18:00:37 <rtheis> #startmeeting networking_ovn
18:00:38 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Sep 29 18:00:37 2016 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is rtheis. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
18:00:40 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
18:00:42 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'networking_ovn'
18:00:50 <russellb> hi
18:00:59 <rtheis> #topic: Announcements
18:01:03 <rtheis> hi russellb
18:01:12 <rtheis> Open vSwitch 2.6.0 released
18:01:19 <rtheis> #link http://openvswitch.org/pipermail/discuss/2016-September/022786.html
18:01:33 <rtheis> networking-ovn Newton RC2 released
18:01:40 <rtheis> #link  http://lists.openstack.org/pipermail/openstack-dev/2016-September/104673.html and https://review.openstack.org/#/c/374820/
18:01:55 <russellb> \o/
18:02:01 <rtheis> I think we are in good shape for newton
18:02:14 <russellb> yep, thanks for staying on top of things rtheis
18:02:19 <rtheis> yw
18:02:34 <rtheis> I don't have any other announcements
18:03:00 <rtheis> #topic: Bugs
18:03:12 <rtheis> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/networking-ovn/+bug/1627810
18:03:13 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1627810 in networking-ovn "gate-grenade-dsvm-networking-ovn-nv [Fail] Couldn't ping server " [Undecided,In progress] - Assigned to Richard Theis (rtheis)
18:03:25 <rtheis> grenade is broken
18:03:49 <rtheis> Babu and I have been looking at it but nothing solid to go on for a fix yet
18:04:22 <russellb> i suggested to him that if after some time (a day or whatever) it still wasn't too clear how to fix it, we might just want to forget about it and wait until we can drop the l3 agent in that job
18:04:26 <russellb> and then worry about getting it working again
18:04:57 <rtheis> sounds good
18:05:40 <rtheis> I'll take another look if I have time ... one more idea to try out
18:05:51 <rtheis> then maybe defer it
18:06:06 <rtheis> #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/networking-ovn/+bug/1621627
18:06:08 <openstack> Launchpad bug 1621627 in networking-ovn "Create multi-node CI job for networking-ovn" [High,In progress] - Assigned to Richard Theis (rtheis)
18:06:20 <russellb> ok
18:06:20 <rtheis> there is also the multi-node CI job
18:06:24 <russellb> how's that going?
18:06:26 <russellb> very exciting
18:06:35 <rtheis> it works
18:06:38 <rtheis> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/376968/
18:07:15 <rtheis> but we aren't doing the heavy lifting yet with floating IPs until l3 support merges
18:07:43 <rtheis> but we can handle that as a change later
18:08:18 <rtheis> once https://review.openstack.org/#/c/376968/ goes in, https://review.openstack.org/#/c/378032/ will move the job to non-voting
18:09:02 <rtheis> And final bug that I have ...
18:09:15 <rtheis> no launchpad bug yet ...
18:09:27 <rtheis> the functional test is broken with ovs 2.6.0
18:09:35 <rtheis> and thus our gate isn't happy
18:09:53 <rtheis> I've triaged it down to ovs transaction mutate support
18:10:21 <rtheis> I think this may be a bug in ovs
18:10:43 * azbiswas ears perk up
18:11:04 <rtheis> running 2 commands that both mutate a column works, but ...
18:11:28 <rtheis> using the idl to get the column data in first command return full set
18:11:30 <azbiswas> rtheis: Do you have no details on this?
18:11:30 <azbiswas> more details
18:11:47 <rtheis> using the idl to get the column data in second commend returns an empty list
18:12:32 <rtheis> end result is that if n-ovn does any comparisons with the column data, it may be inaccurate since the mutate blasted it for subequent commands under the same transaction
18:13:01 <rtheis> unfortunately, there are a couple hits in n-ovn
18:13:15 <azbiswas> We can try running it with the master branch of OVS and see if that fails as well
18:13:17 <rtheis> I have an idea how to fix on n-ovn side and will open a bug
18:14:08 <russellb> hm, i wonder if we want to make the CI jobs for stable/newton use branch-2.6 of ovs vs master ...
18:14:15 <rtheis> azbiswas: has there been a lot of changes between master and ovs 2.6.0 just released on pypi
18:14:21 <azbiswas> That sounds like a bug in idl.
18:14:45 <azbiswas> Not in the idl part
18:15:48 <rtheis> russellb: that's a good idea
18:16:39 <rtheis> that's all I have on this bug for now
18:16:54 <rtheis> I'll finish my investigation and open a bug report with the details
18:17:18 <rtheis> any other bugs?
18:17:49 <rtheis> #topic Reviews
18:18:08 <rtheis> how about reviews?
18:18:25 <russellb> yes!
18:18:48 <rtheis> we still have similar list of new features and unit test coverage improvements in the queue
18:19:01 <rtheis> I'll try doing more reviews once the gate is fixed
18:19:12 <rtheis> was hoping to have more time now that newton rc2 is out
18:19:25 <russellb> is there a gate fix in the queue?
18:19:31 <rtheis> no
18:19:43 <russellb> i'm also interested in the status of the SNAT / Floating IP patch
18:19:55 <russellb> looks like it got rebased yesterday
18:20:09 <rtheis> chandrav ^^^^
18:20:20 <russellb> i was proposing that we should try to merge it soon since tests are passing
18:20:29 <russellb> and address any cleanup or bugs we come across as follow-ups
18:20:58 <rtheis> sounds good to me
18:21:25 <russellb> chandrav: thanks for sticking through with this one!
18:21:31 <azbiswas> The only part remaining from implementation is the sync part
18:21:47 <chandrav> russellb: Also, there is 1 tempest test failing "tempest.scenario.test_network_v6"
18:22:01 <russellb> you have it disabled though right?
18:22:07 <chandrav> I'll raise 2 bugs for sync code and the tempest failure
18:22:07 <russellb> filing a bug / following up on that is OK with me
18:22:12 <chandrav> yes, i disabled it
18:23:14 <rtheis> chandrav: once the bugs are opened, please reference them in the code todos
18:23:16 <rtheis> thanks
18:23:38 <chandrav> will do
18:23:59 <rtheis> anything else on reviews ?
18:24:29 <rtheis> #topic Conferences
18:24:43 <rtheis> We have a room scheduled for OpenStack summit
18:24:51 <rtheis> Workroom setup scheduled on Wednesday from 3:05 to 3:45
18:24:56 <rtheis> #link  https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1TQ-RSlbiBBEclkonIbfUP7R1ExZSJylF1uiEKV2G_Cw/pubhtml?gid=1107826458&single=true
18:25:26 <rtheis> add topics to etherpad https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/networking-ovn-ocata-summit
18:25:53 <rtheis> Also there is a roundtable setup open all day Friday if needed
18:26:20 <rtheis> anything else on conferences?
18:26:54 <rtheis> #topic Open Discussion
18:27:08 <rtheis> I don't have any specific topics
18:27:35 <rtheis> If nothing, we can end early
18:28:51 <rtheis> okay, back to the gate fix and reviews ...
18:29:01 <rtheis> thanks everyone
18:29:02 <rtheis> #endmeeting