15:00:08 <carloss> #startmeeting manila
15:00:08 <opendevmeet> Meeting started Thu Nov  3 15:00:08 2022 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is carloss. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
15:00:08 <opendevmeet> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
15:00:08 <opendevmeet> The meeting name has been set to 'manila'
15:00:17 * carloss missed typing that command :)
15:00:45 <carloss> courtesy ping: vkmc dviroel felipe_rodrigues vhari gouthamr
15:00:50 <felipe_rodrigues> Hi
15:01:09 <carthaca> Hi
15:01:11 <gouthamr> o/
15:01:16 <chuanm> o/
15:01:22 <vhari> o/
15:01:28 <haixin> O/
15:01:37 <kpdev> Hi
15:02:22 <dviroel|rover> o/
15:03:40 <carloss> hello everyone! welcome back after our two weeks without manila weekly meetings :)
15:03:59 <carloss> today's meeting agenda:
15:04:02 <carloss> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Manila/Meetings#Next_meeting
15:04:47 <carloss> as usual, starting with our announcements for this week
15:04:58 <vkmc> o/
15:05:03 <carloss> #topic Announcements
15:05:14 <carloss> first with: Schedule and Deadlines
15:05:20 <carloss> #link https://releases.openstack.org/antelope/schedule.html
15:06:09 <carloss> we are two weeks away from M-1, when we agreed we would host a hackathon for implementing S-RBAC tests
15:06:15 <carloss> (more on that later in this meeting)
15:07:18 <carloss> another thing to highlight is that stable/wallaby transitioned into EM
15:07:40 <carloss> #link https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/releases/+/862327
15:08:02 <carloss> some of you might ask: what does it mean?
15:08:27 <carloss> some good information here:
15:08:30 <carloss> #link https://docs.openstack.org/project-team-guide/stable-branches.html#maintenance-phases
15:09:01 <carloss> it means we will still be able to land fixes to stable/wallaby, but we won't produce releases for that branch anymore
15:10:08 <carloss> the oldest maintained release now is Xena
15:11:04 <carloss> and after taking a look on what other projects are doing, we should start questioning the possibility to EOL some branches of manila
15:11:46 <carloss> the last one we EOL was rocky, but I would like to do that for Stein as well
15:11:56 <carloss> some other projects are heading to the same direction
15:12:23 <carloss> (i.e. ironic, which is willing to move stein to EOL, but reduce testing and jobs for train up to Victoria)
15:13:15 <carloss> I'd say I'm good with EOLing Stein, but we could keep train, ussuri and victoria around for some more time
15:13:47 <carloss> CI could become more of a burden, but we can discuss EOL for those in the future
15:13:49 <carloss> thoughts?
15:14:34 <gouthamr> +1 on EOLing Stein
15:16:49 <carloss> thanks gouthamr
15:17:00 <carloss> hearing no objections to this, let's proceed with this approach
15:17:21 <carloss> I'll be sending an email to the mailing list saying we are going to EOL Stein
15:17:55 <dviroel|rover> RIP Stein
15:18:33 <carloss> RIP Stein :)
15:19:02 <carloss> that's all I had in terms of announcements
15:19:11 <carloss> do you have an announcement you'd like to share with us today?
15:19:41 <felipe_rodrigues> I have one
15:20:22 <carloss> please go ahead felipe_rodrigues
15:20:44 <felipe_rodrigues> sfernand who was part of NetApp team has left us, I think he didn't join here
15:21:13 <dviroel|rover> RIP sfernand
15:22:14 <felipe_rodrigues> For anything related to Manila/NetApp sent/assigned to sfernand, please, send/assign to me
15:22:56 * dviroel|rover is kidding, he is alive ;)
15:23:11 * dviroel|rover and happy
15:23:43 <felipe_rodrigues> that's all
15:24:41 <carloss> oh, okay felipe_rodrigues - I'll look at launchpad and change assignments
15:25:41 <felipe_rodrigues> thanks
15:25:55 <carloss> #topic S-RBAC test Hack-a-thon
15:26:04 <carloss> vhari/lkuchlan, floor is yours
15:26:14 <vhari> ty carloss
15:26:55 <vhari> we are planning a Hack-a-Thon to help with S-RBAC test coverage
15:27:15 <vhari> we discussed M-1 time frame for this
15:27:50 <vhari> current target dates are  11/16 thru 11/18
15:28:48 <vhari> carloss created a taiga board to track the effort for us :)
15:28:50 <vhari> https://tree.taiga.io/project/silvacarloss-manila-tempest-plugin-rbac/kanban
15:29:37 <vhari> details to be announced later
15:29:52 <carloss> reminder to all: if I haven't added you to the board yet, and you want to be there, please dm me your email
15:29:53 <vhari> in the meantime pls feel free to take a look at the cards
15:32:32 <vhari> you can find the current patches under secure-rbac topic
15:32:37 <vhari> #link https://review.opendev.org/q/topic:secure-rbac
15:33:01 <vhari> pls ping us on manila channel if any questions ahead of time
15:33:33 <vhari> carloss, back to you :)
15:34:28 <carloss> thanks vhari :)
15:34:58 <carloss> it would be nice to take a look at these s-rbac open patches
15:35:31 <carloss> and lkuchlan and vhari already implemented great tests that will be used as example for our implementations in the hack-a-thon
15:36:18 <carloss> looking forward to the hackathon days :)
15:36:25 <vhari> ++ :)
15:37:01 <gouthamr> ++
15:37:21 <carloss> I would jump to the next topic, but I realized kpdev would like to have some reviews on https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/manila-specs/+/330306
15:37:31 <carloss> (another topic in between topics)
15:37:39 <carloss> #topic Review focus
15:37:45 <carloss> better this way :)
15:37:54 <carloss> so, can I have some eyes on this specification?
15:39:40 <felipe_rodrigues> I can take a look
15:39:59 <carloss> I can be another reviewer too
15:40:12 <carloss> gouthamr, dviroel|rover, ashrodri - can I have your eyes on this spec? :)
15:41:00 <dviroel|rover> carloss: i can try :)
15:42:35 <carthaca> Will we also get a new review focus etherpad? :)
15:43:15 <carloss> sure carthaca - it's been on my to-do for some time
15:43:42 <ashrodri> great! and ill take a look at the spec as well :)
15:43:54 <carthaca> ++
15:44:09 <carloss> https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/manila-antelope-review-focus - just created based on Zed - will add updates to the changes today
15:45:32 <carloss> etherpad not letting me add the whole content at once :D
15:46:16 <carloss> is there another open change for review you would like some attention?
15:48:34 <carloss> okay, that leaves us some time for
15:48:38 <carloss> #topic Bug Triage
15:48:44 <carloss> vhari: floor is yours
15:48:51 <vhari> ty carloss will jump right in
15:48:53 <vhari> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/manila/+bug/1990693
15:49:10 <vhari> nahimsouza[m], rcs'ed the issue and suggested a fix that worked
15:49:44 <vhari> is there any other concerns about this bug?
15:50:52 <gouthamr> so "Invalid"?
15:50:55 <vhari> if none we will move status to invalid
15:50:57 <vhari> ack
15:51:14 <vhari> is there a potential doc action?
15:53:21 <carloss> maybe netapp specific
15:53:44 <vhari> yes if any
15:53:48 <carloss> ++
15:54:07 <vhari> jumping to next #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/manila/+bug/1989126
15:54:21 <vhari> bug is in progress..
15:55:01 <vhari> can we add link to the fix?
15:55:22 <chuanm> https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/manila/+/856539
15:55:35 <vhari> ty chuanm
15:56:03 <chuanm> I tried to answer the question about the use case of this issue, I hope it's helpful for furthure review
15:56:35 <gouthamr> chuanm: it is, but i'm a bit concerned about the implementation
15:57:38 <gouthamr> chuanm: my initial concern is that this code here doesn't seem to be working for you? https://github.com/openstack/manila/blob/6e8ed59a91934096a4ddc9b184ef50a633cbd1ec/manila/share/drivers/netapp/dataontap/cluster_mode/lib_base.py#L2860-L2866
15:59:16 <gouthamr> felipe_rodrigues: maybe you want to chime in here - you may be able to reproduce the issue
15:59:24 <chuanm> I don't remember what it does, I will take a further look
16:00:17 <gouthamr> chuanm: when promoting, the netapp driver tries to perform a snapmirror update --> so if this is a planned failover, and the primary is healthy, it'll perform a sync prior to the actual replication change
16:00:25 * carloss time check
16:00:30 <felipe_rodrigues> ok
16:00:33 <felipe_rodrigues> I can try
16:00:53 <gouthamr> ack ty felipe_rodrigues; chuanm: we can follow up on the review once you take a look
16:01:08 <vhari> that's a wrap for bugs carloss ty
16:01:09 <carloss> thanks chuanm gouthamr felipe_rodrigues
16:01:15 <carloss> thanks vhari
16:01:21 <gouthamr> ++
16:01:26 <carloss> see you all in #openstack-manila
16:01:32 <carloss> thanks for joining today's meeting
16:01:35 <carloss> :)
16:01:37 <carloss> #endmeeting