14:00:16 #startmeeting networking 14:00:17 Meeting started Tue Feb 26 14:00:16 2019 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is mlavalle. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 14:00:18 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 14:00:20 The meeting name has been set to 'networking' 14:00:32 hi 14:00:38 o/ 14:00:41 o/ 14:01:02 How are y'all? 14:01:22 o/ 14:01:24 hi 14:01:26 o/ 14:02:24 mlavalle: Splendid, and you? 14:02:34 Great 14:02:42 let's get going 14:03:22 #topic Announcements 14:03:46 We almost made it to the end of the Stein cycle 14:03:56 Our Stein-3 milestones is next week 14:05:04 Also, for those of you planning to attend the Summit in Denver, please remember that this week is the end of the "earlybird" registration period 14:05:24 That includes your contributos discount codes 14:05:41 don't let the price hike catch you by surprise 14:05:59 * mlavalle registered last week and made hotel / air reservations 14:06:07 precisely speaking, the deadline is February 27, 2019 at 11:59pm PST 14:06:33 so that's tomorrow 14:06:51 * slaweq registered to PTG only already 14:07:16 Finally, please remember that there is a TC election going on 14:07:31 follow the questions and be ready to cast your votes 14:08:13 any other annoucements? 14:08:21 o/ 14:08:43 although the next week is stein-3, we cut stein beta for neutron stadium. 14:08:54 https://review.openstack.org/#/c/636869/ 14:09:15 I originally thought we can discuss it here, but it has been merged a bit ago 14:09:52 we can align our deliverables in Stein together :) 14:09:56 LOL 14:10:38 so what follows amotoki in terms of deliverables? 14:11:03 the final deliverables after feature freeze? 14:11:14 amotoki: ^^^^ 14:11:19 i think we will also cut Stein-3 next week 14:11:42 the above patch does not include networking-ovn/odl/bgpvpn/bagpipe 14:11:57 ok, cool 14:11:58 I believe we will have stein-3 for all of stadium projects next week 14:12:22 let's move on 14:12:41 #topic Blueprints 14:13:25 These are the blueprints that we are tracking https://launchpad.net/neutron/+milestone/stein-3 14:14:11 mlavalle: subnet onboard is ready to go, thanks goes to Mike Bayer for helping get https://review.openstack.org/#/c/348080/ over the hump with the DB enginefacade issues 14:14:24 As suggested last week by slaweq< i raised the priority of blueprints that require attention 14:14:57 For bulk ports, I think https://review.openstack.org/#/c/624815/ is very very close. But slaweq noticed that the OVN test job had a few failures, so I am investigating that. 14:15:51 tidwellr: you had a faulure in a tox job 14:16:18 the lower-contstraints job, which I thought was a widespread thing.... 14:16:33 I'll rebase and see where it's at 14:16:41 perfect 14:16:59 added it to the reviews I have to do over the next couple of days 14:17:26 njohnston: I'll also keep an eye on yours 14:17:35 mlavalle: thanks! 14:17:40 Thanks tidwellr and njohnston for your hard work 14:18:15 lajoskatona: anything to say on https://blueprints.launchpad.net/neutron/+spec/strict-minimum-bandwidth-support? 14:18:28 mlavalle:yes 14:19:02 we have still a few patches for review, I think the most critical is the batch of rubasov's: https://review.openstack.org/#/q/topic:minimum-bandwidth-allocation-placement-api+(status:open+OR+status:merged)+status:open++owner:%22Bence+Romsics+%253Cbence.romsics%2540ericsson.com%253E%22 14:19:37 mlavalle: and I have a batch in various projects (tempest, novaclient....): https://review.openstack.org/#/q/topic:minimum-bandwidth-allocation-placement-api+(status:open+OR+status:merged)+status:open++owner:%22Lajos+Katona+%253Clajos.katona%2540ericsson.com%253E%22 14:20:10 lajoskatona: do we only need review attention? or is there anything else missing? 14:20:14 Those are not mandatory for the feature (perhaps the one in novaclient is the exception) 14:20:44 mlavalle: yeap that would be good to push the few remaining patch to go in 14:21:17 lajoskatona: how is novaclient related to this blueprint? do we have some change in nova side? 14:21:50 amotoki: in nova there will be a new compute microversion (2.70 as of now) and to boot VM we have to enable that in novaclient 14:22:03 yeap 14:22:19 that's what super gibi has been working on 14:22:26 amotoki: without that you cannot boot from CLI, of course that is nova area, but anyway 14:22:35 mlavalle: exactly 14:22:41 lajoskatona: thanks for clarification! 14:22:58 amotoki: your welcome 14:23:23 In regards to https://blueprints.launchpad.net/neutron/+spec/network-segment-range-management 14:24:07 I spent time revieiwing the patches: 14:24:09 https://review.openstack.org/#/c/624708 14:24:23 https://review.openstack.org/#/c/624709 14:24:52 https://review.openstack.org/#/c/638386 14:25:11 thanks slaweq and liuyulong for merging the last one 14:25:31 liuyulong and I made comments on the first two 14:25:33 this was the easy one :) 14:26:04 IMO, after addressing those comments, they will be ready 14:26:12 liuyulong: what do you think? 14:26:52 There are very positive feedback from Kailun Qin, I think it is very close. 14:27:06 slaweq: yeah, the first one is massive. I spent a whole Saturday afternoon looking at it 14:28:04 ok, let's go over them again and approve if they are ready 14:28:07 I will also go to them this week 14:28:38 thanks slaweq, liuyulong! 14:29:53 I think we are in good shape in the blueprints we are targeting for Stein-3 14:30:39 davidsha: have you heard of our compadres xubozhang and igor in regards to https://blueprints.launchpad.net/neutron/+spec/openflow-based-dvr? 14:31:24 They're still working on them, but no update besides that I'm afraid, last time I was talking to them was last Monday. 14:32:07 davidsha: can I ask you a favor? Please make sure they realize we have moved the L3 meeting to Wednesday 1400 utc 14:32:32 I've let Xubo know already, I'll email Igor now. 14:32:42 davidsha: thanks! 14:32:52 anything else on blueprints? 14:32:52 Np! 14:34:02 #topic Community goals 14:34:27 Do we have anything to say about python3? 14:35:01 not too much 14:35:33 regarding neutron, last job to switch is neutron-tempest-dvr-ha-multinode job 14:35:35 I pushed a change to use python 3 for a few jobs for ovsdbapp 14:35:36 patch is here https://review.openstack.org/#/c/638626/ 14:36:29 I will be taking a sweep of stadium projects to look at the state of things. Obviously the autogenerated mass-push changes took care of unit tests but checking for functiona, fullstack, etc. 14:36:29 is it good to go? 14:36:56 mlavalle: which one? thix https://review.openstack.org/#/c/638626/ ? 14:37:18 yes, asking about that one 14:37:55 yes, it's good to go 14:37:59 cool 14:38:05 thanks njohnston! 14:38:07 still as legacy job but with py3 14:38:13 ok, let's move on 14:38:20 #topic Bugs 14:38:53 Last week, the deputy was zhaobo. I pinged him in WeChat and he responded that he was working on it 14:39:03 did anybody see a report from him? 14:39:44 I didn't 14:39:57 I don't find anything in the discuss list 14:40:07 nor my inboxes 14:41:04 me either 14:41:24 * mlavalle looking at https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bugs?orderby=-datecreated&start=0 14:42:53 It seems that over the past week, evrything High is in progress 14:43:37 3 fwaas / octavia bugs that need triaging 14:44:03 I will take care of them. ocatavia bugs need to be forwarded to storyboard 14:44:21 i also have one bug that may be worth noting if we have time 14:44:30 I will triage https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1817219 14:44:30 Launchpad bug 1817219 in neutron "Failed to list security group tags" [Undecided,New] 14:44:39 boden: please go ahead 14:44:45 https://bugs.launchpad.net/tricircle/+bug/1816644 14:44:45 Launchpad bug 1816644 in Tricircle "tempest-dsvm jobs don't pull required projects from source" [Undecided,New] 14:45:21 so it seems a handful or consumers that use "required projects" (aka "siblings") with legacy devstack based jobs are broken 14:45:41 long story short, I have a solution, but IMO it's not a good one... trying to get QA to engauge, but has been slow 14:46:06 those impacted projects have broken jobs (IIUC) until we resolve this 14:46:30 boden: is there anything I / we can help with? 14:46:53 mlavalle well if we could get someone from QA to look at https://bugs.launchpad.net/tempest/+bug/1817555 it might help 14:46:54 Launchpad bug 1817555 in tempest "No way to pull requirements from source in devstack jobs" [Undecided,New] 14:47:12 boden: ok, I'll ping them today 14:47:19 mlavalle thanks 14:47:22 boden: you can ask gmann 14:47:29 amotoki I have 14:47:33 no response yet 14:48:05 he recently moved to Canada last week, so he might be busy somehow.. 14:48:12 boden: i will check, it is legacy job issue ? 14:48:20 gmann yes 14:48:38 gmann I sent you an email not too long ago :) 14:48:46 amotoki: morning time here so I am ok :) 14:48:57 gmann: https://bugs.launchpad.net/tempest/+bug/1817555 14:48:58 Launchpad bug 1817555 in tempest "No way to pull requirements from source in devstack jobs" [Undecided,New] 14:49:03 regarding this, I cut networking-sfc stein b1, so we can change requirements 14:49:05 it might help us 14:49:09 boden: mlavalle sure, I will check and get back. 14:49:25 gmann: thanks! 14:49:42 ok, our deputy this week is manjeets 14:50:01 he sent me an ack in the Neutron channel, so he is aware 14:50:16 ok, 14:50:20 let's move on 14:50:26 #topic neutron-lib 14:50:37 boden: we already covered on of your topics 14:50:45 please go ahead with the second one 14:51:00 we need to release neutron-lib for stein 14:51:02 like today :) 14:51:06 +1 :) 14:51:13 I just proposed a patch neutron-lib 1.25.0 https://review.openstack.org/#/c/639255/ 14:51:26 are there other patches we need? 14:51:32 I was hoping for https://review.openstack.org/#/c/639117/, but no biggie 14:51:44 I also say https://review.openstack.org/#/c/635907/ 14:51:47 saw 14:51:52 well, I might try to get one in myself 14:52:05 what about this one https://review.openstack.org/#/c/636990/ ? 14:52:10 should we get it in also? 14:52:24 it's related to segments range management 14:52:30 slaweq it depends on neutron patch 14:52:33 could take awhile like that 14:52:50 yeah 14:53:06 but now I'm not sure if that depends on is correct 14:53:07 boden: what is the absolute drop-dead deadline to release? 14:53:19 Thursday, like you suggested in your email? 14:53:23 mlavalle I thought tomorrow, but I'm not sure if that's drop-dead 14:53:39 amotoki: what do you think? 14:53:48 IIUC Thursday is the final deadline 14:54:11 ok, let's the 3 of us touch base at the end of day tomorrow and see where we stand 14:54:17 I'll ping you 14:54:28 is that ok? 14:54:28 mlavalle ok.. let's try not to push the timeline too much :) 14:54:39 let's update https://review.openstack.org/#/c/639255/ if we have more commits to be included. 14:54:50 amotoki ack 14:54:53 amotoki: ack. Thanks! 14:55:06 sorry, but I have to run guys... 14:55:37 #topic On demand agenda 14:55:48 amotoki: we covered what you wanted to discuss, right? 14:55:55 mlavalle: yes 14:56:16 We should probably bring up gmann's mail about the legacy zuul job bionic transition: http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-discuss/2019-February/003129.html 14:57:02 Neutron and neutron-lib are in a good state I thing; the issue here is the stadium 14:57:07 *think 14:57:32 mlavalle: you mentioned few weeks ago a pad for possible update checks, I am not sure if I missed it, and cant find it in my mailbox 14:57:32 njohnston: thanks, it will be good if someone from neutron team can start testing patches and add those in this etherpad - https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/legacy-job-bionic 14:58:14 I can work on it 14:58:14 njohnston: do we need a volunteer? 14:58:25 slaweq: Thanks! 14:58:43 lajoskatona: I'll ping you later in channel 14:58:53 mlavalle: thanks 14:59:06 ok, thanks for attending 14:59:14 have a great week! 14:59:14 bye 14:59:18 o/ 14:59:20 #endmeeting