15:00:39 <carl_baldwin> #startmeeting neutron_l3 15:00:41 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Oct 30 15:00:39 2014 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes. The chair is carl_baldwin. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 15:00:42 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 15:00:45 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'neutron_l3' 15:00:53 <carl_baldwin> #Announcements 15:00:59 <carl_baldwin> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Neutron-L3-Subteam 15:01:20 <carl_baldwin> Summit is next week! 15:01:45 <carl_baldwin> We will not be having this meeting next week. Hopefully, many of us can meet face to face at summit. 15:02:00 <carl_baldwin> Any other announcements? 15:02:30 <carl_baldwin> #topic Bugs 15:02:54 <carl_baldwin> I don’t see any new l3-ipam-dhcp bugs. 15:03:10 <carl_baldwin> Does anyone have any bugs to bring up? 15:03:55 <carl_baldwin> #topic Agenda 15:04:14 <carl_baldwin> I’m short on time today. So, what agenda items do we need to hit today? 15:04:44 <carl_baldwin> One topic I’d like to hit is what we would like to discuss face-to-face in Paris. 15:05:32 <yamahata> I'd like to suggest the topic of 3 agent/plug in refactoring and l3 routervm plugin. 15:05:34 <carl_baldwin> devvesa mention BGP on the mailing list. I don’t see him around today so we’ll take that discussion to the ML. 15:05:50 <matrohon> A dedicated pod to talk about BGP has been planned on wednesday by jaume 15:06:09 <carl_baldwin> matrohon: Thanks. Do you happen to know the time? 15:06:47 <matrohon> carl_baldwin : not yep. can we already book a POD? 15:06:54 <carl_baldwin> yamahata: I’d like some time to talk about the refactoring effort as well. What do you think a good time may be? 15:07:25 <carl_baldwin> matrohon: I don’t think we can book PODs but we should discuss some potential times. 15:07:26 <yamahata> morning or lunch time. Or non neutron session time. 15:07:31 <yamahata> I uploaded my specs. 15:07:39 <yamahata> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/131952/ 15:07:45 <yamahata> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/105078/ 15:08:02 <carl_baldwin> yamahata: Thanks for the links. I will download them for review as I travel. 15:08:54 <carl_baldwin> I encourage others to take a look as well. 15:09:22 <mrsmith> sounds good 15:10:05 <matrohon> please put your name on etherpad to attend BGP POD : https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/bgp-vpn-dynamic-routing 15:10:16 <carl_baldwin> Here are a couple of summit links that I have found useful: 15:10:20 <carl_baldwin> #link http://kilodesignsummit.sched.org/ 15:10:27 <carl_baldwin> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Summit/Kilo/Etherpads 15:10:55 * carl_baldwin just put his name on the etherpad 15:11:14 <carl_baldwin> I see the proposed time too. 15:12:25 <carl_baldwin> I just created this. Please help me propose times and locations and add your names…. 15:12:27 <carl_baldwin> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/kilo-l3-refactoring 15:13:19 <seizadi> Hi, We have session for pluggable IPAM also: https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/neutron-ipam 15:13:33 <carl_baldwin> seizadi: Thanks, you beat me to that one. 15:13:45 <seizadi> http://kilodesignsummit.sched.org/event/a6cc78ce6248f351321feecbad6a5092#.VFJVT77P5Id 15:13:46 <carl_baldwin> IPAM will have a design session that I will moderate. 15:14:11 <carl_baldwin> I will be working on the etherpad for that today. I have a lot of ideas. 15:14:51 <seizadi> Great it is on Thu so may be we can meet before and discuss 15:15:25 <matrohon> concerning l3 agent refactoring, I see some overlaps with modular l2 agent -> is it a target to have one modular agent for all? 15:15:30 <carl_baldwin> seizadi: That would be good. 15:15:50 <seizadi> This week we will submit a patch with the proposed code as you asked. 15:15:52 <carl_baldwin> matrohon: I don’t think that has been a stated goal. 15:16:18 <carl_baldwin> matrohon: However, finding common functionality and abstracting that in to common software should be considered. 15:16:43 <matrohon> carl_baldwin : make sense 15:17:35 <carl_baldwin> Some common functions that have been suggested are state management and synchronization, namespace management, and others that I can’t remember at the moment. 15:18:12 <mrsmith> carl_baldwin - how will all the work get split up? 15:18:58 <carl_baldwin> mrsmith: Something that I would like very much to discuss face to face. 15:19:52 <carl_baldwin> mrsmith: I kind of think that a few things need to be done before things can be split up very effectively. 15:20:14 <mrsmith> just keep me on the list of devs willing to jump in and help 15:20:21 <carl_baldwin> mrsmith: We *really* need functional testing as discussed in the DVR meeting yesterday. 15:20:27 <mrsmith> agreed 15:21:07 <carl_baldwin> Any kind of substantial refactoring will be held up if the functionality is not covered with functional tests. 15:21:31 <carl_baldwin> mrsmith: Do you have any thoughts on how to get a good start on the testing? 15:23:08 <mrsmith> we have someone on our test who has started 15:23:18 <mrsmith> I can check with him to see where he is at 15:23:26 <mrsmith> and what else needs to be done 15:23:39 <mrsmith> I am currently working on a couple backlog patches however 15:23:56 <carl_baldwin> mrsmith: Great to hear. I’d like to include marun and amuller in the process early. Otherwise, I think we’ll be surprised by their feedback in reviews. 15:24:04 <mrsmith> regardless, it is a good reminder that focus needs to be on func testing 15:24:36 <marun> +1 :) 15:24:55 <matrohon> FYI : multi-node tempest test should be writable soon : https://review.openstack.org/#/c/106043/ 15:25:25 <mrsmith> great! 15:25:32 <yamamoto_> great 15:25:55 <carl_baldwin> +1 15:26:40 <carl_baldwin> I’ve got about 5 minutes before I need to get on the road. I will have email most of the time but will not be on IRC. 15:26:45 <carl_baldwin> Any other topics to discuss? 15:27:02 <yamamoto_> nothing from me 15:27:45 <carl_baldwin> I look forward to seeing many of you in Paris. 15:27:57 <chuckC_> :) 15:28:19 <carl_baldwin> Thanks everyone. 15:28:28 <carl_baldwin> #endmeeting