21:01:54 <markmcclain> #startmeeting networking
21:01:55 <openstack> Meeting started Mon Apr 29 21:01:54 2013 UTC.  The chair is markmcclain. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
21:01:57 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
21:01:59 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'networking'
21:02:32 <markmcclain> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Network/Meetings
21:03:04 <markmcclain> #topic Announcements
21:03:26 <markmcclain> In case you missed it the Havana release schedule is availalbe
21:03:29 <markmcclain> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Havana_Release_Schedule
21:03:42 <markmcclain> H1 is a month from tomorrow
21:04:45 <markmcclain> Reminder there is a two day buffer, so features must be merged by end of day on May 28th to make H1
21:05:43 <markmcclain> I know everyone has been working hard to get blueprints file and/or updated
21:06:06 <markmcclain> I'd like to have all of the blueprints in by Friday
21:07:13 <markmcclain> I'd also like to revive Review Days
21:07:21 <markmcclain> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Quantum/ReviewDays
21:07:55 <markmcclain> I recycled the default availability, so take a look and make sure it still works for your current schedule
21:08:17 <markmcclain> Any questions before we move onto reports?
21:08:23 <markmcclain> Do we need to wake garyk up?
21:08:41 <garyk> yeah.
21:09:08 <markmcclain> # topic bugs
21:09:22 <danwent> extra space
21:09:42 <markmcclain> danwent: Add extra to agenda?
21:09:55 <danwent> #topic bugs
21:10:12 <markmcclain> ah
21:10:51 <markmcclain> #topic bugs
21:11:04 <markmcclain> thanks for the correction :)
21:11:32 <markmcclain> garyk reported this bug https://bugs.launchpad.net/quantum/+bug/1174293
21:11:34 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1174293 in quantum "Network creation does not notify DHCP agent" [High,In progress]
21:11:55 <markmcclain> seems to be the only pressing bug at the moment
21:12:00 <markmcclain> are there any others?
21:12:13 <garyk> there is also one about ovs and flows with tunneling. looking for the id.
21:13:27 <markmcclain> this one https://bugs.launchpad.net/quantum/+bug/1167916?
21:13:29 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1167916 in quantum "ovs plugin generating the same endpoint number" [Undecided,Incomplete]
21:14:51 <markmcclain> or this one https://bugs.launchpad.net/quantum/+bug/1174315
21:14:53 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1174315 in quantum "Possible race condition in add_tunnel_endpoint() function" [Undecided,New]
21:14:59 <garyk> no. it was about flow entries being built incorrectly.
21:15:18 <salv-orlando> the KeyError one?
21:15:34 <enikanorov> is this one related? https://bugs.launchpad.net/quantum/+bug/1174315
21:15:41 <garyk> https://bugs.launchpad.net/quantum/+bug/1154383
21:15:43 <enikanorov> ops
21:15:43 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1154383 in quantum "Invalid entries in OVS flow table on a 3 node install using GRE Tunnels" [Undecided,Confirmed]
21:15:44 <enikanorov> sorry
21:16:07 <garyk> sorry it is late and i am slower than usual (which is exceptionally slow...)
21:17:19 <markmcclain> ok.. it was confirmed by someone other than the reporter can someone look into this one?
21:17:55 <garyk> i can try towards the end of the week.
21:18:09 <markmcclain> ok
21:18:58 <markmcclain> #topic API
21:19:02 <markmcclain> salv-orlando: hi
21:19:09 <salv-orlando> hi
21:19:32 <markmcclain> docs look to be improving
21:19:43 <salv-orlando> Let's start with docs
21:20:01 <salv-orlando> We have now 5 outstanding patches, and we need to merge them by tomorrow
21:20:17 <salv-orlando> most of them have at least 1 +2
21:20:42 <salv-orlando> but we need help for: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/27217/
21:20:58 <arosen> salv-orlando:  i can review that one.
21:21:00 <salv-orlando> it would be good if a core dev can step up and help me with ther reviews
21:21:03 <salv-orlando> thanks arosen
21:21:25 <salv-orlando> On the blueprint side, we have two blueprints targeting havana-1
21:21:36 <salv-orlando> salv-orlando is the author for both.
21:22:06 <salv-orlando> We have a question around how to do authZ on ext-gw-modes - and I will follow up on ML
21:22:21 <markmcclain> Iok
21:22:22 <markmcclain> ok
21:22:37 <salv-orlando> 2 patches for make-authz-orthoghonal have already been merged. A 3rd patch will come soon. In total there should be 4 patches
21:23:02 <salv-orlando> There are also some bugs which might be worth discussing, but probably it's better to move to the next topic.
21:23:26 <salv-orlando> Bug are linked in the agenda - and discussion can happen offline
21:24:13 <markmcclain> sounds good.. any questions on the API?
21:24:36 <salv-orlando> markmcclain: I forgot to mention on blueprints
21:24:45 <salv-orlando> are you going to retarget yours for H-1?
21:24:53 <salv-orlando> https://blueprints.launchpad.net/quantum/+spec/l3-router-port-relationship
21:25:03 <markmcclain> Yes… Still updating after our discussion on Friday
21:25:08 <salv-orlando> oh you already did
21:25:08 <salv-orlando> nvm
21:26:21 <markmcclain> #topic L3/IPAM/DHCP/VPNaaS
21:26:27 <markmcclain> nachi_: around?
21:26:48 <garyk> markmcclain: i think he is on vacation
21:27:01 <sthakkar> I can give a quick update on vpn if nachi's out today
21:27:04 <Swaminathan> I can talk for VPNaaS
21:27:11 <markmcclain> sthakkar: go ahead
21:27:19 <sthakkar> sounds good
21:27:30 <sthakkar> so we have decided to prioritize ipsec as the vpn type addressed
21:27:36 <Swaminathan> We have posted the Blueprint for the IPsec VPNaaS
21:27:47 <sthakkar> there is a follow up meeting on wednesday to discuss further details
21:27:51 <sthakkar> at 5pm PST
21:27:56 <sthakkar> all interested parties are welcome
21:28:02 <sthakkar> the goal is nail down the api def
21:28:05 <sthakkar> and then slot work items
21:28:19 <sthakkar> nachi, swami and i are coordinating on this front
21:28:33 <enikanorov> will VPN be implemented as process-on-host as is LBaaS currently?
21:28:38 <sthakkar> by next monday we'll have more details on the full definition
21:28:55 <Swaminathan> Yes that is the current plan to implement vpn as similar to LBaaS
21:29:39 <sthakkar> ill take the action of sending an update after the wednesday meeting on the progress
21:29:49 <sthakkar> thats all for now :)
21:30:06 <markmcclain> great thanks for the update on VPN
21:31:20 <markmcclain> On the IPv6 front, we're working on revising to existing blueprints to bring them within the scope of Havana.. there will me more later in the week
21:31:45 <markmcclain> #topic Nova Integration
21:32:26 <garyk> not much has been done here. i am in the process of trying to test live migrations from nova to quantum (ran into a few issues along the way)
21:32:36 <garyk> i have stared https://docs.google.com/document/d/1K2UuY0NBnOdz1w8FRtW0GTVe6WVA4GuZI80eul59r6I/edit?usp=sharing if antyone wants to add
21:33:34 <markmcclain> The doc looks like a good start
21:33:55 <markmcclain> #topic Security/Firewalling
21:34:00 <markmcclain> arosen:  hi
21:34:17 <arosen> markmcclain: hey
21:34:28 <arosen> so there was one bug reported about the security group stuff. I'm working on a fix for it
21:34:33 <arosen> that's about it on my front
21:34:46 <SumitNaiksatam> I have posted the plan for firewall:
21:34:47 <SumitNaiksatam> https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Quantum/FWaaS/HavanaPlan
21:35:16 <SumitNaiksatam> we have the work items outlined, time to get it to work :-)
21:35:40 <SumitNaiksatam> Rajesh (Dell) also signed up for work, thanks to him!
21:35:58 <SumitNaiksatam> Marco (Embrane) had some good suggestions on two items:
21:36:28 <SumitNaiksatam> 1. from an operational perspective it would be good to have the ability to enable/disable rules in a policy
21:36:44 <SumitNaiksatam> 2. it will be good to have a view of hits for a rule
21:36:55 <SumitNaiksatam> thinking about how to incorporate those
21:37:10 <SumitNaiksatam> otherwise, things look promising
21:37:18 <SumitNaiksatam> thats my update
21:38:06 <markmcclain> yeah those seem like good suggestions.. just want to make sure we don't try to do too much at once
21:38:12 <SumitNaiksatam> yeah
21:38:14 <SumitNaiksatam> agree
21:39:19 <markmcclain> Any questions on Security Groups/Firewalling?
21:39:49 <markmcclain> #topic LBaaS
21:40:00 <enikanorov> i can update
21:40:11 <markmcclain> please do
21:40:27 <enikanorov> we've identified primary tasks we need to do. need to agree on design
21:41:05 <enikanorov> one of the action item would be to think on how to incorporate service types into lbaas api
21:41:29 <enikanorov> I hope salv-orlando will participate in corresponding discussion
21:41:47 <salv-orlando> sure np
21:41:54 <SumitNaiksatam> enikanorov: I think that applies to services in general
21:42:13 <SumitNaiksatam> have some ideas around this
21:42:14 <enikanorov> yes. but i guess lbaas will be there first :)
21:42:44 <emagana> enikanorov: what do you mean by services types?
21:42:45 <SumitNaiksatam> true, but we should do it in a way that all services can use the same framework
21:42:56 <enikanorov> also, i think lbaas needs it's own meeting to discuss design
21:43:07 <enikanorov> emagana: service types framework added by salv-orlando
21:43:50 <enikanorov> in fact there are several important questions around it that need to be resolved.
21:43:57 <markmcclain> we should discuss service types on the mailing list as I think there a few folks that will want to weigh in
21:44:03 <emagana> enikanorov: ok, thanks!
21:44:13 <SumitNaiksatam> enikanorov, markmcclain: agree
21:44:21 <enikanorov> markmcclain: ok. i think i'll start the discussion then
21:44:28 <markmcclain> enikanorov: sounds good
21:44:58 <markmcclain> Any other LBaaS questions?
21:45:12 <danwent> https://bugs.launchpad.net/openstack-manuals/+bug/1157034
21:45:14 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1157034 in openstack-manuals "quantum lbaas install - Ubuntu" [High,Confirmed]
21:45:25 <danwent> we have two 'high' bugs for lbaas docs in grizzly
21:45:50 <danwent> the one above is assigned to ilya
21:45:55 <danwent> but hasn't seen action in a month
21:46:05 <danwent> arisen volunteered today to take on the other one
21:46:05 <enikanorov> Ilya is on vacation until 6th of may
21:46:17 <danwent> https://bugs.launchpad.net/openstack-manuals/+bug/1156828
21:46:19 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1156828 in openstack-manuals "q-admin: basic lbaas workflow" [High,In progress]
21:46:31 <danwent> arosen: can you write up the install stuff as well?
21:46:40 <danwent> should be pretty basic
21:46:42 <arosen> working on the walk through stuff for lbaas doc for that now: https://bugs.launchpad.net/openstack-manuals/+bug/1156828
21:46:44 <arosen> yup
21:46:47 <danwent> thx
21:46:54 <markmcclain> arosen: thx
21:47:24 <markmcclain> #topic Stable Branch
21:47:31 <salv-orlando> enikanorov: good to know about ilya. I will shepherd the lbaas API doc patch then
21:48:48 <markmcclain> Looks like there is only one review pending, so we'll jump to testing
21:48:52 <markmcclain> #topic Testing
21:48:57 <markmcclain> marun: hi
21:49:04 <marun> hi
21:49:26 <marun> Not much to report
21:49:43 <markmcclain> ok
21:49:52 <marun> For everyone else's benefit, I had a conversation with Mark last week whose outcome was limiting the scope of the refactor to the tests.
21:50:28 <marun> I had thought it would be necessary to refactor the code itself to make my intended approach viable, but I agree with Mark's assessment that such an effort is unviable in the short term.
21:51:08 <marun> Nachi and Miguel will have to speak to the progress of their respective testing efforts.
21:51:28 <marun> That's it for me.
21:52:10 <markmcclain> thanks for the update.. I don't see nachi on miguel around
21:52:25 <markmcclain> #topic Other Items
21:52:33 <markmcclain> rkukura: Update on ML2?
21:53:18 <rkukura> Getting some comments on WIP patch - will update tomorrow, then add linuxbridge agent support later this week
21:53:26 <danwent> #info openstack-manuals is having their grizzly release tomorrow
21:53:35 <rkukura> will also update blueprint with plan
21:53:51 <markmcclain> rkukura: great
21:53:57 <danwent> #info any docs you submit after that will need to be back ported for grizzly, so let them know that as part of the bug.
21:54:03 <markmcclain> danwent: hadn't forgotten about you :)
21:54:05 <rkukura> Could use feedback on driver API approach
21:54:21 <danwent> markmcclain: ah, k
21:55:02 <markmcclain> I know there was lots of interest in ML2
21:55:06 <markmcclain> so take a look here: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/20105/
21:55:09 <markmcclain> if you haven't
21:55:31 <markmcclain> danwent: Docs are cut tomorrow
21:55:44 <markmcclain> I'll take a look the backlog that salv-orlando mentioned
21:55:52 <markmcclain> any items we missed with the other reports?
21:56:09 <danwent> markmcclain: yes, db migration + metadata install for admin guide
21:56:21 <danwent> https://bugs.launchpad.net/openstack-manuals/+bugs?field.tag=quantum
21:57:02 <danwent> I'll ask the docs team to deal with appendix B (perhaps for now we just put a caveat that it is not updated for Grizzly?): https://bugs.launchpad.net/openstack-manuals/+bug/1157031
21:57:04 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1157031 in openstack-manuals "q-admin: update or remove appendix B" [High,Confirmed]
21:58:11 <markmcclain> I think that makes sense
21:58:27 <danwent> someone on the docs team says they plan to auto-generate
21:58:33 <danwent> but unlikely to happen by tomorrow
21:58:51 <markmcclain> Yeah
22:00:00 <markmcclain> Any other open discussion items?
22:00:12 <garyk> i am going to crash. good night guys
22:00:19 <markmcclain> oops doc items?
22:00:20 <danwent> garyk: later
22:00:41 <danwent> markmcclain: btw, I was thinking admin docs should have a section that talks about the folsom -> grizzly upgrade overall
22:01:08 <danwent> that is, not just about the db migration, but also about what config options were deprecated, which new ones are required, and which new agents where added.
22:01:40 <markmcclain> I think that would be a good section to have
22:01:49 <danwent> ok, i will file a bug for it.
22:02:24 <markmcclain> great… seems like the kind of item for each release
22:02:49 <danwent> yeah, in fact, it looks like there may be a general bug for all projects already… looking into it.  we can take it offline
22:03:13 <markmcclain> Sounds good… any other open discussion items?
22:04:25 <markmcclain> For the folks with spare cycles, don't forget to take a look at the pending doc reviews.
22:04:30 <markmcclain> #endmeeting