04:00:06 <samP> #startmeeting masakari
04:00:07 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Apr 10 04:00:06 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is samP. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
04:00:08 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
04:00:11 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'masakari'
04:00:12 <tpatil> Hi
04:00:16 <samP> Hi all
04:00:17 <niraj_singh> Hi
04:00:18 <Dinesh_Bhor> Hi
04:00:35 <samP> sorry for last 2 weeks, wasn't able to do much work.
04:01:08 <samP> #topic Bugs/Patches
04:01:40 <samP> Any bugs or patches need to discuss?
04:02:31 <tpatil> Change service type patches are on hold as these patches won't be needed after newer version of openstacksdk is released
04:02:58 <samP> tpatil: got it
04:03:14 <tpatil> # link : https://review.openstack.org/#/c/536668/
04:03:28 <tpatil> Need to find out when openstacksdk team will release newer version
04:04:01 <tpatil> becoz the current master branch is totally broken
04:04:16 <samP> tpatil: let's ask in ML
04:04:33 <tpatil> ok
04:06:32 <tpatil> Louie has requested to review his specs and patches
04:06:34 <tpatil> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/547118/
04:06:54 <tpatil> # link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/534958/
04:07:23 <tpatil> I have started reviewing his implementation
04:07:38 <tpatil> Do you have any comments on his specs?
04:08:00 <samP> tpatil: No comments on specs from my side.
04:09:27 <samP> tpatil: I partially review the implementation. since it is a large patch, nee more time.
04:10:00 <tpatil> samP: Mee too, it's taking lot of time
04:10:36 <samP> I'll try my best to pass comments as soon as possible.
04:10:53 <tpatil> Great!!
04:11:08 <samP> But for the spec, if you have no comments, please mark your +1 for that.
04:11:31 <samP> I will +1 for workflow
04:11:51 <tpatil> Dinesh has voted -1 and the author will need to address his comments
04:12:27 <tpatil> Dinesh_Bhor: Did you propose a patch in masakari-specs to add rocky folder?
04:12:35 <samP> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/469070/
04:12:56 <Dinesh_Bhor> tpatil: Not yet, I will propose it soon
04:13:17 <samP> Dinesh_Bhor: thanks
04:13:21 <tpatil> Dinesh_Bhor: Thank you
04:15:16 <samP> I will ask Greg to move the spec once we create the directory
04:17:10 <samP> I would like to know the current status of masakari command
04:17:18 <samP> sorry for me not in touch
04:17:35 <samP> rkmrHonjo: you propose a new patch?
04:17:59 <tpatil> There is a dependency on newer version of openstacksdk
04:18:38 <samP> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/557634/
04:18:46 <samP> ^^ is this the one?
04:18:48 <tpatil> samP: Correct
04:20:10 <samP> humm, https://review.openstack.org/#/c/555710/ is merged
04:21:47 <samP> for stable/queens, this is still valid,
04:21:53 <samP> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/553319/
04:22:42 <tpatil> Yes
04:22:42 <samP> ^^ sorry for the delay. I will review and merge this and then push a new version for python-masakariclient
04:23:44 <samP> tpatil: thanks
04:23:54 <samP> Any other bugs or patches need to discuss?
04:25:00 <samP> Dinesh_Bhor: thanks for uwsgi support
04:25:07 <tpatil> # link : https://review.openstack.org/#/c/559051
04:25:10 <samP> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/553319/
04:26:05 <tpatil> In this patch, policy.json is referenced. But I have added one new item in rocky etherpad to Register and Document Policy in Code
04:26:22 <tpatil> # link : https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/masakari-rocky-work-items
04:28:08 <tpatil> If we decide to implement policy changes, then no need to add policy.json in data_files in the above patch
04:28:40 <tpatil> I have added three new items for Rocky, please check lines #49-54
04:29:02 <tpatil> All these new items are community wide goal
04:29:25 <tpatil> and I think it's applicable for Masakari as well
04:29:33 <samP> tpatil: thanks. mutable configs, mox3, and doc policy in code
04:29:45 <tpatil> correct
04:29:47 <samP> tpatil: it is.
04:30:48 <samP> tpatil: I think above patch is based on current code base of masakari, where policy.json has fixed content
04:31:44 <samP> tpatil: In that point of view, policy.json could be shipped in data_files
04:32:35 <tpatil> samP: That's true, but if we decide to implement policy in code, then no need to mention policy.json in data_files
04:32:48 <samP> tpatil: agree.
04:32:56 <tpatil> it's only needed if operator wants to override default policy
04:34:08 <samP> tpatil: noob question: how operator finds sample policy file to edit?
04:35:45 <samP> tpatil: agree. after implementing policy in code, we don't need policy.json in /etc/masakari
04:35:55 <tpatil> There is a policy generator tool that you can use to generate policy.json
04:37:37 <samP> https://specs.openstack.org/openstack/oslo-specs/specs/newton/policy-sample-generation.html
04:37:44 <samP> #link https://specs.openstack.org/openstack/oslo-specs/specs/newton/policy-sample-generation.html
04:37:50 <samP> I guess ^^
04:38:07 <samP> tpatil: got it. I will look for that later.
04:38:39 <samP> I will put my comments on that patch
04:38:41 <tpatil> samP: OK, nova example : https://github.com/openstack/nova/blob/master/etc/nova/nova-policy-generator.conf
04:39:23 <tpatil> this is the command to generate policy : tox -egenpolicy
04:39:44 <samP> tpatil: thanks for the info
04:41:13 <samP> Any other bugs or patches?
04:41:56 <niraj_singh> masakaridashboard patches are up for community review waiting for openstacksdk release
04:42:23 <niraj_singh> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/543870/
04:42:57 <samP> niraj_singh: thanks
04:43:18 <samP> niraj_singh: I think you also waiting for this vv
04:43:22 <samP> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/555710/
04:43:55 <samP> ah, yes, it's in tpatil's comment
04:44:02 <niraj_singh> yes
04:45:13 <samP> niraj_singh: thanks, I did a recheck for zuul -1, I will review this
04:45:25 <niraj_singh> ok thank you
04:46:32 <tpatil> samP: recheck won't help as openstacksdk newer version is not yet released
04:47:34 <tpatil> samP: Niraj has confirmed his dashboard changes are working as expected after updating his dev environment with latest openstacksdk master branch
04:47:36 <samP> tpatil: oh yes. thanks
04:48:19 <tpatil> We need newer version of openstacksdk badly
04:48:47 <samP> tpatil: understand, let's ask it on ML
04:49:23 <tpatil> samP: Yes
04:49:44 <samP> I will talk to release team and monty
04:50:17 <tpatil> That will be great, Thank you
04:50:43 <samP> #topic Discussion points
04:50:59 <samP> About next release,
04:51:04 <samP> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/557968/
04:52:08 <samP> Now we have 4 projects for Rocky release. We have follow the deadline
04:52:39 <samP> #link https://releases.openstack.org/rocky/schedule.html
04:53:24 <samP> Next milestone is Jun 04 - Jun 08 R-12
04:53:26 <samP> Rocky-2 milestone
04:54:41 <samP> And I got 2 session for masakari in Vancouver summit
04:54:56 <samP> Project Update and Project Onboarding
04:55:23 <samP> Please let me know if you would like to talk in sessions
04:55:51 <tpatil> Great
04:56:22 <tpatil> This time I might not visit Vancouver summit
04:56:37 <samP> tpatil: really?
04:57:25 <samP> That's too bad ;), anyway how about other members?
04:57:26 <tpatil> I will update you about it in the next week
04:57:39 <samP> tpatil: sure..
04:58:14 <samP> please let me know if you would like to talk, specially in project update session
04:58:52 <tpatil> samP: Sure
04:59:01 <samP> please consider
04:59:10 <samP> We only have 1 mins left
04:59:21 <samP> Thanks you all for your time
04:59:44 <samP> Please use IRC #openstack-masakri or ML with [masakari] for further discussions
04:59:56 <samP> Thanks again..
05:00:04 <samP> #endmeeting