15:00:56 <spsurya> #startmeeting kolla
15:00:57 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Aug 22 15:00:56 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is spsurya. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
15:00:58 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
15:01:01 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'kolla'
15:01:08 <spsurya> #topic rollcall
15:01:14 <ktibi> \o/
15:01:23 <chason> o/
15:01:35 <yankcrime> o/
15:01:36 <spsurya> o/
15:01:41 <donghm_> o/
15:02:27 <spsurya> lets wait 2 more minutes to join people
15:02:29 <mgoddard> o/
15:02:45 <wchy1001> o/
15:04:13 <spsurya> guys egonzalez is a sick today, so chairing meeting
15:04:50 <spsurya> lets move to agenda
15:05:04 <spsurya> any anouncement from community
15:05:05 <spsurya> ?
15:05:26 <spsurya> not from my side
15:06:02 <spsurya> guess not
15:06:27 <spsurya> so no new topic in agenda
15:06:34 <spsurya> it is same as last week
15:07:04 <spsurya> but still we can add something to discuss in Dublin PTG
15:07:15 <spsurya> https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/kolla-stein-ptg-planning
15:07:32 <spsurya> feel free to add more topics
15:07:51 <spsurya> lets move to eatherpad for 5 minutes
15:15:18 <spsurya> updated the rocky accomplishment section : with some of the features
15:15:35 <spsurya> need to add all completed work
15:16:21 <spsurya> Added Kolla-cli section if GUI support is possible with Kolla-cli for PTG discussion
15:17:28 <spsurya> Hope whoever wants to added the topics in https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/kolla-stein-ptg-planning
15:17:41 <spsurya> lets move to https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/kolla-rocky-release
15:18:27 <spsurya> as we are in feature freeze mode    Rc1 will be tag in upcoming week
15:18:52 <spsurya> if anyone have some critical review items
15:19:14 <spsurya> please add same
15:19:35 <spsurya> lets wait 2 minutes for it
15:19:50 <spsurya> donghm_:  mgoddard  ^^
15:19:57 <spsurya> if have please add
15:19:59 <mgoddard> there is also https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/KollaWhiteBoard, nothing on there though
15:20:48 <spsurya> mgoddard: thanks to link
15:20:57 <spsurya> yes we have this too
15:21:23 <mgoddard> when do we need to merge https://review.openstack.org/#/c/591885/?
15:22:25 <spsurya> mgoddard: IIUC  yes we need to
15:22:43 <spsurya> before Rc1
15:23:15 <mgoddard> ok, better get reviewing
15:23:22 <spsurya> yes
15:24:13 <spsurya> #topic open discussion
15:24:34 <spsurya> anyone wants to discuss something
15:24:38 <spsurya> please go ahead
15:24:59 <mgoddard> we have started work on testing upgrades in CI in kayobe
15:25:11 <mgoddard> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/592932/
15:25:20 <mgoddard> currently testing Pike -> Queens
15:25:37 <wchy1001> ok,there many projects has dead ,should we continue to maintain it in kolla ?
15:25:40 <mgoddard> seems to be mostly working, but there is an issue with nova-compute
15:26:05 <mgoddard> it does not properly recover after the SIGHUP sent during upgrade
15:26:18 <mgoddard> I will raise a bug in kolla-ansible and nova
15:27:15 <spsurya> mgoddard: yeah that would be good to track
15:27:21 <spsurya> nice work though
15:27:38 <mgoddard> hopefully we can use some of this work for testing upgrades in kolla ansible CI
15:27:43 <spsurya> wchy1001: have to check dead one
15:28:38 <spsurya> wchy1001: can you list on https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/KollaWhiteBoard
15:29:10 <wchy1001> ok,for example, magnum ? freezer,sahara ,those projects have not update for long time..
15:29:20 <spsurya> mgoddard:   you mean adding a job for that in ka
15:29:31 <spsurya> kolla-ansible*
15:29:45 <mgoddard> yes
15:29:45 <spsurya> that would be great i think
15:30:14 <mgoddard> wchy1001: we use magnum and sometimes sahara
15:30:17 <spsurya> mgoddard: congratulation for your session in Berlin Summit
15:30:24 <donghm_> mgoddard: yeah, great to add that for upgrade gate
15:30:43 <mgoddard> spsurya: thanks. did the kolla hands on lab go through?
15:31:13 <wchy1001> ok,have everyone test gnocchi use redis as incoming  ?i test failed
15:31:20 <spsurya> mgoddard: not this time
15:32:00 <spsurya> wchy1001: i didn't yet, raise the bug we can verify later
15:32:52 <wchy1001> it many be gnocchi bug, i fixed it by modify gnocchi ..but gnocchi is not openstack's project.
15:33:16 <mgoddard> the problem is that we lack testing for non-core projects
15:33:40 <spsurya> mgoddard: agree
15:34:06 <wchy1001> yes
15:34:18 <mgoddard> I am hoping this will change during stein
15:34:35 <spsurya> mgoddard: would be great if somehow we run tempest in kolla-ansible gate job
15:34:36 <mgoddard> I have a CI job for ironic which is close
15:35:02 <spsurya> yeah i saw in review
15:35:03 <mgoddard> spsurya: yes that would be good, or at least a small selection of tests from refstack
15:35:09 <wchy1001> lol,i have see your ps in review
15:35:27 <mgoddard> our test matrix is quite large
15:36:03 <spsurya> mgoddard: have created some test docs ?
15:36:17 <spsurya> test matrics
15:36:19 <mgoddard> spsurya: what do you mean by test docs?
15:37:05 <mgoddard> no, I just mean that we have a lot of variables - OS, container OS, services, scenarios, etc
15:37:34 <spsurya> yeah
15:37:46 <mgoddard> I wonder what would happen if we enable everything in CI...
15:38:05 <mgoddard> if we had a multinode deployment, would there be enough RAM?
15:38:21 <mgoddard> or could we define an inventory to spread the services around?
15:39:06 <spsurya> I think RAM would be enough for multinode deploy
15:41:19 <spsurya> https://www.openstack.org/summit/berlin-2018/summit-schedule/global-search?t=Kolla
15:41:50 <spsurya> Its always pleasure to see kolla being is being used in many session
15:42:52 <spsurya> donghm_: around ?
15:43:09 <donghm_> spsurya: yup
15:43:45 <spsurya> donghm_:  how far we are from upgrade role for all core services ?
15:44:16 <spsurya> swift one is almost there i think
15:44:34 <spsurya> nova one is also pretty close
15:45:03 <donghm_> yes, and neutron is also done,
15:45:13 <donghm_> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/407922/
15:45:52 <mgoddard> has there been any progress on the strategy plugin, or an alternative?
15:46:10 <donghm_> mgoddard: I'm going to working on it
15:46:23 <mgoddard> cool
15:46:25 <spsurya> donghm_:  seems we will get all in the end of Rc2-Rc3
15:46:27 <donghm_> Just started yesterday
15:46:35 <spsurya> donghm_: nice
15:46:51 <mgoddard> I don't think we can merge them into rocky though
15:46:57 <mgoddard> it's a feature
15:47:13 <spsurya> mgoddard: yeah
15:47:22 <spsurya> just for completion
15:47:26 <mgoddard> ok
15:47:51 <donghm_> mgoddard spsurya yes, just only heat project need to completion
15:48:02 <donghm_> and need more test for nova
15:48:05 <spsurya> donghm_: ok
15:49:17 <spsurya> anyone wants to discuss ^^
15:49:41 <spsurya> guess not
15:49:58 <spsurya> Thanks everyone for coming  and supporting
15:50:16 <donghm_> good night every one!
15:50:20 <spsurya> lets end meeting
15:50:22 <spsurya> #endmeeting