14:00:27 <mlavalle> #startmeeting networking 14:00:27 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Nov 20 14:00:27 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is mlavalle. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 14:00:28 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 14:00:30 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'networking' 14:00:39 <mlavalle> hi 14:00:40 <slaweq> hi 14:00:53 <amotoki> hi 14:01:05 <boden> howdy 14:01:18 <amotoki> I still seem to be in jet lag. This meeting time is fine today :) 14:01:50 <mlavalle> amotoki: LOL 14:01:51 <rubasov> o/ 14:02:10 <slaweq> :) 14:02:17 <mlavalle> ok, let's get going 14:02:54 <mlavalle> As usual the meeting's agenda is here: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Network/Meetings 14:03:37 <mlavalle> #Topic Announcements 14:03:59 <mlavalle> Our next milestone is Stein-2, January 7 - 11 14:05:33 <mlavalle> The other topic I wanted to share with the team is that last week the TC approved and merged vision for OpenStack Clouds: 14:05:45 <mlavalle> #link https://governance.openstack.org/tc/reference/technical-vision.html 14:06:06 <mlavalle> This is meant to be a vision developed by OpenStack developers for OpenStack developers 14:06:33 <mlavalle> it is expected to help guide, at a high level, how we develop OpenStack services 14:06:47 <mlavalle> I encourgage the team to read and internalize it 14:07:16 <mlavalle> and of course, if you have more ideas to add to it, please feel free to propose a follow up patch 14:07:19 <njohnston> o/ 14:07:45 <mlavalle> any other announcements? 14:08:49 <mlavalle> ok, let's move on... 14:08:56 <mlavalle> #topic Blueprints 14:09:33 <mlavalle> These are the blueprints that we are targeting for Stein-2: https://launchpad.net/neutron/+milestone/stein-2 14:10:20 <mlavalle> Does anyone have an update / request on the blueprint you are working on? 14:11:38 <mlavalle> ok, I have a couple of updates / questions.... 14:12:04 <mlavalle> First, The StarlingX project has currently is based on the Pike release 14:12:27 <mlavalle> The goal by the end of Stein is to converge with master in all the projects 14:13:06 <mlavalle> In order to do that, there is a number of specs / patches that need to be merged, mostly in Neutron and Nova (minor things in Glance) 14:13:34 <mlavalle> In Neutron we are in very good shape beacause we have been working with them since the PTG in Denver 14:14:11 <mlavalle> I am going to create a blueprint to track the patches / specs that we need to merge in Stein 14:14:31 <amotoki> general question: where are they tracked? 14:14:50 <amotoki> ah... your last comment answered me 14:15:06 <mlavalle> and I am also going to send to the ML the PDF with the "gap analysis" that describes them 14:15:29 <mlavalle> amotoki: and also the PDF sheds light on them. Let's focues on the Neutron section 14:15:39 <amotoki> mlavalle: thanks 14:16:25 <mlavalle> The other point I question I want to ask is in regards to https://blueprints.launchpad.net/neutron/+spec/port-mirroring-sriov-vf 14:16:48 <mlavalle> does anyone know who is core in the Tap-as-a-service project? 14:17:11 <amotoki> I think takashi is a core of taas 14:17:18 <mlavalle> It is not under Neutron governance, so we need help there 14:17:29 <mlavalle> amotoki: perfect, I'll follow up with him 14:17:48 <rubasov> here's the core list: https://review.openstack.org/#/admin/groups/957,members 14:17:50 <amotoki> mlavalle: some other taas cores are from fujitsu. I can ask yushiro to check the status 14:18:09 <mlavalle> amotoki: that would be very helpful. Thanks 14:18:53 <mlavalle> thanks rubasov 14:19:06 <yamamoto> kaz and I are somehow responsive if you ping. other cores are inactive. 14:20:17 <mlavalle> yamamoto: thanks. there is a patch in tap as a service waiting for review for the port mirroring functionality 14:20:31 <mlavalle> if you have time, please take a look 14:20:42 <mlavalle> I know you have been giving feedback on the spec 14:20:46 <mlavalle> Thanks 14:20:58 <yamamoto> i'm aware of the patch. a large patch will take longer :-) 14:21:05 <mlavalle> thanks 14:21:15 <njohnston> Progress continues on bulk port update - battling an enginefacade error when testing with one of the changes but I think there are a couple of changes that are pretty close. 14:22:16 <mlavalle> thanks for the update njohnston :-) 14:22:24 <mlavalle> anything else on blueprints? 14:23:35 <mlavalle> ok, next topic is 14:23:42 <mlavalle> #topic Community goals 14:24:05 <mlavalle> amotoki: any updates on policy in code? 14:24:07 <amotoki> re: policy-incode, I am preparing a email to dev list (now -discuss ML) to drop user_name:neutron from neutron policy.json to simplify the further effort. 14:24:49 <amotoki> as far as I checked no project uses advsvc explicitly, so I concluded it woudl be fine to send a mail to ML along with a devstack patch 14:25:48 <mlavalle> any other help you might need form the team? 14:26:31 <mlavalle> I take that as a no :-) 14:26:36 <amotoki> perhaps I would like to ask testing and detail reviews. 14:26:42 <mlavalle> njohnston: any updates on Python 3? 14:26:44 <amotoki> At least I should pass the test. 14:27:49 <njohnston> So we're discussing Python 3 in the CI meeting, later today, but I put together an etherpad that summs up the current state of things (although I have not delved as far as I need to for the experimental jobs). So I expect that will help drive the work that needs to be done. 14:27:57 <njohnston> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/neutron_ci_python3 14:28:15 <mlavalle> njohnston: do you need volunteers? 14:29:03 <njohnston> I would never say no to a volunteer. :-) 14:29:08 <mlavalle> ok 14:30:02 <mlavalle> so team, if you are interested in helping with the py3 community goals, please look at the etherpad and join the CI meeting at 1600UTC today in this same channel 14:30:08 <yamamoto> i have a question about py3 14:30:28 <yamamoto> what importance should be for py3 related bugs these days? 14:30:36 <yamamoto> like this https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1804173 14:30:37 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1804173 in neutron "Metadata proxy server SSL handshake problem if Python >= 3" [Undecided,New] 14:31:16 <mlavalle> yamamoto: I think the same importance as any other bug 14:31:36 <mlavalle> it really depends on the impact in the project 14:32:04 <yamamoto> ok. makes sense 14:32:15 <yamamoto> btw i have no idea about the above bug so anyone familiar with the topic please help triage it :-) 14:32:33 <mlavalle> LOL. Thanks 14:32:59 * mlavalle notices yamamoto is already performing his bugs deputy duties :-) 14:33:23 <mlavalle> slaweq: any updates on pre-upgrade checks? 14:33:57 <slaweq> actually yes 14:34:08 <slaweq> I wanted to raise for review patch https://review.openstack.org/#/c/615196/ 14:34:38 <slaweq> it's patch which will allow to use checks by entrypoints so e.g. stadium projects will be able to load their checks to neutron cli tool 14:34:53 <slaweq> once this will be done, we will be done with base framework I think 14:35:08 <slaweq> and we will be ready to implement some real checks if that will be necessary 14:35:09 <mlavalle> and the goal for Stein, right? 14:35:27 <slaweq> actually goal is fine now as we have base cli tool merged already 14:35:54 <mlavalle> ahead of the curve.... Nice! 14:36:07 <mlavalle> Thanks for the update? 14:36:20 <slaweq> yw? ;) 14:36:32 <mlavalle> LOL 14:37:27 <mlavalle> ok, let's move on 14:37:43 <mlavalle> #topic Bugs 14:38:15 <mlavalle> Last week lujinluo was our bugs deputy 14:38:31 <mlavalle> She doesn't seem to be on-line 14:38:49 <mlavalle> and I didn't find any message to the ML from her. Did anyone see it? 14:39:00 <slaweq> nope 14:39:14 <mlavalle> ok 14:39:25 <mlavalle> any bugs that should be discussed here today? 14:39:31 <boden> hi 14:39:36 <boden> can I bring one up quick 14:39:41 <mlavalle> of course 14:40:01 <boden> https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1787420 14:40:02 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1787420 in neutron "Floating ip association to router interface should be restricted" [Low,In progress] - Assigned to Michal Kelner Mishali (mkelnermishal) 14:40:06 <boden> for which there's already a patch https://review.openstack.org/#/c/599572/ 14:40:19 <boden> looks like we are still waiting on a response from the drivers team on the patch? 14:41:12 <mlavalle> boden: mhhh. I'll take a look today 14:41:22 <boden> mlavalle thanks 14:41:31 <liuyulong> We met the but https://launchpad.net/bugs/1803919 locally last week. And I added a patch set here: https://review.openstack.org/#/c/618720/ 14:41:32 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1803919 in neutron "[L2] dataplane down during ovs-agent restart" [Undecided,In progress] - Assigned to LIU Yulong (dragon889) 14:41:39 <liuyulong> s/but/bug 14:43:06 <mlavalle> liuyulong: thanks, will take a look at it 14:43:42 <mlavalle> This week, our deputy is yamamoto, who, as you have noticed, is already hard at work. Thanks! 14:43:54 <mlavalle> let's move on 14:44:06 <mlavalle> #topic neutron-lib 14:44:13 <mlavalle> boden: you are up 14:44:17 <boden> hi 14:44:24 * mlavalle has an update for boden 14:44:31 <boden> go ahead mlavalle 14:45:12 <mlavalle> I had conversations with some people regarding networking-sfc. I targeted people I though have interest in the project, since their own projects depened on it 14:45:43 <mlavalle> This people are: the Tacker PTL. He indicated he is available to help to merge patches 14:46:20 <boden> mlavalle; ok we can see how it goes... I think SFC is behind already so I'll have to take some time to submit some patches to get them up to date 14:46:48 <mlavalle> in the OPNFV community, they also use networking-sfc. In fact, they have a sfc project that depends on it. Manuel Buil(mbuil) is the PTL and he has also accepted to help merging patches 14:47:08 <mlavalle> I talked to him in Berlin 14:47:43 <mlavalle> and finally, I also taked to tmorin, who also accepted to help. his project depends on it 14:47:51 <boden> thanks for taking the time to reach out to these folks 14:47:52 <mlavalle> that's my update 14:48:08 <boden> ok I just have a brief update for neutron-lib 14:48:12 <amotoki> mlavalle: which project does mbull work on as PTL in OPNFV? 14:48:35 <mlavalle> amotoki: the sfc project. I don't remeber the excat name 14:48:52 <amotoki> thanks, my colleague work on OPNFV actively and I will let him know this. 14:48:54 <mlavalle> and it is mbuil 14:49:06 <mlavalle> amotoki: ^^^^ 14:49:30 <amotoki> i made typo... :( 14:49:30 <mlavalle> He is based out of Spain, so closer to you in time zones 14:49:42 <mlavalle> boden: go ahead 14:49:50 <boden> I know we just released 1.20.0, but I'd like to plan another release in the near future; maybe next week after the holiday.. there's a few patches I need for some of the decouple-db work 14:50:12 <mlavalle> that is fine with me 14:50:15 <boden> still waiting for https://review.openstack.org/#/c/615941/ but after that lands I'd be ready to do a release 14:50:52 <boden> other than that, just business as usual.. moving pretty slow this release, but I won't whine too much about it :) 14:50:55 <boden> and that's it for me 14:51:00 <mlavalle> in fact I have some changes to the extension definition for qos rules alias, based on my experience with https://review.openstack.org/#/c/613820/ 14:51:14 <yamamoto> boden: thank you for your patience with subprojects 14:51:21 <mlavalle> so the new release is timely for me 14:51:40 <mlavalle> boden: yes, you do great job on that 14:52:07 <boden> thanks guys.. nothing else from me 14:52:12 <mlavalle> :-) 14:52:32 <mlavalle> I don't see hongbin on line, so we will skip os-ken 14:52:41 <mlavalle> #topic On demand agenda 14:52:53 <mlavalle> Anything else we should discuss today? 14:54:00 <mlavalle> ok, I give back 5 minutes to your busy days 14:54:04 <mlavalle> Have a great week 14:54:07 <boden> cheers 14:54:15 <mlavalle> and happy Thanksgiving for those in the USA 14:54:24 <mlavalle> #endmeeting