14:02:18 <mestery> #startmeeting networking 14:02:19 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Dec 16 14:02:18 2014 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is mestery. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 14:02:20 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 14:02:22 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'networking' 14:02:29 <mestery> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Network/Meetings Agenda 14:02:31 <mestery> #topic Announcements 14:02:45 <mestery> The Neutron mid-cycle was last week in Lehi, Utah. 14:03:00 <salv-orlando> aloha 14:03:01 <mestery> Thanks to all who attended, I think it was very succesful and we accomplished a lot! 14:03:01 <mestery> #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2014-December/052715.html Mid-cycle report 14:03:47 <mestery> Neutron SAD was yesterday 14:03:52 <mestery> #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2014-November/050958.html 14:04:10 <mestery> The neutron-drivers team is still pouring through some remaining specs, we had so many it's taking longer than expected 14:04:24 <mestery> I expect we'll be done with this process by the end of the week at the latest 14:05:01 <mestery> In the meantime, I'm yak shaving LP and putting approved specs into either Kilo-2 or Kilo-3, if I've placed yours wrong, please let me know. 14:05:31 <mestery> Also, we've already granted a few specs an extension until Friday, so if you've gotten one, please iterate quickly on it this week 14:05:33 <mestery> Any questions on SAD or specs in general? 14:06:42 <mestery> One more announcement: Kilo-1 is this week 14:06:55 <mestery> I have a 1:1 with ttx after this meeting, we'll likely cut Kilo-1 Wednesday 14:07:10 <mestery> Since we accomplished the services split, it will be great to have people test the tarballs and ensure things are smooth there 14:07:15 <mestery> Any other announcements for the team? 14:08:04 <mestery> #topic Bugs 14:08:18 <mestery> enikanorov enikanorov__: Hi, are you around? 14:09:24 <mestery> OK, in lieu of enikanorov__ enikanorov not being here, does anyone have a bug they'd like to bring up with the broader team? 14:09:40 <ihrachyshka> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/python-neutronclient/+bug/1401555 ? that's a regression in client 14:09:42 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1401555 in python-neutronclient "subnet: --enable-dhcp=False/True syntax is not accepted since 2.3.5" [High,In progress] 14:10:01 <mestery> ihrachyshka: Is this the one we discussed last week? 14:10:04 <ihrachyshka> yes 14:10:25 <mestery> ihrachyshka: I'll review this one ASAP once hte meeting concludes, I looked at the review last week already, thanks! 14:11:12 <mestery> ihrachyshka: As we discussed, once this one merges, I'll roll a new version of the client and push to pypi. 14:11:17 <ihrachyshka> thanks 14:11:42 <obondarev> mestery: I know enikanorov wanted to bring up https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1382064 again 14:11:44 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1382064 in neutron "Failure to allocate tunnel id when creating networks concurrently" [High,In progress] 14:12:00 <obondarev> it showed up in https://review.openstack.org/#/c/140493/ 14:12:48 <obondarev> last time IIRC the desision was to try make READ_COMMITED globally 14:13:16 <mestery> obondarev: I recall that discussion 14:13:37 <obondarev> trying to find that patch... 14:13:49 <marun> Didn't enikanorov find that the global fix didn't work? 14:13:57 <marun> And was working on a localized fix? 14:14:19 <marun> He didn't give any details as to why the global fix was a non-starter though. 14:14:54 <obondarev> AFAIK there were lots of lock wait timeout failures 14:15:26 <obondarev> so READ_COMMITED globally seems tot to be the right way to goy 14:15:31 <obondarev> go* 14:15:41 <ihrachyshka> obondarev: was it the same with mysql-connector? 14:16:06 <obondarev> ihrachyshka: don't know about that 14:16:15 <obondarev> so the current fix is https://review.openstack.org/#/c/129288/8 14:16:55 <obondarev> which seems working , at least here https://review.openstack.org/#/c/140493/ there are no such failures 14:18:05 <mestery> marun: Looks like you've been actively reviewing these, can you work with enikanorov on a path forward here? Do you have time for that? 14:18:23 <obondarev> I think the discussion may be continued on gerrit though 14:18:33 <marun> Can do 14:18:41 <mestery> marun: Thanks! 14:19:01 <mestery> OK, any other bugs for the team to discuss this week? 14:19:25 <lintan_> I have one https://launchpad.net/bugs/1384577 14:20:14 <lintan_> It's about to Enable adding new tag with options 14:20:42 <mestery> lintan_: Looking 14:20:55 <lintan_> here is detail https://review.openstack.org/#/c/130498/ 14:21:22 <mestery> lintan_: Thank you for adding the unit tests to this one, I'll look at this in detial post meeting as well. 14:22:08 <lintan_> OK thanks 14:22:18 <matrohon> I still have this bug : https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1361540 14:22:30 <matrohon> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1361540 14:23:34 <mestery> matrohon: Looks like this one is in review now, you have some comments from arosen in there too 14:24:19 <sweston> I also have one I'd like to get some input on, I have written the unit tests for it, https://review.openstack.org/#/c/109848/ 14:24:19 <matrohon> mestery : yes, I'm not sure to understand his proposal... 14:24:40 <matrohon> I was haoping to find arosen here :) 14:24:44 <mestery> matrohon: I don't see arosen here, so lets sort it out either on the ML or in gerrit :) 14:24:49 <mestery> sweston: Looking 14:24:51 <sweston> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/109848/ 14:26:10 <marun> sweston: I'll provide some feedback post-meeting about the testing on that patch 14:26:21 <mestery> marun sweston: Thanks! 14:26:51 <sweston> marun mestery: excellent, thank you! this is my first unit test, so be gentle 14:27:02 <mestery> lol 14:27:06 <marun> sweston: :) 14:27:17 <mestery> OK, lets move on now. 14:27:22 <mestery> #topic Docs 14:27:38 <mestery> I'm not sure if emagana is here, but he has updated the wiki for this section 14:27:44 <mestery> so I'll link some things here for the record 14:28:01 <mestery> #link https://github.com/ionosphere80/openstack-networking-guide/blob/master/scenario-dvr/scenario-dvr.md New networking diagram for DVR 14:28:07 <mestery> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/NetworkingGuide/TOC Networking Guide TOC 14:28:22 <mestery> #link https://github.com/openstack/openstack-manuals/tree/master/doc/networking-guide Docs gerrit for the networking guide 14:28:43 <mestery> #topic On Demand Agenda 14:28:54 <mestery> I'll encourage folks to read the pluggable devstack spec 14:28:55 <mestery> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/137054/ 14:29:05 <mestery> This is close to landing, and will affect neutron drivers in devstack 14:29:25 <mestery> #topic Services Split Update 14:29:31 <mestery> dougwig: Around? 14:29:36 <dougwig> sort of. :) 14:29:45 <mestery> #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2014-December/052713.html 14:29:54 <dougwig> this is the final split update. it should all be working now, and devstack should be happy. 14:29:55 <mestery> dougwig: Want to fill folks in, or I can if the red bull hasn't kicked in ;) 14:30:18 <dougwig> broken 3rd party CI's, excepting vmware, should be updated as necessary. devstack-gate CI's should've picked up changes automatically. 14:30:21 <mestery> *sigh* 14:30:21 <ihrachyshka> dougwig: how about upgrade for Juno users? ;) 14:30:39 <dougwig> if you've got service reviews, please re-submit against the new repos. 14:30:47 <dougwig> Moving extensions, config files/items, and separating tempest tests remain and will be part of Kilo 14:30:55 <dougwig> please file bugs for any issues that you see at this point. 14:31:04 <marun> What about specs? 14:31:19 <dougwig> oh, a net split. 14:31:31 <mestery> yeah, net split. meh 14:31:55 <amotoki> dougwig: do we still use neutron launchpad for lbaas bugs? just a confirmation. 14:32:02 <mestery> amotoki: Yes 14:32:14 <mestery> We have a single LP project and specs repo for all these new repos 14:32:16 <amotoki> thanks for the clarification 14:32:46 <mestery> Any other split questions? 14:33:00 <ihrachyshka> whether we are going to fix upgrade before kilo-1 14:33:18 <ihrachyshka> I have a bug assigned to me, but probably little capacity right now 14:33:31 <ihrachyshka> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1401895 14:33:40 <dougwig> ihrachyshka: current plan was that driver paths must be updated in neutron.conf, and kilo-1's neutron package will include all four repo's travels. 14:33:41 <ihrachyshka> so if anyone wants to handle that before kilo-1, cool :) 14:33:53 <dougwig> /travels/tarballs/ 14:34:20 <mestery> ihrachyshka: armax committed a fix for the grenade issue already? 14:34:25 <mestery> ihrachyshka: Are you talking about a cleaner fix? 14:34:28 <ihrachyshka> dougwig: I don't think it's anything but short-term fix. upgrade should work without messing with config files 14:34:38 <mestery> ihrachyshka: Got it 14:34:41 <ihrachyshka> yes, we need smooth upgrade 14:34:54 <mestery> ihrachyshka: It's unlikely that will get fixed before Kilo-1, which is Wednesday, unless someone else jumps on this. 14:35:04 <jlibosva> mestery: ihrachyshka: I volunteer 14:35:11 <jlibosva> I will try to send patches today 14:35:15 <ihrachyshka> jlibosva++ 14:35:20 <ihrachyshka> coooool 14:35:21 <mestery> jlibosva: Awesome! Include me, armax and dougwig on the reviews please 14:35:25 <mestery> thanks jlibosva! 14:35:26 <ihrachyshka> me too 14:35:26 <jlibosva> will do 14:35:33 <ihrachyshka> assigning bug to Jakub 14:35:41 <dougwig> thanks jlibosva 14:35:50 <mestery> Great! 14:36:12 <mestery> Anything else services split related? 14:36:28 <pc_m> mestery: grenade issue fix? Is that for the current oslo.db issue? 14:36:44 <pc_m> mestery: Seeing pretty much all grenade tests failing right now. 14:36:58 <ihrachyshka> pc_m: no, that's for service_provider entries requiring update after moving to split repos 14:37:11 <ihrachyshka> another split thing: 14:37:13 <ihrachyshka> #link http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2014-December/052972.html 14:37:15 <mestery> pc_m: Link to a bug for the issue you're looking at? Or did you just see this now? 14:37:20 <salv-orlando> dougwig, mestery: I hope you can forgive the vmware ci for being still broken. I only have two hands, two eyses, and one brain (well just more than half) 14:37:34 <ihrachyshka> I encourage people to check whether current plan to manage oslo-incubator stuff is ok 14:37:36 <mestery> salv-orlando: lol 14:37:46 <pc_m> mestery: just saw now that my (and many other commits are failing). Saw some chatter on infra this morning. 14:37:47 <dougwig> salv-orlando: no worries, i know that kobis is working on getting the vmware plugin working again as well 14:38:02 <jlibosva> mestery: pc_m it's an issue with sqlalchemy version required by oslo.db, leading to swift not starting 14:38:16 <mestery> jlibosva: Thanks! 14:38:27 <jlibosva> I think https://review.openstack.org/#/c/141927/1 is the patch that is supposed to fix it 14:38:39 <mestery> Since we've moved here at this point ... 14:38:42 <mestery> #topic Open Discussion 14:38:42 <pc_m> jlibosva: I hoipe so. Thanks! 14:38:44 <salv-orlando> kobis is doing part of that yes. 14:38:46 <mestery> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/141927/1 14:40:20 <mestery> OK, thanks again for everyone's efforts! 14:40:40 <mestery> I encourage folks to test the Kilo-1 tarballs once they land this week from a services perspective, it will be our first time post-split to release so testing is critical. 14:40:48 <mestery> We'll see you all on the ML and in-channel! 14:40:51 <mestery> #endmeeting