21:03:18 <markmcclain> #startmeeting Networking
21:03:19 <openstack> Meeting started Mon Sep  9 21:03:18 2013 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is markmcclain. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
21:03:21 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
21:03:23 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'networking'
21:03:40 <markmcclain> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Network/Meeting
21:03:58 <markmcclain> oops
21:04:00 <markmcclain> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Network/Meetings
21:04:07 <markmcclain> #topic Announcements
21:04:16 <markmcclain> H3 was released last Friday
21:04:20 <emagana_> hi all!
21:04:33 <marun> hi
21:04:34 <amotoki> hi
21:04:34 <markmcclain> #link http://tarballs.openstack.org/neutron/neutron-2013.2.b3.tar.gz
21:04:40 <emagana_> sorry.. I'm late..
21:05:32 <markmcclain> Everyone put in a tremendous effort and this was our biggest milestone yet: 52 blueprints completed and 171 bugs fixes
21:06:34 <ivar-lazzaro> hi!
21:06:35 <markmcclain> We're now in the feature freeze which means our focus should be on fixing bugs and polishing up the release
21:07:29 <markmcclain> Any new features that have not been granted feature freeze exemptions will be given temporary −2s until Icehouse opens in a few weeks.
21:08:23 <markmcclain> #topic bugs
21:08:25 <emagana_> markmcclain: dummy question, how can we quickly check if a feature has been granted, in launchpad?
21:08:40 <markmcclain> #undo
21:08:41 <openstack> Removing item from minutes: <ircmeeting.items.Topic object at 0x3271890>
21:08:43 <markmcclain> #link https://launchpad.net/neutron/+milestone/havana-3
21:09:22 <markmcclain> emagana_: These the blueprints granted exemptions.
21:10:08 <mestery> markmcclain: That is the list of implemented blueprints, right?
21:10:25 <amotoki> #link https://launchpad.net/neutron/+milestone/havana-rc1
21:10:26 <amotoki> is the correct one
21:10:30 <markmcclain> mestery: you're right
21:10:36 <markmcclain> I have a bad link in the agenda :)
21:10:42 <mestery> amotoki: Thanks, that one looks right. :)
21:11:19 <amotoki> wiki page seems to have a wrong link. rc1 is linked to havana-3 :-(
21:11:26 <emagana_> Thanks!
21:11:38 * markmcclain needs to learn to copy/paste better
21:12:25 <markmcclain> We've got 8 still open and our goal is to get them to merge as sooner rather than later so that we can focus ensuring the release candidate is ready on time
21:12:55 <markmcclain> #topic bugs
21:13:06 <markmcclain> https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bugs?search=Search&field.importance=Critical&field.status=New&field.status=Confirmed&field.status=Triaged&field.status=In+Progress
21:14:06 <markmcclain> We've got a few critical bugs that we need to fix in order to keep the gate moving
21:15:00 <markmcclain> https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1211915
21:15:01 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1211915 in neutron "Connection to neutron failed: Maximum attempts reached" [Critical,Confirmed]
21:15:04 <markmcclain> https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1223000
21:15:06 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1223000 in neutron "ML2 port-binding fails if FQDN not used" [Critical,Confirmed]
21:15:20 <markmcclain> Are there any other bugs the team needs to be aware of?
21:15:38 <wolfdreamer> ok, I have bug I would like reviewed -- How do I go about getting it looked at bug 1211513
21:15:40 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1211513 in neutron "neutron.api.extensions should resolve full module path when importing extensions so that proper base class comparison is done" [Undecided,In progress] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1211513
21:16:40 <wolfdreamer> from a (extension) development standpoint, I think its important this get fixed
21:17:15 <marun> who's working on 1211915?
21:17:35 <wolfdreamer> I'll take a look at it, if nobody else is
21:17:45 <salv-orlando> marun: I was under the impression nati-ueno was on it; but he's not here today.
21:17:48 <markmcclain> marun: nachi was looking at it
21:17:57 <marun> ok.  i'll follow up with him when he returns
21:18:02 <markmcclain> ok
21:18:32 <salv-orlando> wolfdreamer: I think there's already a patch under review for that.
21:19:01 <wolfdreamer> 1211513, yes I submitted several weeks ago. But I haven't had much luck in having anybody take a look
21:19:31 <markmcclain> wolfdreamer: I'll remove the −2 on the proposal… I think most of the reviewers were focused on getting the proposals for H3 merged
21:19:52 <wolfdreamer> ok, sounds fine
21:19:53 <salv-orlando> ok, I will have a look at it later (which is tomorrow morning GMT)
21:19:57 <wolfdreamer> thanks
21:20:24 <markmcclain> this change is also interesting because it changes the behavior of the import that we've been using Folsom.  So the review will have to consider the disruption risk of changing this comparison so late in the cycle
21:20:53 <wolfdreamer> yes, which is one reason I would like to get feedback
21:21:04 <markmcclain> Any other bugs the team needs to discuss?
21:21:13 <wolfdreamer> I do have this one as well, bug 1219795
21:21:14 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1219795 in neutron "Inconsistent DHCP port creation" [Undecided,In progress] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1219795
21:21:29 <wolfdreamer> not sure about priority
21:22:37 <markmcclain> It's currently medium
21:22:55 <wolfdreamer> ok, thanks
21:23:40 <markmcclain> Any other bugs?
21:24:00 <markmcclain> #topic Docs
21:24:13 <emagana_> VPN aPI still in review
21:24:34 <annegentle_> bug list at https://bugs.launchpad.net/openstack-manuals/+bugs/?field.tag=neutron
21:24:50 <pcm_> just did update based on Nachi's feedback.
21:24:57 <salv-orlando> I am going to monitor progress on API docs for havana as I did for grizzly. Hopefully I'll do a better job this time.
21:25:14 <markmcclain> annegentle_: thanks for the link
21:25:16 <emagana_> pcm_: I also review it, it looks good
21:25:17 <salv-orlando> At this stage, I think, we are still lacking a patch for FWaaS API.
21:25:27 <pcm_> emagana_: yes. thanks!
21:25:37 <SumitNaiksatam> salv-orlando:  posted a patch today, but need to add a lot more to that
21:25:40 <emagana_> salv-orlando: Nachi told me that he will work on that
21:25:59 <salv-orlando> I guess SumitNaiksatam can coordinate with him
21:26:06 <emagana_> salv-orlando: sorry, mixing FW with VPN
21:26:17 <markmcclain> mestery or rkukura: do we have a contact for ml2 docs?
21:26:19 <salv-orlando> enikanorov: do you think we should extend/update docs for service providers?
21:26:30 <enikanorov> salv-orlando: yes
21:26:40 <markmcclain> arosen: will you be able contribute docs for: https://bugs.launchpad.net/openstack-manuals/+bug/1215166
21:26:41 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1215166 in openstack-manuals "Implement Allowed Address Pairs" [Medium,Confirmed]
21:26:43 <rkukura> markmcclain: I think I'm assigned, and plan to work with mestery this week
21:26:46 <arosen> sure
21:26:56 <markmcclain> arosen: thanks!
21:26:59 <salv-orlando> enikanorov: do you or somebody from your team have cycles for that? We'll need assistance for API and admin docs
21:27:03 <mestery> markmcclain rkukura: I'm ready to work together with rkukura on this, we've been in contact.
21:27:20 <enikanorov> salv-orlando: yeah. I'll take care of that
21:27:34 <SumitNaiksatam> on fwaas, both admin and API patches are posted, but are WIP, and I am working towards completing them
21:27:39 <salv-orlando> arosen: you might want to file openstack-api-site bugs for multi-provider and allowed-adress-pairs
21:27:50 <arosen> salv-orlando: k, i'll do that.
21:28:27 <markmcclain> rkukura, mestery: great!
21:29:17 <markmcclain> Metering is another feature that needs docs.  I'll reach out to code proposer and see if he can help with docs
21:30:03 <markmcclain> I'll add a entry for API docs next week since I forgot to add it this week.
21:30:06 <markmcclain> Any other doc items?
21:30:22 <salv-orlando> ETOOMANYFEATURES
21:30:53 <annegentle_> markmcclain: there is a new docs patch for metering at https://review.openstack.org/#/c/45592/2/api-ref/src/wadls/metering-api/src/v2/os-metering-api-2.0.wadl
21:31:26 <annegentle_> markmcclain: but I don't know if that's what you're needing exactly
21:31:51 <markmcclain> annegentle_: I was thinking about this one: https://bugs.launchpad.net/openstack-manuals/+bug/1202967
21:31:52 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1202967 in openstack-manuals "Add Neutron l3 metering agent" [Medium,Confirmed]
21:33:08 <markmcclain> #topic Client
21:33:30 <markmcclain> #info python-neutronclient 2.3.0 was released last week
21:33:36 <markmcclain> #link https://pypi.python.org/pypi/python-neutronclient/2.3.0
21:34:25 <markmcclain> There will most likely be a 2.3.1 release before Havana is officially released
21:34:55 <markmcclain> we have a few reviews to merge to support the new features that landed late in H3
21:35:07 <markmcclain> #topic Horizon
21:35:22 <amotoki> hi
21:35:28 <markmcclain> Two features in Horizon we're granted FFEs.
21:35:46 <amotoki> vpnaas support has been merged :-)
21:35:54 <markmcclain> That's great!
21:36:23 <amotoki> now small improvements fo vpnaas from my are under reivew
21:36:30 <nati_uen_> Hi sorry late
21:36:30 <amotoki> fwaas support is close to merge. it is a good news too.
21:36:37 <markmcclain> awesome
21:36:40 <SumitNaiksatam> thanks amotoki
21:36:50 <SumitNaiksatam> we had several iterations over the weekend
21:37:48 <markmcclain> I want to thank the Horizon team for agreeing to the FFEs and for our teams working hard to make sure features work well in horizon.
21:38:21 <SumitNaiksatam> (KC's just had a baby girl and he was still working on this in the hospital!)
21:38:43 <markmcclain> wow.. that's dedication
21:38:44 <amotoki> wow! congrats!
21:38:53 <amotoki> I will continue to work on them for better shape.
21:39:10 <markmcclain> amotoki: we just need to make sure we keep testing it right?
21:39:20 <nati_uen_> congrats! KC
21:39:29 <SumitNaiksatam> thanks, i will convey it him
21:39:45 <amotoki> i hope every one use horizon for testing -:)
21:39:46 <SumitNaiksatam> he will be very happy if this merges :-) can get some sleep
21:39:47 <mestery> Yes, congrats and thanks to KC here!
21:40:04 <amotoki> i posted vpnaas horizon support for devstack https://review.openstack.org/#/c/45751/
21:40:25 <markmcclain> garyk: will you have to time to look at it?
21:41:22 <mestery> markmcclain amotoki: I will review that patch.
21:41:23 <markmcclain> Any other Horizon items to discuss?
21:41:26 <SumitNaiksatam> the merged fwaas devstack patch already had horizon support, so unless we change something in the current horizon patch, we should be good on devstack for fwaas
21:41:55 <amotoki> i already uses both fwaas and vpnaas at the same time.
21:42:03 <markmcclain> SumitNaiksatam: awesome
21:42:05 <markmcclain> amotoki: cool
21:42:25 <mestery> Horizon is very cool in Havana! I think people will be very excited to see the changes there.
21:42:42 <amotoki> i believe.
21:43:10 <markmcclain> yeah it does have lots of cool changes from Grizzly
21:43:17 <markmcclain> #topic Open Discussion
21:43:41 <mestery> markmcclain: When is the deadline to submit design summit proposals?
21:44:31 <marun> Reviews welcome for my effort to minimize ovs l2 agent polling: https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+project:openstack/neutron+branch:master+topic:bug/1177973,n,z
21:45:15 <markmcclain> mestery: that's a good question.. I haven't seen a hard deadline, but it is usually 1-2 weeks prior to summit
21:45:17 <rkukura> marun: Curious why we need an option for this, disabled by default?
21:45:23 <mestery> markmcclain: thanks!
21:45:38 <mestery> marun: Agree with rkukura, why not make this the default?
21:45:54 <marun> rkukura: I talked with Mark about this and his suggestion was to make it optional to make it more palatable for reviewers.
21:46:15 <markmcclain> Yeah.. if this is earlier in the cycle default on makes sense
21:46:29 <marun> There's nothing stopping the default from becoming true either as part of the review or subsequently.
21:46:51 <marun> (or via devstack, since it should speed up gate runs)
21:46:51 <mestery> OK, that makes sense marun and markmcclain.
21:46:53 <rkukura> marun: It didn't look very risky, and I'm concerned that we don't have gating on both code paths
21:46:57 <markmcclain> but since this is later we've got two choices to either defer until Icehouse or consider shipping a preview or experimental support in Havana
21:47:24 <markmcclain> rkukura: that is a good point
21:47:35 <rkukura> marun, markmcclain: optional is OK if that's what's needed
21:47:39 <emagana_> I need to leave early today! Thank you all
21:47:46 <markmcclain> emagana_: see ya
21:48:07 <amotoki> question on client.
21:48:08 <amotoki> do we create a new milestone for 2.3.x version of client?  Several number of bugs have the status "Fix Commited". We need to clean up the bugs.
21:48:35 <mestery> amotoki: Good point, I have one bug I wanted to target to that version but didn't see it in Launchpad.
21:48:54 <markmcclain> amotoki: spent way too much time getting items through the gate last week...it's on my list to clean-up
21:49:43 <amotoki> yeah, i appreciate your effort on gating conflict very much.
21:50:36 <markmcclain> yeah.. I'm hoping we can come up with a solution before Icehouse development heats up to handle migration merge conflicts
21:50:53 <mestery> markmcclain: +1000
21:51:16 <markmcclain> Any other Open items?
21:52:29 <garyk> there is a review in nova for service vms
21:52:42 <mestery> garyk: Link?
21:52:53 <garyk> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/45691/ (sorry it is late and I am dreaming)
21:53:25 <mestery> garyk: I hope the dreams are all of unicorns and rainbows. :)
21:53:45 <garyk> :)
21:55:06 <markmcclain> garyk: thanks sharing
21:55:34 <markmcclain> this definitely a fix needs for folks to run service vms
21:57:35 <markmcclain> seems like an additional change would be needed too.. I'll have compare with some internal stuff in our labs
21:59:06 <garyk> markmcclain: ok, on nova or neutron?
21:59:09 <markmcclain> Everyone thanks for stopping in this week.  Let's focus on testing and docs so that we'll be release ready when the release candidate is cutSeptember 26th
21:59:19 <markmcclain> garyk: I believe Nova
21:59:27 <garyk> markmcclain: ok, thanks
21:59:35 <markmcclain> #endmeeting