16:03:07 <Sukhdev> #startmeeting networking_ml2
16:03:08 <openstack> Meeting started Wed Jan  7 16:03:07 2015 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is Sukhdev. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
16:03:09 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
16:03:11 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'networking_ml2'
16:03:32 <Sukhdev> #topic Agenda
16:03:41 <Sukhdev> #link: https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/ML2#Meeting_January_7.2C_2015
16:04:13 <Sukhdev> #topic: Announcements
16:04:22 <Sukhdev> Happy New Year to all
16:04:41 <Sukhdev> Hope you had relaxing holidays and wonderful start to New Year
16:05:30 <shivharis> thanks, same to all
16:05:32 <Sukhdev> Just a reminder Kilo-2 is approaching soon - in less than a month
16:05:53 <Sukhdev> #link - https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Kilo_Release_Schedule
16:06:16 <Sukhdev> Anybody has any announcement to make?
16:06:50 <Sukhdev> #topic: L2 Gateway Update
16:07:23 <Sukhdev> I thought I give you a quick update - a new effort has been kicked off in the networking team
16:08:18 <Sukhdev> A bi-weekly meeting is scheduled every other monday - you can see details here -  https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings#Networking_L2_Gateway_meeting
16:08:48 <Sukhdev> The team's goal is to come up with an API for L2 Gateway functionality
16:09:16 <Sukhdev> This project is being kicked off from stackforge - not as part of neutron tree
16:09:51 <Sukhdev> If anybody is interested in the topic, feel free to join us in the meetings or feel free to ping me for more details
16:10:20 <Sukhdev> We have initial version of API and the goal is to have a working version within Kilo cycle
16:10:45 <Sukhdev> Any questions on this topic before moving on?
16:11:02 <rkukura> Sukhdev: Thanks - I’ll take a close look
16:11:04 <yamahata> Sukhdev: where is the past log?
16:11:30 <Sukhdev> yamahata: The first meeting took place yesterday
16:12:23 <Sukhdev> yamahata: the logs will be here - http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/networking_l2gw/
16:12:35 <yamahata> Sukhdev: thanks. will take a look.
16:13:08 <Sukhdev> #topic: ML2 Drivers decomposition
16:13:24 <Sukhdev> We covered this topic in our last meeting
16:13:51 <Sukhdev> and provided details about what transpired in SLC sprint related to this issue
16:14:24 <Sukhdev> The question I wanted to ask the team is if we should follow up on this topic here in this meetings?
16:14:24 <moshele> Sukhdev: do we have a working example of the split like odl?
16:15:06 <Sukhdev> moshele: I started to work on it - I am more than half way done, and then got pulled into something else unfortunately
16:16:06 <Sukhdev> moshele: mestery had ODL almost done few back - I did not check if he posted the final version yet
16:16:13 <Sukhdev> has anyone seen it
16:16:15 <shivharis> link to etherpad?
16:16:20 <Sukhdev> mestery: are you here?
16:16:50 <Sukhdev> mestery: have you completed the OLD driver split?
16:17:16 <mestery> Sukhdev: Here, yes. Yes, ODL is split, but I do not have the changes merged upstream yet to make it fully work.
16:17:20 <mestery> But the repo is out there, yes.
16:17:24 <mestery> stackforge/networking-odl
16:17:51 <moshele> ok,  thank I will look into that
16:18:07 <Sukhdev> so looks like mestery and I are both in same stage
16:18:57 <Sukhdev> Hopefully within next couple of weeks, I hope to complete the Arista ML2 driver split
16:19:43 <Sukhdev> Shall we keep this item on the agenda until we have couple of working examples?
16:20:00 <moshele> I think so
16:20:13 <rkukura> Sukhdev: I think its a good idea
16:20:36 <Sukhdev> Sounds good - thanks
16:20:49 <banix> +1
16:21:11 <matrohon> just a question : can l2pop MD stay in the tree?
16:21:34 <rkukura> matrohon: I think so, at least for now
16:21:51 <matrohon> rkukura : ok thanks
16:21:54 <Sukhdev> matrohon: Good question - I think so
16:22:52 <Sukhdev> Decomposition is really proposed to help vendors to have more control over the code changes and to relieve the cores to spend time on core work
16:23:18 <Sukhdev> Anything else on this before we move on?
16:23:57 <Sukhdev> #topic: Blueprint list consolidation
16:24:16 <Sukhdev> shivharis: I do not see Manish here
16:24:26 <Sukhdev> shivharis: do you want to provide update?
16:24:42 <Sukhdev> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Tracking_ML2_Subgroup_Reviews#Under_Review
16:24:52 <shivharis> we have mostly completed the list in the etherpad
16:25:05 <shivharis> sorry wiki...
16:25:27 <shivharis> would like to get others to look thru and see if we missed anything..
16:25:39 <shivharis> so it is out there for updates
16:25:50 <shivharis> thats all from me on this.
16:26:06 <Sukhdev> shivharis: Sounds good - thanks
16:26:14 <Sukhdev> anybody has any question?
16:26:40 <Sukhdev> Please have a look  - I posted the link above and feel free to update the wiki directly
16:26:54 <Sukhdev> #topic: Bugs
16:26:54 <rkukura> I’d suggest we keep the vendor-specific BPs in a separate section, since these don’t go through the normal spec review process any more
16:27:04 <Sukhdev> #undo
16:27:05 <openstack> Removing item from minutes: <ircmeeting.items.Topic object at 0x3bc0bd0>
16:27:25 <Sukhdev> rkukura: That is a good idea
16:27:45 <Sukhdev> shivharis: is it easy enough to do?
16:28:02 <shivharis> we can take care of that
16:28:15 <Sukhdev> shivharis: thanks
16:28:23 <Sukhdev> #topic: Bugs
16:28:45 <shivharis> bugs: i am still seeking info on the high priority bugs
16:28:46 <Sukhdev> #link: https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron?field.searchtext=ml2
16:29:10 <shivharis> https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1378732
16:29:12 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1378732 in neutron "migrate_to_ml2 script doesn't work for Juno release" [High,New]
16:29:42 <shivharis> markmacclain ?
16:30:00 <shivharis> markmcclain ?
16:30:35 <shivharis> i think this bugs needs resolution before k2
16:30:56 <shivharis> I am hoping to get some guidance from mark on this
16:31:46 <shivharis> we are covered on this: https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1367391
16:31:49 <uvirtbot> Launchpad bug 1367391 in neutron "ML2 DVR port binding implementation unnecessarily duplicates schema and logic" [High,Confirmed]
16:32:03 <shivharis> i think rkukura is on top of this
16:32:27 <rkukura> shivharis: I hope to get back to working on this by the end of the week
16:32:48 <rkukura> I think its important to get it into k2
16:32:48 <matrohon> rkukura : did you already start an implementation?
16:32:53 <shivharis> the other 2 high bugs seem to be not progressing - i will ping the folks again for these
16:33:32 <shivharis> I plan to sort this vendor specific bugs and assign to vendor specific contributors this week
16:33:33 <rkukura> matrohon: I have a branch but don’t recall how much progress I had made.
16:34:06 <matrohon> rkukura : fine, k2 would be very nice!
16:34:28 <matrohon> rkukura : ha_router needs it too
16:34:39 <shivharis> Also requesting others to pick up the medium priroity bugs and work on these.
16:34:55 <Sukhdev> deadline for k2 is 2/5/15
16:34:57 <rkukura> matrohon: I’ve been tied up with GBP, but we just did our Juno release so I’m soon back to working on ML2
16:34:59 <shivharis> Any questions regarding bugs please feel free to jump in
16:35:15 <matrohon> rkukura : cool!
16:35:38 <Sukhdev> shivharis: thanks for update
16:35:42 <shivharis> that all i have this time from my side
16:35:50 <Sukhdev> anything else on the bugs?
16:36:12 <Sukhdev> #topic Open Discussion
16:36:36 <Sukhdev> Anybody has anything to discuss?
16:37:09 * Sukhdev is waiting
16:37:29 <matrohon> does anybody is working with linuxbridge?
16:38:27 <Sukhdev> Looks like we done - enjoy the extra time
16:38:43 <Sukhdev> thanks for joining folks
16:38:49 <matrohon> I'm interested in understanding the future of lb, since no gate is running with it and major features doesn't take it into account (DVR)...
16:38:50 <banix> thank. bye
16:39:21 <Sukhdev> matrohon: you may want to ask the same question at - #openstack_neutron
16:39:39 <Sukhdev> #openstack-neutron
16:39:46 <Sukhdev> #endmeeting