15:00:07 #startmeeting ironic 15:00:08 Meeting started Mon Oct 28 15:00:07 2019 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is TheJulia. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 15:00:09 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 15:00:11 o/ everyone 15:00:11 o/ 15:00:11 The meeting name has been set to 'ironic' 15:00:19 o/ 15:00:20 o/ 15:00:31 Our agenda can be found on the wiki as always. 15:00:33 #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Ironic#Agenda_for_next_meeting 15:00:47 #topic Announcements/Reminders 15:00:54 o/ 15:01:24 As many of you are likely aware, the Open Infrastructure Summit and Project Teams Gathering is next week. 15:01:26 o/ 15:01:31 o/ 15:02:00 \o 15:02:23 The schedule is being somewhat left open to see who joins us for PTG discussions. Which means we'll formalize the list of discussion topics based upon those present. That being said, if there is a specific topic you wish to see discussed, you may wish to ensure it is on the list before people land. 15:02:27 #topic https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/PVG-Ironic-Planning 15:02:29 o/ 15:02:30 #undo 15:02:31 Removing item from minutes: #topic https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/PVG-Ironic-Planning 15:02:32 #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/PVG-Ironic-Planning 15:02:34 doh! 15:02:41 ops =X 15:03:01 o/ 15:03:05 As next week is the Summit/PTG, there will be no weekly meeting for the group. 15:03:14 #info No weekly meeting next week during the Summit/PTG 15:03:50 o/ 15:03:57 I personally expect limited connectivity and availability while in China, so if you need to reach me your best bet is going to be to send me an email. 15:04:14 Does anyone have anything else to add? 15:04:25 should we cancel the meeting after the summit too? 15:04:40 * iurygregory was wondering this ^ 15:04:44 I'm not sure who will or will not be avail then. 15:04:50 I should be available most of the time, although the planned relocation may cause unexpected absences 15:05:19 I'm anticipating holding the meeting the week after. My hope is we begin to form up our plans for this cycle starting next week. 15:05:20 i think w/o representation from people who were at the summit... is it worthwhile having a meeting? guess we can read the etherpads... 15:05:47 ok, if TheJulia will be there, then it is a go :) 15:06:07 I know some may still be in transit, and I think I have 13 hours of layovers.... :\ 15:06:20 ouch D: 15:06:27 Okay, then lets carry on! 15:06:39 Moving on if there are no objections 15:06:58 #topic Review Action Items from Previous Meeting 15:07:01 #link http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/ironic/2019/ 15:07:06 #info No action items from last week. 15:07:18 #topic Review subteam status reports 15:07:36 #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/IronicWhiteBoard 15:07:51 Starting around 263 15:07:55 Line 263 15:09:12 * iurygregory forgot to mention in announcements that most integration jobs are running under Python3 already o/ 15:09:22 Dmitry Tantsur proposed openstack/bifrost master: Switch to IPA-builder for building ironic-python-agent https://review.opendev.org/691665 15:10:16 iurygregory: \o/ 15:10:50 Hmm, no mkrai to ask about flask. 15:11:33 etingof: looks like indicators are still pending reviews, if you want to update the status 15:12:17 dtantsur: under mdns, is ironic-lib updates still needed? 15:12:21 yezs 15:12:29 working on python-zeroconf bits still 15:12:59 Dmitry Tantsur proposed openstack/bifrost master: Use a real IP address for ironic-inspector endpoint_override https://review.opendev.org/691661 15:13:07 ahh, I thought that merged last week :( 15:13:19 TheJulia: follow ups were requested by the maintainer 15:13:27 ahh 15:13:28 okay 15:13:28 before he makes a release 15:13:31 ack 15:14:28 Dmitry Tantsur proposed openstack/ironic-inspector master: Create a job with boot and networking managed by ironic https://review.opendev.org/688920 15:14:45 etingof: when you have a few minutes, please update "DHCP-less/L3 Virtual media boot" 15:14:53 On the IronicWhiteboard. Thanks! 15:15:24 * iurygregory it's holiday here in Czech Republic 15:15:32 iurygregory: \o/ 15:15:42 iurygregory: I hope it involves beer 15:15:50 Are we good to proceed? 15:15:53 in Czech Republic everything involves beer :D 15:15:56 ++ 15:16:09 let's 15:16:22 #topic Deciding on priorities for the coming week 15:16:46 #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/IronicWhiteBoard 15:16:48 Line 171 15:16:53 I've dropped a few more inspector boot mgmt items on the list already 15:17:06 * iurygregory : for me it involves beer and cooking 15:17:59 dtantsur: thanks 15:18:12 Did we end up with any py2->py3 related items last week that need reviews? 15:18:35 From me side i have some patches 15:18:51 to switch the jobs and I'm stil working on others =) 15:19:00 can I put the link for review? 15:19:13 TheJulia: Do we have an update on https://review.opendev.org/#/c/689603/ ? 15:19:14 patch 689603 - ironic (stable/train) - Update sushy library version - 1 patch set 15:19:50 arne_wiebalck: xXraphXx: Should we drop https://review.opendev.org/#/c/674879/ from the list 15:19:50 patch 674879 - ironic-python-agent - image extension, install_bootloader improvements - 10 patch sets 15:20:10 rpioso: off the top of my head, I do not have an update besides it seems all packagers were already packaging 2.0.0 and not 1.9.0 for release 15:20:23 rpioso: has anyone proposed a global-requirements patch? 15:20:59 dtantsur: I don't know. 15:21:13 well, that's the next step 15:21:41 dtantsur: Which repo is that in? 15:21:42 Has not been proposed it looks like 15:22:13 rpioso: openstack/requirements 15:22:17 dtantsur: And which must merge first? 15:22:27 rpioso: the requirements one 15:22:36 at least that seems to be the consensus on the ML 15:22:49 xXraphXx: Same quesiton as above for https://review.opendev.org/#/c/674803/ 15:22:50 patch 674803 - ironic-python-agent - Software raid: default partition table type change - 11 patch sets 15:23:04 We'll propose the global-requirements change. 15:23:29 o/ 15:23:44 dtantsur, TheJulia: Thank you! 15:23:51 thx! 15:23:55 * rpioso hopes we can get those landed this week. 15:25:15 quite likely 15:26:02 TheJulia: for s/w RAID patches from xXraphXx: we will need this work to make UEFI work; some of this is covered in the rootfs uuid patches now I think, I'll have a look 15:26:05 Okay, I've deleted the merged items and added items related to some security related patches for Ironic/Ironic-python-agent. There is another that I'm still trying to sort my way through which I'll likely add to the list later in the week. 15:26:14 arne_wiebalck: thanks 15:27:37 does the list look good for everyone for the next two weeks? 15:27:52 Could use reviews on new patch set for https://review.opendev.org/#/c/670360/ 15:27:53 patch 670360 - sushy - Add Task Monitor support for async operations - 5 patch sets 15:29:50 We are expecting a change set on https://review.opendev.org/#/c/668987/ today, but would love to get some eyes on it after that has been submitted 15:29:50 patch 668987 - ironic - Improve iDrac Documentation - 16 patch sets 15:30:36 if people have time, I'd be curious what they thought about https://review.opendev.org/#/c/689551/ ! 15:30:36 patch 689551 - ironic - Allow node owners to administer nodes - 1 patch set 15:30:53 tzumainn: it's on our priority list 15:30:57 (and my personal as well) 15:31:03 dtantsur, oh, okay - thanks! 15:31:08 tzumainn: and btw, I'm planning to propose a spec amendment to cover allocations 15:31:18 just need to allocate (heh) a few minutes 15:31:26 dtantsur, haha, sounds good! 15:31:49 TheJulia: can we put https://review.opendev.org/#/c/688913/ and https://review.opendev.org/#/c/690580/ on the list? 15:31:49 patch 688913 - ironic-python-agent-builder - DIB: add --branch argument to override IPA branch - 3 patch sets 15:31:51 patch 690580 - ironic-python-agent-builder - CLI: add --verbose and --extra-args - 1 patch set 15:31:53 they're quite trivial 15:33:05 tzumainn: also on my list as well, but I can't make any promises this week with meetings and needing to get some last things ready to fly out to Shanghai 15:33:11 dtantsur: sure 15:33:15 TheJulia, of course! 15:33:20 dtantsur: if you wouldn't mind adding? 15:33:25 not at all 15:33:27 Thanks 15:33:35 Anything else for the list? 15:34:08 I'm trying to fix bifrost to use IPA-builder. no luck so far. 15:34:13 the CI is pretty red without it. 15:34:23 :( 15:34:39 Well, if there are more patches required we can go ahead and add them to the list 15:34:54 Are we good to move on? 15:35:34 and somebody really has to update bifrost to zuul v3... 15:35:50 that would be silly easy if I sat down and did it 15:35:55 and I think we still have xenial there.... 15:36:04 I don't _think_ so 15:36:08 but yeah, it needs some work 15:36:36 Anyway, since we have no discussion items this week, we can proceed directly to the Bare Metal SIG 15:36:45 Dmitry Tantsur proposed openstack/bifrost master: Switch to IPA-builder for building ironic-python-agent https://review.opendev.org/691665 15:36:55 we definitely have xenial there 15:37:01 #topic Bare Metal SIG 15:37:03 dtantsur: *sigh* 15:37:14 :/ 15:37:23 maybe I'll sort it out in a break between packing boxes :) 15:37:39 we are trying to revive the SIG, with primary focus on the white paper 15:37:48 https://docs.google.com/document/d/1BmB2JL_oG3lWXId_NXT9KWcBJjqgtnbmixIcNsfGooA/edit 15:37:52 #link https://docs.google.com/document/d/1BmB2JL_oG3lWXId_NXT9KWcBJjqgtnbmixIcNsfGooA/edit 15:37:58 contributors are more than welcome 15:38:35 arne_wiebalck: should I mention the overall model? 15:38:40 Merged openstack/ironic-ui master: Switch to Ussuri jobs https://review.opendev.org/691264 15:38:42 please! 15:39:38 Early on in the whitepaper, the mentions a model that the paper will cover. Not all content aligns with this model and things definitely need to be resorted, but to quote the existing text of the whitepaper: 15:39:40 In this paper, we will explore how the OpenStack community has addressed the bare metal provisioning problem with entirely free open source software. We will discuss the issues operators or enterprise face in discovering and provisioning servers, how the OpenStack community has solved these issues with the Ironic project, specific case studies of Ironic use in production, and the future of open infrastructure 15:39:40 and hardware management. 15:41:15 If anyone has any questions, please feel free to ask arne_wiebalck. 15:41:35 If anyone wants to tag team on writing words, I'm happy to try and help :) 15:42:16 do we need any input from the PTG/Forum? 15:42:22 I guess the main content aspect that could use help is use case studies. If anyone here is in a position to describe how they leverage ironic, that would be useful. 15:43:13 Especially for Bare Metal logo program members... 15:43:16 dtantsur: on the whitepaper? 15:43:20 yep 15:44:23 i remember the white paper is only reviewable, one needs to be invited if he wants to edit 15:44:28 There should probably be a discussion on what the SIG should focus on after the white paper ... the mandate is quite wide at the moment. 15:44:52 kaifeng|afk: I think you can edit. 15:44:59 How does one join the Bare Metal log program? 15:45:08 kaifeng|afk: Or you should be able to, in suggesting mode. 15:45:10 s/log/logo/ 15:45:26 On the whitepaper, I kind of doubt it, but maybe in discussion about the SIG in general we'll have some input. Some of the whitepaper is an overview of history, conceptual problems these cases experience, user cases from the field, and then were we think the future is heading 15:45:54 Dmitry Tantsur proposed openstack/ironic-inspector stable/train: Add IPv6 support to dnsmasq example https://review.opendev.org/691697 15:45:59 arne_wiebalck: ack, may take a look after the summit. 15:46:03 rpioso: That is a really good question. 15:46:26 rpioso: I believe the person to reach out to right now is diablo_rojo. If you need her email address, just let me know. 15:46:30 It'd be good to know if people would like more docs, reference architectures, occasions to exchange ops experiences, ... 15:46:41 ... or something else :) 15:46:46 TheJulia: Thank you! 15:47:05 kaifeng: cool, thx! 15:47:32 arne_wiebalck, TheJulia: How we identified who's taken over hogepodge's responsibility for the SIG? 15:47:39 s/How/Have/ 15:47:40 arne_wiebalck: added to agenda 15:48:05 rpioso: diablo_rojo is serving as our current foundation point of contact for the baremetal sig 15:48:15 TheJulia: Gotcha :-) 15:48:39 dtantsur and I volunteered already at the very beginning of the sig, so diablo_rojo reached out to us again 15:50:08 TheJulia: thanks 15:50:35 Well if there is nothing else with the SIG, I think we can move forward to Open Discussion 15:51:47 #topic Open Discussion 15:54:04 * TheJulia hears crickets 15:54:15 Well everyone, I think that covers it for this week. 15:55:50 Thanks everyone! 15:56:00 thanks TheJulia 15:56:32 thanks! 15:57:39 #endmeeting