16:00:54 <sdake> #startmeeting kolla
16:00:55 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Aug 31 16:00:54 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is sdake. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
16:00:56 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
16:00:58 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'kolla'
16:01:06 <sdake> #topic rollcall
16:01:09 <duonghq> o/
16:01:11 <egonzalez90> o/
16:01:11 <coolsvap> o/
16:01:13 <Jeffrey4l_> 0/
16:01:15 <akwasnie> hi all :)
16:01:16 <berendt> o/
16:01:17 <hrito> o/
16:01:20 <sdake> there are epics in the fire...
16:01:26 <rhallisey> hi
16:01:33 <mandre> hello
16:01:50 <inc0> o/
16:02:55 <sdake> #chair rhallisey
16:02:56 <openstack> Current chairs: rhallisey sdake
16:03:08 <sdake> #topic announcements
16:03:16 <sdake> ryan will be handling the meeting at the :25 minute mark or so
16:03:24 <sdake> I have an unmovable conflict
16:03:26 <vhosakot> o/ sorry I'm late
16:03:33 <sdake> 1. our deadline is today for milestone #3
16:03:48 <sdake> 2. our deadline for rc1 is september 15th
16:03:56 <zhubingbing> hello
16:04:02 <sdake> 3. at rc1, the tree branches, so no more features after the 15th
16:04:20 <sdake> I'd like to use a big chunk of this meeting time to sort out what goes in rc1 and what goes to occata
16:04:38 <sdake> beecaue i have hard time tracking all the patches in my head ;)
16:04:40 <britthouser> 0/
16:05:00 <sdake> 4. OSIC TESTING IS COMPLETED
16:05:04 <britthouser> w00t! =)
16:05:09 <berendt> great
16:05:10 <pbourke> o/
16:05:11 <sdake> we were able to run 12 sscenarios only on ubuntu
16:05:17 <sdake> which is better then zero ;)
16:05:21 <vhosakot> sdake: was any scenario run on centos?
16:05:25 <sdake> big heroic effort to deploy centos, which we got done
16:05:39 <sdake> but ran out of time to run the scenario unfourtnately :(
16:05:39 <vhosakot> sdake: yes, 12 scenarios is great!
16:05:44 <vhosakot> cool
16:05:50 <sdake> if we get osic time again, we will be more prepared
16:05:59 <sdake> anything from the community?
16:07:01 <britthouser> yeah I think having the tests proofed on a smaller scale ahead of time would have speeded things up.  But hindsite is 20/20
16:07:02 <sdake> #topic Vote on etherpad for fishbowl or design session for ODS
16:07:11 <sdake> britthouser no doubt
16:07:28 <sdake> #link #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/kolla-O-summit-planning
16:07:31 <sdake> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/kolla-O-summit-planning
16:07:38 <sdake> please open that up and vote today
16:07:46 <sdake> I am submitting requirements at 5pm pst
16:07:54 <sdake> if you dont care for a sesson don't vote
16:08:01 <sdake> if you do care for a sesson put a F or D next to it
16:08:13 <sdake> our schedule is flexible all the way up to summit
16:08:16 <sdake> atleast has been in the pat
16:08:21 <sdake> but slots is not
16:08:22 <sdake> are not
16:08:43 <sdake> any Q/A?
16:08:46 <duonghq> sdake: do the previous votes count?
16:08:54 <sdake> duonghq yes please dont vote twice
16:08:58 <duonghq> roger
16:09:02 <sdake> use a unique coolor if your voting as a new voter
16:09:11 <sdake> and put yur name in the contirubtors list please
16:09:50 <sdake> the new ptl will be fine tuning the agenda after I pass the baton :)
16:10:03 <duonghq> what does "sync with sean-k-mooney" mean in the bare metal?
16:10:06 <sdake> i expect this to change abit
16:10:13 <sdake> duonghq no idea
16:10:21 <sdake> i think abut what topics he woudl like to discuss there
16:10:33 <duonghq> fine
16:10:45 <sean-k-mooney> well if you figure it out let me know too :)
16:10:54 <sdake> #topic OSIC scale testing documentation creation
16:11:05 <duonghq> you got many vote sean-k-mooney, actually
16:11:08 <sdake> we need to create osic scale testing documentation
16:11:10 <britthouser> I think it was "get a debrief from sean"
16:11:23 <sdake> we have all the data captured in a review
16:11:30 <inc0> sdake, mind putting all our results and data on google drive or somewhere?
16:11:32 <sdake> not sure who if anyone can take thiss on
16:11:39 <inc0> so we can take a longer look at it?
16:11:47 <sdake> inc0 i can put the tarball in google drive
16:11:50 <sdake> after meting
16:11:53 <inc0> please do
16:12:02 <sdake> Jeffrey4l_ has /etc tarball
16:12:08 <sdake> Jeffrey4l_ can you email me that tarball pls
16:12:16 <Jeffrey4l_> sdake, np
16:12:37 <inc0> I'll handle the whitepaper or whatever, will discuss with OSIC folks what's best way
16:12:38 <sdake> inc0 i've got bck to back meetings this mornign - so wont get to it until this afternoon or tonight sometime
16:12:56 <inc0> np, plenty of work with N-3 anyway
16:13:06 <sdake> so sounds like inc0 is up for it
16:13:09 <sdake> I am also up or it
16:13:12 <sdake> after the 15th
16:13:25 <inc0> yeah, we're not that time constrained
16:13:34 <inc0> on that front
16:13:50 <inc0> but would be nice to have it for summit
16:13:52 <inc0> for our own sake
16:14:01 <sean-k-mooney> inc0: i think there i a tar of all the results in the review also
16:14:02 <sdake> agree - want it done for summit
16:14:10 <sdake> sean-k-mooney there is but not of /root
16:14:31 <sdake> sean-k-mooney while we got ya- if you can fill in subbullets for the baremetal seession at sumit that would be helpful
16:14:44 <sdake> ok now for boring boring time ahead ;)
16:14:51 <sdake> #topic newton-1
16:14:58 <sdake> the idea here is to triage blueprint
16:14:58 <sdake> s
16:15:10 <sdake> they either go in occata 1
16:15:13 <sdake> or newton-rc1
16:15:20 <sdake> or if they are finished, they should be marked as ssuch
16:15:41 <sdake> #link https://launchpad.net/kolla/+milestone/newton-3
16:15:45 <sdake> can folks open that page up pls
16:16:09 <sdake> we are just triaging the blueprints at this point
16:16:24 <sdake> if your patches will merge by 5pm tody to make the blueprint done - pleae mark it as needs review
16:16:41 <sdake> if yu dont hae permissions to do so please yell out ;)
16:17:08 <sdake> i'll put a clock of 4 minutes for folks to go through the blueprints and make appropriate changes
16:17:14 <sdake> 9:20 - we will revisit list
16:18:36 <duonghq> sdake: I set my bp to o-1
16:19:00 <duonghq> I think it's ok
16:19:07 <sean-k-mooney> sdake the kolla host and bifrost blueprints have not been targeted to a release. should i set them to newton-3
16:19:23 <sdake> sean-k-mooney please do
16:19:40 <sdake> sean-k-mooney newton series, newton-3 milestone
16:20:46 <berendt> What about https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/performance-monitoring ?
16:20:56 <berendt> Should this be added to newton?
16:21:19 <berendt> implemntation should be good progress
16:22:05 <duonghq> I think it's missing something to gather data from cluster
16:22:15 <duonghq> sdake: right?
16:22:17 <zhubingbing> This BP I have modified the test passed.
16:22:32 <sdake> berendt please
16:23:10 <berendt> sdake I cannot set the progress
16:23:21 <sdake> berendt i'll do so
16:24:16 <sdake> anything in started state that hsould go to good progress state - please do so now
16:24:21 <sdake> clock of 3 minutes
16:24:24 <sdake> 9:27
16:24:28 <sdake> rather :27 ;)
16:25:23 <sdake> zhubingbing https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/aodh-role
16:25:29 <sdake> zhubingbing what state should that be in?
16:25:29 <berendt> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/aodh-role should be implemented
16:25:51 <zhubingbing> sure
16:25:55 <zhubingbing> yes
16:26:04 <zhubingbing> should be implemented
16:27:22 <sdake> boucning this to o1; https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/build-logging-per-container
16:28:47 <vhosakot> there is a patch set for that..
16:29:03 <sdake> now we go through all the good progress blueprints and see which ones we want to keep for newton
16:29:15 <berendt> I think we finished https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/third-party-plugin-support today?
16:29:17 <sdake> we need to eliminate many blueprints from newton if possible
16:29:22 <sdake> inc0 around?
16:29:32 <sdake> berendt ya I think that is more or less done
16:29:44 <inc0> one more nit I want to add
16:29:45 <sdake> we can use trivialfix for problems found on that one
16:29:50 <inc0> reno notes;)
16:29:55 <berendt> sdake I think somebody should recheck the list in the bp, it is not up to date
16:29:59 <inc0> after that I'll close bp
16:30:07 <inc0> berendt, that's on me
16:30:16 <inc0> I'll do full house cleaning today
16:30:24 <sdake> berendt sometimes the automated link to launchpad d oesn't work
16:30:39 <berendt> sdake no we have a manual list at the end of the bp
16:30:50 <sdake> ok - top to bottom one at a time
16:30:53 <sdake> rhallisey : https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/api-interface-bind-address-override
16:31:01 <sdake> will that make rc1, or shudl we bounce to o1?
16:31:15 <rhallisey> o1 since that changes with a repo split
16:31:22 <sdake> rhallisey please make the change ;)
16:31:50 <sdake> pretty sure this will make n1 - any detractors? :) https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/keystone-fernet-token
16:32:03 <sdake> ok rhallisey gotta jet
16:32:09 <sdake> rhallisey pleae drive this process from here
16:32:12 <sdake> i'll bein irc
16:32:17 <sdake> and provide guidance if needed
16:32:21 <sdake> just go through em one at a time
16:32:36 <rhallisey> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/sanity-check-container
16:32:37 <berendt> inc0 I think https://review.openstack.org/#/c/357746/ and https://review.openstack.org/#/c/358193/ are related to the 3rd party bp
16:32:38 <sdake> and igure out if they need to go to o1, stay in newton (they will finish merging by 15th)
16:33:29 <inc0> ahh the footer controversy
16:33:32 <rhallisey> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/kuryr-docker-plugin
16:33:53 <rhallisey> this looks close
16:33:55 <berendt> sdake so it is fine to add https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/performance-monitoring to n-3?
16:34:39 <rhallisey> berendt, how many patches are left to merge there?
16:34:44 <inc0> I think we should bump
16:34:45 <Jeffrey4l_> rhallisey, that one is not implemented.
16:34:46 <rhallisey> looks like some need a rebase
16:34:51 <inc0> there is too much stuff to be done
16:35:04 <berendt> rhallisey I have not count them, but they are in a good progress
16:35:26 <sdake> perf will land
16:35:32 <sdake> in rc1
16:35:33 <inc0> sdake, can we merge it by rc1?
16:35:39 <sdake> i am hopeful
16:35:41 <inc0> yeah, let's put hard deadline for 15th
16:35:45 <rhallisey> berendt, I reviewed some of those. I think they are close, but I can see some rebasing is needed
16:35:50 <inc0> if it's not there then, it's O
16:35:53 <sdake> 15th is a hard deadline for all patches merging
16:35:55 <duonghq> I'm sorry but anybody can make sure that all Kolla was migrated to ansible2?
16:36:03 <sdake> duonghq that has been done
16:36:15 <inc0> duonghq, it has, otherwise it wouldn't work at all
16:36:15 <rhallisey> berendt, going to target rc2
16:36:17 <rhallisey> rc1*
16:36:33 <rhallisey> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/vmtp-container
16:36:35 <inc0> it's already bumped to rc1
16:36:38 <rhallisey> this is also close
16:36:45 <duonghq> sdake, inc0, it worked but still has many warning, or we can safely ignore those?
16:36:52 <rhallisey> rc1 perhaps
16:37:03 <inc0> let's make it rc1
16:37:17 <berendt> rhallisey "series goal" should be acctepted for newton series
16:37:32 <rhallisey> yes
16:37:34 <inc0> duonghq, we should make note of them and submit bugs, could you do this?
16:37:39 <rhallisey> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/ansible-trove
16:37:49 <inc0> btw bugs aren't affected by deadlines we talk about now
16:37:52 <inc0> only new features
16:37:59 <inc0> any issue with ansible2 is a bug now
16:38:00 <duonghq> inc0: okay
16:38:09 <duonghq> understand
16:38:15 <Jeffrey4l_> inc0, no. ansible2 works fine
16:38:26 <rhallisey> inc0, let's do that after we go through the bps
16:38:37 <inc0> Jeffrey4l_, yeah, that's my impression too, but if duonghq see something wrong, bugs are way to go now
16:38:39 <rhallisey> ansible-trove needs some reviews and rebases
16:38:44 <rhallisey> bumping to 0
16:38:53 <sdake> yes - please only do blueprint triage
16:39:00 <sdake> i'll sort out the bug triage
16:39:09 <rhallisey> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/build-debian
16:39:34 <rhallisey> this looks done
16:39:44 <berendt> rhallisey I do not think so
16:39:53 <rhallisey> what's missing?
16:39:59 <rhallisey> gate & docs
16:40:01 <berendt> a gate job for debian for example
16:40:03 <inc0> there are still containers not done
16:40:07 <Jeffrey4l_> rhallisey, no one test this and no gate for debian.
16:40:10 <berendt> and there are a lot of containers missing
16:40:11 <inc0> kibana being one of them
16:40:12 <rhallisey> ah true
16:40:19 <rhallisey> bumping to o
16:40:25 <inc0> yeah, I think so
16:40:29 <Jeffrey4l_> ok
16:40:38 <berendt> and progress should be set to slow
16:40:42 <rhallisey> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/calico
16:40:56 <inc0> O for sure for calico
16:41:06 <rhallisey> ya o
16:41:14 <berendt> is somebody working on it?
16:41:16 <inc0> unfortunately person who did that moved to different project
16:41:20 <inc0> so atm nobody
16:41:21 <berendt> last comment in the request from june
16:41:24 <rhallisey> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/cleanup-playbooks
16:41:42 <inc0> but I'd love to see it done anyway, so I might pick that one up next release:)
16:41:50 <rhallisey> no one is working on this
16:41:54 <rhallisey> bumping..
16:42:16 <rhallisey> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/enable-networking-sfc-support
16:42:52 <rhallisey> I think this is close
16:43:08 <rhallisey> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/346842/
16:43:13 <rhallisey> needs some review
16:43:20 <Jeffrey4l_> yep
16:43:24 <rhallisey> that could make n-3
16:43:43 <rhallisey> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/barbican-ansible
16:44:03 <rhallisey> bumping to o
16:44:23 <sdake> barbican will land
16:44:27 <sdake> its ready to merge
16:44:30 <rhallisey> uh
16:44:33 <berendt> barbican is good progress, n-3
16:44:48 <rhallisey> ok
16:44:55 <rhallisey> I think rc-1
16:44:57 <rhallisey> tbh
16:44:58 <inc0> rhallisey, rc-1
16:45:07 <inc0> it's -verified now
16:45:09 <berendt> yes makes sense
16:45:19 <inc0> and all the gates red
16:45:23 <rhallisey> it's actively being worked on and it looks close
16:45:28 <rhallisey> ya my concern is the gate
16:45:33 <rhallisey> but rc-1 it could make it
16:45:34 <inc0> zhubingbing, will you make it before 15th?
16:45:55 <Jeffrey4l_> found some merge conflict, it should be easy to solve.
16:46:07 <rhallisey> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/collectd-ceilometer-plugin
16:46:11 <inc0> yeah, but gates are all red
16:46:28 <rhallisey> that seems done
16:46:33 <inc0> no
16:46:45 <rhallisey> what's missing?
16:46:47 <sean-k-mooney> collectd still needs the ansible role i belive
16:46:47 <berendt> rhallisey the docker part only?
16:46:52 <Jeffrey4l_> some failed merge file failed like <<< in the file.
16:46:56 <inc0> deployment of collectd and ceilometer conf
16:46:57 <berendt> yes i think ansible is missing
16:46:59 <rhallisey> err
16:47:05 <sean-k-mooney> i will ping pritive but i belive he has something
16:47:11 <berendt> but should be realistic for rc1
16:47:17 <inc0> I'd bump it to O tbh
16:47:20 <rhallisey> hm
16:47:35 <rhallisey> k I though it was an addition to the logging
16:47:41 <inc0> since we don't have reviews up for missing pieces
16:47:41 <rhallisey> ya it does need ansible bits
16:47:48 <rhallisey> rc-1
16:47:59 <sean-k-mooney> rhallisey: its independent of the loggin but could be used with it
16:48:04 <inc0> ok, let's make it rc-1 we can always bump it more
16:48:12 <rhallisey> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/multinode-gate
16:48:14 <rhallisey> bumping this
16:48:17 <inc0> O
16:48:20 <Jeffrey4l_> O
16:48:20 <berendt> o
16:48:20 <inc0> definetly
16:48:36 <rhallisey> I link you guys vote
16:48:37 <rhallisey> lol
16:48:57 <rhallisey> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/ansible-gnocchi
16:49:15 <Jeffrey4l_> r1
16:49:28 <rhallisey> rc-1 agreed
16:49:36 <rhallisey> being actively worked on
16:49:48 <egonzalez90> yes, is nearly finished
16:50:05 <rhallisey> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/enable-congress-container
16:50:12 <berendt> cool, i need gnocchi for cloudkitty
16:50:23 <rhallisey> needs a rebase here
16:50:36 <inc0> rc-1
16:50:42 <rhallisey> rc-1
16:51:06 <rhallisey> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/neutron-vpnaas-agent
16:51:13 <berendt> rc-1 :)
16:51:14 <inc0> Daviey, ?
16:51:20 <inc0> rc-1 or O?
16:51:21 <rhallisey> looks wip
16:51:23 <inc0> which one you want?
16:51:25 <berendt> I will finisih the work on it this week
16:51:30 <rhallisey> berendt, ok
16:51:34 <rhallisey> rc-1
16:51:35 <inc0> kk so rc-1
16:51:51 <inc0> ahh, my bad, it was yours berendt ;)
16:51:55 <rhallisey> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/kolla/+spec/bifrost-support
16:51:57 <rhallisey> last one
16:52:13 <inc0> bifrosts are almos ready to merge if not merged:)
16:52:13 <Jeffrey4l_> expect it is done in rc-1
16:52:17 <rhallisey> ok
16:52:19 <inc0> so I'd keep it n3
16:52:25 <rhallisey> looks super close
16:52:28 <rhallisey> may be n3
16:52:47 <rhallisey> ok that looks much better
16:52:50 <sean-k-mooney> its currently targeting n3 in launchpad
16:52:52 <rhallisey> good job team
16:53:06 <inc0> gerrit is acting up
16:53:15 <inc0> I think only one review left from bifrost
16:53:23 <sdake> biforst merging todya
16:53:23 <rhallisey> #topic (jeffrey4l) should we merge this? support first found config file win
16:53:24 <sdake> dont move it
16:53:34 <rhallisey> #link https://review.openstack.org/306928
16:53:46 <Jeffrey4l_> need a undo?...
16:53:48 <rhallisey> that's already merged
16:53:51 <rhallisey> #undo
16:53:51 <openstack> Removing item from minutes: <ircmeeting.items.Link object at 0x7f5bbf298550>
16:53:53 <rhallisey> ..
16:54:03 <rhallisey> #topic Open Discussion
16:54:05 <sean-k-mooney> inc0: there are two reviews left but yes almost all merged
16:54:10 <Jeffrey4l_> ya. it is merged.
16:54:12 <rhallisey> we put kolla-kube in here
16:54:16 <rhallisey> got only 6 min
16:54:20 <inc0> sean-k-mooney, one already is in gates
16:54:37 <inc0> so about kolla-k8s
16:54:43 <inc0> what needs doing to spawn a VM?
16:54:53 <rhallisey> sbezverk_, has it working
16:54:57 <wirehead_> yep!
16:55:03 <inc0> w00t
16:55:07 <rhallisey> I'm re doing the docs atm
16:55:11 <rhallisey> they're almost done
16:55:12 <wirehead_> sbezverk_ has successfully completed the challenge of doom.
16:55:17 <rhallisey> that way it's easlier to jump in
16:55:27 <wirehead_> and is granted the right to dance on the graves of our enemies.
16:55:34 <rhallisey> :)
16:55:40 <rhallisey> for people looking for work
16:56:00 <rhallisey> there are lots of services that can be added using the same template as the rest of the pods
16:56:08 <rhallisey> those are great to pick up
16:56:23 <imcsk8> rhallisey: i would like to help
16:56:25 <wirehead_> I agree. :)
16:56:30 <rhallisey> if you're up for a python adventure the CLI could use some work too
16:56:51 <inc0> I'll work on these HA issues we discussed
16:57:09 <rhallisey> inc0, ya those I'm also curoiuus about
16:57:22 <rhallisey> imcsk8, awesome! I'll see if I can find a blueprint you can bite into
16:57:41 <imcsk8> rhallisey: thanks! i really dig kolla :)
16:57:58 <inc0> don't dig too deep, there are corpses laying around
16:58:01 <rhallisey> woo :)
16:58:33 <rhallisey> inc0, you did too deep you realize we're surrounded by a container
16:58:33 <inc0> thanks guys!
16:58:42 <Daviey> Sorry, arrving late.. Clashing meeting!
16:58:42 <rhallisey> thanks everyone
16:58:50 <inc0> hey, it's my idea! docker run kolla-deploy;)
16:58:53 <Jeffrey4l_> https://bugs.launchpad.net/kolla/+bug/1616268
16:58:53 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1616268 in kolla mitaka "Stale namespace removal causing "RTNETLINK answers: Invalid argument" errors" [Critical,Confirmed]
16:58:53 <wirehead_> Can we try to contain the puns? :P
16:58:58 <Jeffrey4l_> this bug need eyey.
16:59:05 <Jeffrey4l_> eye. it is very critical.
16:59:06 <rhallisey> Jeffrey4l_, ah yea
16:59:12 <sdake> meeting time up guys
16:59:17 <sdake> overlfow into #kolla :)
16:59:25 <rhallisey> interesting
16:59:26 <Daviey> #openstack-kolla
16:59:29 <sdake> thanks for coming :)
16:59:31 <rhallisey> sbezverk_, also saw that
16:59:33 <sdake> thanks Daviey
16:59:36 <rhallisey> flowing over!
16:59:40 <rhallisey> #endmeeting kolla