15:00:09 <bswartz> #startmeeting manila
15:00:10 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Mar 17 15:00:09 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is bswartz. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
15:00:11 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
15:00:13 <bswartz> hello all
15:00:14 <gouthamr> hello o/
15:00:14 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'manila'
15:00:14 <cknight> Hi
15:00:18 <tpsilva> hello
15:00:18 <ganso> hello
15:00:21 <jseiler_> hi
15:00:24 <xyang1> hi
15:00:24 <Poornima> Hi
15:00:36 <ameade> o/
15:00:42 <Zhongjun_> Hi
15:01:03 <aovchinnikov> hi
15:01:23 <bswartz> okay guys today there's not a ton to talk about
15:01:35 <bswartz> #agenda https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Manila/Meetings
15:01:48 <bswartz> #topic RC1 status
15:02:09 <bswartz> so last week I was very nervous about RC1, given the huge number of remaining bugs
15:02:16 <markstur> hi
15:02:32 <bswartz> we are still behind schedule w.r.t. RC1 but it's starting to look manageable
15:02:43 <bswartz> #link https://launchpad.net/manila/+milestone/mitaka-rc1
15:02:56 <toabctl> hi
15:02:59 <bswartz> as you can see we have 48 fixed bugs and 18 remaining
15:03:23 <kaisers_> hi
15:03:26 <bswartz> I'm going to cover the remaining bugs and we will try to resolve what we can
15:03:28 <dgonzalez> hi
15:03:30 <mkoderer___> hi
15:03:32 <bswartz> my goal is to cut RC1 this week
15:03:34 <vponomaryov> hi
15:03:49 <tbarron> hi
15:03:50 <bswartz> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1544725
15:03:51 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1544725 in Manila "manage API ignores snapshot_support in the share_type" [High,New]
15:04:30 <bswartz> this one has no owner
15:04:44 <bswartz> looks like gouthamr had it but has dropped it
15:04:48 <gouthamr> bswartz: i planned on working on it. I unassigned it a few minutes ago. .will talk to ganso right after this meeting.
15:05:06 <bswartz> if nobody wants to take over this bug right now I will retarget
15:05:16 <ganso> bswartz: I can take it
15:05:38 <bswartz> ganso: we need a fix today
15:05:38 <gouthamr> thanks ganso!
15:05:54 <mkoderer___> bswartz: if we remove LXC bug https://bugs.launchpad.net/manila/+bug/1555554 is gone
15:05:55 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1555554 in Manila "Neutron plugin does port binding without checking port state" [Medium,In progress] - Assigned to Marc Koderer (m-koderer)
15:05:59 <bswartz> if I don't see a patch by the end of the day I'll boot it out
15:06:14 <bswartz> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1552526
15:06:15 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1552526 in Manila "manila access-allow doesn't appear to properly handle 0.0.0.0" [High,New] - Assigned to Surya Ghatty (ghatty)
15:06:16 <mkoderer___> bswartz: so we can close the bug with the removal
15:06:38 <mkoderer___> bswartz: ah sry wanted to interfere
15:06:46 <bswartz> mkoderer___: let me go through them in priority order
15:06:49 <ganso> mkoderer___: I thought it was also related to generic driver concurrency problems, no?
15:07:09 <bswartz> sghatty: ping
15:07:18 <mkoderer___> ganso: no, it's just about a bug introduced with LXD/LXC
15:07:40 <bswartz> I haven't seen any updates to this and sghatty isn't here
15:08:00 <bswartz> this appears to be a longstanding bug
15:08:06 <cknight> bswartz: is this one in core or in generic?
15:08:27 <bswartz> it's a driver bug, but we don't know how many drivers have the same issue
15:08:29 <vponomaryov> cknight: it affects LVM and Generic drivers
15:08:43 <vponomaryov> cknight: all that use NFS-kernel server
15:08:52 <cknight> vponomaryov: got it, thanks
15:09:01 <bswartz> Unless someone wants to take this one over and fix it I'm inclined to push it
15:09:08 <toabctl> not sure if there is a way to define a wildcard by ip with nfs-kernel server
15:09:11 <bswartz> any volunteers to fix this today?
15:09:17 <vponomaryov> cknight: ZFSonLinux was affected too, but it is fixed here already
15:09:21 <bswartz> toabctl: yes it's supported
15:09:37 <cknight> vponomaryov: is there a fix that can be easily ported over?
15:09:43 <toabctl> vponomaryov: if you point me to the zfs fix, I can have a look howto port it over
15:09:52 <bswartz> there's no way this is a lot of work
15:09:54 <vponomaryov> toabctl, cknight: usage of long CIDR instead of short
15:10:00 <bswartz> but to test it you need to be able to fire up those drivers
15:10:27 <bswartz> okay any takers?
15:10:39 <cknight> sounds like toabctl volunteered
15:10:42 <toabctl> :)
15:10:56 <toabctl> I have an hour left. If I can prepare a fix in that time, I'll post it.
15:11:01 <bswartz> okay thanks  toabctl
15:11:04 <cknight> toabctl: thanks
15:11:12 <bswartz> let me know if you don't get to it so I can retarget today
15:11:19 <bswartz> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1546303
15:11:21 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1546303 in Manila "Drivers need more information to ensure snapshots of a replicated share across replicas" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Goutham Pacha Ravi (gouthamr)
15:11:21 <toabctl> ok
15:11:45 <bswartz> gouthamr: this is the large bugfix youv'e been iterating on, correct?
15:12:24 <bswartz> ... we lost gouthamr
15:12:28 <gouthamr> bswartz: yes
15:12:35 <bswartz> oh there he is
15:12:38 <vponomaryov> gouthamr: is PS5 is latest or you planmore updates?
15:12:43 <gouthamr> bswartz: #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/292659
15:12:44 <bswartz> can it be merged today?
15:13:05 <gouthamr> bswartz: i was hoping i can get some reviews for it.
15:13:08 <vponomaryov> bswartz: latest PS #5 breaks NetApp and ZFS drivers
15:13:15 <bswartz> I've been following this one and I have a good feeling
15:13:23 <bswartz> but yes there are required driver changes
15:13:28 <bswartz> for the 2 drivers that support replication
15:13:33 <gouthamr> vponomaryov: new [atch is coming up
15:13:39 <gouthamr> patch*
15:13:44 <bswartz> okay good enough
15:13:45 <vponomaryov> gouthamr: ok, waiting for it
15:13:49 <bswartz> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1550295
15:13:50 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1550295 in Manila "Concurrent requests to allow access get lost" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Tiago Pasqualini da Silva (tiago.pasqualini)
15:14:09 <bswartz> tpsilva and I were just discussing this in the channel earlier
15:14:22 <tpsilva> yep
15:14:22 <cknight> tpsilva: is a new patch ready?
15:14:31 <tpsilva> I implemented the new approach that we just discussed and it seems to work... I'll keep testing it and if I don't see any flaws, I'll fix any broken unit_tests and push it
15:14:39 <bswartz> okay thanks
15:14:48 <cknight> tpsilva: if you push it sooner, we can review in parallel
15:14:49 <bswartz> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1551064
15:14:50 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1551064 in Manila "Shares created from snapshot of a replicated share do not support replication" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Goutham Pacha Ravi (gouthamr)
15:14:58 <tpsilva> cknight: okay, will do that
15:15:05 <gouthamr> bswartz: fixed in the same patch
15:15:09 <bswartz> gouthamr: this is pretty minor isn't it?
15:15:11 <gouthamr> bswartz: #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/292659/5
15:15:14 <bswartz> oh okay
15:15:17 <gouthamr> bswartz: yes
15:15:26 <bswartz> no worries then -- just get that patch merged
15:15:33 <bswartz> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1554170
15:15:34 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1554170 in Manila "NetApp cDOT: When backend is unreachable replica status is being set incorrectly." [High,In progress] - Assigned to Alex Meade (alex-meade)
15:15:45 <ameade> up for review
15:15:59 <bswartz> I thought this was has been up for a while...
15:16:07 <ameade> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/291803/
15:16:07 <gouthamr> bswartz: related bug, up for review #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/291803/
15:16:10 <ameade> need one more review
15:16:26 <bswartz> okay core reviewers ^
15:16:33 <bswartz> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1555093
15:16:34 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1555093 in Manila "Keystone v3 support broken (all clients)" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Marc Koderer (m-koderer)
15:16:47 <mkoderer___> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/290511/13
15:17:04 <mkoderer___> I addressed hopefully all finding from cknight and jamie lennox
15:17:18 <bswartz> wow it's a big one
15:17:19 <mkoderer___> jenkis is currently running
15:17:24 <mkoderer___> bswartz: yes it is
15:17:32 <bswartz> but this is important
15:17:34 <mkoderer___> and a very critical (at least for us)
15:17:43 <bswartz> yeah we can't boot this one out
15:17:59 <mkoderer___> so reviews welcome
15:18:00 <bswartz> so let's make sure this gets reviews and merges
15:18:08 <bswartz> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1557071
15:18:10 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1557071 in Manila "NetApp cDOT: Does not handle replicated snapshots" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Goutham Pacha Ravi (gouthamr)
15:18:25 <bswartz> gouthamr this is related to the other bug right?
15:18:43 <gouthamr> bswartz: yes
15:18:48 <bswartz> separate bugs for drivers
15:19:09 <bswartz> okay the ZFS one is the same issue http://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1557283
15:19:10 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1557283 in Manila "ZFSonLinux driver fails replcation tests with snapshot instance fix" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Valeriy Ponomaryov (vponomaryov)
15:19:17 <bswartz> but both being worked on
15:19:33 <bswartz> that covers the high importance
15:19:39 <bswartz> and thankfully we have no more criticals
15:20:20 <bswartz> so assuming we can get 2 patches for the "new" bugs and merge teh fixes for the 7 other highs, I'll feel pretty good
15:20:29 <bswartz> let's cover the 6 mediums
15:20:35 <bswartz> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1479174
15:20:36 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1479174 in Manila "Lock required in delete share/snapshot" [Medium,In progress] - Assigned to Madhu Mohan Nelemane (mmohan-9)
15:21:11 <bswartz> mmohan: ping
15:21:46 <bswartz> I see this has been worked on since last week
15:21:49 <bswartz> and new patchset today
15:22:10 <bswartz> anyone have a good feeling about this merging soon?
15:22:16 <bswartz> do we need it in Mitaka?
15:22:43 <bswartz> I fixes a race condition, but probably one that's been around since liberty
15:22:50 <bswartz> it*
15:23:14 <mkoderer___> bswartz: need to have a closer look to that one
15:23:24 <bswartz> okay I'm not hearing much interest in this
15:23:41 <cknight> bswartz: sounds good in principle, haven't reviewed yet
15:23:45 <bswartz> this one will probably get pushed out unless it get attention quickly
15:24:15 <bswartz> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1539668
15:24:16 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1539668 in Manila "Quick start guide uses keystone client" [Medium,In progress] - Assigned to Daniel Gonzalez Nothnagel (dgonzalez)
15:24:27 <mkoderer___> I tranfered the bug to dgonzalez
15:24:31 <bswartz> this is docs bug
15:24:34 <dgonzalez> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/274136/
15:24:38 <bswartz> it should be fixed but it's not a RC1 stopper
15:24:42 <bswartz> I will retarget now
15:24:45 <mkoderer___> bswartz: +1
15:24:59 <bswartz> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1550337
15:25:00 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1550337 in Manila "api_version_request.matches does not accept a string or None" [Medium,In progress] - Assigned to Scott DAngelo (scott-dangelo)
15:25:20 <bswartz> wtf
15:25:33 <bswartz> oh I see -- it affects 3 projects
15:25:39 <bswartz> that's why there are so many patches
15:25:51 <bswartz> manila is the only project that hasn't fixed this
15:25:51 <cknight> bswartz: we technically don't need it now
15:26:18 <cknight> bswartz: it's a minor enhancement to microversion matching, but nothing is broken in manila
15:26:20 <bswartz> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/285426/
15:26:31 <bswartz> so do we not want to fix this ever?
15:26:40 <bswartz> I can -2 the fix and take manila off the bug
15:26:51 <cknight> bswartz: it's a fine enhancement, but not a blocker now
15:26:52 <bswartz> but I imagine scottda is trying to fix a real issue
15:26:58 <bswartz> oh okay
15:27:07 <bswartz> so retarget now? it's not ready to merge by RC1?
15:27:08 <mkoderer___> just retarget it
15:27:19 <bswartz> alright
15:27:34 <bswartz> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1555554
15:27:36 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1555554 in Manila "Neutron plugin does port binding without checking port state" [Medium,In progress] - Assigned to Marc Koderer (m-koderer)
15:27:41 <mkoderer___> we can remove this one
15:27:51 <bswartz> mkoderer___: earlier you said you wanted a fix in Mitaka
15:27:56 <mkoderer___> when LXD is dropped the issue in manila core goes away
15:28:11 <mkoderer___> bswartz: yes sorry I didn't saw your ML mail
15:28:18 <bswartz> mkoderer___: I expect LXD (or some other container driver) to come back in Newton
15:28:32 <mkoderer___> bswartz: then I have a fix
15:28:36 <mkoderer___> :)
15:28:41 <bswartz> should the fix go in now or newton?
15:29:01 <mkoderer___> bswartz: it's actualy the first patch for HPB too... so we can close this bug
15:29:04 <mkoderer___> I'll do
15:29:08 <bswartz> okay
15:29:18 <bswartz> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1557031
15:29:19 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1557031 in Manila "ZFSonLinux share driver does not report dedupe and compression capabilities" [Medium,In progress] - Assigned to Valeriy Ponomaryov (vponomaryov)
15:29:23 <cknight> This one is in the gate now.
15:29:29 <bswartz> awesome
15:29:35 <bswartz> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1557854
15:29:36 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1557854 in Manila "fix the scheduler choose a disable share service" [Medium,In progress] - Assigned to zhongjun (jun-zhongjun)
15:29:59 <bswartz> fix abandoned?
15:30:01 <Zhongjun_> Waiting for review
15:30:08 <bswartz> oh there are 2 fixes
15:30:26 <bswartz> very small change
15:30:31 <bswartz> let's get reviews on this
15:30:34 <bswartz> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/293246/
15:30:38 <Zhongjun_> Abandoned the same one
15:30:52 <bswartz> that's all the mediums
15:31:00 <bswartz> the last 3 bugs are low importance
15:31:06 <bswartz> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1536592
15:31:07 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1536592 in Manila "Manila should reuse sslutils and modules from oslo" [Low,In progress] - Assigned to Thomas Bechtold (toabctl)
15:31:22 <bswartz> https://review.openstack.org/289382
15:31:29 <mkoderer___> sounds like a nice to have for me
15:31:30 <mkoderer___> toabctl: ?
15:31:37 <bswartz> mkoderer___: you -1 this
15:31:52 <toabctl> hm. iirc I updated that this morning or so
15:32:01 <mkoderer___> ah yes.. it removed some config variables
15:32:08 <bswartz> okay let's resolve the discussion around it
15:32:13 <cknight> bswartz: looks like it fixes another bug with py3
15:32:14 <bswartz> seems like it can get in today
15:32:37 <bswartz> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1536936
15:32:38 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1536936 in Manila "scheduler choose wrong pool" [Low,In progress] - Assigned to zhaohua (zhaohua-zhao)
15:32:48 <toabctl> mkoderer___: see cknight and my comment.
15:32:57 <mkoderer___> toabctl: ok
15:33:10 <bswartz> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/271172/
15:33:16 <bswartz> no changes since Feb 23
15:33:26 <bswartz> looks like it got a bunch of -1 and no followup
15:33:41 <bswartz> can we live without this fix?
15:35:00 <bswartz> anyone from huawei here? I don't see zhaohua around
15:35:16 <ameade> Zhongjun_:  is huawei right?
15:35:23 <Zhongjun_> Yes
15:35:46 <bswartz> Zhongjun_: maybe you can ping zhaohua about following up in that review?
15:35:55 <bswartz> I'd like to simply retarget now though
15:36:18 <Zhongjun_> Ok, I will ask he
15:36:22 <bswartz> it's low importance
15:36:23 <cknight> bswartz: +1  It's been long enough with no response, it must not be that critical.
15:36:36 <bswartz> okay retargeted
15:36:47 <bswartz> remember we can backport fixes too
15:36:57 <bswartz> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1545720
15:36:58 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1545720 in Manila "generic driver: availability_zone not returned by ShareInstance model" [Low,In progress] - Assigned to Marcus Furlong (furlongm)
15:37:12 <bswartz> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/280223/
15:37:26 <bswartz> another old fix, from February
15:37:31 <bswartz> it has -1 and no followup
15:38:05 <bswartz> Marcus Furlong is from Aptira
15:39:08 <bswartz> gouthamr you had the problem with his
15:39:11 <bswartz> this
15:39:14 <bswartz> did you read the latest response?
15:39:28 <bswartz> oh I see
15:39:31 <bswartz> you can't repro
15:39:38 <bswartz> well I don't want to spend more time on this bug
15:39:45 <bswartz> it seems minor and not-urgent
15:40:09 <bswartz> pushed to newton
15:40:12 <bswartz> that was the last one
15:40:17 * bswartz refreshes page
15:40:23 <tpsilva> bswartz: what about the manilaclient bugs?
15:40:27 <bswartz> #link https://launchpad.net/manila/+milestone/mitaka-rc1
15:40:54 <bswartz> tpsilva: 1 sec
15:41:00 <tpsilva> k, sorry :)
15:41:01 <bswartz> okay we have 13 left
15:41:21 <bswartz> and I'm hoping they're all fixable today
15:41:26 <bswartz> so I can cut RC1 tomorrow
15:41:31 <bswartz> (it was supposed to be today)
15:41:50 <bswartz> thanks tpsilva for mentioning client
15:41:54 <bswartz> #link https://launchpad.net/python-manilaclient/+milestone/mitaka-rc1
15:42:39 <bswartz> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1556956
15:42:40 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1556956 in python-manilaclient "Functional tests for access rules is waiting for access_rules_status=active" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Tiago Pasqualini da Silva (tiago.pasqualini)
15:43:08 <tpsilva> this one just needs +A... it depends on the other update_access fix from manila
15:43:35 <bswartz> okay core reviewers please ^
15:43:38 <bswartz> err
15:43:42 <bswartz> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/293392/
15:43:47 <bswartz> that's the patch
15:43:55 <bswartz> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1516562
15:43:56 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1516562 in python-manilaclient "Functional tests do not support Keystone v3 auth" [Medium,Triaged]
15:44:05 <bswartz> this is a test issue
15:44:09 <bswartz> and no assignee
15:44:21 <bswartz> any reason to not boot it to newton?
15:44:30 <bswartz> anyone want to take it over?
15:44:40 <vponomaryov> bswartz: boot it
15:44:51 <bswartz> done
15:45:04 <bswartz> okay!
15:45:15 <bswartz> #topic Design summit planning
15:45:30 <bswartz> the design summit is not far away
15:45:45 <bswartz> I don't have an etherpad yet, but please start collecting your ideas for sessions
15:46:10 <bswartz> with the shortened cycle we probably won't have much time to pull the design summit together
15:46:28 <bswartz> space wise, I asked for and we received the same amount of space that we did in Tokyo
15:47:10 <bswartz> so I'll collect the proposed topics and try to arrange them into a sane schedule
15:47:19 <bswartz> look for a ML post from me
15:47:28 <bswartz> #topic open discussion
15:47:32 <bswartz> anything else today?
15:47:56 <vponomaryov> bswartz: LXD removal?
15:48:06 <bswartz> vponomaryov: I think that was covered in the ML post
15:48:16 <vponomaryov> bswartz: in scope of RC1?
15:48:23 <Poornima> bswartz, anything where new contributors can look ?
15:48:40 <bswartz> #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2016-March/089522.html
15:48:50 <bswartz> no replies there
15:49:25 <bswartz> the TL;DR version is that the LXD driver wasn't ready for production due to problems with LXD itself
15:49:45 <vponomaryov> bswartz: so, is it correct to say that we remove it in RC1?
15:49:46 <bswartz> we took a gamble and hoped that LXD would be stable in time for Mitaka release, and we lost that gamble
15:50:20 <bswartz> yes I haven't checked if the removal patch merged yet
15:50:36 <bswartz> not that we're not killing that driver
15:50:38 <bswartz> note*
15:50:42 <cknight> not merged yet
15:50:57 <bswartz> it's just being taken out of the release so more work can be done before releasing in newton
15:51:28 <bswartz> and it's possible that we'll use something other than LXD for container management which might cause the driver to change names
15:51:41 <bswartz> Poornima: welcome
15:52:31 <bswartz> Poornima: I recommend getting involved with code reviews and perhaps looking as the list of unfixed bugs in launchpad
15:52:58 <bswartz> oh and I suppose I should remind everyone about docs
15:53:14 <bswartz> if you haven't updated your config refs, do it now
15:53:15 <Poornima> alright :)
15:54:03 <bswartz> we will need to spend some time after RC1 updating various manuals related to manila, based on changes between liberty and mitaka
15:54:24 <bswartz> and for those that don't know, manila will have an install guide this cycle
15:54:51 <bswartz> thanks to the work of dencaval
15:55:15 <bswartz> anything else for today?
15:56:14 <bswartz> alright thanks everyone
15:56:17 <bswartz> let's wrap up RC1
15:56:24 <bswartz> #endmeeting