15:00:44 #startmeeting Ironic 15:00:44 Meeting started Mon Nov 7 15:00:44 2022 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is JayF. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 15:00:44 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 15:00:44 The meeting name has been set to 'ironic' 15:00:56 Good morning; expecially early morning to those of us in the US after DST 15:01:01 o/ 15:01:03 o/ 15:01:05 o/ 15:01:06 o/ 15:01:15 o/ 15:01:19 o/ 15:01:37 #topic Announcements/Reminders 15:01:49 #link https://tinyurl.com/ironic-weekly-prio-dash 15:01:50 o/ 15:02:16 Reminder to contributors and reviewers, please review things hashtagged #ironic-week-prio and mark patches you need reviewed with that hashtag 15:02:42 #note Announcement: Be aware that almost all upstream meetings are UTC-based, US-based contributors may wanna check their calendar. 15:03:13 Anyone else with an announcement or reminder before we move on? 15:03:41 #topic Review action items from last meeting 15:04:04 o/ 15:04:08 Looks like dtantsur arne_wiebalck and I were looking at BM SIG quarterly meeting ideas; we need to continue that and get something done-done soon 15:04:30 JayF: ack 15:05:06 That's the only action item from last meeting; I reopened that etherpad and will stare at it some when we're done :) 15:05:16 #topic Review Ironic CI Status & update whiteboard if needed 15:05:33 TheJulia and I have been working, generally, on trying to get older CI things working 15:05:53 I specifically noted here that there's a hard failure for stable/wallaby ironic-prometheus-exporter that appears based in ansible version 15:07:26 This is problematic because I think that job uses the ansible zuul uses to setup the job 15:07:52 We're going to end up having to either refactor or remove a large number of jobs (and maybe even branch support on some of these) in order to get CI freed 15:08:48 What do folks think of retiring just some repositories older stable branches? e.g. in this case, ironic-prometheus-exporter. We've never backported anything of substance to that repo, stable/wallaby branch, for instance 15:10:09 JayF, today I can check the ironic prometheus exporter CI 15:10:23 I mean, I think my question is still worth consideration: is it even worth it 15:10:36 if we haven't backported stuff to this repo; it seems like a bad use of anyones' time to fix it rather than retiring it 15:13:04 There's clearly minimal engagement about this right now, I'll take an action to email the list about it 15:13:06 I can help without problems to fix it 15:13:26 I mean, I appreciate the help I just question the value 15:13:27 not sure what other folks think about 15:13:51 I'd rather you be making other things work better than keeping CI alive for the hell of it on branches we literally have never backported something to in 3 years 15:14:27 but either way, the status is out there, I'm going to move on 15:14:42 #topic 2023.1 workstreams in progress 15:14:59 Reminder we're keeping track of status for those who want to here: https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/IronicWorkstreams2023.1 15:15:45 Also a reminder, please review the workstreams doc here: https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/ironic-specs/+/862538 -- we should try to get this landed in the next week or two 15:16:00 Any questions about those before we move on? 15:16:33 There is nothing for RFE Review this week; going to skip that. 15:16:37 #topic Open Discussion 15:16:56 I believe Kirill_ had something they wanted to mention about console support? 15:17:08 yep 15:17:09 HI 15:17:27 i've added vnc console to ironic 15:17:46 #link https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/ironic/+/860689 15:18:09 it is a first stap to new graphical console interface 15:18:40 Nice work; there's a couple of things -- if you don't mind, can you document you're working on this feature by opening an issue on https://storyboard.openstack.org 15:18:50 it also requires some changes on nova side. but lets focus on ironic) 15:19:14 For those patches; I'll take a look at them, but I can tell you right now you'll likely also need to add more detailed commit messages (see: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/GitCommitMessages) and a release note 15:19:50 We have some contributors on weird schedules this week; but I'll try to make sure you get some feedback this week. 15:20:09 Kirill_: Is there a particular reason you came to contribute this? It's exciting to get a new person involved! 15:20:28 we have this spec: https://specs.openstack.org/openstack/ironic-specs/specs/not-implemented/vnc-graphical-console.html 15:20:38 i've done it for my company 15:20:42 Oh, perfect. 15:20:53 also new graphical console interface is done on my side 15:20:53 Can you just put a link to that bug in the commit message? 15:21:02 We usually do storyboard stuff now, but we're migrating back 15:21:05 so the launchpad bug will be perfect 15:21:52 sure, i'll add a link to massage 15:22:32 Thanks, and good work o/. Glad that you're having a chance to contribute. If there's anything you get stuck on or have questions about feel free to ask. 15:22:48 Is there anything else for Open Discussion today? "Have a free feature" is a hard act to follow :D 15:22:57 so to be on a same page:i need to add link to spec, and wait for your review? 15:23:18 Just indicate it belongs to that bug should be good enough to get it linked to the spec 15:23:23 you'll need a release note for it at some point too 15:23:34 but you can wait for a real-review on the PR to worry about either of those things 15:23:50 I'm making a note to review it today; if I don't get to it I'll do it tomorrow during my office hours 15:24:40 got it. Thanks 15:25:01 also ping me for any questions) 15:25:19 Last call for more items for open discussion before closing out the meeting 15:27:43 I'll be here next week to run the next meeting. 15:27:45 Thanks everyone o/ 15:27:47 #endmeeting Ironic