15:01:13 #startmeeting ironic 15:01:14 Meeting started Mon Nov 16 15:01:13 2020 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is TheJulia. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 15:01:15 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 15:01:17 The meeting name has been set to 'ironic' 15:01:22 o/ 15:01:23 \o 15:01:24 dtantsur: I mean, I could revise the docs and note it in tuning docs 15:01:27 o/ 15:01:36 o/ 15:01:40 maybe just -1 my tuning doc update and I can put it in place. 15:01:45 anyway! Good morning everyone! 15:02:00 Time for our meeting of ironic irony! 15:02:02 TheJulia: let's figure it out in a follow-up then? 15:02:08 dtantsur: wfm 15:02:09 o/ 15:02:16 Our agenda can be found on the wiki 15:02:27 #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Ironic#Agenda_for_next_meeting 15:02:47 #topic Announcements / Reminders 15:02:56 o/ 15:02:59 o/ 15:03:06 I have two, well, ultimately three items this morning to bring up 15:03:10 The first! 15:03:21 o/ 15:03:22 #info The Wallaby priorities have merged. 15:03:41 #info The Wallaby priorities have been added to the Ironic Whiteboard. 15:03:53 well, that was two 15:04:03 The final item that I have to remind everyone is that the first sprint ends soon 15:04:21 #info Sprint 1 is targetted to end around December 14th. 15:05:20 I suspect many contributors will be taking time off to recharge and de-stress during the month of December, so if there are any changes required or reviews needed please remember to raise them sooner rather than later 15:05:25 Dmitry Tantsur proposed openstack/ironic-python-agent-builder master: [WIP] Clean up installed packages https://review.opendev.org/762816 15:05:59 Also, people in the states tend to take part if not most of next week off as well. Just something to keep in mind. 15:06:10 Hello everyone! I have a patch https://review.opendev.org/#/c/762343/ and it fails to pass ironic-tempest-ipxe-ipv6 & ironic-inspector-tempest-partition-bios-redfish-vmedia jobs. In the first one I get “RTNETLINK answers: No route to host” and the second seems to be related to rabbitmq-server.service. Can someone please point out how I can debug ipv6 routing and rabbitnq with my local changes to identify the ex 15:06:10 act issue? 15:06:10 patch 762343 - ironic - Allow disabling automated_clean per node - 9 patch sets 15:06:22 And with that, does anyone have any announcements they would like to make or remind us of things? 15:06:39 fmuyassarov: that is a known issue with focal 15:06:41 fmuyassarov: we're in the middle of our weekly meeting, Could we save this discussion for a little later? 15:06:58 Definitely TheJulia 15:07:03 thanks 15:07:38 Looks like we had no action items raised last week 15:08:09 So I guess if nobody has anything to announce we can proceed to a fairly quick update of subteam status 15:08:43 * TheJulia hears crickets 15:09:08 * TheJulia hears lots of crickets 15:09:12 crrrrricket 15:09:12 ++ 15:09:12 Carrying on I guess! 15:09:35 #topic Review subteam status reports 15:09:42 #link https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/IronicWhiteBoard 15:09:59 Starting around line 285 15:10:11 If anyone has more ideas for Not getting more insane, add them! 15:10:32 dtantsur: Thank you for bringing back the SPUCs 15:10:39 SPUC \o/ 15:11:19 Merged openstack/ironic master: Make driver documentation more prominent on the landing page https://review.opendev.org/762179 15:11:55 I've added the links to the etherpad 15:12:21 Anyhow there should be space for all of the listed items, and if there is nothign else we can move on to priorites for the week? 15:13:14 I can also carry things like oslo.privsep up from below or well, anyone can do that 15:13:26 * TheJulia wonders if she forgot to hand out coffee this morning 15:13:37 or.... I've I've had too much. 15:15:03 So onward to priorities for the coming week? 15:15:09 ++ 15:15:16 let's 15:15:57 #topic Deciding on priorities for the coming week 15:16:05 #link https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/IronicWhiteBoard 15:16:22 The list starts at line 129, but in essence a LOT of things merged last week 15:16:31 so first, I'm going to remove the merged items as always. 15:16:40 I've been adding new items for consideration below stable 15:17:16 Leo McGann proposed openstack/ironic-specs master: Add security interface spec https://review.opendev.org/576718 15:18:03 Is everyone good with the items proposed around lien 176? 15:18:09 And does anyone have have more items to add? 15:18:15 seems good to me 15:18:31 looks good 15:19:24 That can be cleaned up later 15:19:40 Well then, onward! 15:19:55 #topic Discussion 15:20:08 We have one item listed on the agenda for discussion today. 15:20:10 #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Ironic#Agenda_for_next_meeting 15:20:30 The item is in essence do we want to schedule a review jab so we can effectively begin to work through stevebaker's API patches 15:20:52 I think we do, but wanted to raise it as a discussion item since I think we should schedule a time and get moving forward on that. 15:21:55 o/ 15:21:59 * arne_wiebalck is late 15:22:04 o/ arne_wiebalck 15:22:22 I guess we need to schedule a time where stevebaker can be present, or do we just want to do a general review session ? 15:22:24 oh, good point. I completely forgot about that 15:22:37 I think the idea was to schedule 2 slots: during his morning and his evening 15:22:43 ++ 15:22:50 ok 15:23:15 and not really be presentation, more work through the patches, try to understand, raise changes at once if needed or just approve if they are good 15:23:32 I know some of us have done some sporatic reviews of patches, but I'd love to see that work begin to merge 15:23:46 yep 15:23:46 right, sounds good 15:23:59 Maybe, we ask steve to schedule the windows that way he can indicate the times he is comfortable with 15:24:00 TheJulia: do you have overlap with him? maybe discuss later today? 15:24:12 Yeah, I overlap with him in his morning 15:24:27 so I guess that is an action item to bestow an action item upon stevebaker 15:24:44 #action TheJulia to talk with steve about getting some review jabs scheduled 15:25:05 Next stop, BareMetal SIG 15:25:08 #topic Baremetal SIG 15:25:21 arne_wiebalck: anything here? I guess the best question is when is the next meeting 15:25:28 I think Dec 8 15:25:44 interop profiles if rpioso is still up for it 15:26:00 Awesome, sounds good 15:26:00 otherwise NTR 15:26:12 Sounds good, then I guess that means we're at open discussion 15:26:15 #topic Open Discussion 15:26:20 arne_wiebalck: I am :-) 15:26:30 excellent, thanks! 15:26:31 Anyone have anything they would like to discuss? 15:26:38 hi! 15:26:57 hi tzumainn 15:26:59 I've been trying to understand the networking required to boot-from-volume 15:27:12 and I've been failing miserably :) is there anyone with the expertise to help me out post-meeting? 15:27:27 tzumainn: I can chat with you a little later today after I have breakfast 15:27:36 TheJulia, that sounds great, thanks! 15:28:24 anything else this morning? 15:28:32 a general question - have there been ideas about not launching IPA if it is not needed? E.g., there are OOB cleaning steps that don't really need IPA. 15:29:15 ajya: there have and there were notes on the path forward in the Shanghai and Berlin PTG notes if memory serves 15:29:46 and Geneva midcycle 15:30:03 does anyone have those links at hand? 15:30:34 ajya: They are linked from the whiteboard 15:30:40 well, the idea is quite simple: update decorator with a new flag that defines if the step requires a ramdisk 15:30:41 the erase_pstore clean step: there are concerns with having it enabled by default ... should we disable to start with, and gather some experience (and then revisit at some point)? 15:30:42 Towards the very top 15:30:52 the implementation is going to be really challenging 15:31:01 arne_wiebalck: I think that seems reasonable 15:31:01 saying that as the person who has last touched that area of code :) 15:31:19 :) ok, I'll take a look 15:31:37 that means that idea is not discarded but just need some resources? 15:31:38 TheJulia: the only thing is that noone will run it and we probably won't collect any experience 15:31:49 arne_wiebalck: this is true :\ 15:32:02 maybe enable by default but have conductor flag? 15:32:06 TheJulia: still fine with me ... I think it is good if we offer this at least 15:32:25 technically it is a device, just stored/accessed totally differently, more like a MTD 15:32:38 Any objections or concerns? 15:32:56 yeah, I don't think one can break stuff by deleting files ... but you never know 15:33:21 Indeed 15:33:27 Well if there is nothing else, thanks everyone! 15:34:28 thank you! 15:34:33 \o 15:34:35 thank you :) 15:34:48 #endmeeting