16:01:11 <Sukhdev> #startmeeting ironic_neutron
16:01:13 <openstack> Meeting started Mon Dec  7 16:01:11 2015 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is Sukhdev. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
16:01:14 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
16:01:16 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'ironic_neutron'
16:01:35 <Sukhdev> Good morning everybody
16:01:50 <Sukhdev> jroll : are you here?
16:02:08 <Sukhdev> #topic: Agenda
16:02:18 <Sukhdev> #link: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Ironic-neutron#Meeting_December_7.2C_2015
16:02:40 <Sukhdev> vs
16:03:02 <Sukhdev> Anybody like to add anything to the agenda?
16:03:37 <jroll> Sukhdev: yep, sorry I'm late
16:03:57 <Sukhdev> jroll : no worries
16:04:08 <Sukhdev> #topic: Announcements
16:04:26 <Sukhdev> I got no announcements this week - anybody has anything to share?
16:04:45 <Sukhdev> Actually one thing comes to mind - some of you were not here last week -
16:05:30 <Sukhdev> we had a great discussion on two alternative frameworks available to test neutron-ironic integration testing
16:05:45 <Sukhdev> we will cover more later during the agenda
16:06:05 <Sukhdev> #topic: Patches under review
16:06:35 <Sukhdev> I took some time to update our famous etherpad with all the patches
16:07:00 <Sukhdev> couple of our patches from neutron and nova got approved and merged last week
16:07:08 <sambetts> \o/
16:07:15 <Sukhdev> I have added 4 new patches to the list under Devstack
16:07:43 <Sukhdev> We discussed about these patches in last week's meeting
16:08:11 <Sukhdev> We need your cycles to review these - please have a look at the etherpad
16:08:33 <Sukhdev> thanks to vsaienko to drive these patches
16:08:59 <Sukhdev> Anybody has any question on these?
16:09:31 <Sukhdev> #topic: CI Discussion
16:09:41 <Sukhdev> vsaienko: are you here?
16:09:45 <vsaienko> yes
16:10:11 <Sukhdev> vsaienko: you were going to look into CI - any update?
16:10:52 <vsaienko> there is CR that should add experimental job
16:10:55 <vsaienko> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/252814/
16:11:56 <vsaienko> but I think that patches to devstack should be reviewed/merged first
16:12:26 <jroll> nice
16:12:57 <Sukhdev> vsaienko : thanks
16:13:22 <Sukhdev> I looked at the patches, but, have not had time to test them yet
16:14:43 <Sukhdev> team - lets all spend some review cycles this week to review/test these patches
16:15:16 <Sukhdev> I added the link to test steps to the ether pad as well - https://github.com/jumpojoy/ironic-neutron/blob/master/devstack/examples/ironic-neutron-vm.md
16:16:10 <Sukhdev> jroll : you are more familiar with this stuff - will you be able to review these
16:16:58 <jroll> Sukhdev: I will try, I'm not caught up yet from being out
16:17:30 <Sukhdev> jroll : understood - thanks
16:18:27 <Sukhdev> vsaienko : so, this is chicken-n-egg. These patches need to merge before the infra patch to be approved?
16:18:57 <jroll> yes, the devstack patches should go first
16:19:06 <jroll> vsaienko: you should use depends-on for the project config patch
16:19:36 <vsaienko> jroll: ok, I'll update commit
16:20:24 <jroll> idk if it's required for all the devstack stuff to land, but we'll want to make sure the variables aren't going to change, at least
16:20:57 <jroll> to land first*
16:23:57 <Sukhdev> jroll : are you asking if all 4 of these patches to land?
16:24:44 <jroll> Sukhdev: I'm saying it may not be required to land all of the devstack patches first, but they should be close enough that the variables used in the project-config patch won't change, etc.
16:25:32 <Sukhdev> jroll : ah I see
16:25:58 <Sukhdev> they all seem very inter-related
16:26:24 <Sukhdev> I have couple of commitments - as soon done, I will test them this week and post comments
16:26:51 <jroll> ditto, I will do my best to get to those
16:26:55 <jroll> excited to run this code :D
16:26:57 <Sukhdev> lazy_prince is not here - he would have liked to test these as well
16:27:29 <Sukhdev> he was missing last week as well - hope he reviewed the meeting minutes and is aware of this
16:28:03 <Sukhdev> anything else on this?
16:28:25 <Sukhdev> #topic: Tempest testing
16:28:42 <Sukhdev> yuriy_yekovenko: any update?
16:29:05 <jroll> what's the difference between "CI" and "tempest testing"
16:29:05 <jroll> ?
16:29:11 <yuriy_yekovenko> I'm working on the script. but don't have a patch for review for now
16:29:30 <yuriy_yekovenko> hope to send it to review within this week
16:30:06 <yuriy_yekovenko> jroll: I think tempest testing means implementing of specific test script
16:30:18 <yuriy_yekovenko> jroll: I think tempest testing means implementing specific test script
16:30:54 <jroll> yuriy_yekovenko: what does that test script do?
16:31:14 <jroll> I don't see what more we would need besides what tempest already does for ironic
16:31:33 <jroll> besides configuring this feature, of course
16:31:54 <yuriy_yekovenko> jroll: the idea is to boot instances in different tenants and show they are isolated from each other
16:32:03 <jroll> ah
16:32:48 <devananda> ++
16:32:51 <Sukhdev> Bug describes some high level steps - https://bugs.launchpad.net/tempest/+bug/1520230
16:32:51 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1520230 in tempest "Test Case: Create a test scenario to verify that Ironic supports multitenancy" [Undecided,New] - Assigned to Yuriy Yekovenko (yyekovenko)
16:33:01 <Sukhdev> #link: https://bugs.launchpad.net/tempest/+bug/1520230
16:33:46 <Sukhdev> yuriy_yekovenko: look forward to your patch - this is much needed work
16:34:08 <yuriy_yekovenko> ok. trying to do my best)
16:34:24 <Sukhdev> anything else?
16:35:07 <Sukhdev> #topic: Integration testing
16:35:34 <Sukhdev> As I mentioned, couple of our patches are already merged -
16:35:42 <Sukhdev> we need to pick up on the Ironic patches -
16:36:18 <Sukhdev> I was going over them over the weekend - some minor comments need to be addressed
16:36:58 <Sukhdev> jroll : BTW - thanks for pushing the nova spec - you were missing last week, I wanted to thank you for that
16:37:21 <jroll> Sukhdev: not a problem - I'll be updating the host_id patch asap
16:37:46 <Sukhdev> jroll : cool - that is one of the items left on our list of TODO
16:38:03 <jroll> Sukhdev: yep, then on to the ports/portgroups part of the nova series
16:38:06 <Sukhdev> Please look at the etherpad - we are down to two items - 2 and 7
16:38:41 <jroll> Sukhdev: I believe 2 is fixed now
16:39:01 <jroll> Sukhdev: and I'll be taking care of 7 when I tackle the nova portgroups patch
16:39:39 <Sukhdev> jroll : you are correct - I will update the etherpad - I missed this one :-)
16:40:07 <Sukhdev> jroll : this will help us kick off portgroup testing
16:40:19 <Sukhdev> yhvh : are you here?
16:40:24 <yhvh> yup
16:40:47 <jroll> yep :)
16:40:57 <Sukhdev> yhvh: there are few patches which have some minor comments - if you could look at them
16:41:12 <yhvh> Sure np
16:41:13 <Sukhdev> also yhvh - have you had any chance on the portgroup testing?
16:41:21 <yhvh> I am mid-setting up env
16:41:52 <Sukhdev> yhvh : cool - thanks - let me know if you need any help
16:41:58 <yhvh> ty :)
16:42:19 <Sukhdev> anything else on this?
16:42:50 <Sukhdev> vsaienko, yuriy_yekovenko : have you guys had any chance to play with these patches?
16:44:02 <Sukhdev> #topic: Documentation
16:44:05 <yuriy_yekovenko> I'm debugging my script draft on patched devstack
16:44:16 <Sukhdev> #undo
16:44:17 <openstack> Removing item from minutes: <ircmeeting.items.Topic object at 0x9306050>
16:44:24 <yuriy_yekovenko> it worked for me at least in manual mode
16:44:39 <Sukhdev> yuriy_yekovenko : cool - good to know
16:44:57 <vsaienko> Sukhdev: I've tested ironic/ironicclient patches
16:45:01 <yuriy_yekovenko> I mean I checked isolation between VMs in different tenants and they look isolated
16:45:31 <Sukhdev> cool - thanks guys -
16:45:47 <Sukhdev> #topic: Documentation
16:46:03 <Sukhdev> we are 1/2 way there with the documentation -
16:46:22 <Sukhdev> not much progress to report on this - hopefully more progress next week
16:46:40 <Sukhdev> #topic: Open Discussion
16:47:03 <Sukhdev> jroll : I will be off for two weeks (last weeks of the year) -
16:48:04 <Sukhdev> jroll : will you be able to chair (or any other volunteer) to chair two meeting?
16:48:18 <jroll> Sukhdev: yeah, I'll be around the rest of the year
16:48:18 <Sukhdev> two last meetings of the year
16:48:35 <Sukhdev> jroll : cool - do I hear a volunteer :-):-)
16:49:02 <jroll> Sukhdev: yeah, I don't mind running it
16:49:03 <jroll> :)
16:49:16 <Sukhdev> thanks
16:49:47 <Sukhdev> I am done with the agenda - anybody wants to discuss anything?
16:50:26 <Sukhdev> I guess we are done -
16:50:29 <jroll> I've got nothing :)
16:50:45 <Sukhdev> last call - :-)
16:50:49 * Sukhdev waiting
16:51:03 <sambetts> Nothing from me
16:51:18 <Sukhdev> OK - folks thanks for attending - was a good meeting
16:51:25 <jroll> thanks for hosting!
16:51:25 <Sukhdev> see you next week
16:51:32 <yhvh> ty
16:51:34 <sambetts> thanks Sukhdev cya later
16:51:36 <sambetts> o/
16:51:41 <Sukhdev> bye
16:51:43 <pc_m> bye
16:51:49 <Sukhdev> #endmeeting