? 15:36:31 jroll: getting there ;) 15:36:44 mjturek: no objections here 15:36:45 mjturek: +1 15:37:11 cool thank you! 15:37:44 :sambetts, yes, I've setup a gerrit user "lenovo_lxca_ci", and "ssh -p ..." works as zuul user 15:38:13 Well, if there is nothing else to discuss as a team, everyone can have about twenty minutes back 15:38:26 TheJulia: ty :-) 15:38:51 Thanks everyone! 15:38:57 thanks :) 15:39:23 #endmeeting