16:00:43 <Sukhdev> #startmeeting ironic_neutron
16:00:43 <openstack> Meeting started Mon Sep 12 16:00:43 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is Sukhdev. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
16:00:44 <mjturek> o/
16:00:45 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
16:00:48 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'ironic_neutron'
16:01:02 <sambetts> o/
16:01:15 <Sukhdev> do we have usual crowd for this meeting?
16:01:16 <hshiina> o/
16:01:38 <sambetts> Not sure if jroll is around for this one
16:01:53 <Sukhdev> #topic: Agenda
16:01:59 <Sukhdev> sambetts : thanks
16:02:01 <jroll> I'm in another meeting but keeping an eye here
16:02:12 <Sukhdev> jroll : cool - thanks
16:02:19 <Sukhdev> #link: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Ironic-neutron#Meeting_September_12.2C_2016
16:02:44 <Sukhdev> #topic: Announcements
16:03:13 <Sukhdev> I do not have any specific one - other than that we are approaching close to the release time
16:03:47 <Sukhdev> does anyone know when is the cutoff for RC for Ironic?
16:04:16 <sambetts> we don't have RC in the same way as other projects, jroll can explain a bit better than I
16:04:32 <jroll> yeah, not sure when we'll release yet
16:04:38 <jroll> probably next week, maybe week after
16:04:59 <Sukhdev> cool - so, there is still some time
16:05:19 <Sukhdev> #topic: Security Groups -
16:05:37 <Sukhdev> link: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/361451
16:05:45 <Sukhdev> This one is ready to go
16:06:07 <Sukhdev> jroll  - will this make it? considering we have time ?
16:06:48 <jroll> it's pretty late, and doesn't have associated CI
16:07:01 <jroll> but I can't decide on my own, we'll need to see what the ironic team things
16:07:03 <jroll> thinks
16:07:24 <Sukhdev> jroll : this does not really require CI
16:07:32 <jroll> I disagree :)
16:07:38 <sambetts> we should test this in the multitenant CI probably
16:07:59 <sambetts> I'm sure we're probably doing something in there to work around this right now already
16:08:10 <jroll> I'm not worried about landing it without CI, more about being this late without it
16:08:27 <jroll> if this breaks, it breaks very hard :)
16:08:53 <Sukhdev> jroll : I see - makes sense
16:08:59 <jroll> right now I'm -0.5 on landing this for newton, but I'll have to check with the rest of the team
16:09:53 <Sukhdev> #topic Port Groups
16:10:05 <Sukhdev> I noticed those patches did not make either
16:10:23 <jroll> yeah :(
16:10:35 <Sukhdev> do we have CI for those?
16:10:53 <Sukhdev> Any chance they will make it?
16:10:55 <jroll> not that I'm aware of
16:11:00 <jroll> even if we did, it's too much too late
16:11:13 <Sukhdev> I saw the IRC chat on those :-)
16:13:15 <Sukhdev> So, looks like from the networking point of view, every thing is sealed for Newton - except 50% chance for Security Groups
16:15:08 <Sukhdev> sambetts : any update on VxLan aware servers?
16:16:02 <vsaienko> Sukhdev, jroll: I have some thought in setupping CI for portgroups, OVS support lacp so theoretically it should be possible
16:16:19 <jroll> yeah agree
16:16:26 <Sukhdev> right
16:16:27 <sambetts> The trunk APIs etc have merged into Neutron now, but they havn't got all the documentation and things ready yet, and they are still working on the linux bridge/example implementations for it, so we should be able to get up and running with it next cycle
16:17:48 <Sukhdev> sambetts : yup - I saw the patches - looks like next cycle we should be good
16:18:21 <sambetts> I also want to get the attach/detach API spec/code merged as a platform for developing the V(x)LAN aware BM stuff in Ironic instead of in Nova
16:19:10 <Sukhdev> sambetts : this one - https://review.openstack.org/#/c/327046/
16:19:35 <sambetts> I've updated the Agenda with all the POC code for getting that too work, it needs changes in Nova, ironicclient and Ironic itself
16:19:56 <sambetts> Sukhdev: yup thats the Ironic part of the puzzle
16:20:59 <Sukhdev> Looks like we will have good chunk of work in next cycle as well :-)
16:21:25 <Sukhdev> vsaienko : I want to pick up a tip or two from you about adding Security Groups to CI as well
16:22:08 <vsaienko> Sukhdev: it is also possible, ovs supports filtering
16:22:09 <Sukhdev> vsaienko : SG is ready to go, but, according to jroll, it is missing CI part - which I am not much familiar with
16:22:10 <sambetts> Yup :) other places we might need to contribute include cloud-init to support the full network-data.json for configuring bonding and VLANs for portgroups and VLAN aware BM
16:22:44 <jroll> again, I'm fine landing SG without CI, just not this late in the cycle
16:22:54 <jroll> and with CI coming behind it
16:23:15 <Sukhdev> jroll : oh - I got it - thanks for clarifying
16:23:42 <Sukhdev> sambetts : +1
16:24:10 <vsaienko> sambetts: having bond support ind cloud-init would be super useful!
16:24:20 <Sukhdev> vsaienko : if you have a pointer or two about CI which you could send my way, I could look into this
16:25:42 <vsaienko> Sukhdev: half of work is done: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/333362/ I need to add ovs support only. And another part is to have tempest test that would test it
16:26:12 <Sukhdev> #link: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/327046/
16:26:21 <sambetts> Sukhdev: did you get on OK trying out the inspector LLDP part? Unfortunatly my Neutron patches to get inspector using the neutron DHCP didn't go anywhere again this cycle, perhaps I can use your leverage on the Neutron side next cycle to get those in too?
16:27:04 <vsaienko> Sukhdev: I will check with my team, and try to find volunteer for tempest tests. and in background add ovs support to networking-generic-switch
16:27:43 <Sukhdev> sambetts : I can work with you next cycle - armax and I spoke about it - he assigned the task to me to work with you to get this done. I kind of dropped the ball - so, my bad
16:27:58 <Sukhdev> sambetts : I will work with you to get this done in neutron side
16:28:27 <sambetts> Sukhdev: Awesome :D I was quite busy my end this cycle so didn't push that hard either, thanks
16:28:32 <Sukhdev> vsaienko : thanks a ton for this - I will look at the patch that you sent me
16:30:32 <Sukhdev> Anything else on this?
16:30:57 <Sukhdev> #topic Open Discussion
16:31:18 <Sukhdev> Anybody wants to discuss anything?
16:32:06 <Sukhdev> Be sure to watch big game tonight - season opener for 49ers vs. Rams
16:32:53 <Sukhdev> armax, kevinbenton and I were suppose to go to Levi to watch it tonight - plan got changed
16:33:24 <Sukhdev> be sure to try to pick me from the crowd on the TV :-):-)
16:33:34 <Sukhdev> folks, just having fun :-)
16:34:04 <Sukhdev> If we have nothing else, lets wrap it up
16:34:08 <sambetts> Have an awesome time man!
16:34:24 <Sukhdev> sambetts : I intend to - thanks
16:34:49 <Sukhdev> Thanks folks
16:34:57 <sambetts> thanks again :)
16:35:04 <Sukhdev> bye
16:35:11 <Sukhdev> #endmeeting