15:00:23 <gouthamr> #startmeeting manila
15:00:23 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Oct 10 15:00:23 2019 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is gouthamr. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
15:00:24 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
15:00:26 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'manila'
15:00:42 <tbarron> \o
15:00:45 <carloss> hey :)
15:00:52 <lseki> o/
15:01:02 <gouthamr> courtesy ping: xyang toabctl bswartz ganso erlon tpsilva vkmc amito jgrosso dviroel
15:01:08 <ganso> o/
15:01:10 <vkmc> o/
15:01:13 <vkmc> \o
15:01:15 <vkmc> \o/
15:01:20 <gouthamr> \o/
15:01:27 <bswartz> .o/
15:01:42 <dviroel> o/
15:01:50 <tbarron> this is pretty enthusiastic
15:01:52 <gouthamr> ascii figures ftw
15:02:01 <gouthamr> hello everyone! :)
15:02:25 <gouthamr> thanks for joining
15:02:29 <gouthamr> here's the meeting agenda
15:02:30 <tbarron> \o/  /o\ \o/
15:02:32 <gouthamr> #link: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Manila/Meetings#Next_meeting
15:02:37 <tbarron> jumping jacks to wake up
15:02:53 <gouthamr> lol
15:02:57 <gouthamr> #topic Announcements
15:03:17 <gouthamr> first off, let's formally welcome our newest core reviewer, dviroel
15:03:23 <dviroel> \o/
15:03:26 <vkmc> <tbarron> this is pretty enthusiastic <- this is all we got in irc, we need to exploit it
15:03:37 <lseki> 👏
15:03:37 * tbarron does a deep bow
15:04:00 <gouthamr> thanks for your hard work, dviroel - and everyone for your votes
15:04:02 <gouthamr> #link: http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-discuss/2019-October/009910.html
15:04:08 <tbarron> in dviroel's direction
15:04:09 <vkmc> dviroel++
15:04:37 <dviroel> gouthamr: ty for providing the opportunity
15:05:24 <gouthamr> as mentioned in that email, we'd like to grow the core maintainers team - if you're interested to join, please let your interest known to one of us, and we'll help guide you
15:05:47 <bswartz> \o/
15:05:51 <bswartz> Hooray
15:05:57 <gouthamr> krakenbot somewhere: you're doing great work, dviroel
15:06:27 <dviroel> thanks everyone
15:06:55 <jgrosso> Hi
15:06:57 <jgrosso> :)
15:07:01 <gouthamr> next up, please review our List of Shanghai events
15:07:02 <gouthamr> hey jgrosso
15:07:12 <jgrosso> hey gouthamr
15:07:18 <gouthamr> we have a few good talks proposed:
15:07:19 <gouthamr> #link: https://www.openstack.org/summit/shanghai-2019/summit-schedule/global-search?t=manila
15:07:53 <gouthamr> and we're meeting on Wednesday, Nov 6th for our project technical gathering
15:07:55 <gouthamr> #link: https://www.openstack.org/ptg/
15:08:11 <gouthamr> we'll speak a bit about this in a while
15:08:35 <gouthamr> but, what's new on the schedule is a fishbowl/forum session, led by tbarron and vkmc
15:09:10 <gouthamr> our future directions for manila-csi will be discussed there, so please plan on attending if you're in Shanghai
15:09:39 <gouthamr> any other announcements?
15:09:44 <lseki> andrebeltrami is a new netapper in the team
15:09:49 <carloss> \o/
15:09:53 <andrebeltrami> o/
15:09:57 <gouthamr> oh, nice - welcome andrebeltrami
15:10:02 <dviroel> welcome andrebeltrami
15:10:03 <lseki> will work on cinder though
15:10:18 <andrebeltrami> thank you gouthamr!
15:10:25 <tbarron> hi andrebeltrami, welcome!
15:10:39 <andrebeltrami> thank you all! :)
15:10:40 <gouthamr> that's okay, we won't hate you if you'd like to sneak in a few contributions to manila andrebeltrami
15:10:54 <dviroel> for sure =)
15:10:59 <carloss> haha
15:11:08 <gouthamr> #topic: "Meet the project leaders" opportunities in Shanghai
15:11:15 <gouthamr> #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-discuss/2019-October/009925.html
15:11:19 <gouthamr> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/meet-the-project-leaders
15:12:18 <gouthamr> a f2f meeting with project leaders has been proposed during the summit
15:12:28 <gouthamr> there are two separate dates and times
15:13:02 <gouthamr> if you're at the summit, please do participate
15:13:42 <gouthamr> the event's for contributors to get to know core reviewers, PTLs, TC members, SIG heads and all manner of leaders in the community
15:14:06 <gouthamr> you're all leaders in the manila community :)
15:14:57 <gouthamr> so, mark your calendars - tbarron will be around, and i'm volun-telling him to lead our brigade
15:15:27 <tbarron> aye aye sir
15:16:01 <gouthamr> awesome, anything more to add about the summit/planning?
15:16:20 <gouthamr> well, we have one more thing...
15:16:21 <gouthamr> #topic Ussuri PTG Planning
15:16:27 <vkmc> aye gouthamr
15:16:35 <gouthamr> ty vkmc
15:16:38 <gouthamr> ty tbarron
15:16:41 <gouthamr> #link: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/manila-shanghai-ptg-planning PTG Planning Etherpad
15:17:40 <gouthamr> thanks for adding topics, i reorganized the existing ones a little bit
15:18:10 <gouthamr> i know there will be more of them - please copy the template and keep adding them
15:18:23 <gouthamr> we'll groom them and see how we can go about the day
15:19:31 <gouthamr> we still don't know if we can have any sort of remote participation, but, setting our agenda helps us plan the extra remote-only PTG that we intend to have
15:20:14 <gouthamr> anything else on this $topic?
15:21:11 <gouthamr> nice, for the first time in three weeks, let's shine some light on bugs!
15:21:17 <gouthamr> #topic Bugs (jgrosso)
15:21:17 <vkmc> just my two cents, it might be a good idea to organize note takers... I volunteer to do it
15:21:25 <vkmc> because remote participation this time around is gonna be really hard
15:21:33 <vkmc> so, documentation is kinda critical now
15:21:40 <gouthamr> ah!
15:21:42 <gouthamr> #undo
15:21:43 <openstack> Removing item from minutes: #topic Bugs (jgrosso)
15:21:58 <bswartz> Bugs live to see another day!
15:22:00 <vkmc> that's it gouthamr, sorry for the delay to add that comment
15:22:00 <gouthamr> yes vkmc, it'll be critical
15:22:03 <jgrosso> :(
15:22:13 <vkmc> we need two or more people taking notes in turns
15:22:15 <vhari> sorry jgrosso :(
15:22:28 <jgrosso> vhari its ok
15:22:35 <gouthamr> even if we can't connect remotely, we should hope to note things down and possibly record the in-person meeting if technology allows
15:22:47 <vkmc> ++
15:22:48 <gouthamr> thanks for bringing this point up
15:23:05 <gouthamr> #topic  Bugs (jgrosso)
15:23:12 <gouthamr> like Bugs bunny, just cooler
15:23:16 <jgrosso> thanks gouthamr
15:23:18 <jgrosso> :)
15:23:26 <jgrosso> ok so https://bugs.launchpad.net/manila/+bug/1846836
15:23:26 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1846836 in Manila "Share network update returns success when it shouldn't" [Undecided,New]
15:23:42 <jgrosso> this is a new one from last week
15:23:55 <carloss> I'm working on this one... Will assign it to me, jgrosso :)
15:24:15 <jgrosso> carloss thanks!
15:24:28 <gouthamr> carloss: what's the impact of this bug?
15:24:47 <gouthamr> carloss: does the update get lost? or does a new subnet get created?
15:25:18 <carloss> I think it is a minor one...
15:25:58 <carloss> A new subnet does not get created... When the user tries to update the share network and there is no default subnet, it should raise an error
15:26:06 <carloss> But it isn't happening
15:26:16 <gouthamr> ack, so nothing happens in the database
15:26:24 <gouthamr> the API doesn't fail
15:26:27 <carloss> And manila returns success to the user, even if there is no subnet to be updated
15:26:31 <carloss> gouthamr: yes
15:26:54 <jgrosso> so the importance is low ?
15:26:56 <gouthamr> okay, seems like a minor annoyance to me
15:27:34 <gouthamr> jgrosso: i'd set it to medium, and i think it warrants a backport to Train
15:27:45 <jgrosso> done
15:28:00 <carloss> I'm pretty close to upload the PS with the fix :)
15:28:08 <gouthamr> thanks carloss
15:28:13 <carloss> Just waiting for functional tests execution
15:28:18 <carloss> yw gouthamr
15:28:24 <jgrosso> hey carloss since your here
15:28:26 <jgrosso> https://bugs.launchpad.net/manila/+bug/1807126
15:28:26 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1807126 in Manila "Cannot create shares using generic driver" [Medium,Confirmed]
15:28:31 <jgrosso> any update on this one ?
15:28:47 <jgrosso> i know one is paid to work on this
15:28:55 <jgrosso> no one is paid*
15:29:15 <carloss> I don't have updates on this one jgrosso :/
15:29:25 <jgrosso> :) cool thanks
15:29:36 <jgrosso> https://bugs.launchpad.net/manila/+bug/1818569
15:29:36 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1818569 in Manila "access rule apply races allow duplicates" [Medium,Triaged]
15:29:55 <gouthamr> jgrosso: we can close https://bugs.launchpad.net/manila/+bug/1807126 - i'll comment on it
15:29:56 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1807126 in Manila "Cannot create shares using generic driver" [Medium,Confirmed]
15:29:57 <jgrosso> just curious was this discussed at last PTG or the upcoiming PTG
15:30:21 <jgrosso> gouthamr ack about 1807126
15:30:29 <tbarron> jgrosso: on 1807226 the question is whether the issue still occurs after several potentially relevant fixes
15:31:25 <tbarron> 1807126 ^^
15:31:41 <jgrosso> tbarron yes
15:31:57 <tbarron> oh I see gouthamr's remark now
15:32:04 <jgrosso> gouthamr: :)
15:32:11 <jgrosso> yes he is going to close
15:32:37 <jgrosso> so what about https://bugs.launchpad.net/manila/+bug/1818569
15:32:37 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1818569 in Manila "access rule apply races allow duplicates" [Medium,Triaged]
15:33:13 <tbarron> jgrosso: it's an open issue
15:33:25 <jgrosso> tbarron that will be disussed in shanghai
15:33:30 <jgrosso> ?
15:33:32 <tbarron> jgrosso: no reports from the field
15:33:44 <jgrosso> tbarron ack
15:33:45 <tbarron> we discussed it but haven't figured it out
15:33:56 <jgrosso> tbarron thanks
15:34:10 <jgrosso> https://bugs.launchpad.net/manila/+bug/1652823
15:34:10 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1652823 in Manila "capability_create_share_from_snapshot_support is not set for some shares that are being used in create_share_from_snapshot tests" [Medium,In progress] - Assigned to yankee (yankeefu)
15:34:28 <jgrosso> yankee  still around ?
15:34:57 <gouthamr> haven't seen him/her for a while
15:35:19 <gouthamr> but, this bug must be fixed now
15:35:31 <jgrosso> gouthamr ack will unassign, do we think it needs to be fixed
15:35:38 <jgrosso> gouthamr ack
15:35:40 <gouthamr> digs up vkmc's patch
15:35:57 <gouthamr> #link https://review.opendev.org/#/c/540070/
15:36:09 <gouthamr> "Create a generic share type (api tests)"
15:36:27 <tbarron> yeah I was going to say that should take care of it
15:36:28 <gouthamr> the idea behind this was to create a share type that has all the configured/needed extra-specs
15:36:31 <vkmc> do we need to do something alike?
15:36:39 <vkmc> a share type to rule them al
15:36:40 <vkmc> l
15:37:10 <gouthamr> vkmc: hopefully not, your fix was what the tests needed - they now work without a default share type
15:37:36 <jgrosso> gouthamr so this has been verified and can be closed?
15:37:43 <gouthamr> so the workaround suggested on the bug isn't required anymore
15:37:54 <vkmc> oh cool
15:38:06 <gouthamr> jgrosso: yes - we can reference vkmc's fix and close it
15:38:17 <jgrosso> excellent I will do it
15:38:18 <gouthamr> vkmc: do you want to assign the bug to yourself and do that?
15:38:23 <vkmc> gouthamr, sure
15:38:28 <jgrosso> thats all i had for today
15:38:29 <gouthamr> or jgrosso :)
15:38:35 * gouthamr closing bugs is fun
15:38:49 <jgrosso> dont want to steal any ones thunder here
15:38:51 <jgrosso> :)
15:39:11 <gouthamr> hehe, ty for bringing these up jgrosso
15:39:21 <jgrosso> gouthamr: you we welcome
15:39:28 <gouthamr> regarding https://bugs.launchpad.net/manila/+bug/1818569
15:39:28 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1818569 in Manila "access rule apply races allow duplicates" [Medium,Triaged]
15:40:04 <gouthamr> tbarron: there's a similar bug you were investigating when you found this ^
15:40:05 <gouthamr> https://bugs.launchpad.net/manila/+bug/1808127
15:40:05 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1808127 in Manila "intermittent tempest duplicate access rule failure" [Low,Confirmed] - Assigned to Tom Barron (tpb)
15:40:39 <tbarron> jgrosso: the problem with these bugs is that the assignee is a slacker
15:40:49 <gouthamr> is this still an issue with the cephfs-nfs driver, or a generic issue?
15:41:00 <gouthamr> the latter that is
15:41:01 <jgrosso> tbarron no way man he is a rockstar!
15:41:19 <vhari> jgrosso: true that :)
15:41:21 <tbarron> I think it's likely a general issue that I saw there
15:41:23 <jgrosso> :)
15:41:26 <gouthamr> yeah, " Unassigned" is a rockstar
15:41:32 <tbarron> But can't sweart to it
15:41:35 <tbarron> swear
15:42:03 <jgrosso> gouthamr one is low and one is medium but your saying they are relatred
15:42:07 <jgrosso> related*
15:42:24 <jgrosso> shall I unassign both for now
15:42:28 <tbarron> jgrosso: They both are access-rule race issues
15:42:33 <gouthamr> jgrosso: likely
15:42:39 <jgrosso> right
15:42:46 <gouthamr> jgrosso tbarron: i'll take a look at this
15:42:53 <tbarron> jgrosso: yeah, unassign in order to encourage anyone who wants to look but
15:43:00 <jgrosso> tbarron ack
15:43:10 <jgrosso> or assign to gouthamr :)
15:43:17 <tbarron> I still feel some obligation, just haven"t had insight or dedicated bandwidth
15:43:32 <gouthamr> yes, i'll consult with you tbarron
15:43:39 <tbarron> jgrosso: leave them unassigned, if he wants to pick it up that's cool
15:43:45 <jgrosso> done
15:43:58 <gouthamr> alright, anything else about $topic
15:44:16 <gouthamr> okay... moving on..
15:44:18 <jgrosso> nope
15:44:22 <gouthamr> #topic: Open Discussion
15:44:49 <gouthamr> i missed an important announcement
15:45:01 <gouthamr> today's the last day for any RCs
15:45:16 <gouthamr> and we haven't found any release critical bugs
15:45:33 <gouthamr> however, i'll be proposing a re-release for manila-tempest-plugin
15:45:59 <gouthamr> if anyone thinks we ought to do another train release for manila, please let me know
15:46:32 <gouthamr> remember: we'll be doing a release again in ~3 weeks if we have backports that affect users
15:47:06 <gouthamr> but, it's up to the distributors to pick up these updated bits, which, they can ofcourse do directly off of our git repos too
15:48:06 <gouthamr> i can think of carloss' share networks bug as the first of many candidates that'll be backported
15:48:14 <gouthamr> s/bug/bugfix
15:49:28 <gouthamr> in other news, i know we're all zorilla-forever, but:
15:49:28 <gouthamr> https://www.npr.org/2019/10/09/768475870/stuffed-with-sockeye-salmon-holly-wins-fat-bear-week-heavyweight-title
15:49:53 <lseki> lol
15:50:07 <jgrosso> :)
15:50:08 <carloss> haha
15:50:18 <jgrosso> Holly is a BIG gear
15:50:21 <jgrosso> bear
15:50:52 <gouthamr> #teamholly
15:51:13 <gouthamr> alright folks, if that's it - let's catch up next week
15:51:25 <vkmc> I have one thing
15:51:59 <vkmc> the functional gate for python-manilaclient is failing
15:52:06 <vkmc> I was breaking my head to understand why
15:52:13 <vkmc> gouthamr pointed me to this fix https://review.opendev.org/#/c/681340/6
15:52:29 <gouthamr> #link https://review.opendev.org/#/c/686142/
15:52:53 <vkmc> I'm aware that our manila-tempest-plugin was brokwn in a weirder way and was fixed by dviroel
15:52:54 <vkmc> well
15:53:00 <vkmc> this also affect python-manilaclient
15:53:27 <dviroel> vkmc: I can take a look on this
15:53:29 <vkmc> and the reason, in that case, is that we are using stestr 2.5.1
15:53:34 <vkmc> for python-manilaclient
15:53:42 <vkmc> that workaround only fixes up to 2.5.0
15:53:53 <gouthamr> oh
15:54:04 <vkmc> not sure why, in the first place, they pinned it up to 2.5.0
15:54:11 <vkmc> maybe some of you have an idea on this?
15:54:17 <vkmc> otherwise I was going to ping tempest folks :)
15:54:33 <vkmc> possible solutions would be to stick with 2.5.0 or fix the workaround to also cover 2.5.1
15:54:58 <vkmc> I'd go with the latter since I don't like to be a special snowflake and pin to a specific version
15:55:36 <tbarron> +1
15:55:41 <vkmc> that's it :)
15:56:05 <vkmc> I want to fix that gate so we can start pushing the keystoneclient patch that has been sitting there for so long, and the openstack client first implementation
15:56:53 <gouthamr> ack, there are atleast three things that are ready for review last time i looked, it'd be nice to have this fixed
15:57:03 <vkmc> yeah
15:57:15 <vkmc> ok, I'll proceed to ping tempest folks, dviroel let me know if you think on a better workaround
15:57:24 <dviroel> vkmc: ack
15:57:28 <vkmc> workaround for the workaround :|
15:57:55 <gouthamr> /gif perfect-loop
15:58:18 <gouthamr> ty for bringing this up, vkmc
15:58:27 <vkmc> +1
15:58:33 <dviroel> two-minute warning
15:58:39 <gouthamr> lets chat further on #openstack-manila
15:58:43 <dviroel> =)
15:58:49 <gouthamr> thanks everyone
15:58:59 <gouthamr> #endmeeting