13:59:48 #startmeeting neutron_drivers 13:59:49 Meeting started Fri Aug 3 13:59:48 2018 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is mlavalle. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 13:59:50 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 13:59:52 The meeting name has been set to 'neutron_drivers' 13:59:54 hi 14:00:07 o/ 14:00:16 I think I jumped the gun by a few seconds 14:00:20 oh well 14:01:04 Hi 14:01:15 Hi All 14:01:35 hi longkb, yushiro, SridarK. Welcome! 14:01:42 mlavalle: i am in another simultaneous meeting, but will keep one eye open here 14:01:50 haleyb: ack 14:02:12 mlavalle, Hi :) 14:02:47 let's wait a couple of minutes to see if amotoki or yamamoto join the meeting 14:02:49 Thanks mlavalle 14:03:08 haleyb, Hi, long time no see since Denver :) 14:03:36 yushiro: yes, and i will be there in September, hope to see you there 14:04:29 haleyb, me tooooooo :p I'm glad to hear that. 14:04:46 ok, let's get going 14:04:58 #topic Rocky rc1 14:06:19 So we have landed all the code in Neutron that we targeted for the rc1 14:07:06 except https://review.openstack.org/#/c/588079/ 14:07:11 hi 14:07:27 as a consequence, we are almost ready to cut rc1. however, we are still waiting to see what happens with the patches for the logging feature in FWaaS 14:08:17 That is why I invited today longkb, yushiro and SridarK, so we can assess where we stand 14:08:37 mlavalle, OK. Thanks for inviting us. 14:08:45 welcome FWaaS friends! 14:08:59 Thanks a lot! mlavalle :) 14:08:59 njohnston, Yeeees :) 14:09:14 so where do we stand? do you have a pointer to the patches in question? 14:09:41 mlavalle, We're reviewing following 8 patches in fwaas for logging. 14:09:54 https://review.openstack.org/#/q/status:open+project:openstack/neutron-fwaas+branch:master+topic:bug/1720727 14:10:51 These patches depended on neutron patches and need to wait until these are merged. So, now these patches pass zuul checking and restart reviewing. 14:11:34 are they passing zuul tests consistently? 14:11:46 sorry irc issues 14:12:17 mlavalle, yes, currently they passed. (Now some patches are waiting zuul reply) 14:12:31 It seems 3 of them have already passed zuul consistently 14:13:04 mlavalle, Therefore, would it be possoble to wait for keep on reviewing for fwaas patches ?? 14:13:04 RPC and validator patches are waiting for zuul testing :) 14:13:59 Look, I already granted the FFE to this and I am not going to widthdraw it while you are fighting hard to land the feature 14:14:44 mlavalle: thx 14:14:56 That sounds greate! mlavalle 14:15:09 we have until next week to cut rc1. So no need to cut this effort prematurely 14:15:22 mlavalle, Thank you so much. 14:15:53 Having said that, I want to remind everybody that we all have the duty with the community to deliver solid software 14:16:09 it is starting to look tight to me 14:17:31 mlavalle: what would be a drop dead deadline - so there is some buffer so we are comfortable with more testing 14:17:50 so let's continue the effort but I urge all the team members to keep a balanced assesment on whether we should deliver this or not 14:18:35 Let's give ourselves until Wednesday of next week to decide whether we go forward with this or we pull the plug 14:19:00 mlavalle: thats very reasonable thx 14:19:11 Next Wednesday, I see. Thanks mlavalle. 14:19:16 That means Wednesday end of day USA time 14:19:22 Thanks mlavalle :) 14:19:50 mlavalle, OK, i'll check JST time :) 14:20:09 which translates to early morning in East Asia 14:20:20 Thursday morning 14:20:41 mlavalle, Aha. Thanks. 14:21:50 how about we all meet again on Thursday at 0200UTC? 14:22:27 SridarK: that is going to be 2100 my time and 1900 your time on Wednesday 14:22:35 mlavalle: perfect thx 14:22:53 that is east Asia friendly as well 14:23:12 yushiro, longkb: what time is that in Japan and Vietnam? 14:23:20 mlavalle, Yes, I definitely join. It's 11:00 JST and 09:00 VST. 14:23:44 +1 yushiro :D It's reasonable for us 14:23:46 so yeah, perfectly friendly for our East Asia friends 14:24:05 we will meet in the #opentask-fwaas channel. does that work? 14:24:28 +1 for #openstack-fwaas 14:24:35 mlavalle, It's very very helpful and friendly for us. OK, no problem to meet at #openstack-fwaas 14:25:04 +1 14:25:14 ok, I'll be keeping an eye on those patches over the next few days 14:25:33 good luck! I'll keep my fingers crossed in one hand.... 14:25:44 and the az in the other one ;-) 14:25:49 ax^^^ 14:25:50 mlavalle: i had one more issue to bring up after we are done on this 14:26:12 SridarK: go ahead please 14:26:32 We had a bug for which we are trying to get a fix in 14:26:49 #link https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1762454 14:26:49 Launchpad bug 1762454 in neutron "FWaaS: Invalid port error on associating ports (distributed router) to firewall group" [Medium,In progress] - Assigned to Yushiro FURUKAWA (y-furukawa-2) 14:27:03 #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/580552/ 14:27:52 Yes, thank you SridarK. 14:27:56 yushiro: has a review out 14:28:07 mlavalle: just want to keep that on ur radar 14:28:20 SridarK: ok, I'll keep an eye on it 14:28:43 the fix as such is quite simple on validation, the concern is on datapath behavior on HA with switchover 14:29:00 have asked haleyb for comments on the patch as well 14:29:27 so hopefully quite straightfwd once we get clarifications and also on testing yushiro is doing 14:29:37 thats all from me 14:30:06 yeah, I see haleyb is involved. I'll take a look and see if I can help 14:30:28 mlavalle: perfect thx much 14:30:41 Now, I'm testing this patch and associating firewall with HA router port. We'd like to verify correct behavior when the router switchovered regarding conntrack. 14:30:52 s/firewall/firewall group 14:30:59 ack 14:31:01 mlavalle: if u look at my last review comment 14:31:33 mlavalle, haleyb i'll paste on gerrit for etherpad link for the result of testing. 14:31:44 yushiro: +1 14:31:47 SridarK: yes, that makes sense 14:31:55 yushiro: yes, that will be helpful 14:32:38 :) 14:32:54 yushiro, longkb, SridarK: thanks for your hard work. Your efforts are much appreciated :-) 14:33:42 mlavalle: no worries - mainly yushiro longkb & annp on the logging feature - great work 14:33:52 Thanks for the update 14:33:58 mlavalle, SridarK Me too. Thanks for managing our community and helping :) 14:34:16 yushiro: +1 cant say more for mlavalle 14:34:17 SridarK, mlavalle: Thank you, too :) 14:34:27 +Inf for neutron :) 14:34:59 haleyb: I don't think we have qurum for the RFEs portion of this meeting. so you can focus on your other meeting ;-) 14:35:03 THanks guys 14:35:08 * njohnston is just glad we all managed to get authenticated and past the spambot blockers 14:35:15 mlavalle: it just ended 14:35:23 haleyb: LOL 14:35:34 guys, let's tal on Wednesday 14:36:05 ok 14:36:09 haleyb, njohnston, manjeets: although you are welcome, no need for you to aattend the Wednesday meeting. I can handle that 14:36:30 not very convenient time for US based folks 14:36:44 #endmeeting