17:00:29 <jlvillal> #startmeeting ironic_qa
17:00:29 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Dec 16 17:00:29 2015 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is jlvillal. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
17:00:31 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
17:00:33 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'ironic_qa'
17:00:42 <vdrok> o/
17:00:43 <mjturek1> heyo \o
17:00:45 <krtaylor> o/
17:00:45 <sambetts> Hello everyone
17:00:45 <[1]cdearborn> \o
17:00:47 <maurosr> \o
17:00:51 <sinval> o/
17:00:57 <krtaylor> yea, jlvillal is back  :)
17:01:02 <jlvillal> o/
17:01:04 <jlvillal> Hi all
17:01:08 <aarefiev> hi
17:01:15 <jroll> \o
17:01:16 <jlvillal> So I'm a bit rusty at this...
17:01:32 <jlvillal> #topic Announcements
17:01:38 <lucasagomes> o/
17:01:47 <jlvillal> I don't have any announcements. Does anyone have anything to announce?
17:02:07 <jlvillal> I'll take that as a no.
17:02:18 <jlvillal> #topic Grenade testing
17:02:18 <krtaylor> just fyi, we (powerkvm) are planning on starting comments soon
17:02:18 <sinval> OneView driver CI is now able to test deployment workflow
17:02:34 <jlvillal> #undo
17:02:35 <openstack> Removing item from minutes: <ircmeeting.items.Topic object at 0xa684f90>
17:02:57 <mjturek1> yep, maurosr and I have been debugging the tempest runs and we're very close to having a successful run, pretty exciting
17:03:01 * jroll has announcements
17:03:03 <krtaylor> jlvillal, let us slow typists have a chance :)
17:03:14 <jlvillal> Remind me how to make a note...
17:03:38 <jroll> we're now running ironic changes via a devstack plugin, soon the same for grenade. that work is here: https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open++branch:master+topic:ironic-devstack-plugin,n,z
17:03:42 <jroll> err.
17:03:46 <jroll> #info we're now running ironic changes via a devstack plugin, soon the same for grenade. that work is here: https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open++branch:master+topic:ironic-devstack-plugin,n,z
17:04:16 <jroll> another announcement: the gate's in terrible shape. we've bumped the timeout to 600 to hopefully mitigate in the meantime
17:04:20 <maurosr> yeah I have some patches (necessary to power systems) on devstack that I need to re-work to fit on this new format
17:04:39 <jlvillal> #info we're now running ironic changes via a devstack plugin, soon the same for grenade. that work is here: https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open++branch:master+topic:ironic-devstack-plugin,n,z
17:04:52 <jlvillal> Hmmm. I expected a notification about that.
17:04:52 <jroll> maurosr: the code in the devstack plugin is almost identical, should be easy to move
17:04:59 <jroll> nah, no notifications
17:05:05 <jlvillal> Okay.
17:05:18 <maurosr> nice!
17:05:35 <jlvillal> #info powerkvm are planning on starting to make comments soon
17:05:43 <rajinir> o/
17:05:46 <mjturek1> jroll: very cool
17:05:59 <jlvillal> #info OneView driver CI is now able to test deployment workflow
17:06:00 <krtaylor> oh, cool, thanks jlvillal
17:06:21 <jlvillal> Any other announcements?
17:06:22 <krtaylor> here come the CI systems  :)
17:06:48 <jlvillal> In 3
17:06:50 <jlvillal> 2
17:06:53 <jlvillal> 1
17:06:59 <jlvillal> #topic Grenade testing
17:07:21 <jlvillal> So I have not worked on it for about 5 weeks :(
17:07:39 <jlvillal> though I think that moving devstack to become a plugin should make the work easier.
17:07:51 <kcalman> o/
17:08:05 <jlvillal> I'm trying to decide which has higher priority. functional testing work or grenade testing. I'm leaning towards grenade.
17:08:12 <jlvillal> jroll, Would love your thoughts.
17:08:23 <jroll> jlvillal: grenade, for sure
17:08:34 <jroll> jlvillal: also, you saw we're doing the grenade plugin thing, right?
17:08:38 <jroll> so should be easier to iterate on
17:08:52 <jroll> but I'd love to be able to assert we can do online upgrades - grenade is the missing piece there
17:08:56 <jlvillal> #info jlvillal to focus on getting grenade jobs working first, and then functional testing.
17:09:10 <jlvillal> jroll, Yep I saw the patch. Thanks for that.
17:09:21 <jlvillal> Okay moving on...
17:09:28 <jlvillal> #info functional testing
17:09:35 <jlvillal> #topic functional testing
17:09:47 * jlvillal should have undone that. Oh well...
17:10:16 <jlvillal> #info Once grenade work is done jlvillal will start again on functional testing. But if other people would like to work on it, that would be great.
17:10:34 <jlvillal> So if anyone is interested in working on functional testing that would be wonderful.
17:10:53 <krtaylor> I'll take a look
17:10:57 <jlvillal> I think vdrok was doing some stuff that looked somewhat related...
17:11:08 <krtaylor> but will make slow progress due to holidays
17:11:09 <jlvillal> Or at least vdrok had good ideas on bringing up the services.
17:11:12 <mjturek1> jlvillal: I'd like to lend a hand as well
17:11:24 <jlvillal> mjturek1, krtaylor great
17:11:55 <jlvillal> #info WIP patch for functional testing: https://review.openstack.org/235612
17:11:59 <vdrok> jlvillal, nope, I was not looking into it much yet, but will try to some time this week
17:12:03 <jlvillal> krtaylor, mjturek1 ^^^
17:12:26 <jlvillal> vdrok, I think you had made a good comment in my review. So I thought vdrok knows about functional testing :)
17:12:34 <vdrok> :)
17:12:42 * jlvillal jumped for joy
17:12:47 <mjturek1> jvillal: thanks!!
17:12:51 <jlvillal> Anything else?
17:12:59 <vdrok> eh, it does not open, and I don't remember my comment :)
17:13:27 <jlvillal> vdrok, Yeah I think Gerrit maybe has an issue?
17:13:45 <jlvillal> Moving on ...
17:14:03 <jlvillal> #topic 3rd Party CI
17:14:17 <jlvillal> I'll open the floor for comments.
17:14:42 <jlvillal> Is the iLO test still failing?
17:14:57 <krtaylor> spec merged, thanks to jroll and all that contributed!
17:14:57 <vdrok> jlvillal, no, it's upgrading, there was a notice ~10 mins ago
17:15:16 <jroll> yeah, gerrit is down for ~4 hours
17:15:36 <jlvillal> #info 3rd party CI spec was merged. Thanks krtaylor and everyone else involved.
17:15:36 <lucasagomes> jlvillal, I think iLO still failing yes, at least ased on the last votes I saw from it
17:16:11 <jlvillal> #info iLO CI is currently voting. But all votes are failure at this point. Work is in progress to fix it.
17:16:15 <jlvillal> lucasagomes, Thanks
17:16:26 <jlvillal> Any other 3rd party CI?
17:16:35 <jlvillal> Oneview are you good with the announcement before?
17:17:00 <sinval> yep, we are still in check experimentl
17:17:10 <jlvillal> sinval, thanks
17:17:13 <sinval> and soon we'll be in every patch
17:17:22 <jlvillal> If nothing else we can move on.
17:17:35 <jroll> just a note
17:17:49 <jroll> "voting" is typically used to mean "a -1 blocks a patch from merging"
17:18:07 <jroll> whereas "commenting" is meant as "submits a comment with a +1 or -1"
17:18:23 <jroll> let's try to use the right word to keep things straight :)
17:18:25 <jlvillal> undo
17:18:29 <jlvillal> #undo
17:18:30 <openstack> Removing item from minutes: <ircmeeting.items.Info object at 0xa7c1cd0>
17:19:04 <jlvillal> #info iLO CI is currently commenting. But all comments are failure at this point. Work is in progress to fix it.
17:19:15 <jroll> :)
17:19:16 <jlvillal> jroll, Thanks
17:19:27 <jlvillal> Okay moving on
17:19:33 <jlvillal> #topic General QA topics
17:19:43 <jlvillal> Anyone have anything to discuss here?
17:20:08 * jlvillal is not sure if gate failures fall into this category
17:20:46 <jlvillal> #info Gate has had many job failures recently. Due to timeout being exceeded. Patch was put in to extend timeout to 600 seconds.
17:20:53 <jroll> I put it in announcements too because holy cow
17:20:55 <jroll> it's so bad
17:21:07 <lucasagomes> yeah, it's failing a lot
17:21:31 <jlvillal> #info A patch is proposed to capture all of the 'baremetal' logs so that we have better insight into failures. https://review.openstack.org/257987
17:21:34 <lucasagomes> we tried a couple of things to mitigate it, ipxe, changing the driver to virtio... but nothing worked effectively
17:21:51 <lucasagomes> but I still think it would be good to get that stuff in regardless, every little helps
17:21:57 <jlvillal> Thanks jroll lucasagomes
17:22:06 <jlvillal> Anything else before we have open discussion?
17:22:23 <jlvillal> Okay moving on then.
17:22:30 <jlvillal> #topic Open Discussion
17:22:33 <rajinir> 3rd
17:23:05 <jlvillal> rajinir, ???
17:23:25 <jlvillal> Anyone have anything?
17:23:59 <jlvillal> Ending meeting in 5
17:24:00 <lucasagomes> not sure, unless people wants to try to brainstorm what could possible making the gate so slow to timeout
17:24:16 <jroll> isn't "general qa discussion" the same as "open discussion" in a qa meeting? :P
17:24:21 <lucasagomes> tho we don't have much data...
17:24:25 <jroll> or can I talk about beer now
17:24:34 <lucasagomes> os Star Wars... it's coming!
17:24:37 <lucasagomes> or*
17:24:37 <jlvillal> lucasagomes, I'm not sure. I think your patch is probably going to help figure it out.
17:24:46 <lucasagomes> jlvillal, yeah I hope so
17:25:09 <jlvillal> lucasagomes, At the moment it doesn't seem like we have the data to understand why.
17:25:20 <lucasagomes> yeah
17:25:21 <jlvillal> But if people have some ideas that would be great!
17:25:26 <lucasagomes> we can work with theories
17:26:08 <jlvillal> Okay. I think we are done for this meeting.
17:26:15 <jlvillal> Thanks everyone for attending!
17:26:18 <jroll> yeah, I think we needs more datas
17:26:23 <jroll> thanks for hosting jlvillal :)
17:26:37 <lucasagomes> thanks
17:26:37 <jlvillal> #info No meetings for next two weeks
17:26:55 <jlvillal> #info Next meeting 6-Jan-2015
17:27:03 <jlvillal> Thanks all. Ciao
17:27:10 <vdrok> thanks!
17:27:10 <jlvillal> #endmeeting