16:01:38 <rakhmerov> #startmeeting Mistral
16:01:40 <openstack> Meeting started Mon Feb  6 16:01:38 2017 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is rakhmerov. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
16:01:41 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
16:01:43 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'mistral'
16:02:26 <ddeja> o/
16:02:47 <sharatss_> o/
16:02:48 <rakhmerov> hi
16:02:59 <rakhmerov> #topic Review Action Items
16:03:10 <mgershen> o/
16:03:32 <rakhmerov> 1. ddeja: send an email to openstack-dev about the issue with the murano client
16:03:35 <rakhmerov> hi mgershen
16:03:42 <rakhmerov> the issue is solved
16:03:46 <ddeja> rakhmerov: not done, but Issue is solved
16:03:52 <rakhmerov> yes :)
16:03:58 <mgershen> hi rakhmerov :)
16:04:01 <rakhmerov> not relevant anymore
16:04:06 <rakhmerov> Michal, how's it going?
16:04:12 <ddeja> and the fact that muranoclient is failing had nothing to do with murano itself
16:04:22 <ddeja> it was our fault
16:04:26 <rakhmerov> yes
16:04:33 <mgershen> rakhmerov: well, working on internal stuff.
16:04:37 <rakhmerov> ddeja: again, thanks a ton, great job
16:04:45 <ddeja> no problem
16:04:52 <rakhmerov> mgershen: ok, good
16:05:00 <rakhmerov> #topic Current status (progress, issues, roadblocks, further plans)
16:05:37 <rakhmerov> my status: reviewing, making various performance optimizations, fixing RPC and serialization
16:05:53 <rakhmerov> planning to work on serialization one day more
16:06:09 <mgershen> I was wondering if I should write some release notes/documentation for the feature that allows to query all failed tasks of an execution including nested tasks - https://review.openstack.org/#/c/394194/5/specs/ocata/approved/yaql-tasks-function.rst
16:06:29 <ddeja> my status: fixing gate and some fixes in kombu driver. I don't have anything specyfic planned for next week, I'll be doing reviews and maybe I'll smash some bus
16:06:43 <rakhmerov> mgershen: yes, please do
16:06:50 <rakhmerov> before the end of RC2
16:07:05 <rakhmerov> ~2 weeks left till that
16:07:28 <mgershen> ok, only release note or docs as well?
16:07:36 <rakhmerov> ddeja: do I remember correctly that d0ugal was planning to be on vacation this week?
16:07:46 <rakhmerov> mgershen: both please :)
16:07:46 <ddeja> rakhmerov: I'm not sure
16:07:55 <ddeja> rakhmerov: but maybe
16:08:03 <mgershen> rakhmerov: ok will do.
16:08:28 <rakhmerov> starting next cycle I'd like to make a strict rule to add documentation as part of the task, otherwise it can't be considered done
16:08:47 <ddeja> +2 ;)
16:09:01 <rakhmerov> I think it's still ok to create docs in a separate commit but reviewers need to remind somehow about writing docs
16:09:07 <rakhmerov> we'll discuss it separately
16:09:30 <rakhmerov> we recently found some more undocumented things with Dougal
16:09:43 <rakhmerov> like engine commands (succeed, fail, pause)
16:10:14 <rakhmerov> sharatss_: any updates from you?
16:10:25 <rakhmerov> from anyone else?
16:10:42 <sharatss_> rakhmerov: nothing much. Some small nits and doc bugs
16:10:51 <rakhmerov> ok
16:11:03 <rakhmerov> sharatss_: you'll be at the PTG, right?
16:11:27 <sharatss_> rakhmerov: yeah. I'm arriving on 21st there
16:11:33 <rakhmerov> ok
16:11:35 <rakhmerov> awesome
16:11:49 <rakhmerov> so, I don't have any special topics for today
16:12:01 <sharatss_> rakhmerov: super excited to meet you guys
16:12:08 <rakhmerov> this week I need to fill our PTG etherpad with more details
16:12:17 <rakhmerov> next week we need to create a schedule
16:12:39 <rakhmerov> so at the next meeting I'd like to finalize a list of topics
16:12:51 <rakhmerov> review what we have
16:12:55 <mgershen> sharatss_: looking forward to meeting you too. you make mistral better with code & reviews. your #5 in reviews currently.
16:13:05 <rakhmerov> :)
16:13:16 <rakhmerov> and #1 as far as number of commits ;)
16:13:30 <rakhmerov> #topic Open Discussion
16:13:41 <rakhmerov> so? Anything else guys?
16:13:48 <sharatss_> mgershen: rakhmerov: contributing my bit :)
16:14:18 <ddeja> rakhmerov: nothing from my side
16:14:19 <rakhmerov> we can finish earlier today since Dougal and Ryan and others are not here
16:14:40 <mgershen> fine by me
16:14:45 <rakhmerov> ddeja: do you think the idea of my patch itself is OK?
16:15:07 <ddeja> yes, it's totally OK to move the serialization out of engine to rpc
16:15:14 <rakhmerov> ddeja: btw, on your comment about the same return value format I made it on purpose, I think I just need to document it well
16:15:18 <rakhmerov> it's an optimization
16:15:40 <ddeja> OK
16:15:42 <rakhmerov> ddeja: I just want to make it 1) flexible 2) transparent where is what
16:15:56 <ddeja> but I still will dislike it ;)
16:16:09 <rakhmerov> 3) be able to define serialization for custom classes easily
16:16:19 <rakhmerov> ddeja: dislike a different format?
16:16:23 <rakhmerov> :)
16:16:52 <ddeja> I just don't like when functions may have so different returns, regarding the input
16:16:55 <rakhmerov> I dunno, I can experiment with it. It's not gonna make a serious difference, of course, in terms of performance
16:17:04 <rakhmerov> ddeja: totally agree
16:17:17 <ddeja> well, I'm not going to block it if it helps with other thing
16:17:28 <rakhmerov> but we don't have much freedom in general on how we do serialization
16:17:35 <ddeja> yup
16:17:43 <rakhmerov> ddeja: ok, let's see, I'll take a look at it again
16:17:49 <ddeja> OK
16:18:11 <rakhmerov> generally, I'm with my both hands for making a return value unified for the same function
16:18:21 <rakhmerov> it's made only for the sake of performance
16:18:26 <ddeja> OK
16:18:40 <rakhmerov> yes, ok, I'll continue with it tomorrow
16:18:50 <ddeja> sure
16:18:58 <rakhmerov> I also want to experiment with adding compression/decompression
16:19:13 <rakhmerov> and measure RPC speed with and without it
16:19:19 <ddeja> ACK
16:19:22 <rakhmerov> ok, let's finish earlier today
16:19:25 <rakhmerov> I'm done
16:19:28 <rakhmerov> last call
16:19:31 <rakhmerov> anything else?
16:19:35 <rakhmerov> mgershen, sharatss_?
16:19:47 <mgershen> nothing
16:19:53 <sharatss_> rakhmerov: nothing
16:19:56 <rakhmerov> ok
16:19:59 <rakhmerov> thanks for joining
16:20:04 <rakhmerov> have a great week
16:20:07 <rakhmerov> bye
16:20:08 <ddeja> thank you all
16:20:11 <mgershen> bye
16:20:14 <rakhmerov> #endmeeting