15:00:34 <tbarron> #startmeeting manila 15:00:35 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Sep 12 15:00:34 2019 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is tbarron. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 15:00:36 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 15:00:38 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'manila' 15:00:39 <bswartz> .o/ 15:00:43 <lseki> hi 15:00:44 <amito> .o/ hello! 15:00:49 <tbarron> courtesy ping: gouthamr xyang toabctl bswartz ganso erlon tpsilva vkmc amito jgrosso dviroel lseki carloss 15:00:54 <vkmc> o/ 15:00:55 <jgrosso> hello! 15:00:57 <carloss> hey :) 15:01:13 <dviroel> o/ 15:01:32 <toabctl> hey 15:01:50 * tbarron waits for seattle to wake up 15:02:16 <gouthamr> o/ 15:02:24 <tbarron> Hello all! 15:02:28 * gouthamr i'm up i'm up 15:02:33 <tbarron> #topic agenda 15:02:45 <tbarron> https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Manila/Meetings 15:02:54 <vhari> o/ 15:02:57 <tbarron> if you change it ping here and I'll reload 15:03:10 <tbarron> #topic Announcements 15:03:22 <tbarron> Schedule 15:03:36 <tbarron> #link https://releases.openstack.org/train/schedule.html 15:04:15 <tbarron> It's week R-5 15:04:24 <tbarron> "R" is for release :) 15:05:05 <tbarron> This week is M-3, Feature Freeze, Client library final relase, Soft StringFreeze, and Requirements Freeze 15:05:11 <tbarron> among some other deadlines 15:05:27 <tbarron> we'll talk about pending features as a separate agenda item 15:05:57 <tbarron> But all in all we'll pivot next week to testing in preparation for 15:06:24 <tbarron> Release Candidate 1 which is targeted for the week of 23 September 15:07:05 <tbarron> When you do reviews, even for bug fixes, please be aware that we don't want to change user-facing strings at this point. 15:07:54 <tbarron> I will be proposing manila-ui and python-manilaclient releases towards the end of this week so if you have something critical for these 15:07:57 <tbarron> ping me 15:08:08 <dviroel> ack 15:08:09 <tbarron> I'm aware of the stuff on our review focus etherpad 15:08:50 <tbarron> Any remarks, questions, discussion w.r.t. schedule? 15:09:23 <tbarron> OK, let me also remind you that this is Forum brainstorming season 15:09:38 <tbarron> We will submit forum topics 20 September 15:09:52 <tbarron> and are collecting ideas and interest here: 15:10:06 <tbarron> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/manila-shanghai-forum-brainstorming 15:10:35 <tbarron> You don't have to be going to Shanghai to make suggesetions or register interest. 15:10:49 <tbarron> So far we have two topics: 15:11:02 <tbarron> 1) U & V goals for Manila 15:11:09 <tbarron> 2) Manila CsI 15:11:56 <tbarron> We usually get pretty good ops attendance at these sessions and anticipate of course more engagement from APAC than usuaal 15:12:22 <tbarron> Does anyone have any other announcments today? 15:12:42 <tbarron> #topic tempest 3rd party CI 15:12:49 <tbarron> Any updates on this front? 15:13:17 <tbarron> crickets, folks have been busy with features given the deadline .... 15:13:35 <tbarron> I'll keep this as a standing agenda item so we can track ... 15:13:43 <tbarron> #topic cross project goals 15:14:29 <tbarron> Technically M3 is the deadline for these but it's to some extent up to the champions of these goals to determine the actual 15:14:32 <tbarron> deadline. 15:14:45 <bswartz> Did we achieve them all? 15:14:49 <tbarron> We don't have the test job for IPv6 that is coming. 15:14:52 <tbarron> still. 15:15:01 <tbarron> I don't anticipate issues there. 15:15:13 <tbarron> The other goal is pdf doc generation, 15:15:24 <tbarron> Thanks to toabctl we have this for manila proper. 15:15:50 <tbarron> we should ideally do it for the client and ui before we release them tomorrow. 15:16:35 <gouthamr> the PDF isn't getting published anywhere, though, yet? 15:16:40 <tbarron> If anyone wants to try this pls. ping me or just post a review, otherwise I may be able to attemot it. 15:16:47 <tbarron> gouthamr: I don't think so, no. 15:17:07 <gouthamr> ack - sorry i haven't caught up to it.. 15:17:11 <tbarron> gouthamr: but that's a central thing I think, not something we change in each project. 15:17:28 <gouthamr> are the bindep changes required for us to do that eventually? 15:17:48 <tbarron> toabctl may know better than I 15:18:07 <tbarron> but I think that will be central too 15:19:00 <gouthamr> oh, awesome - although a bit weird for local testing 15:19:04 <tbarron> we may want to document something along those lines for local builds, etc. later 15:19:54 <tbarron> bswartz: did we answer your questions? 15:20:14 <bswartz> The IPv6 interests me 15:20:17 <bswartz> Who owns that? 15:20:34 <gouthamr> gmann does 15:20:38 <bswartz> AIUI, the openstack test cloud has supported ipv6 for yeras 15:20:40 <bswartz> years even 15:20:55 <bswartz> I wonder what the holdup could be 15:21:08 <gouthamr> yep, this one is to have an ipv6-exclusive job in each project 15:21:35 <tbarron> and gmann has already built the job for zuulv3 native jobs 15:22:16 <tbarron> he's now building an equivalent for legacy job frameworks 15:22:40 <tbarron> I think we'll be in good shape when it arrives 15:23:13 <gouthamr> https://storyboard.openstack.org/#!/story/2005477 15:23:16 <gouthamr> #LINK https://storyboard.openstack.org/#!/story/2005477 15:23:53 <gouthamr> there's a bunch of projects in TODO state; the jobs added have been finding bugs elsewhere 15:26:09 <tbarron> #Topic Our Work -- Reviews 15:26:21 <dviroel> \o/ 15:26:25 <carloss> :) 15:26:34 <tbarron> #Link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/manila-train-review-focus 15:26:42 <tbarron> Here's our review focus board 15:26:53 <tbarron> Let's start with the smaller ones 15:27:05 * tbarron teases dviroel and carloss 15:27:20 <tbarron> We have a UI fix 15:27:52 <tbarron> but it *is* a bug fix and so far as I can tell requires a corresponding fix in horizon 15:28:13 <tbarron> so I'm not going to wait on it before releasing the UI 15:28:28 <tbarron> we can do another point release if everything lines up later 15:28:36 <tbarron> it's not a *new* feature 15:29:01 <tbarron> We have vkmc's keystoneclient work in manilaclient 15:29:32 <tbarron> which has a -1 at this point 15:29:50 <tbarron> so unless that gets resolved quickly we'll carry that work forwards 15:30:22 <tbarron> since we need to release manilaclient this week. 15:30:33 <tbarron> Any comments/questions about those two? 15:30:53 <gouthamr> yes 15:30:56 * gouthamr looks for link 15:31:13 <gouthamr> #LINK https://review.opendev.org/#/c/647538/ 15:31:48 <gouthamr> this does improve the client, but we should get this tested against manila-ui too, attn: vkmc 15:32:12 <gouthamr> i tested the session client, and the unit tests look good, but need to tty regarding the httpclient 15:32:18 * ganso sneaks in 15:32:36 * gouthamr has signed ganso's hall pass 15:32:42 * tbarron notices ganso 15:33:38 <tbarron> gouthamr: vkmc: we can do bug fixes after this week but no feature additions so you two decide risk/benefit of whether to 15:33:47 <tbarron> merge and defer some testing 15:33:55 <tbarron> or carry forward to the next release 15:34:08 <tbarron> my job is to push releases tomorrow at the latest 15:34:12 <tbarron> for client and ui 15:34:26 <gouthamr> tbarron: yeah, this change modifies the requirements file - i also don't know if it's time to do a 2.0 release 15:34:41 <tbarron> gouthamr: so put ptl hat on as well as reviewer hat when considering benefit/risk 15:35:09 <tbarron> all requirements changes have to be now, not later in this release 15:35:33 <tbarron> we don't need to answer the question here, the two of you can put your heads together and decide 15:35:53 <gouthamr> tbarron: we can talk on #openstack-manila after, but i'm a teeny bit wary about it surprising someone - vkmc's improved the code a lot and it's way more readable now 15:36:08 <tbarron> until U starts, "decide" means recommend strongly with reasons :) 15:36:31 * gouthamr practices roaring 15:36:34 <tbarron> :) 15:36:48 <tbarron> gouthamr will "roar" like a grizzly 15:37:18 <tbarron> OK, let's talk about these changees: 15:38:08 <tbarron> https://docs.google.com/drawings/d/1oTdJn6s47tSKstH14NEaekm0V1zVnuOxs95Ljt7DI7Y/edit 15:38:16 * tbarron had to find the nice diagram 15:38:30 <tbarron> Where are we on 671043? 15:38:42 <tbarron> That's the key change here. 15:38:48 <dviroel> yeah 15:38:49 <gouthamr> ooh, arrows have shifted 15:39:00 <carloss> tbarron: i've submitted a new PS this morning addressing some gouthamr comments 15:39:10 <tbarron> #link https://review.opendev.org/#/c/671043/ 15:39:41 <dviroel> tbarron: we still need to add share-network-subnet-list operation, right gouthamr ? 15:40:00 <dviroel> tbarron: that is almost done 15:40:10 <gouthamr> dviroel: you don't need that right away - unless it's a slam dunk 15:40:48 <dviroel> gouthamr: ack, just need to add units test 15:40:58 <gouthamr> dviroel: nice, thanks 15:41:01 <tbarron> All, we've agreed that we can merge the tempest changes next week, after feature freeze, also the dummy driver change (it's not feature code) 15:41:34 <gouthamr> the dummy driver could always do DHSS=True replication 8) 15:42:02 <tbarron> But if this is going to make it we need 671043, 671044, and 675368 15:42:26 <dviroel> Dummy depends on 677573 15:42:43 <tbarron> forget dummy for this week is what I'm saying 15:43:00 <dviroel> tbarron: yeah 15:43:45 <tbarron> carloss: dviroel: gouthamr: i'll probably be paying attention but ping me when you've merged 671044 15:43:51 <tbarron> or when it needs workflow 15:44:03 <carloss> tbarron: ack 15:44:16 <tbarron> b/c I'll try to not release python-manilaclient until it's ready 15:44:31 <dviroel> tbarron: ack, thanks 15:44:39 <tbarron> but please get it ready in reasonable time :) 15:44:40 <carloss> I need to fix two tests regarding 671044 15:44:56 <carloss> tbarron: sure 15:44:58 <dviroel> tbarron: sure 15:45:26 <tbarron> I'm grousing, pushing, but also want to express lots of appreciation for the work that dviroel carloss lseki and gouthamr are doing 15:45:38 <tbarron> This is complicated stuff and impacts the core 15:45:55 <tbarron> So I really appreciate your perseverance and attention to quality. 15:46:02 <carloss> yeah, thank you folks for the support with the changes 15:46:07 <dviroel> yes, thanks gouthamr for reviewing all those changes so far 15:46:12 <carloss> ^ 15:46:17 <tbarron> Anything else on this? 15:46:33 <tbarron> any other review topics we've missed? 15:47:01 <tbarron> #Topic Bugs 15:47:10 <tbarron> jgrosso: got any for us this week? 15:47:14 <jgrosso> I dont have anything today Tom 15:47:33 * tbarron imitates a hungry lizard 15:47:35 <gouthamr> \o\ /o/ 15:47:38 <tbarron> jgrosso: oh well 15:47:43 <tbarron> thanks anyways 15:47:51 <tbarron> Anyone else? 15:48:06 <tbarron> #topic Open Discussion 15:48:37 <tbarron> crickets 15:48:44 <tbarron> OK, thanks everyone!! 15:48:49 <carloss> thanks tbarron 15:48:50 <tbarron> Let's get to work! 15:48:55 <dviroel> Thanks guys 15:48:56 <bswartz> Ty 15:48:58 <lseki> thanks 15:49:05 <tbarron> #endmeeting