14:59:57 <carl_baldwin_> #startmeeting neutron_l3
14:59:58 <openstack> Meeting started Thu Apr 23 14:59:57 2015 UTC and is due to finish in 60 minutes.  The chair is carl_baldwin_. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
15:00:00 <openstack> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
15:00:02 <openstack> The meeting name has been set to 'neutron_l3'
15:00:11 <carl_baldwin_> #topic Announcements
15:00:24 <carl_baldwin_> I think RC2 is still in the works.
15:00:33 <carl_baldwin_> Other than that I don’t have any.
15:01:00 <carl_baldwin_> Thanks to mlavalle for cleaning up https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings/Neutron-L3-Subteam
15:01:11 <mlavalle> carl_baldwin_: :-)
15:01:26 <mlavalle> mlavalle: i'll clean up further over the next few days
15:01:33 <carl_baldwin_> The Kilo release is planned for 1 week from now.
15:02:09 <carl_baldwin_> #topic Bugs
15:02:59 <carl_baldwin_> Bug: #1446261
15:02:59 <openstack> bug 1446261 in neutron "gate-neutron-dsvm-functional race fails HA/DVR tests with network namespace not found" [Critical,In progress] https://launchpad.net/bugs/1446261 - Assigned to Carl Baldwin (carl-baldwin)
15:03:36 <carl_baldwin_> I’m working on this one.  There must be another similar one lurking in there.  Still working on it.
15:04:06 <carl_baldwin_> Any other bugs?
15:04:46 <carl_baldwin_> #topic bgp-dynamic-routing
15:05:25 <carl_baldwin_> devvesa cannot make it today.
15:05:43 <carl_baldwin_> tidwellr is also interested in pitching in here and couldn’t make it today either.
15:06:01 <carl_baldwin_> vikram: How is your work going?
15:06:01 <vikram> I have discussed about my proposal with Jaume and we have concluded that the existing proposal will be specific to BGP
15:06:32 <vikram> BP review is done.. Jaume got to modify
15:06:45 <vikram> I am checking the code now
15:06:50 <carl_baldwin_> vikram: I will have another look.  Thanks for your comments there.
15:07:17 <carl_baldwin_> BTW, for those interested, devvesa has put together a nice document for how to set up a test environment.
15:07:32 <carl_baldwin_> #link https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Neutron/DynamicRouting/TestingDynamicRouting
15:07:41 <vikram> I am drafting my proposal will send to you by next week
15:07:58 <carl_baldwin_> vikram: where will your proposal fit with the existing proposal?
15:08:06 <vikram> yes
15:08:32 <vikram> not much of changes
15:09:06 <vikram> i have already discussed with Jaume yesterday
15:09:17 <carl_baldwin_> vikram: I will watch for it.
15:09:23 <carl_baldwin_> Anything else BGP related?
15:09:45 <carl_baldwin_> #topic neutron-ipam
15:10:29 <vikram> Yes.. auth part need changes... moreover we were thinking to make the design such a way so that adding policy and vpn support will be easier later
15:10:46 <carl_baldwin_> #undo
15:10:46 <openstack> Removing item from minutes: <ircmeeting.items.Topic object at 0xa814ed0>
15:11:32 <carl_baldwin_> vikram: By vpn, do you mean MPLS / BGP vpn?
15:11:53 <vikram> yes. MPBGP support
15:12:05 <carl_baldwin_> And could you clarify what you mean by policy?
15:12:25 <vikram> it's required as different tenant can have same prefixes.. adv these prefixes will clash
15:12:49 <vikram> by policy i meant ACL support for filtering route adv
15:13:01 <vikram> if required
15:14:07 <carl_baldwin_> I see.  I have some thoughts on the tenant prefix clashing thing.  I need to finish up a BP specification and post it for that.
15:14:12 <carl_baldwin_> vikram: Thanks.
15:14:28 <carl_baldwin_> #topic neutron-ipam
15:14:44 <carl_baldwin_> johnbelamaric: pavel: salv-orlando:  How are things going on this front?
15:15:17 <johnbelamaric> pavel_bondar has most CI passing - there is still the issue around the auto address flag
15:15:22 <salv-orlando> carl_baldwin_: been busy with other things during the past week. I thing we should see soon a spec from johnbelamaric. afaict the plan is still the asame as last week
15:15:48 <johnbelamaric> salv-orlando: yes, it may take another week or so for me to put something together
15:16:47 <carl_baldwin_> I need to take another pass over the reviews to see what discussion I’ve missed.
15:17:41 <carl_baldwin_> It sounds like we just keep marching in the same direction.
15:18:03 <johnbelamaric> carl_baldwin_: ok. pavel_bondar keeps rebasing and working to get all the tempest tests passing.
15:18:36 <johnbelamaric> carl_baldwin_: yes. there is the item you mentioned about passing subnet dict instead of just ID - according to pavel_bondar this was necessary in order to avoid fetching the subnet, which was causing open contrail to fail in a mysterious way
15:19:51 <carl_baldwin_> johnbelamaric: Right.  We need to finished our discussion on https://review.openstack.org/#/c/150485/19/neutron/ipam/drivers/neutrondb_ipam/driver.py
15:20:04 <carl_baldwin_> I left that hanging.  I’ll get back to it today.
15:20:24 <carl_baldwin_> I think it was key to not having to look up the subnet.
15:20:37 <johnbelamaric> carl_baldwin_: thanks
15:20:58 <carl_baldwin_> johnbelamaric: Thanks for the reminder.
15:21:23 <carl_baldwin_> Anything else on ipam?
15:21:47 <johnbelamaric> carl_baldwin_: nope. other than that issue it's just the CI which pavel_bondar is targeting for completion in the coming week
15:21:59 <johnbelamaric> carl_baldwin_: CI failures that is
15:21:59 <carl_baldwin_> johnbelamaric: Great progress.
15:23:01 <johnbelamaric> carl_baldwin_: thanks - let's wrap this up :)
15:23:14 <carl_baldwin_> johnbelamaric: Agreed.  :)
15:23:21 <carl_baldwin_> #topic routing-networks
15:24:29 <carl_baldwin_> I put up this spec.
15:24:30 <carl_baldwin_> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/172244/
15:25:20 <mlavalle> carl_baldwin_: Is https://review.openstack.org/#/c/88619/ related to this?
15:25:30 <carl_baldwin_> I think it is key to reducing some complexity in DVR and reducing extra public address consumption.
15:25:35 * carl_baldwin_ looking
15:25:51 <carl_baldwin_> mlavalle: Yes, it is superseded.
15:26:06 <carl_baldwin_> The scope of 88619 was too big and it needed some more thought.  I’ve broken it up.
15:26:15 <mlavalle> carl_baldwin_: I'll replace it in the agenda with the new one
15:26:52 <carl_baldwin_> Thanks.  Be sure to mark it as superseded.  If I recall, 172244 has a link to it in the references.
15:26:56 <carl_baldwin_> mlavalle: Thanks.
15:28:22 <carl_baldwin_> I’d like it if reviewers could review it and bring any questions to me.  I’m happy to discuss it.
15:28:25 <mlavalle> carl_baldwin_: will do
15:28:29 <carl_baldwin_> #topic Open Discussion
15:29:54 <carl_baldwin_> If there is nothing else, we’ll make it a short meeting.
15:30:33 <carl_baldwin_> Thanks everyone.
15:30:51 <mlavalle> bye
15:31:22 <yamamoto> bye
15:31:22 <carl_baldwin_> #endmeeting