21:00:15 #startmeeting networking 21:00:15 Meeting started Mon Jan 21 21:00:15 2019 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is mlavalle. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 21:00:16 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 21:00:18 The meeting name has been set to 'networking' 21:00:29 hi 21:00:51 hi 21:01:32 hi 21:01:47 is this a holiday for you haleyb? 21:02:43 mlavalle: no, i am taking tomorrow off though 21:03:06 haleyb: have fun. Great game last night! 21:03:32 ok, let's get going 21:03:40 #topic Announcements 21:04:13 Next milestone is Stein-3, March 4 - 8 21:06:16 and the the deadline to submit proposals for talks during the Denver summit is January 24 at 7:59am UTC 21:06:30 that's two days away 21:06:53 any other announcements from the team? 21:07:41 ok, moving on 21:07:48 #topic Blueprints 21:08:04 These are the blueprints we are tracking for Sten-3 21:08:16 #link https://launchpad.net/neutron/+milestone/stein-3 21:09:08 I want toi mention that this past Friday there was a google hangout meeting about https://blueprints.launchpad.net/neutron/+spec/strict-minimum-bandwidth-support 21:09:34 it was a meeting woth Nova, Placement and Neutron team members 21:10:08 The plan is to finish the functionality in Nova and Neutron this cycle supporting the creation of instances 21:10:35 Moving instances will happen in Train. But from the point of view of Neutron the functionality will be finished this cycle 21:11:26 In regards to https://blueprints.launchpad.net/neutron/+spec/port-mirroring-sriov-vf 21:12:48 we are having trouble getting the implementaion reviewied in Tap as a Service 21:13:11 is manjeets around? 21:13:57 ok, I'll follow up with him directly 21:14:35 any other blueprints we should discuss today? 21:15:23 ok, let's move on.... 21:15:31 #topiuc Community goals 21:15:36 #topic Community goals 21:16:21 slaweq: since we have completed the pre-upgrades checks work for this cycle, is it ok if I remove it from the meeting topic? 21:16:44 mlavalle: IMO yes 21:16:55 ok, I'll do it after the meeting 21:16:59 ++ 21:17:14 are amotoki or njonhston around? 21:17:55 njohnston is probably off today 21:18:18 and it's too early for amotoki, although sometimes he is around 21:19:03 yeah, 6:19 am 21:19:06 mlavalle: one more thing about upgrade checks 21:19:11 sure 21:19:28 recently You added action to send email to ML to ask about ideas of real checks 21:19:35 did You send it? 21:19:37 :) 21:19:46 no I didn't 21:19:58 I'll do it as soon as we finish the meeting 21:20:02 thanks for the reminder 21:20:13 sure, I just wanted to remind :) 21:20:19 thanks :-) 21:20:43 that's what El Comandante does.... keep everybody on track 21:21:09 ok, let's move on 21:21:22 #topic Bugs 21:21:36 LOL 21:21:54 Last week, our deputy was njohnston 21:22:00 I don't see him around 21:22:22 and couldn't find message to the ML from him wioth a deputy report 21:22:29 did you see any? 21:22:41 nope 21:23:05 ok, let's talk about https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1812552 21:23:07 Launchpad bug 1812552 in neutron "tempest-slow tests fails often" [Critical,In progress] - Assigned to Slawek Kaplonski (slaweq) 21:23:28 yes 21:23:35 I'm bit puzzled with this one 21:23:49 I sepnt some time today looking at it, after slaweq pinged me during my morning 21:24:15 I left a note with my findings so far, right before this meeting 21:24:21 I noticed in grafana that it start just after my patch https://review.openstack.org/#/c/631584/ was merged 21:24:28 I am also puzzled about it 21:24:54 so I proposed revert https://review.openstack.org/#/c/631944/ and indeed on this revert tempest-slow job was fine 5 or 6 times alred 21:24:57 already 21:25:07 but also in logstash we can see clearly the problem starts with the patch 21:25:22 mlavalle: yes 21:25:29 before the patch , the failures were ony in Nova and Cinder 21:25:42 but from the other side, I saw also patches without https://review.openstack.org/#/c/631584/ where it failed in same way 21:25:45 and were: tempest.exceptions.BuildErrorException: Server 3da71d4f-e884-4487-a692-be6671fed440 failed to build and is in ERROR status 21:25:56 and I saw some patches with https://review.openstack.org/#/c/631584/ where is passed 21:26:30 and TBH I have no idea why this patch can cause such issue 21:26:41 but after the patch I can see a lot of Neutron failures and all of them are ssh failure 21:26:49 mlavalle: yep 21:26:55 the instance fails to get ip lease from DHCP 21:27:00 mlavalle: so my idea for now is to revert this patch 21:27:02 in allcases 21:27:14 the instance is not getting connected to the network 21:27:39 yes, and it's always after unshelve instance 21:28:11 this last detail is something I didn't notice 21:28:32 it might be the key to the reason 21:29:04 maybe it has to do with the way the vif is being plugged 21:29:13 after the unshelve 21:30:12 mlavalle: I though that so I deployed 2 nodes devstack and I'm running slow temopest tests on it 21:30:21 and it didn't fail for me :/ 21:30:49 slaweq: why don't you add a note to the bug indicating the fact that the failure happoens after the unshelve 21:31:09 I forgot to add it 21:31:11 sorry 21:31:12 and then ping sean-k-mooney tomorrow. He might have something to say 21:31:47 that is very good idea, I will add such info today to the bug and ask him tomorrow morning 21:32:15 ok 21:32:41 if he will not have idea about the reason of issue, I propose to revert this my change 21:32:55 ok 21:33:06 in fact, it might be that it will not be very necessary with patch https://review.openstack.org/#/c/631829/ merged to os-vif 21:33:09 in the meantime, I will try to dig deeper 21:33:14 mlavalle: thx 21:33:59 ok, any other bugs we should discuss today? 21:35:32 not from me 21:36:01 ok, our deputy for this week is lajoskatona. I know he is already working on it, because he asked me last week to be added to the neutron bugs team in Launchpad 21:36:33 and next week the deputy is swami. I'll send him an email 21:37:03 #topic os-ken 21:37:19 hongbin: any updates on this? 21:38:14 ok, I take that as a no 21:38:29 #topic neutron-lib 21:39:12 mhhh, boden is not around. Maybe MLK day is a holiday for him. haleyb and I used to get it at HP 21:39:36 and Presidents day in February... not anymore 21:39:43 nope 21:40:17 #topic On-demand agenda 21:40:26 anything else we should discuss today? 21:40:44 o/ 21:40:59 hey, nice to see you hongbin :-) 21:41:05 o/ 21:41:08 mlavalle: sorry, missed your ping 21:41:14 no problem 21:41:20 mlavalle: i think the os-ken effort is completed 21:41:26 we are just glad to see you 21:42:18 mlavalle: that is the only update from me about the os-ken topic ^^ 21:42:34 hongbin: do we have any docs indicating what to do if a bug is found? How to proceed? 21:43:02 mlavalle: not yet, i can create one if you want 21:43:23 hongbin: that would be appreciated. 21:44:00 let's wrap it up with a little red bow in the docs ;-) 21:44:28 mlavalle: also, it might help to recruit new cores for the os-ken repo 21:44:50 ok, i'll take that action item 21:45:19 good point 21:45:39 we can start with you and me 21:45:50 and ask for volunteers in the ML 21:45:55 sure 21:46:01 ok 21:46:05 cool 21:46:32 anything else we should discuss today? 21:47:17 ok, thanks for attending today 21:47:23 Have a great week! 21:47:29 #endmeeting