14:00:30 <slaweq> #startmeeting networking
14:00:30 <openstack> Meeting started Tue Sep 10 14:00:30 2019 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is slaweq. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:00:31 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:00:32 <slaweq> hi
14:00:33 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'networking'
14:00:39 <lajoskatona> Hi
14:00:43 <rubasov> hi
14:00:44 <tidwellr> hi
14:00:50 <mlavalle> o/
14:00:59 <ralonsoh> hi
14:01:00 <njohnston> o/
14:01:24 <bcafarel> o/
14:01:49 <slaweq> ok, I think we can start
14:01:51 <slaweq> #topic Announcements
14:02:07 <slaweq> T-3 milestone and feature freeze is this week
14:02:14 <slaweq> #link https://releases.openstack.org/train/schedule.html
14:02:51 <slaweq> so no new features merged after this week until Train branch will be created
14:03:20 <amotoki> hi
14:03:45 <slaweq> It is also week of final release for client libraries
14:03:48 <slaweq> hi amotoki
14:04:20 <slaweq> amotoki: so I think we should release final python-neutronclient version for Train this week, right?
14:04:36 <amotoki> slaweq: yes, I will check it soon
14:04:41 <slaweq> amotoki: thx a lot
14:04:52 <slaweq> ok, next announcement
14:04:56 <slaweq> PTL and TC nominations and (no) elections are done
14:05:01 <slaweq> http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-discuss/2019-September/009072.html
14:05:09 <slaweq> congrats to our new TC member njohnston :)
14:05:21 <njohnston> o/
14:05:25 <mlavalle> Congratulations to our next PTL, slaweq !
14:05:27 <slaweq> and amotoki who is now Horizon PTL :)
14:05:31 <ralonsoh> njohnston, congrats!!
14:05:43 <ralonsoh> and amotoki !
14:05:44 <njohnston> congrats to all - we have an incredible team of people
14:05:45 <amotoki> njohnston and slaweq: congrats
14:05:50 <mlavalle> congrats to njohnston
14:05:54 <slaweq> and of course Thank You mlavalle for all Your hard work as PTL
14:06:01 <tidwellr> +1
14:06:06 <njohnston> +1000
14:06:08 <ralonsoh> +1
14:06:18 <amotoki> +1000 :)
14:06:23 <lajoskatona> +1
14:06:25 <mlavalle> all the succeses were thanks to you
14:06:28 <mlavalle> all
14:06:36 <mlavalle> and the failures are all mine :-)
14:06:46 <haleyb> +2 +W
14:06:49 <slaweq> LOL
14:06:50 <bcafarel> congrats all new and former "titles" :)
14:06:56 <haleyb> not about the failures of course
14:07:02 <mlavalle> LOL
14:07:22 <slaweq> ok, next one
14:07:24 <slaweq> Shanghai PTG planning etherpad
14:07:29 <slaweq> https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/Shanghai-Neutron-Planning
14:07:52 <slaweq> PTG will be in less than 2 months so please start thinking about topics and add them to etherpad
14:08:11 <slaweq> and speaking about etherpads
14:08:35 <slaweq> last week we created brainstorming etherpad for potential forum sessions' topics
14:08:38 <tidwellr> any thoughts on remote PTG participation?
14:08:42 <slaweq> https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/neutron-shanghai-forum-brainstorming
14:08:51 <mlavalle> tidwellr: yes, we are exploring options
14:09:51 <mlavalle> going back to the forum etherpad
14:10:03 <slaweq> ok, thx mlavalle
14:10:09 <mlavalle> slaweq and I added some topics there
14:10:23 <mlavalle> we have a tight deadline to propose them
14:10:30 <mlavalle> Sep 20th, I think
14:10:34 <slaweq> correct
14:10:56 <mlavalle> so I.d say our internal deadline shoud be next Monday
14:11:05 <slaweq> mlavalle++
14:11:23 <mlavalle> ay that point we make a final decision and propose the topics
14:11:34 <slaweq> I was thinking that we can discuss final proposals on team meeting next monday
14:11:45 <mlavalle> so if you have any ideas, this the week to dump them in the etherpad
14:12:00 <mlavalle> slaweq: yes, let's do that
14:12:18 <mlavalle> so I will leave the topic I added to the on demand agenda section
14:12:23 <mlavalle> we can skip it today
14:12:32 <mlavalle> since we alreade talked about it
14:12:40 <slaweq> thx mlavalle
14:13:16 <slaweq> about ideas, please wrote them to etherpad even if You will not be there or You don't want/can't moderate such session
14:13:18 <slaweq> :)
14:13:46 <slaweq> ok, and the last one announcement for today:
14:13:56 <slaweq> Train PTG summary: http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-discuss/2019-May/006408.html (just as a reminder)
14:14:08 <slaweq> any other announcements from the team?
14:15:34 <slaweq> ok, lets move on than
14:15:43 <slaweq> #topic Blueprints
14:15:57 <slaweq> blueprints targeted for T-3 https://launchpad.net/neutron/+milestone/train-3
14:16:17 <slaweq> any updates about them?
14:16:42 <njohnston> No update for ethertype; I hope to do some serious work on it for this week but I am in doubt that it will make Train
14:17:25 <rubasov> the extraroute stuff is currently held up by rechecks on this: https://review.opendev.org/680980
14:18:07 <slaweq> according to extraroute, it looks for me that we are only missing https://review.opendev.org/#/c/670851/
14:18:10 <slaweq> is that right?
14:18:23 <rubasov> reviewers please keep in mind that the whole topic is quite well reviewed but it looks bad (zuul -1s) because of unmerged cross-repo dependencies
14:18:23 <slaweq> and this can be done when we will bump neutron-lib version in neutron, right?
14:18:52 <amotoki> rubasov: I think requirements bump can be done in parallel.
14:19:11 <amotoki> we need both but it is not a blocker except lower-constraints job
14:19:33 <rubasov> slaweq: and then these: https://review.opendev.org/#/q/status:open+topic:extraroute
14:19:46 <mlavalle> rubasov: so if we take this as a feature freeze exception, are you willing to continue pushing it?
14:20:00 <rubasov> mlavalle: absolutely
14:20:03 <rubasov> thank you
14:20:15 <slaweq> rubasov: but in this list there is only this one neutron patch which I mentioned
14:20:21 <slaweq> and python-neutronclient
14:20:33 <slaweq> other than that, those are patches to heat and OSC
14:20:37 <rubasov> neutronclient is a dependency for heat
14:20:51 <rubasov> sdk and asc is more important from neutron perspective
14:20:55 <rubasov> for cli of course
14:21:01 <mlavalle> but neutron cleint has already W+, right?
14:21:04 <rubasov> sdk and osc ^^^
14:21:17 <rubasov> mlavalle: yes
14:21:38 <mlavalle> so if we focus on getting that lib patch
14:21:50 <mlavalle> plus the neutron patch, we did our bit, coorect?
14:22:00 <amotoki> osc and neutronclient patches depend on neutron implementation, right?
14:22:05 <amotoki> s/osc/sdk/
14:22:13 <rubasov> ideally: bump+neutron+sdk+osc
14:22:25 <rubasov> amotoki: yes
14:22:59 <mlavalle> I am just trying to highlight what the neutron team controls
14:23:04 <amotoki> so, this week is the freeze week for sdk + neutronclent, so we need to get the neutron patch merged soon to land them.
14:23:09 <rubasov> mlavalle: understood
14:23:15 <mlavalle> and that is the neutron-lib and the neutron patches, correct?
14:23:19 <rubasov> then bump+neutron
14:23:58 <mlavalle> cool
14:24:24 <mlavalle> njohnston: let's revisit the ethertypes during the drivers meeting on Friday, ok?
14:24:29 <mlavalle> we make a decision then
14:24:30 <slaweq> so lets focus on this bump neutron-lib patch and neutron patch then - I hope gate will be unblocked today
14:24:30 <rubasov> with urls: https://review.opendev.org/680980 and https://review.opendev.org/670851
14:24:31 <njohnston> mlavalle: sounds good
14:24:43 <rubasov> thank you everybody
14:24:44 <amotoki> is the heat patch targeted for Ussuri or do they consider FFE?
14:25:02 <rubasov> amotoki: I don't know at the moment
14:25:04 <amotoki> it affects the importance on SDK merge.
14:25:30 <amotoki> rubasov: okay, so it looks like we can defer SDK stuffs to Ussuri.
14:26:20 <mlavalle> I know we are trying to think as a broader community....
14:26:39 <rubasov> amotoki: sdk is actually not a dependency for heat
14:26:45 <mlavalle> but this extension has value in itself, regardless of whether we land the corresponding part in heat, right?
14:26:49 <rubasov> it is a dependency for osc
14:26:55 <rubasov> mlavalle: yes
14:27:18 <mlavalle> so for this week, in the neutron team let's focus on landing the extension
14:27:28 <rubasov> it feels like I should have a put an ascii art of the dependency tree in the commit messages :-)
14:28:06 <amotoki> heat --> neutronclient --> neutron --> req bump
14:28:12 <slaweq> mlavalle: sounds good, and lets check if we have all what's needed on friday's drivers meeting
14:28:14 <amotoki> osc --> openstacksdk --> neutron
14:28:15 <slaweq> will that be ok?
14:28:16 <rubasov> amotoki: yes
14:28:28 <slaweq> or do we need to release neutronclient on Thursday?
14:28:30 <rubasov> slaweq: will attend
14:28:57 <amotoki> neutronclient release can wait till Thur and if the neutron patch lands we can adjust the commit hash.
14:29:23 <slaweq> ok
14:29:27 <amotoki> I see three small commits in neutornclient since the last release
14:29:36 <slaweq> so we have plan for this one :)
14:29:38 <amotoki> so it looks better to release the client.
14:31:13 <slaweq> for other BPs, we will have to move them to Ussuri cycle, right?
14:31:52 <mlavalle> yes
14:32:05 <mlavalle> but let's wait until Friday
14:32:12 <slaweq> mlavalle: sure :)
14:32:20 <slaweq> ok, next topic
14:32:22 <slaweq> #topic Community goals
14:32:38 <slaweq> any updates about python3 or pdf docs?
14:33:29 <bcafarel> I saw some additional pdf docs merged I think
14:33:39 <njohnston> lajoskatona: How are things with python3 for networking-odl CI jobs, especially https://review.opendev.org/#/c/672925/ ?
14:34:09 <amotoki> Re pdf docs, we succeeded to have pathces for all stadium repos :)
14:34:36 <amotoki> I think they are not urgent as they are doc changes.
14:35:26 <amotoki> I added the review links to the meeting wiki
14:35:27 <lajoskatona> njohston: that one is still failing, I have to ping again the ODL team about that
14:35:31 <slaweq> amotoki: only urgency which I see is that this week is also "Train Community Goals Completed"
14:35:47 <slaweq> so my assumption is that it should be finished this week
14:35:57 <slaweq> but we can easily finish it later for stadium projects
14:35:58 <lajoskatona> njohston: thanks to the reviews other jobs are now in quite good sape
14:35:58 <amotoki> not till the release date?
14:36:53 <amotoki> ah, I found https://releases.openstack.org/train/schedule.html#t-goals-complete
14:37:09 <slaweq> amotoki: yes, that was the link I was referring to
14:37:53 <amotoki> re the pdf goal, I will discuss it with asettle later. she is the goal champion.
14:38:08 <slaweq> ok, thx amotoki
14:38:19 <slaweq> according to IPv6-Only Deployments in Neutron we are good
14:38:25 <mlavalle> cool
14:38:33 <slaweq> there are WIP patches for networking-ovn and networking-odl now
14:38:47 <amotoki> community goals are tracked by storyboard, so we can update the corresponding stories.
14:39:40 <slaweq> tidwellr: can You check if we would need similar IPv6 only job for neutron-dynamic-routing also?
14:40:24 <tidwellr> slaweq: I'll double-check
14:40:31 <tidwellr> we might not need one though
14:40:31 <slaweq> thx tidwellr
14:40:54 <slaweq> I will also email tmorin with similar question about networking-bagpipe
14:41:23 <slaweq> ok, let's move on
14:41:25 <slaweq> #topic Bugs
14:41:40 <slaweq> our bug deputy last week was njohnston
14:41:46 <slaweq> he sent summary in Bugs report for week of September 2nd: http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-discuss/2019-September/009261.html
14:42:10 <slaweq> this week our bug deputy is mlavalle so we are in very good hands :)
14:42:13 <njohnston> Much gate turmoil last week
14:42:35 <mlavalle> let's see if I don't wreck the house ;-)
14:43:01 <njohnston> thanks rubasov for taking https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1843285
14:43:02 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1843285 in neutron "Trunk scenario test test_subport_connectivity failing with iptables_hybrid fw driver" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Bence Romsics (bence-romsics)
14:43:17 <njohnston> but https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1843290 is still unassigned
14:43:18 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1843290 in neutron "Remove network flavor profile fails" [High,New]
14:43:20 <rubasov> njohnston: of course
14:43:56 <njohnston> and while the report indicates https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1843282 is complete; the CI is still failing.  slaweq pushed a change to make some CI nonvoting as a result https://review.opendev.org/#/c/681186/
14:43:57 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1843282 in neutron "Rally CI not working since jsonschema version bump" [High,Fix released] - Assigned to Rodolfo Alonso (rodolfo-alonso-hernandez)
14:44:31 <ralonsoh> once rally releases a new version, we'll have rally-openstack working again
14:45:44 <njohnston> and one bug I was not able to reproduce properly, so if someone is familiar with the network ip availability API: https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1843211
14:45:45 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1843211 in neutron "network-ip-availabilities' result is not correct when the subnet has no allocation-pool" [Undecided,New]
14:45:58 <njohnston> those are the highlights of outstanding issues
14:46:21 <amotoki> njohnston: I will check it.
14:46:36 <slaweq> thx njohnston for update
14:46:38 <njohnston> thank you amotoki
14:47:17 <slaweq> ok, let's move on than
14:47:19 <slaweq> #topic neutron-lib
14:47:23 <slaweq> boden: any updates?
14:47:31 <boden> hi
14:48:18 <boden> no technical updates from me, but I did want to mention that due to a change in focus, I won't have much time to work on neutron-lib moving forward
14:48:48 <boden> that said, there's still plenty of neutron-lib work left... if anyone wants to pick it up, I'm available to help ramp someone else up
14:49:18 <mlavalle> is this change in your focus imediate or is there going to be a transition period?
14:49:50 <boden> it's immediate, but as I mentioned I still have some cycles here and there.
14:50:17 <boden> I think the neutron-lib work is at a good point for this anyway; there's nothing much I'm aware of in neutron-lib that's pending consumption in neutron
14:50:20 <mlavalle> in that case, I'll send a message to the ML indicating that we need a new neutron-lib champion
14:50:50 <boden> I do have some pending consumption patches out there, but they have been slow moving... some dating back months and month
14:50:57 <njohnston> thank you boden for the incredible quantity and quality of work you have done over the years
14:51:23 <boden> welcome... I'll still be around so feel free to ping me for reviews, etc..
14:51:27 <mlavalle> would you be able to respond to that message indicating whan needs to be done forward and the priorities?
14:51:46 <boden> mlavalle I can, but we've had a list out there for a long time now
14:52:07 <boden> https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/neutron-lib-volunteers-and-punch-list
14:52:08 <mlavalle> ok, just point to the list in that case in your response
14:52:21 <boden> nothing changed here; all still valid
14:52:21 <slaweq> boden: that's sad news but I understand it, thx a lot for all this hard work on neutron-lib
14:52:23 <mlavalle> ok, nevermind, I'll point to it in my message
14:52:51 <mlavalle> and yes, I join the rest of the team in thanking for all your efforts....
14:53:08 <boden> been my pleasure
14:53:09 <mlavalle> and wishing you good luck in your future endeavours
14:53:37 <boden> thank you
14:54:15 <bcafarel> indeed thanks a lot for all the work you've completed there boden!
14:54:20 <slaweq> ok, let's move on than
14:54:22 <slaweq> #topic On demand agenda
14:54:37 <slaweq> in the meeting agenda there is only one item from mlavalle but we already talked about it
14:54:48 <mlavalle> we'll keep it for next week
14:54:54 <slaweq> anyone has anything else to talk about?
14:54:58 <slaweq> we have 5 minutes
14:55:57 <slaweq> ok, if not, I will end this meeting here
14:56:00 <slaweq> thx for attending
14:56:04 <slaweq> and have a great week
14:56:07 <slaweq> #endmeeting