17:00:07 <igordcard> #startmeeting network_common_flow_classifier
17:00:08 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Sep 27 17:00:07 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is igordcard. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
17:00:09 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
17:00:11 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'network_common_flow_classifier'
17:00:14 <igordcard> hi all
17:00:17 <igordcard> let's wait 2 minutes to improve the chances of everyone being around
17:00:31 <davidsha> hi
17:00:38 <igordcard> hi davidsha
17:00:56 <davidsha> hey igordcard
17:01:55 <ralonsoh> HI
17:02:09 <igordcard> hi ralonsoh
17:02:14 <ralonsoh> problems in freenode?
17:02:44 <ralonsoh> maybe it's not the best day for this... too many people down
17:03:00 <davidsha> There seems to be an excessive amount of people loosing connection
17:03:21 <clarkb> yes freenode has said christmas has come early and they arereceiving many packets
17:03:53 <davidsha> kk, thanks clarkb
17:04:10 <igordcard> yep looks like it, and I'm also having network connectivity issues, apologies if I stay silent for a few minutes
17:04:24 <igordcard> anyone else here for the classification framework + ovs flow management meeting?
17:04:36 <davidsha> *Raises hand
17:05:02 * igordcard raises hand as well ...
17:06:35 <igordcard> 5 minutes now, I'll go through the topics anyway to keep them documented, and we can better discuss next meeting or at the summit
17:06:50 <igordcard> #info Agenda: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Neutron/CommonFlowClassifier#Discussion_Topic_27.2F9.2F2016
17:06:54 <igordcard> we'll start with the Common Classification / Common Classifier part of the meeting
17:06:59 <igordcard> #topic Can we converge on a first approach (https://review.openstack.org/#/c/333993)?
17:07:15 <igordcard> we have 3 approaches documented - we should vote on a specific one so we can start development asap
17:07:24 <igordcard> any preferences towards a specific approach?
17:07:57 <igordcard> this is one of the questions that need to be answered and agreed
17:08:48 <davidsha> Approach 2 seemed good, I'll need to review the spec again though to make sure I understand it.
17:09:05 <igordcard> davidsha: yep people seemed to lean towards that approach, overall
17:09:53 <davidsha> igordcard: ack, Not sure if we can make a decision for this at the moment though with only those in attendance
17:10:12 <igordcard> no, no, I'm just documenting the topics for this meeting
17:10:42 <igordcard> moving on...
17:10:46 <igordcard> #topic Next steps on the common classifier
17:11:23 <tamilhce> /msg NickServ identify openstack
17:11:29 <igordcard> next steps will be defined after we converge to an approach
17:12:28 <davidsha> kk, this is being developed outside of Neutron correct, it's going into neutron-classifier right?
17:12:42 <igordcard> davidsha: right, that's the next topic
17:12:45 <igordcard> moving on...
17:12:48 <davidsha> igordcard: ack
17:12:52 <igordcard> #topic Repo: new repo or neutron-classifier repo?
17:13:40 <davidsha> igordcard: my 2 cents is use neutron-classifier, it's already set up and is meant for this purpose.
17:13:57 <igordcard> overall, people seem to think it's a good idea to base the new common classification framework on the neutron-classifier, independently of which approach is chosen
17:14:16 <igordcard> davidsha: yep I would also vote for that
17:14:40 <davidsha> igordcard: As in use the repo or base the approach on the existing neutron-classifier code?
17:16:07 <igordcard> davidsha: at least the repo... but if part of the code is already well-aligned with what we will plan to do, then code may be reused as well, sure
17:16:23 <davidsha> igordcard: ack
17:16:48 <igordcard> we'll have to better figure out what to develop, and that depends on what approach gets chosen
17:16:57 <igordcard> moving on...
17:16:59 <igordcard> #topic Classification Framework: Barcelona Summit arrangements
17:17:30 <igordcard> so, for the record, I will be going the the barcelona summit
17:17:47 <davidsha> I'll be there as well.
17:17:49 <igordcard> we should meet-up there to accelerate the common classification framework
17:18:06 <davidsha> +1
17:18:50 <igordcard> I'm hoping that more people come to the next meeting so we can know who else is going and schedule some meetups
17:19:43 <davidsha> igordcard: there will be another meeting on the october 11 so we can grab more people on IRC
17:20:08 <igordcard> davidsha: +1
17:20:12 <igordcard> switching to the OVS Flow Management part of the meeting..
17:20:21 <igordcard> moving on..
17:20:23 <igordcard> #topic Status of https://review.openstack.org/#/c/320439/
17:20:45 <igordcard> there is good agreement on the current state of the OVS flow management spec
17:20:55 <igordcard> davidsha: would you like to take over this topic of the meeting?
17:21:12 <davidsha> igordcard: sure, there isn't much to add though.
17:21:36 <davidsha> The spec is almost merged and there seems to be an agreement on the approach
17:22:35 <davidsha> I'll resume the POC code I developed and aim to have it ready for Ocata-1 in November. Code reviews would be appreciated.
17:23:28 <igordcard> davidsha: alright, that's https://review.openstack.org/#/c/323963/ right?
17:23:32 <davidsha> I'll need to sync with ajo as well to make sure there isn't any misunderstandings.
17:23:39 <davidsha> igordcard: yup
17:23:45 <igordcard> cool
17:24:42 <igordcard> alright
17:24:44 <igordcard> moving on..
17:24:45 <igordcard> #topic OVS Flow Management: Barcelona Summit arrangements
17:25:11 <igordcard> same as what I said for the classification framework part
17:25:19 <igordcard> we'll defer this until the next meeting
17:25:25 <igordcard> moving on..
17:25:28 <igordcard> #topic Open discussion
17:25:31 <igordcard> anything else you want to discuss?
17:25:39 <davidsha> I'm good, you?
17:25:44 <igordcard> davidsha: great!
17:25:54 <igordcard> thanks all! *cough* davidsha
17:26:09 <igordcard> I guess this is everything for now
17:26:11 <davidsha> Lol, thank igordcard!
17:26:17 <igordcard> cya
17:26:20 <davidsha> cya
17:26:24 <igordcard> #endmeeting